Fry’s Still Using Monster "HDMI Difference" Scam

What is just disgusting is that there's never any charges brought on this type of crap.

Car Dealers do this constantly too, but when was the last time you heard any of these scumbags being even fined for their shady ways?
 
Problem is Monster isn't doing anything illegal. Monster can just claim that their prices are high because you're buying their name. Bose does this. Sony too.

What's the word? Caveat emptor?
 
I lay the blame squarely on Fry's. It's their store, they should be aware of what's going on. I'm sure the huge profit margin they get on those cables helps them to look the other way. I wouldn't be surprised if the Fry's people set up this display in the first place.
But it's not illegal. As long as it just says, "The difference between Monster and non Monster" and the HDMI cable is Monster and composite is not, then it's not illegal, just immoral.
 
Problem is Monster isn't doing anything illegal. Monster can just claim that their prices are high because you're buying their name. Bose does this. Sony too.

What's the word? Caveat emptor?

Yeah Monster isn't doing anything illegal, unless its any of their techs who set up the TVs, or their set of instructions on how to set them up. Caveat emptor does not apply in the United States when it comes to lying in advertising.
 
Article is a bit misleading. On the signs in front of the TVs it actually states "difference between Monster HDMI vs Standard Composite", but its definitely a dirty sales tactic since most people will assume they NEED a Monster HDMI cable for $80 and not just a regular $15 one.
 
However Tokamak is correct here, and this really is a non story, and hell isn't even a scam, as the sign actually says composite video cable

4-21-08-wacky-hdmi-comparis.jpg
 
Wow, the only thing immoral now is the article trying to make Fry's/Monster look bad. If it's advertised plain as day that it's HDMI vs composite, there's nothing to it. Still a little shady, but actually more honest than almost all advertising.

However Tokamak is correct here, and this really is a non story, and hell isn't even a scam, as the sign actually says composite video cable

4-21-08-wacky-hdmi-comparis.jpg
 
Wow, the only thing immoral now is the article trying to make Fry's/Monster look bad. If it's advertised plain as day that it's HDMI vs composite, there's nothing to it. Still a little shady, but actually more honest than almost all advertising.

When you consider that the tvs are hooked up to a blu-ray player that probably comes with component cables, this comparison is pretty misleading since it's it's comparing the monster cable to something worse than the consumer would already have. It's not lying though, and this is why people need to do their research before buying.
 
Another sensationalized "News" story? Someone out to get a few quick hits on their blog, regardless of the ethical implications or reality?? Say it isn't so...
 
However Tokamak is correct here, and this really is a non story, and hell isn't even a scam, as the sign actually says composite video cable

Now that's funny if they can work their way around the scam accusations like that. I know there are still a lot of people who don't know the difference between Composite and HDMI.
 
Not a scam, they are comparing composite with hdmi, nothing to see, move along.

What I find funny is that people attack frys like this but then beg them to come to their state. Fry's can pull all the ad scams they want as long as they move to my state... I'll be happy :)
 
Where are their signs in the audio department pitting "Monster audio cables" to coat hangers? :p

Where is the disclaimer that the signal through the composite cable isn't actually HD? I was under the impression that people wouldn't even be able to watch blu-ray movies over composite... So this really is a scam.
 
Where are their signs in the audio department pitting "Monster audio cables" to coat hangers? :p

Where is the disclaimer that the signal through the composite cable isn't actually HD? I was under the impression that people wouldn't even be able to watch blu-ray movies over composite... So this really is a scam.

I wonder if anyone notices the LCD screen size too. 19" is hardly a reasonable testbed for high definition vs standard definition comparison.
 
Monster cables are of excellent build quality, though that has nothing to do with transferring the signal.
They are way over priced but you do get a high quality product for your money.
 
Not a scam, they are comparing composite with hdmi, nothing to see, move along.

What I find funny is that people attack frys like this but then beg them to come to their state. Fry's can pull all the ad scams they want as long as they move to my state... I'll be happy :)

Heh, same here. I'd like them to build a Fry's on top of a Best Buy store so I can go shopping and then take a leak off their balcony when I'm done. :p ;)
 
Monster cables are of excellent build quality, though that has nothing to do with transferring the signal.
They are way over priced but you do get a high quality product for your money.

