first REAL shader 2.0 vs 3.0 comparison

Bad_Boy

2[H]4U
Joined
Dec 17, 2003
Messages
3,282
just a preview

http://www.bit-tech.net/feature/43/
theres some diffrence ....ill wait on better images to make my opinion. but go ahead and make yours as this is all we got so far.

edit:

2.0
5.jpg

A fairly bad quality example (as far as my camera capabilities are concerned). This is a screeny from FarCry, using Shader 2

******

3.0
6.jpg

This is the same section using the Shader 3 patch. Notice how the textures on the wall and the floor seem so much deeper and more detailed.
 
hahahahhaha
:rolleyes:

thats all on the net right now bro, obviously i would put up better images if i had them. if you can do better, feel free my friend. :D

the quotes under each picture arnt mine, they are from the guy from bit-tech, who went to the show.
 
So what are the differences? And remember they talked a bunch about displacement mapping, which will make the textures look different, but it is a feature the 420 will support
 
Originally posted by Bad_Boy
hahahahhaha
:rolleyes:

thats all on the net right now bro, obviously i would put up better images if i had them. if you can do better, feel free my friend. :D

just relax, it will all come about on it's own. The shot supposedly with the 2.0 doesn't resemble what it looks like on my 9800pro. Something doesn't seem right.
 
number6. no offence but i think that first image is without the shader model. so no PS on the first one. but if you can prove me otherwise, feel free

edit:
ok im editing my post because i just checked the site and it says 2.0 for the first one also....

O_O
 
The bottom picture most defintely looks better [from what BB posted]. And yes, n69's first pic looks like it's lacking PS2.

Actually, BB, what you SHOULD have done was just post both pics and NOT tell us which was PS2 and PS3. That would have been intersting.

Now the question remains, does the lower pic look better SOLEY becuase of PS3, and if not, can we expect to see such IQ fidelity on the X800. Also, what kind of performance hit [if any] are we going to take becuase if PS3.

So far, I'll say I'm impressed, but I'll withhold judgement at this point. PS3's got my interst, just not my dollar...yet.
 
Originally posted by Bad_Boy
number6. no offence but i think that first image is without the shader model. so no PS on the first one. but if you can prove me otherwise, feel free.

No I think they're right, but its still not going to give an accurate comparison as the shots are using VS3.0 features like displacement mapping which is gonna make those textures look a hell of a lot more 3d
 
Originally posted by Bad_Boy
number6. no offence but i think that first image is without the shader model. so no PS on the first one. but if you can prove me otherwise, feel free

edit:
ok im editing my post because i just checked the site and it says 2.0 for the first one also....

O_O

Click on the link the site is in another language, they label the top as PS2.0 and the bottom as PS3.0.
 
on the site you posted with the 2.0 vs 3.0
under the pics it says

UPDATE

Molto probabilmente si tratta di un fake, dato che abilitando i PS2.0 la grafica non è così scarna.

can somebody translate this??
it might be shader 0.0 we are looking at on the first one

---------
i gotta say the 2.0 from bit-tech and the one from the link you posted look very similar as do both the 3.0's
 
Originally posted by Bad_Boy
on the site you posted with the 2.0 vs 3.0
under the pics it says

UPDATE

Molto probabilmente si tratta di un fake, dato che abilitando i PS2.0 la grafica non è così scarna.

can somebody translate this??
it might be shader 0.0 we are looking at on the first one

---------
i gotta say the 2.0 from bit-tech and the one from the link you posted look very similar as do both the 3.0's

It's Italian, I think it might be a fake.



:: FarCry: PS2.0 Vs PS3.0 .:: 15/Aprile/2004
They begin to fioccare in net the screen of FarCry with qualifies you the PS3.0, thanks to the famous one patch that it would have had to qualify them.
Next to the beginning it was believed that it added alone the support to the cards that Ultra support them (at the moment only the 6800), but instead from how much it can be observed from the two screen under being are differences enough:


Pixel Shader 2.0



Pixel Shader 3.0





UPDATE

A lot probably draft of a fake, since qualifying the PS2.0 the diagram is not therefore scarna.
 
anybody take italian III+ ? lol
i took french so i cant help on this translation.
 
Originally posted by Bad_Boy
anybody take italian III+ ? lol
i took french so i cant help on this translation.

Did you read my post? :rolleyes:

I translated it for you, it's Italian.
 
Originally posted by number69
Did you read my post? :rolleyes:

I translated it for you, it's Italian.

Somebody who knows italian needs to translate the last part as altavista wont
 
Originally posted by SnakEyez187
Yeah like its not possible for you to go to altavista yourself and see the translation :rolleyes:

Uh, ok, apparently that joke went totally over your head buddy.

I meant altavista's translations are usually so horrible that it's a good thing it didn't go through.

:rolleyes:
 
yeah i read your post, im still kinda confused if its a fake or not.

look at the two 2.0 pics
and the two 3.0 pics

they look awfully similar
 
Translation!
UPDATE

"Molto probabilmente si tratta di un fake, dato che abilitando i PS2.0 la grafica non è così scarna. "


Ok, i'm not italian but i work for a italian company and understand it a litle....

