Finally getting an MP3 Player! Help?

ditzilla

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 17, 2006
Messages
421
So, I've been to so many sites, read reviews, made notes and at this point my head's going to explode. I'm looking to get my first MP3 player. I'm older (52) so I'm tech challenged, also I'm on my own with this -- there isn't anyone here to ask How do I, Which One should I, etc. Only one friend of mine has had a player, that was an iPod and she went through way too much with hers.

Therefore, I come to you to ask your advice and guidance. To my Do's and Don'ts:

I don't want:

an iPod, Zune or anything else expensive (have maybe $100 to spend total);
anything that needs special software or services in order to use it;
anything I have to "mess with" with firmware updates and that sort of thing;
HDD based;
for my plea for help to in any way turn into a flame war ... I really do want and need your help, but please don't bicker :) It would give me the awful guilts.

I do want:
flash based;
would actually prefer one that uses regular batteries;
ability to get music from my computer to the player using WMP 11 (my own CDs), perhaps a service - Rhapsody or eMusic (any feedback on these is also welcome);
I'd love to be able to use an SD card, but didn't see that option except for one I looked at.

Now, this will more than likely be coming from Wally World (online at that). Why?! Because I have a gift card for $50. And they deliver since there's not one close by. And this is the only reason I can even consider splurging on one.

I believe I only need 1 to 2 gig -- I'll be using this anywhere from 2 to 6 hours a day 5 or 6 days a week for a huge gardening project. I'm going to need something to help keep me somewhat sane. I'll be up and down, so a lanyard is not an option - I'd hang myself or get it tangled in shrubs, keeping it in a pocket isn't really a good option either. I'm going to need an armband (or speaker?).

Here's the ones I am thinking about on the site (* next to the ones I'm really interested in, thus voices of experience with these sought):

http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.do?product_id=4768013
* SanDisk Sansa 1 GB - uses regular AAA batteries and has the arm band - that could come in handy, and I think SanDisk is the only one that provides it (older models at least).

http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.do?product_id=5272620
Creative MuVo V100 1 GB - uses AAA batteries

* http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.do?product_id=4659585
Creative Zen Nano Plus 1 GB - uses AAA, has the armband and something I think is really neat (if it works) - the line-in so I could record from my CD player

http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.do?product_id=5375521
Creative Zen V Plus 2 GB MP3 Video Player
The 2 GB is nice, that's alot! of music. But I doubt I'd ever use anything else. On the other hand, it's pink ... yes I am a girl:p

http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.do?product_id=5774428
SanDisk Sansa Shaker 512MB -- does this thing actually work? can the pre-recorded songs be erased? -- this one does take SD cards ... and has a built-in speaker.

This is just for music. I can't be taking the time to stop and look at pictures or video when I'm working on the garden, and my eyes aren't that great - which is really what first attracted me to the Zen V Plus. The screen looks easily readable!

Again, I'd be putting music from CDs, perhaps a music service or if this is possible:

I've been slowly, using Audacity and my boombox, recording/uploading old cassettes, then burning them onto CDs. I'm saving them as WAV. These are my old aerobics tapes that I made. They're mixes (once upon a time had 2 pitch control turntables/mixer, etc. - I am of the analog generation), so there's no stop or pause -- it's an hour to an hour and a half of straight music.

I've saved the Audacity format, so I think? I should be able to resave these as MP3 if needs be. Would it be even possible to send something that long music-wise to whatever player I get? WMP has them in My Library, but as "Unknown Artist" and all the tapes I've gotten done are listed under that - they are named there, but I can't change the main Title.

Thanks to any and all who read this for your patience and your advice!
 
I've owned a Creative Zen Nano Plus 1 GB. Must say it was a very nice player but i needed more storage. Really easy to use. I just plugged it into my pc then found its folder on My Computer. All you do is copy and paste your WMA / MP3 files into the folder and hey presto. Only downside is if you want to change an album your in it stops the track you are listening to. Hope this helps. Any other questions feel free to PM me.
 
The Zen Stone or Zen Stone Plus sounds perfect for you.

They are flash based and getting music on the player is as easy as dragging and dropping. It shows up in "My Computer" as a removable hard drive so there's no software to install or sync managers to mess with. The stone has 1 gig of memory and is $30 shipped at buy.com after using google checkout and $40 everywhere else (like Wallyworld). The stone plus is going to be around $65 and has 2 gig memory, a small screen, fm tuning/recording, mic recording, stopwatch, and clock.

Personally I would stay away from anything that uses AAA batteries.

Those sansa players are nice, I'd also check out Cowon Audio's players. www.anythingbutipod.com is a great site to read some unbiased reviews as well. Good luck.
 
cowon iaudio u2, comes in 1gb or 2gb. Been using two units for ages now and I love them for the sound quality. Great bass. Tons of options and a simple drag and drop interface and plenty of info on the screen. Tiny too. Newegg has them I think.
 
Any of the zens. Get one used for really cheap, or get on of the higher end zens for a good price around $100.
 
I really like the Sony Walkman MP3 player, but I'm in the minority.

It has some annoying quirks, and the PC software is kind buggy, but I really like the interface design. Decent sound quality too.
 
Back
Top