first WC build need some advice on these components

Layer01

Weaksauce
Joined
Mar 22, 2007
Messages
75
Hi guys
first post on this forum, first watercool job :D
I've been doing a lot of reading on the subject recently and i've got an idea of what i'd like to do and a list of parts to do it with, but i'd like some advice on the matter :)

Here are some of the system specs (none of which are final)

Processor: INTEL CORE2 QUAD Q6600 2.4GHZ
Mobo: ABIT AW9D-MAX LGA775 I975X P4/C2D ATX BOARD
GfxCard: XFX 8800 GTX XXX
Ram: OCZ2G8002GK PC2-6400 (4x1GB)
Case: SILVERSTONE TJ07

So thats the core of the machine that I intend to watercool.
I've been looking at various Kits, most i dont like the look of visually, but i am quite fond of the Evercool 202

pic 1
pic 2
read a review of it here

From what i can tell (the 5 or so reviews i've read on it) it seems quit good. Not "hardcore" in a DIY sense i guess but it seems to deliver what i'd need, but i'd be interested in hearing people's experiences with this setup.

The thing that i like the most about it is that its compact and fits away nicely out of sight, but also gives you a front plate with easy access for top ups/filling and temp info/"control".

However i have been thinking about making some mods to it, to squeeze out every last bit of cooling from it.
For starters not using the generic heat paste that it comes with it but using some Thermaltake paste, which supposedly can help shave off a degree or so.
Replacing the water block for the CPU and GPU.
The CPU with a SwiftTech Apogee
pic 3
For the GPU i was originally thinking of getting a Dangerden GTX waterblock, but i was told they had had some bad/or mixed reviews and that i should go for a EK-FC8800 GTX - Acetal
pic 4
but i'm not sure..so i need some advice there.

I was also considering either replacing the included external Radiator with a Black Ice extreme 2 Rad, which would go down the bottom on its side next to the PSU.
pic 5

so the loop could look like this:
Evercool>GPU>external rad(included)>CPU>Evercool
This is because i am thinking the external rad would be more efficient at cooling the water than the internal. (i should point out that when i say internal i mean in the drive bay, and external i mean still within the case but in its own section of the case, either at the back or down at the bottom)

According to reviews it seem to be able to cool quite well with its included rad's But because it will be a quad core (and i may try to OC it just a fraction, nothing insane but no reason why not if the wc can handle it) i thought it might need some better cooling. Which is where the Black Ice would come in.

in which case the loop could look like
Evercool>GPU>Black ice>CPU>Evercool
or if i got some more tubing i could keep the original external rad in the loop as well
Evercool>GPU>black ice>CPU>original rad>Evercool..or some such thing
But i'm not sure if this would even have an effect...

A few more Questions.
When adding/removing blocks from your loops, after its all set up once and running, how do you go about doing this without taking of a tube and liquid spurting everywhere? or do you just take it all out and drain it and start again. Its just i get the impression from reading some people's posts thet you can make additions to the loop without dismounting and rebuilding..just curious, not planning on making any changes once its set up.

I'm trying to decide between
PrimoChill PC ICE Non-Conductive Water Cooling Fluid - UV
and
MCT-5 Non-Conductive Solution (i thought i found an MCT-40 but i can't find it anymore :confused: )
If the promochill is as effective at being non conductive i'd get it, because it looks better and is UV reactive. but its the (relative) safety of my system that i'm more concerned about.

Thanks for your time and help :cool:
 
Before I even start, I do believe it is against forum rules to display images that you do not host personally. Called bandwidth theft, change the img to a link.

Few things.

First off, quad cores are very difficult to cool. They produce a ton of heat, and all over the place. If you look at Danger Den forums, you will see this come up 24/7 with watercooling.

Let me set one tihng straight. Do not get a kit. If you are cooling an 8800GTX and a Quad, you have a TDP of ~ 250W (at stock!). That is quite a lot of heat. It WILL need a custom setup to get good temps on that.

First off, the CPU block.

I have never personally used a quad core before, I am only relaying information stated multiple times by regular posters on the dangerden forums.

Currently out, if you are cooling a quad-core, you should grab a D-Tek Fuzion. It is supposudly the best block out to cool QC. If you are willing to wait around a bit, DD will likely be releasing the Maze5CPU, and that may work well for quad core as well, since I am sure they are taking that heavily into the design of the block.

Second off, radiator.

I would VERY strongly recomend a PA120.3 radiator. They are the the deepest radiator (from what I know), and cool very effectively. With a TDP of 250+, you will need a powerful radiator, and if you want to keep your system at all quiet, I'd grab a PA120.3. It is very effective with lower CFM fans, keeping your system quieter, yet it is still able to keep a quad and a 8800GTX cool.

