Game Over for Mac Clone Maker Psystar

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The final nail in Psystar’s coffin has just been slammed home. Not sure how well that Rebel EFI thing is going to work for them but the company’s days as a Mac clone maker are over. Oh well, it was entertaining while it lasted.

U.S. District Court William Alsup said Florida-based Psystar has until midnight, Dec. 31, 2009, to comply with the injunction, and told the company not to drag its feet. "Defendant must immediately begin this process, and take the quickest path to compliance," Alsup wrote in the order, which was filed Tuesday in a San Francisco federal court.
 
So the government tries Intel for non-compete practices after Intel has already settled with AMD, yet they do nothing about Apple's non-compete practices... Don't you love the irony.
 
So the government tries Intel for non-compete practices after Intel has already settled with AMD, yet they do nothing about Apple's non-compete practices... Don't you love the irony.

Well Intel did sell the rights and license to AMD and other chip makers. Apple did not. Psystar assumed the rights on their own.
 
Article said:
The injunction, however, is more or less moot, as Psystar shut down its Mac clone business earlier this month when it struck a settlement deal with Apple that requires it to pay nearly $2.7 million in damages if it loses appeals to the next level.

Not a big deal since they've already stopped producing mac clones. The judgement didn't rule against producing the Rebel EFI software, even though the Judge said they were on thin ice producting said software....
 
Meanwhile the Judge retired to his chambers to write his decision on his new MacBook Pro.
 
Well Intel did sell the rights and license to AMD and other chip makers. Apple did not. Psystar assumed the rights on their own.

Not really. What happened was AMD and other companies reverse engineered the x86 architecture and made their own chipsets, then when Intel tried to force the issue, the courts sided with the clone makers and said Intel had to license their product. However, for some reason they say no such thing about many of the other processors, chipsets, and software out there.
 
Not really. What happened was AMD and other companies reverse engineered the x86 architecture and made their own chipsets, then when Intel tried to force the issue, the courts sided with the clone makers and said Intel had to license their product. However, for some reason they say no such thing about many of the other processors, chipsets, and software out there.

Remember, it only applies to the largest companies. In the grand scheme of things, Apple isn't as big as Intel or Microsoft, so it doesn't apply to them.
 
Not really. What happened was AMD and other companies reverse engineered the x86 architecture and made their own chipsets, then when Intel tried to force the issue, the courts sided with the clone makers and said Intel had to license their product. However, for some reason they say no such thing about many of the other processors, chipsets, and software out there.

Ahh, I wasn't aware AMD started before getting licenses. I wonder what made the judge side with them.
 
Ahh, I wasn't aware AMD started before getting licenses. I wonder what made the judge side with them.

I don't know the exact details of what happened, when, where or how, but there were many clones of the x86 architecture. The licensing agreement was for the chipset only, not the hardware. AMD completely ripped off the entire 286 architecture design from Intel, right down to the pin counts.

Remember, it only applies to the largest companies. In the grand scheme of things, Apple isn't as big as Intel or Microsoft, so it doesn't apply to them.

And yet they have gone after Nvidia, which clearly isn't as large as Apple.
 
I don't know the exact details of what happened, when, where or how, but there were many clones of the x86 architecture. The licensing agreement was for the chipset only, not the hardware. AMD completely ripped off the entire 286 architecture design from Intel, right down to the pin counts.



And yet they have gone after Nvidia, which clearly isn't as large as Apple.

But it was bigger than ATI. It's all segmented. Anyways. Apple still sucks :p
 
I don't know the exact details of what happened, when, where or how, but there were many clones of the x86 architecture. The licensing agreement was for the chipset only, not the hardware. AMD completely ripped off the entire 286 architecture design from Intel, right down to the pin counts.



And yet they have gone after Nvidia, which clearly isn't as large as Apple.

--- AMD ripped off the 486 too - I had an AMD 486 133Mhz at one point...
 
Too bad. Not a big surprise though.

The judge's comments on Rebel EFI are a lot more interesting IMO. Depending how you read his tone it sounds like he thinks it violates this injunction as well. Frankly, I think that's ridiculous. It's standalone software, not directly related or based off OSX in any way. I don't see why Apple should have the power to say anything whatsoever about software they had no part in the making of. But these are the consequences of the asinine DMCA I suppose; perhaps it will stand, but that would be a sad day for users.
 
Ahh, I wasn't aware AMD started before getting licenses. I wonder what made the judge side with them.

Actually, AMD was a second-source for Intel for a while at first. The issues arose when Intel decided against renewing their agreements. At that point, AMD and others decided to reverse engineer Intel's processors to keep up. AMD went further and sued Intel and the rest is history...or rather just an ongoing string of lawsuits for about the past 20 or so years that usually end up with cross-licensing agreements.
 
You guys are all over the place with the whole AMD thing. It all started when Intel went to AMD to help produce the 8086/8088 and later the 80286. The problem between the two didnt start until Intel released the 386 and told AMD that the contract they had didn't cover the new CPU. AMD then reverse engineered the 386 and started selling clones while they worked on the lawsuit (that they would eventually win, since the 386 was quit similar to the 286). Intel started working on their Pentium CPU that would not be similar in name or design to their previous CPUs, ensuring AMD couldn't win a legal battle that would allow them to make clones. AMD at this point had to develope their own CPU from scratch (and did with the K5).
 
Ten years ago it would have been nice to run Mac OS on a windows machine because of the limited publishing software and Postscript issues on Windows, but now days why would anyone want to do such a thing? Win 7 does everything you would want it to and there is no need for OSX. On a side note though I would think Apple would love this since it might get a few more people to use their OS.
 
You guys are all over the place with the whole AMD thing. It all started when Intel went to AMD to help produce the 8086/8088 and later the 80286. The problem between the two didnt start until Intel released the 386 and told AMD that the contract they had didn't cover the new CPU. AMD then reverse engineered the 386 and started selling clones while they worked on the lawsuit (that they would eventually win, since the 386 was quit similar to the 286). Intel started working on their Pentium CPU that would not be similar in name or design to their previous CPUs, ensuring AMD couldn't win a legal battle that would allow them to make clones. AMD at this point had to develope their own CPU from scratch (and did with the K5).

Ummm, where did this come from? AMD reverse engineered Intel's product and created an exact clone of the 286. Intel had licensed use of their "chipset" not their architectural design. Intel didn't go to AMD for help producing the 8086. They chose AMD as a second supplier since IBM demanded 2 suppliers for the 8086. At that time Intel licensed x86 chipset to AMD. AMD then reverse engineered Intel's hardware and made their own chips, including a 286 which was exactly like Intel's. This prompted Intel to cancel the agreement due to a number of their patents and technologies being stolen by AMD. That is what started the whole affair.

As for producing CPUs from scratch, AMD had been doing their own CPUs since the 386 because of the legal battles they were in with Intel.

The whole thing is basically which came first, the chicken or the egg. They have been doing back to back legal battles for decades.

In anyway, we are hijacking this thread from the Psystar affair. The original point was that it seems the FTC is only interested in taking over companies and doing that by trying to broaden their powers through court cases and current litigation. Apparently that keeps them from actually doing their real job and trying cases against Apple for using non-compete practices against competitors and creating a monopoly for their product.
 
Back
Top