You can get the same quality for 80% lower cost no-name brand.
 
lol monster cables... glad I still have monoprice.com to get all my cable needs!
 
Not a scam, they are comparing composite with hdmi, nothing to see, move along.

What I find funny is that people attack frys like this but then beg them to come to their state. Fry's can pull all the ad scams they want as long as they move to my state... I'll be happy :)

I'll second a Fry's coming to the great lakes area. Scams don't fade me like the rest of the sheeple out there.
 
Fry's is a crap store so I'm not surprised. I rank them right down there with Radio Shack.
 
Where are their signs in the audio department pitting "Monster audio cables" to coat hangers? :p

Where is the disclaimer that the signal through the composite cable isn't actually HD? I was under the impression that people wouldn't even be able to watch blu-ray movies over composite... So this really is a scam.

Ummm... you are kidding me right?

You can get the same quality for 80% lower cost no-name brand.

Not exactly true. We would assume that you can get the same quality IF the cable that was no name brand was assembled properly and made proper contact. You do get bad HDMI cables out there, those are usually due to failures in quality control.

With a monster cable, you get a cable with a high quality control.

Granted you can buy 10 cheap cables and and for the most part all 10 will work great, some people do not have the time and want something to work and work the first time.

Fry's is a crap store so I'm not surprised. I rank them right down there with Radio Shack.

I guess you are not much of a computer enthusiast? This is the mecca for geeks.
 
ACTUALLY...

The TVs in the article are two different TVs than the picture Tokamak posted. I am sure there are some companies that DO put signs up (remember the HD cable versus non HD cable stuff last year where the signs were conveniently covered?) but this isn't one of those cases. Obviously the black matte TVs are not the same shiny white ones with the sign.

The reason this is even news is because after the 4000th incident like this we posted last year....we thought they had stopped doing this crap.

I still like in Tokamak’s picture how they have a Blu-ray HD DVD drive running through a composite cable, like it can even do HD content. Like that isn't deceiving enough as it is.

Everyone should take a camera (or phones) to their local big box retailer and take pictures...let's see how many of them actually have signs up saying s-video versus HDMI. ;)
 
ACTUALLY...

The TVs in the article are two different TVs than the picture Tokamak posted. I am sure there are some companies that DO put signs up (remember the HD cable versus non HD cable stuff last year where the signs were conveniently covered?) but this isn't one of those cases. Obviously the black matte TVs are not the same shiny white ones with the sign.

The reason this is even news is because after the 4000th incident like this we posted last year....we thought they had stopped doing this crap.

I still like in Tokamak’s picture how they have a Blu-ray HD DVD drive running through a composite cable, like it can even do HD content. Like that isn't deceiving enough as it is.

Everyone should take a camera (or phones) to their local big box retailer and take pictures...let's see how many of them actually have signs up saying s-video versus HDMI. ;)

Take a picture if you see any box retailer still running s-video... that alone should be a crime. :p
 
Fry's is a crap store so I'm not surprised. I rank them right down there with Radio Shack.

Now you're just being mean :p Seriously though, Fry's is a great store. You just need to be aware of the returned item stickers and to avoid them, and you're good to go. Fry's is still one of my favorite places to shop, they've got any kind of electric doo dad around and the selection is the best when it comes to stores. Try and find the kind of selection of video cards/CPUs/memory Fry's has at any other walk in store. You won't.
 
Wow, the only thing immoral now is the article trying to make Fry's/Monster look bad. If it's advertised plain as day that it's HDMI vs composite, there's nothing to it. Still a little shady, but actually more honest than almost all advertising.

I'm gonna agree... Unless there's something there that I can't read.

To me it looks like they're comparing composite to HDMI, which is a valid comparison. Now if they were claiming that it was Monster vs OtherHDMI and were really using composite (or purposely lowering quality in some other way) I would call it a scam.
 
