GameFly Files USPS Complaint over Broken Discs

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
According to this story, GameFly has filed a formal complaint against the U.S. Postal Service claiming that the USPS provides preferential treatment to its competitors to cut down on broken discs.

"GameFly is not the only mailer to experience significant DVD breakage rates on automated mail processing equipment," reads the filing. "In response...the Postal Service has adopted a practice of manually culling out the DVD mailers of two high-volume shippers of DVDs, Netflix and Blockbuster, for special processing."
 
The process isn't that hot for Netflix... most of my discs are scratched to hell and have crappy skips or interruptions in them. Though I cannot say if thats from the mailing process or other customers using them as coasters...they should do a better job replacing scratched discs in general imo.
 
The process isn't that hot for Netflix... most of my discs are scratched to hell and have crappy skips or interruptions in them. Though I cannot say if thats from the mailing process or other customers using them as coasters...they should do a better job replacing scratched discs in general imo.

I believe they don't replace the disc, I think the use a machine to buss the disc so it not have the scratches but there is only so many time you can do it?
 
I believe they don't replace the disc, I think the use a machine to buss the disc so it not have the scratches but there is only so many time you can do it?

Yes, at some point you're going to completely buff away the substrate and then the smallest ding will ruin the disc for good.

With the amount of stress some of the mailing equipment can put on the discs, I'm amazed as many make it through right now. I would guess that previous apes- err, customers- are to blame for scratches and smudges, and mail service for cracks and chips.
 
The process isn't that hot for Netflix... most of my discs are scratched to hell and have crappy skips or interruptions in them. Though I cannot say if thats from the mailing process or other customers using them as coasters...they should do a better job replacing scratched discs in general imo.

I have been a member for about 3 or 4 years now, normally get about 10+ movies a month and only 1 has ever been damaged to the point where it wouldn't play (disc was cracked). The rest have never really been scratched up or if they do have a few scratches it doesn't ever effect the playback.
 
Apparently Gamefly isn't aware that Blockbuster and Netflix pay a premium for manual sorting...but of course I have no references for the aforementioned statement, but in America I think it is kind of a given.
 
Apparently Gamefly isn't aware that Blockbuster and Netflix pay a premium for manual sorting...but of course I have no references for the aforementioned statement, but in America I think it is kind of a given.

Actually some people over there mention that Gamefly currently pays MORE for shipping than Netflix/Blockbuster (and that's why their envelopes specifically say Process on ASFM 100), yet Netflix/Blockbuster is still getting treated better they say.
 
Gamefly's claim is BS. I work for the post office and on the machines that process the discs. We treat all of them (gamefly, netflix, blockbuster) equally crappy. Most processing plants, like mine, are getting rid of their AFSM 100 machines. Besides, Gamefly has the better packaging for their discs.
 
I've noticed that when I rent Blu-rays on Netflix, they always arrive in near-perfect condition (almost no scratches and smudges). I don't know if its because Blu-rays are more robust, but I think it's more of an issue with consumers treating DVDs like crap. Blu-ray is newer and more expensive, so there's less hicks to toss them on the floor and step on em after use :D.
 
I've noticed that when I rent Blu-rays on Netflix, they always arrive in near-perfect condition (almost no scratches and smudges). I don't know if its because Blu-rays are more robust, but I think it's more of an issue with consumers treating DVDs like crap. Blu-ray is newer and more expensive, so there's less hicks to toss them on the floor and step on em after use :D.

Comes down to simply that less people rent BluRay. I don't always put new releases in my list. I'll wait for something to be about a year old so that I can get everything in order in my queue. By the time I get some movies, it's probably not out of the question to say it's been sent to over 100 people. (little more than one year, 3 to 4 day average turnaround)
 
I've noticed that when I rent Blu-rays on Netflix, they always arrive in near-perfect condition (almost no scratches and smudges).

Consider yourself lucky. I just got my third copy of "Forgetting Sarah Marshall" this week, and it's cracked and unplayable just like the last two. So I called Netflix customer service and they gave me a number for the USPS that they want me to use to complain. Ridiculous.

So no, GameFly isn't being treated any differently than Netflix.
 
Neal Boortz would point out how USPS is .gov run and we should avoid universal health care.
 
