• Some users have recently had their accounts hijacked. It seems that the now defunct EVGA forums might have compromised your password there and seems many are using the same PW here. We would suggest you UPDATE YOUR PASSWORD and TURN ON 2FA for your account here to further secure it. None of the compromised accounts had 2FA turned on.
    Once you have enabled 2FA, your account will be updated soon to show a badge, letting other members know that you use 2FA to protect your account. This should be beneficial for everyone that uses FSFT.

Finding the best VM solution for my setup.

N

nowwhatnapster

Limp Gawd
2FA
Joined
Aug 9, 2009
Messages
406
I am still up in the air to whether or not I should use ESXi or Windows7 + VMWare or possibly some other combination.

Here is my current situation: (Sorry if its long winded, you need to understand where I am coming from)

Currently I have a WHS machine performing NAS and backup duty for my LAN. Unfortunately, I am experiencing some silent data corruption due to the use of my Adaptec 5405 and the ASUS P5N-D motherboard. I previously had a GA-P35-DS3L motherboard in the server and that "definitly" gave me silent data corruption. It's been a learning experience and I am realizing most desktop grade motherboards were never designed to hold anything but a graphics card in their PCI-E slots.

Moving on, I used to host a game server on my WHS machine, however, due to demigrator issues WHS placed too many IOPS on the raid 5 array which inturn caused lag in the game server. So I decided as a short term solution to move my game server to my workstation inside a virtual machine. My workstation is currently using Windows 7 Pro, so I shoved the game server inside the "XP Mode" and gave it a dedicated hard drive and NIC and that solved the lag. Unfortunately, now I have to keep my workstation on 24/7 until I get my server fixed.

I have decided to build a completely new server. The specs are as follows:
  • (new) ASUS P6T6 WS Pro
  • (new) Xeon W3550
  • (new) 6GB ECC DDR1333
  • (old) Adaptec 5405 Raid 5 - 4x500GB WD-RE3 (NAS for LAN)
  • (old) 2TB Sata (for backup of Raid 5)
  • (old) 1.5TB Sata (for second backup of Raid 5)
  • (old) 500GB Sata (game server)
  • (old) Seasonic M12 700w
  • (old) Norco RPC-470 w/ I-Star 4 in 3 backplain
  • (planned) Norco RPC-4220
  • (planned) 4x250GB Sata Raid 10(game server drives)

I will have some time to play with the new server hardware while my old server is still running. When I migrate my Raid 5 array to the new machine then I will decomission the old server. This should fix the silent data corruption with the Adaptec 5405. I see no reason why it wont work in this board.

So that leaves me with figuring out the OS and what drives to store it on.

Option 1: It seems the simplest option for me would be to purchase 2 drives for Raid 1 via the MOBO and set it up in the following fashion:
  • Host OS: Windows 7 64bit (For NAS) (On Raid 1)
  • Guest OS: CentOS 64bit (For Game Server) (On Raid 10)
  • Guest OS: WHS (If it works) (For LAN PC Backups) (On Raid 1)
This option seems a little less elegant than option 2 as the Host OS must be stable as two VM's are dependent on it. Not sure how I would perform a backup of all these machines. Seems a little messy, I suppose Windows 7's built in backup feature could be configured to backup itself and the two VM's.

Option 2: Would be to try ESXi. Install that on a spare 40GB drive I have kicking around? Not really sure how hard it is to backup or restore the ESXi install. Then the following VM's:
  • Windows 7 Pro (For NAS) (On Raid 1 partitioned)
  • CentOS 64-bit (For Game server) (On Raid 10)
  • WHS (If it works) (For LAN PC Backups) (On Raid 1 partitioned)
Seems a little more safe, but I am not familiar with ESXi so initial setup might be rough. I believe there are some tools out there to backup the VM's easily? I could be wrong.

Option 3: Your suggestions...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top