I agree it is a bit misleading. Even with the signs they are implying that their equipment is worth $200 to get the better image quality, when if you used the comonant cable that comes with you BD player or pick up a $5 HDMI cable on line, but would really start wondering if any of this is worth it. I would never spend $100 for an HDMI cable and even if I had a poor power signal I could get a few good HDMI cables and a good surge protector/filter/battery back-up unit for $100 for everything and be 2x better off. Even good thick double ferrite cables are pretty cheap as long as you do not but them at a retail chain and stay away from Monster.
 
ACTUALLY...

The TVs in the article are two different TVs than the picture Tokamak posted. I am sure there are some companies that DO put signs up (remember the HD cable versus non HD cable stuff last year where the signs were conveniently covered?) but this isn't one of those cases. Obviously the black matte TVs are not the same shiny white ones with the sign.

The reason this is even news is because after the 4000th incident like this we posted last year....we thought they had stopped doing this crap.

I still like in Tokamak’s picture how they have a Blu-ray HD DVD drive running through a composite cable, like it can even do HD content. Like that isn't deceiving enough as it is.

Everyone should take a camera (or phones) to their local big box retailer and take pictures...let's see how many of them actually have signs up saying s-video versus HDMI. ;)

My local worst buy does this, except the wiring is actually hidden in the back, the same as their "calibration" demo TV.

And really does it matter that this is number 4000 ? its playing on the ignorance of some of the customers. Anybody doing this is running a scam, legal or not.
 
I guess you are not much of a computer enthusiast? This is the mecca for geeks.

I assume the post was referring to the salespeople. They (usually) don't know shit. Dumb as stumps with shitty sales practices. They lie to the uninformed consumer, make false claims, sell a product that the customer doesn't need or want, etc...

Tons and tons of awesome stuff, though. As long as you know what you are doing (or just want to play around), Fry's is an AWESOME, KICK ASS store. Just don't ask for help. They are only good for asking directions. And even that is difficult for them sometimes.
 
To me it looks like they're comparing composite to HDMI, which is a valid comparison. Now if they were claiming that it was Monster vs OtherHDMI and were really using composite (or purposely lowering quality in some other way) I would call it a scam.

The only thing that is confusing the issue is the picture posted by sfsuphysics in this thread. That picture is from an article we linked almost a year ago....that has nothing to do with the article we posted today.

I repeat, the picture posted in this thread showing a sign labeling the TVs is from April of last year. It has absolutely NOTHING to do with the news item we posted today.

(link)
 
If there was a sign it might have been ok. But if there wasnt than wow. shame on them.

Monster must sure have it hard trying to hide the fact that normal cables are just as good.
 
I assume the post was referring to the salespeople. They (usually) don't know shit. Dumb as stumps with shitty sales practices. They lie to the uninformed consumer, make false claims, sell a product that the customer doesn't need or want, etc...

Tons and tons of awesome stuff, though. As long as you know what you are doing (or just want to play around), Fry's is an AWESOME, KICK ASS store. Just don't ask for help. They are only good for asking directions. And even that is difficult for them sometimes.

Didn't you just sum up pretty much every sales person? :p ;)
 
I don't give a shit what Fry's did in their store, the fact you can actually buy a non-Monster brand cable there alone means this whole damn thing is a non-story.
 
I hate these scams. Sure they are telling you the truth in their sign, but that's not what the average consumer is going to think. If they had $100 Monster HDMI vs. $20 cheapie HDMI, I would bet they would choose the cheaper one, but that's not the idea of running a chain of stores.

Does your printer print clearer pictures if you get a Monster USB cable, too?
 
If they had $100 Monster HDMI vs. $20 cheapie HDMI, I would bet they would choose the cheaper one, but that's not the idea of running a chain of stores.
Fry's sells a regular HDMI cable for $11 or $12 (regular price), and another that goes on sale often for under $5. If I saw that display in my local Fry's I'd plug in one of those $5 cheapies. :cool:
 
edit: or even better, leave some of those $5 cables next to the display on the Monster side.
 
Guys, your missing the point. Fry's is bashing Monster with this display.

They are telling you the only Monster hdmi cables are better then is composite!
 
Back
Top