"Probably it is a FAKE, since using PS2.0 the grafic is not like the first picture."

That is what the text means, not exact words but that is the real meaning.

I do agree since using PS2.0 in my 9700 it doesn't look that bad, it is really identicall to the second picture :rolleyes:
 
thanks for the clarification bro ....i guess all we have to look off now is the bad quality shots from bit-tech :(
 
Originally posted by Bad_Boy
thanks for the clarification bro ....i guess all we have to look off now is the bad quality shots from bit-tech :(

I tried.
 
Well it didn't foolled me, i would look further in seeing that, because i'm at the watter pump level of the game and for me it looks way much more (to tell the truth EXACTLY) like the second picture, the fisrt one can be done with DX7 guys......
Just play any inside cave part of the game and u know.....
 
Originally posted by Santroph
Well it didn't foolled me, i would look further in seeing that, because i'm at the watter pump level of the game and for me it looks way much more (to tell the truth EXACTLY) like the second picture, the fisrt one can be done with DX7 guys......
Just play any inside cave part of the game and u know.....

shhh... don't ruin it... they'll stop looking
 
i hate to say it, but even with blurry/bad quality pictures from bit-tech, you can definately tell a diffrence, weather its a huge or small diffrence, i gotta say i like it. but ill wait to truly lay my opinion down as soon as we gett some better pics in here.

i wont base the 6800ultra vs x800XT solely off shader 3.0 support, but it WILL be a factor in my decision in june.
 
Bad boy pointed me to this thread, those comparison shots are one with no PS and the other with PS 3.0 and if you check the filenames they were ripped from PC perspective which you will find here http://www.pcper.com/comments.php?nid=145 they were also discussed in Beyond 3D.

There have been no comparisons between PS2.0 and PS3.0 to date.

Edit: if u notice those are the pics that you saw on bit tech and think why was the comparison between no PS and PS3.0 surely they would comnpare to PS2.0 to show how much better it is.
 
Originally posted by creedAMD
shhh... don't ruin it... they'll stop looking

Hey man I run FC on a 5600NU [pre-flip chip even, didn't get something more powerful since the Williamete would just bottleneck it], that's pretty much what it looks like to me lol.
 
Originally posted by crazyspike
Bad boy pointed me to this thread, those comparison shots are one with no PS and the other with PS 3.0 and if you check the filenames they were ripped from PC perspective which you will find here http://www.pcper.com/comments.php?nid=145 they were also discussed in Beyond 3D.

There have been no comparisons between PS2.0 and PS3.0 to date.

i pointed you to this thread... (the one your fucking posting in)
if you even read the first page you would realize it. the only comparison of ps2 and ps3 ARE on the first page.

and there is a diffrence.

edit: the comparison on bit-tech WAS ps2.0 vs ps3.0
you need to read more. they are from the nvidia show so they are legit.
 
How do you know that displacement mapping is adding the little bit that you see? You do know that the 420 is going to add that too right?
 
That's pretty clearly not a comparison between PS2.0 and PS3.0. Anyone with a card that does functional PS2.0 knows the water and lighting do not look like this.
In fact, I believe the water pixel shading is a PS1.1 effect, meaning the comparison pictures are almost certainly comparing a card running no pixel shading to a card running PS3.0.
 
creedAMD no need to be picky, i dont know anything else
besides

those images on bit-tech WERE ps2.0 vs 3.0. and thats what im comparing off of. and so far we know nothing about the r420 so frankly i dont know why the fuck your asking me about as if i would have some special ability to find that out for you.

and from looking at the small, bad quality pics from bit-tech, i can CLEARLY see that there is difference between the two. and from what i see, is that i like it. hate me for it, i dont care. all ill say right now, is that i like what i see so far from bad quality pics, and i hope to see better quality ones to compare more.
 
Originally posted by Bad_Boy
i pointed you to this thread... (the one your fucking posting in)
if you even read the first page you would realize it. the only comparison of ps2 and ps3 ARE on the first page.

and there is a diffrence.

edit: the comparison on bit-tech WAS ps2.0 vs ps3.0
you need to read more. they are from the nvidia show so they are legit.

especially when you are WRONG. look at the other thread, even with bad quallity pics you can definately see a diffrence between PS2.0 and PS3.0 ...and thats all i gotta say about that.

The above quote was from (Vampire:BL + nV Shader 3.0 = pissed ATI) not this one and you told me too come here, and the comparisons you showed according to a lot of technical folks over at beyond 3d are not ps2.0 and ps3.0 they are none ps and ps3.0 but hey im not that technical and I rely on what they say and even democoder thinks its non PS and he went to that event too.
 
Originally posted by leukotriene
That's pretty clearly not a comparison between PS2.0 and PS3.0. Anyone with a card that does functional PS2.0 knows the water and lighting do not look like this.
In fact, I believe the water pixel shading is a PS1.1 effect, meaning the comparison pictures are almost certainly comparing a card running no pixel shading to a card running PS3.0.

wtf pictures are you looking at???? im talking about the 1st two pictures on the first post of this thread. ill post them again if it makes you happy. i know now that those other pics from pcper are no ps and ps3.0, but the ones from bit-tech are clearly ps2.0, and ps3.0
 
Back
Top