Game Developer Sues Game Critic For $10 Million

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Okay, so this game developer has filed a ten million dollar lawsuit against a video game critic for assault, libel, and slander. Things get even weirder when the game developer immediately seeks $75k on GoFundMe donations for its legal fees (total donations are at $190 so far).

On March 16, Digital Homicide formally filed a lawsuit in Arizona District Court, accusing Sterling of “assault, libel, and slander” to the tune of $10 million. (The only reason “assault” is listed is because libel is, legally speaking, part of a broader category when filing a lawsuit. Ignore that.) The lawsuit was filed by Digital Homicide co-founder James Romine.
 
DH are two insane brothers that are gonna get laughed out of court. They filed it by themselves, under a federal court, a place were those frivolous claims are thrown out left and right, and heck they couldn't even count properly in the claim (there are two points 10, they forgot to account for some 800k dollars that they feel they are owed from their time "researching the law to file the claim" and are delusional to the point that they don't recognize that when they threatened to dox him and other shady silly stuff they did had them as the attackers, they feel that they were defending... pure insanity).
 
And the best part
Update - 12:25 pm: Digital Homicide has taken down its crowdfunding request “due to harassers donating amounts specifically to cause charges rather than donations and charge backs to cause financial fees...[W]e will be seeking another avenue for donations”

ha ha ha ha ha haha
 
Amazed that people still don't understand how the internet works. The world is a very very small place now.
 
Here's a recent video by the guy they're sueing. He's pretty funny. The games are horrible.

 
Hmmm sounds like the reviewer is based in the UK. Will be interesting to see how that works.
 
Hmmm sounds like the reviewer is based in the UK. Will be interesting to see how that works.
If by the UK, you mean the Deep South USA (Mississippi?) then correct. Either way, I cannot WAIT to see how this plays out. These guys (DigiHom) have gone full derp for years now.
 
Last edited:
What I find hilarious about this is that they're insane enough to sue a guy that not only makes over 100k a year from Patreon, so he has the money to get a decent lawyer, but I believe he is also partnered with Polaris for his Youtube content. Polaris is owned by Disney so there's that. On top of that Jim's channel is one of the few that Youtube has pledged to protect from lawsuits regarding his content. That means, if YT considers this a valid case, that Jim will have Youtube's legal team and something like a million dollars worth of legal defense to back him up.
 
You know a civil case has no shot of winning when the the plaintive needs money for legal fees.
 
There are so many problems with this lawsuit, I don't know where to begin.

1.Most of the claims are of torts against his LLC, Digital Homicide, yet he is suing as an individual. An individual has no standing to sue for torts against a corporate entity, even if they own 100% of it.

2.Additionally, corporations are considered separate legal persons and therefore cannot be represented pro se by a non-attorney, even if the owner of the corporation owns 100% of it.

3.He sued under the federal civil rights act (42 USC 1985) but then claimed diversity rather than federal question jurisdiction. In addition, 1985 only applies to protected races and classes and "developers of bad video games" is not considered a protected class.

4.There is no allegation of facts or any background information. He jumps straight into the claims.

5.He is asking for $800 hour x 1000 for the time he had to spend doing legal research. Plaintiffs pro se are not eligible to collect attorney fees from the opposing party because they are not attorneys.

I could go on but this one won't even survive the initial motions. I wouldn't be surprised to see this sua sponte dismissed before Jim Sterling's lawyers have to even lift a finger.
 


jim Sterling interviews Digital Homicide back in july 11, 2015

kind of hilarious



Oh i'm listening to this video. The amount of Snark on both sides is hilarious. The Dev's are trying to blow moles into mountains and them attempting to claim foul over any small thing. Jim is right on so many levels and these dev's are trying to straw men every example.
 
There are so many problems with this lawsuit, I don't know where to begin.

3.He sued under the federal civil rights act (42 USC 1985) but then claimed diversity rather than federal question jurisdiction. In addition, 1985 only applies to protected races and classes and "developers of bad video games" is not considered a protected class.
:LOL::LOL::LOL::LOL:
 
Initially I thought the developer was just a whiner but after about 30 minutes into the interview I kind of started to see his side of things. Now that doesn't mean he's responded to the criticism correctly, he's been wrong, but he does make good points against Sterling.
 
Initially I thought the developer was just a whiner but after about 30 minutes into the interview I kind of started to see his side of things. Now that doesn't mean he's responded to the criticism correctly, he's been wrong, but he does make good points against Sterling.

Jim can be an ass and take things a little far at times but no, they don't have any point. He's a critic and they make shitty games. They filed a false and technically illegal DMCA claim to try and silence criticism. Failing that they created TWO videos directly attacking and insulting Jim. They can't take criticism and refuse to put any real effort into their products. The interview is pure insanity. Yes, Jim makes money off of looking at shitty games. Boo fucking hoo. If a shitty developer can't handle their shitty game being made fun of they should find a line of work they're actually good at instead of trying to rip people off.
 
Not a fan of sterling or anything, but he does talk about some good stuff every now and then...

That said, the one part in that interview that got to me the most was mainly the guy complaining about sterling making money off of stuff that aren't "professional" looking and sterling actually think the same. It doesn't matter to me, if it is what I want. And the complaint was based on sterling criticizing his game. News flash, criticizing something doesn't stop you from making your money, it only lets other people know what they would be getting if they paid, which is what we all should know if we buy a product. That said, I can't remember the original vid, if the bullet counter was in plain sight, then sterling's just an idiot for not seeing it... which is what I already think of most of his stuff anyway. But it would be a bad criticism since it's wasn't based on facts.

Also, the idiot dev actually pulled out the "you don't create games, you can't criticize it" card, which made me facepalm.
 
I look forward to Sterling going nuclear on these idiots once this current fiasco is swept aside. If they focused their energies on learning some actual game development skills rather than continuing to dig themselves into this hole, everyone would benefit.
 
Back
Top