Third, GPU block. I do not know too much about the EK block. all i know is that both the DD or the EK block get nearly the exact same performance. While the DD block is solid copper though, I am not sure about the EK block, and that would be something you would want to check before buying it. If you get the DD block, don't get the PC version, as it is more prone to cracks.

4) Pump
I am not that experienced with pumps, as I have only used a DDC12 pump with the petra's top, but I would personally recomend it, as it is very quiet, and very small. Otherwise the D5 seems to be a very popular pump.

5) Fluid
If you use all quality components (copper only, no chance for corrosion), you will get the best performance with straight distilled water with possibly a drop or two of algecide. If you want a little less maintenance, try mixing pentosin G11 in with a 15 to 1 (distilled to pentosin) ratio, or even lower (keeps performance higher with lower ratios).

Oh, and yes, you do have to drain most of the system when making a change, however, if you are like me, and have the radiator at the bottom of your loop (and its a PA120.3), you don't have to drain 1/2 of the water out lol.
 
If you're cooling a quad...

Get a Fuzion waterblock... For sure.

Also, get a Thermochill radiator or a black ice GTX radiator... Or on the cheap, go for a Swiftech MCR radiator... Thermochill being about 30% better than the swiftech.

The EK waterblock is good.
 
black ice GTX radiator

Ew, are you kidding me? Those things are so restrictive! To both air and water! You need massive ammounts of air pushing through those things to keep them cool. If I recall, they are two pass, and two pass on a 120X360 is death. So much pressure drop.

For $5 more get the praised PA120.3
 
Yep running same setup here ( just not the quad cpu) some temps to make ya watery...

Swiftech Apogee ( you get the GTX version cools 4°C better than mine)
Swiftech NB
EK 8800GTX waterblock
Swiftech MCP655 pump
Thermochill PA120 rad with 3x Scythe flex fans at 1000rpm
1/2 inch ID tygon tubing

CPU at 3600mhz 1.42 volts idle at 35°C coretemp measured , load 52°C
GPU idle 29°C load 36°C

Pls get a good rad for this setup and a triple rad is not overkill it will keep it all nice and cool.. all of your components are top class pls don't go with the more restrictive Blackice

My parts are here in the worklog http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/showthread.php?t=131061

mobo&
 
Get a HR-05 on the NB and your temps will most likely go down a bit on your CPU. I am idling 23C according to speedfan. (I do have the GT version however).

And I would not recomend the GTX version yet. Wait a few months, see the reviews before you buy it. However, the GT has the same fin design, so grab that if you want.
 
First of all thanks a lot for your time and help :) its much appreciated.

Sorry about the photos, i'll take em down. I just hate big-block-o-text-posts so thought i'd help make it easier to look at, and was too lazy to download the pics and re up them again.

First off, Jomanscool2 what do you mean by TDP of ~ 250W? just some terminology i'm not familier with.

ok, so a kit is not going to be what i want eh..damn..but thats ok, i think with all the reading (and the help on these forums) i'm feeling much more confident could pull it off :cool:

So lets recap.

For the CPU i should be looking at the D-tek fusion

and use a PA120.3 radiator
Any advice on the best place to buy one of these, price wise and they also have to be able to ship internationaly. And I'd have to buy some 3/8" hose barbs for the Rad, as well right?
Also Jomanscool2 whats wrong with the Black ICE line? I got the impression from reviews they were good..You say they are restrictive and that "and two pass on a 120X360 is death" could you elaborate?

I'll stick with the EK 8800GTX waterblock for the GPU i think.

And a Swiftech MCP655 pump
Few questions about this pump: it says it has 1/2" barb fittings, but i'm planning on using 3/8" tubing, how do i get around this?
it also says "Pump speed can be adjusted to yield top performance or virtually silent operations" how is this done? do i need some external control device, or is it done on the pump?

leeghoofd i couldn't find the Swiftech NB? what is it? and Jomanscool2 what do you mean by "Get a HR-05 on the NB and your temps will most likely go down a bit on your CPU" i looked and is this what you're talking about? but how does that fit in with WCing?

Also since i'm giving up the kit idea, i'll need a good place to buy 3/8" tubing, that ships internationaly (obviously aiming for the lowest possible price too ;) )
and what sort of clamps would you recommend/where should i go looking for them.