Consider yourself lucky. I just got my third copy of "Forgetting Sarah Marshall" this week, and it's cracked and unplayable just like the last two. So I called Netflix customer service and they gave me a number for the USPS that they want me to use to complain. Ridiculous.

So no, GameFly isn't being treated any differently than Netflix.

I've found that bad luck with one specific title is pretty much the norm... while occasionally you'll get a well worn copy, a cracked disc for multiple replacements of the same title is pretty frequent. I think it mainly comes down to the type of plastics/glue used in the making of that disc and how well (or badly, in this case) it handles flex stressing during transit.
 
Anyone know why these rent via mail companies do not use sturdy plastic/cardboard mailers? If this were implemented, would we see a huge spike in rates?
 
Neal Boortz would point out how USPS is .gov run and we should avoid universal health care.

I would point out how every other civilized country in the world manages to provide care to their citizens at a lower cost per capita and with better results. I would also point out how health insurance companies don't really provide any service, yet siphon billions that could be spent on care.
 
I would point out how every other civilized country in the world manages to provide care to their citizens at a lower cost per capita and with better results. I would also point out how health insurance companies don't really provide any service, yet siphon billions that could be spent on care.
I'd like to point out how they ration and have shitty doctors, and how my hospital parking lots in Michigan are full of Canadian license plates coming for treatments. If you were to provide every citizen in the US with full health coverage, you haven't got a clue how many tens of trillions of dollars it would cost. It's unsustainable due to our growing population, especially the portion of our population that is growing that doesn't even pay into the tax system.

Read a few stories and wake up to reality:
http://www.liberty-page.com/issues/healthcare/socialized.html
 
I'd like to point out how they ration and have shitty doctors, and how my hospital parking lots in Michigan are full of Canadian license plates coming for treatments. If you were to provide every citizen in the US with full health coverage, you haven't got a clue how many tens of trillions of dollars it would cost. It's unsustainable due to our growing population, especially the portion of our population that is growing that doesn't even pay into the tax system.

Read a few stories and wake up to reality:
http://www.liberty-page.com/issues/healthcare/socialized.html

Ever considered that those Canadian license plates are doctors working there?
 
I'd like to point out how they ration and have shitty doctors, and how my hospital parking lots in Michigan are full of Canadian license plates coming for treatments. If you were to provide every citizen in the US with full health coverage, you haven't got a clue how many tens of trillions of dollars it would cost. It's unsustainable due to our growing population, especially the portion of our population that is growing that doesn't even pay into the tax system.

Read a few stories and wake up to reality:
http://www.liberty-page.com/issues/healthcare/socialized.html

I'd like to point out that this is a the wrong mother fucking topic for this political bullshit. If I wanted to see a couple morons debate politics I'd watch Fox news.
 
Anyone know why these rent via mail companies do not use sturdy plastic/cardboard mailers? If this were implemented, would we see a huge spike in rates?

Gamefly added a cardboard protector. Beyond that, it would be very expensive to do anything heavier. If they did they would have to raise their rates to cover it. The volume that Netflix, Blockbuster, and Gamefly ship out has to come with some insane prices.
 
I saw a sideshow of netflex, they have places where they get the disc back they open it. check if there are strachs, and mail to next person if none.

If there are straches they replace the disk and throw away the old
 
Ever considered that those Canadian license plates are doctors working there?
Many probably are, plenty of doctors leave Canada because of the shit pay passed down onto them by the awful health system.

Anyone that thinks the Canadian system isn't 2-tier is kidding themselves. The masses go to the over-crowed under-funded hospitals and wait 6 months for a routine surgery, and the people with money just drive across the border.
 
This is about gamefly.

Gamefly ships there stuff crazy different then Netflix. Netflix just does a paper envelope, and then the sleeve the disk sits in.

Gamefly you place then game in a protective cardboard sleeve. inside the paper sleeve, inside the envelope. If those game disc are getting damaged, netflix movies should be completely destroyed. When I get home i'll take a picture of how game fly packs the disk.
 
Ever considered that those Canadian license plates are doctors working there?
No, there are dozens of patients each day that come for treatment because they can't get it in Canada. My best friend is a medical assistant at the hospital.
 
Back
Top