I really dont want to mix my own fluid if i can avoid it, there is enough new stuff to learn atm. I've read good things about the PrimoChill PC ICE including this review that seems pretty good. it also would appear to be better at keeping non conductive than distilled water when exposed to contaminents. So unless there is some other easier/better alternative i'll stick with PC ice i think.

and lastly, a few questions about the new loop.
Would something like this be good?
Pump>CPU>GPU>rad>pump

my concern is that if the CPU is really hot, wouldn't that reduce the cooling efficiancy for the GPU? would it be worth getting a small single fan rad to put between the CPU and the GPU to help remove some of the heat from the CPU?

thanks again, sorry if i'm asking dumb Q's but this is a whole new world for me, and i do sort of need to be hand guided lol :p

EDIT:
oh and any advice on a good res? I would preffer something that will be easy to get at and refill, i like the idea of Drive bay one's but not sure if they meet the criteria.
 
No problem, I love helping people out. TDP is basically how much heat is released.

First off, Jomanscool2 what do you mean by TDP of ~ 250W? sorry its just some terminology i'm not familier with.

TDP is basically how much heat is released.

To give you an idea, a C2D has a TDP 65W, and you have 250 with just a quad core and a 8800GTX. That is like cooling nearly four C2D's, and if you are OCing, that can easily go higher.


For the CPU i should be looking at the D-tek fusion

Yup, should do you well.

and use a PA120.3 radiator
Any advice on the best place to buy one of these, price wise and they also have to be able to ship internationaly. And I'd have to buy some 3/8" hose barbs for the Rad, as well right?

Wherever you can get em, get em. PPC has the 120.3 (in stock I believe), and they do ship internationally, however not for cheap. The radiator comes with fittings, but I'd grab some different ones. They use plastic fittings (fine) but use teflon for a secure seal (not fine, can dislodge and clog blocks). Here are some nickel plated brass fittings from Petra's [link]

Also Jomanscool2 whats wrong with the Black ICE line? I got the impression from reviews they were good..You say they are restrictive and that "and two pass on a 120X360 is death" could you elaborate?

They try to market it is as better due to the higher fins per inch, however, this is not always true. This means two things. One, tubes are smaller for the water to flow through = larger restriction.With a smaller rad, this isn't that much of an issue, but on a large radiator, this is very bad.
Two, more fins means you need higher static pressure and airflow to keep air going through it.

I am not saying the BI rads are bad, they can be good. But if you want to have a larger loop, and have performance and quiet at the same time, there are better radiators out there. (although they are nice due to their slim sizes!).

And a Swiftech MCP655 pump
Few questions about this pump: it says it has 1/2" barb fittings, but i'm planning on using 3/8" tubing, how do i get around this?
it also says "Pump speed can be adjusted to yield top performance or virtually silent operations" how is this done? do i need some external control device, or is it done on the pump?

Why would you use 3/8" tubing? All it does is restrict your loop more. You have a large case, why not use 1/2" tubing? Or, use 7/16" MasterKleer tubing on 1/2" fittings. Get better flow, and a completely secure seal.

And the speed is dont with a dial on the pump, however, you should just leave it on full. You should not be able to hear it at all. However, if you are willing to spend $30 more, I'd grab a swiftech MCP-355 and a DDCT-01 (or 02 if it comes out) from Petra's Tech Shop. Its what I use and love it, but many people don't want to have to deal with changing the tops (even though it is no harder than mounting a CD drive), and also the extra cost. I think it is smaller, and I know for a fact that it is DEAD silent.

leeghoofd i couldn't find the Swiftech NB? what is it? and Jomanscool2 what do you mean by "Get a HR-05 on the NB and your temps will most likely go down a bit on your CPU" i looked and is this what you're talking about? but how does that fit in with WCing?

Do not watercool the chipset unless you are going more for the pride of modding than the performance it brings. NB blocks are not really worth it to add to your loop. They add restriction and possible leaks, with the extra 4 inches of tubing and the block itself.

I was talking to leg about getting rid of the NB waterblock. He has a Striker, which has a horrible heat problem. with an i975 you should not even have to replace the stock cooling. I would just keep it as is, maybe replace the thermal material with artic silver ceramique.

The HR-05 really should have no concern to you.

Also since i'm giving up the kit idea, i'll need a god place to buy 3/8" tubing, that ships internationaly (obviously aiming for the lowest possible price too ;) )
and what sort of clamps would you recommend/where should i go looking for them.

Once agian, I'd go with 7/16" ID MasterKleer tubing on 1/2" fittings.

it also would appear to be better at keeping non conductive than distilled water when exposed to contaminents.
Impossible (as far as I know). Liquid becomes conductive because conductive elements are introduced into the mix, such as copper particles. I doubt there is any water that the PCICE could slow this down. Personally, I'd mix it. I did it on my first build, not hard at all. If you can make lemonade, you can do this.

my concern is that if the CPU is really hot, wouldn't that reduce the cooling efficiancy for the GPU? would it be worth getting a small single fan rad to put between the CPU and the GPU to help remove some of the heat from the CPU?

It adds too much restriction to be worth it. If you have good flow, which you should since your using only quality components (BTW KEEP YOUR TUBES AS SHORT AS PHYSICALLY POSSIBLE FOR BEST PERFORMANCE!), the temperature difference in the water between the CPU and the GPU really shouldn't matter THAT much. Plus, 8800GTXs are made to handle so much. I mean, anything that runs 60+ on stock cooling can definately handle the temps it gets while watercooled =D.


Oh, and order should be, with arrows indicating water flow, pump --> CPU --> GPU --> Radiator --> t-line/res --> pump.

If you really want a res, get a Swiftech MCRES-Micro. It is a smaller res, I do admit, but it is one of the few silent reses, and it is designed for performance. The problem with bay reses is that, one, they are very difficult to refill. Two, when they are even a bit low, air gets sucked into the tubes, messing up your temps. If you want a shorter loop, you can also put in a T-Line. many people perfer them to reses, but it doesn't really matter that much. If you get the MCRES and want a slightly sleeker look, pick up two DD Hi-Flow 1/2" fittings (G1/4") and use them on the res VS the huge black plastic ones they ship it with. If you get a res, you need to put it a few inches higher in your loop than the pump.

Oh, and even better, if you get the swiftech MCRES from PPC with your PA120.3, you can get it drilled with a G1/4" thread at the top so you can attach a tube leading to a fillport at the top of your case. This way you can fill/refill the case without even opening it!

And don't worry about the dumb Q's. First off, they really arn't that dumb, I've seen much, MUCH worse. In no time I'm sure you'll be sayin' "Hey ma, look! No hands!"
 
great, thanks for the tips.
and also about the keeping tubes short, makes sense :D

ok so now as it stands i'll get masterclear 7/16" ID, 5/8" OD Tubing.

a PA120.3 radiator with brass platted barbs.

a D-tek fusion, but i'll need to get new barbs for this, would any do (so long as they output to 7/16" or are there special ones for cpu blocks?

a Swiftech MCP355 12v DC Pump

and some sort of (non bay ;) ) res, haven't made up my mind on this yet. but the Swiftech MCRES-Micro seems good, but i'll keep looking for whats out there.

So as this stands this should be a pretty good setup right and be able to handle the CPU temps?

If so i think i'm all good to go :D

one last thing, if you could explain to me again what/and how you mixed in to your water and provide some links or the products full names, and i'll look into that too :)
 
Ew, are you kidding me? Those things are so restrictive! To both air and water! You need massive ammounts of air pushing through those things to keep them cool. If I recall, they are two pass, and two pass on a 120X360 is death. So much pressure drop.

Thermochill said:
The PA120 radiator series features a dual-row dual-pass 120mm form factor

The GTX also has about 20FPI, similar to the Thermochill...

No offence, You've given great (and accurate) advice so far, but have you ever tested a GTX, or are you just going with what you've read...

I'll agree that the Thermochill is a better rad (or at least a PROVEN rad) but the GTX deserves a bit more credit than you're giving it... Especially because I'm almost positive the design differences are minimal.


OP: Why are you getting different barbs for your Fuzion?

one last thing, if you could explain to me again what/and how you mixed in to your water and provide some links or the products full names, and i'll look into that too

A mixture of 95% distilled water, 2.5% pentosin G11 and 2.5% Dtek UV dye is what I'm running. There's currently a supply problem with the Pentosin coolant, so any Propylene glycol antifreeze can easily take it's place. I know Petras Tech Shop has something similar in stock (although I'm not 100% sure what he's got right now).

I just bought a gallon jug of distilled water, poured a tiny bit out. Then added around 95ml of both of the mentionned additives. Capped and shook.

Filled the loop with a funnel.
 
The thermochill works best and better than any other rad with low rpm fans ( meaning 600-800 region), once you go with high rpm fans 1200rpm and more there's not much difference in cooling ability between the rads...

Nice link and comparison here :

http://www.over-clock.com/ivb/index.php?showtopic=17958

Keep in mind though it's on the thermochill supported forum :p

I know the HR05 will drop my CPU temps a bit , but the NB block really puts almost no extra strain on the loop (meanign flow restriction), but indeed increases CPU/GPU temps by 4-5°C due to the extra heat, was thinking of adding an extra 120mm rad in between the NB and GPU. But performance is more than sufficient for me now...
 
If you're cooling a quad...

Get a Fuzion waterblock... For sure.

Also, get a Thermochill radiator or a black ice GTX radiator... Or on the cheap, go for a Swiftech MCR radiator... Thermochill being about 30% better than the swiftech.

The EK waterblock is good.

What he said. I second the motion. Don't go for a kit.
 
Back
Top