Finally, a Civil War FPS!

I STILL wish they'd come up with a ironclad/civil war ship battles simulator someday...If done right, it could be really fun.
Anyhow, i'd play a civil war FPS if done right and IF was sufficiently randomized to provide replayability. Everyone nowadays wants all the awesome firepower and fast guns in FPS, but taking it slower would (as the poster a few a posts above mentions) make it more immersive and more tactical imho.
 
any historically accurate cival war FPS sounds extremely boring to me...



line up in a line

shoot your gun

hope it goes strait

spend 45 seconds reloading

repeat 100,000 times
 
coolxboxgamer said:
they had machine guns in the civil war btw.....
The automatic weaponry they had was primitive, very large, and cumbersome to move. In other words: boring in a game.
 
dotK said:
The automatic weaponry they had was primitive, very large, and cumbersome to move. In other words: boring in a game.

Why's it boring? Because you can't run amuck slaughtering anyone you want without having to use any kind of a strategy?
 
ScreamingBroccoli said:
Melee combat in Riddick was awesome

What a shock huh.... a game from a movie that's fucking fantastic. In fact, the game blows the movie way out of the water.
 
texuspete00 said:
What a shock huh.... a game from a movie that's fucking fantastic. In fact, the game blows the movie way out of the water.

Technically it's not based on the movie. It's a prequel or something (I've never watched the movie, I saw pitch black tho). The game was great :)
 
Stiler said:
Why's it boring? Because you can't run amuck slaughtering anyone you want without having to use any kind of a strategy?
You do realize you would basically sit in one spot and mow down a row of enemies, right? The kind of stuff that you can find in flash based games. There would be no strategy to it - spray and pray.
 
I'm curious as to how this game was pitched to the execs at Activision. I mean a Civil War FPS? Come on...

Developer: "So we have this great new idea for an FPS: Battlefield 1863! It will feature an exciting new combat system never before seen in PC gaming! The player will participate in authentic line-up and shoot combat! Weapons will be historically accurate, taking almost 30 seconds to reload and garunteeing 90% of twitchy FPS gamers will be mashing their 'R' key until it breaks out of frustration."

Activision Executive: "BRILLIANT! Here is eleventy billion dollars to develop this game!"
 
dotK said:
You do realize you would basically sit in one spot and mow down a row of enemies, right? The kind of stuff that you can find in flash based games. There would be no strategy to it - spray and pray.

as i stated before they had machine guns in the civil war.... but they also had some dam good snipers too.... and they could easily pick off a machine gunner because those things were huge and you had to be out in the open, and btw you couldnt just turn it on a dime either (sneaking up ????) theres a ton of ways to defeat machine guns...... although if they place them in realllllllly gay places and you have a lot of people guarding them it could be a problem...
 
coolxboxgamer said:
as i stated before they had machine guns in the civil war.... but they also had some dam good snipers too.... and they could easily pick off a machine gunner because those things were huge and you had to be out in the open, and btw you couldnt just turn it on a dime either (sneaking up ????) theres a ton of ways to defeat machine guns...... although if they place them in realllllllly gay places and you have a lot of people guarding them it could be a problem...


your knowledge of the civil war is miserable at best...


i suggest reading some Foote, then coming back to this thread
 
In order to cut down the repetition of long reload times between shots, they should incorporate weapons from the American West. These may include (but are not limited to) carbines, revolvers and other repeating rifles. And yes, I am thinking Gattling gun too.
 
Personally, i think alot of people nowadays seem to have the attention span of a 4-year old imho. If they can't win or beat a game in as short as time as possible, then it's not good. My brother won't play anything unless he can wreck it or finish it quick and he's 40+ lol.
Sometimes, taking your time makes the game better rather than racing through it honestly. Fast games have their niche, but so do slower ones.
And as was said, civil war battles were at times just as intense and bloody as any ww1 or 2 battles, so a game could be done if done right. If not, then it would probably sink to the bottom like a stone in fun.
 
kamxam said:
Personally, i think alot of people nowadays seem to have the attention span of a 4-year old imho. If they can't win or beat a game in as short as time as possible, then it's not good. My brother won't play anything unless he can wreck it or finish it quick and he's 40+ lol.
Sometimes, taking your time makes the game better rather than racing through it honestly. Fast games have their niche, but so do slower ones.
And as was said, civil war battles were at times just as intense and bloody as any ww1 or 2 battles, so a game could be done if done right. If not, then it would probably sink to the bottom like a stone in fun.

qft, I'm usually on the other end of the fence, I've grown tired of games like Quake/UT and the fast-paced shooters. Much more a fan of games like Rainbow six/Ghost recon/operation flashpoint/Red Orchestra and such.
 
kamxam said:
Personally, i think alot of people nowadays seem to have the attention span of a 4-year old imho. If they can't win or beat a game in as short as time as possible, then it's not good. My brother won't play anything unless he can wreck it or finish it quick and he's 40+ lol.
Sometimes, taking your time makes the game better rather than racing through it honestly. Fast games have their niche, but so do slower ones.
And as was said, civil war battles were at times just as intense and bloody as any ww1 or 2 battles, so a game could be done if done right. If not, then it would probably sink to the bottom like a stone in fun.

Some people actually have personal lives which include having a family for that matter and want a game that is quick and easy to get in and out because of this. Maybe once you are 40 you will understand this, or do you envision yourself as being playing games all day when you are 40?

That being said, I do not see how a realistic civil war game would be fun at all for the reasons already pointed out in this thread.
 
BladeX said:
Some people actually have personal lives which include having a family for that matter and want a game that is quick and easy to get in and out because of this. Maybe once you are 40 you will understand this, or do you envision yourself as being playing games all day when you are 40?

That being said, I do not see how a realistic civil war game would be fun at all for the reasons already pointed out in this thread.

.........

Just because a game isn't quick fast paced and easy doesn't mean you can't enjoy it or HAVE to play it all day, wtf?

Most people I know that like games like Operation flashpoint and such are 30+ years old with families/jobs, not kids/teens that have no commitment or such to anything and can play all the time.
 
oooooooooh how I've waited to play in a game where one side marches towards you and the other takes aim and fires cannons lol.
 
Or you can have a game where you have the other side hiding in the trees and coming at you through the woods, while your guys are are trying to get into position for a good shot. Or your sniper sneaking behind enemy lines and taking out the cannons that are giving you grief. Or sneaking into the city while the enemy is pounding you with artillery and doing house to house fighting. As i said, if done RIGHT, it could be fun.
The civil war wasn't just 2 sides lining up and shooting each other all the time although it did happen. It had city skirmishes, woodland battles, naval engagements,ect;. Everything that the more FUN wars had according to popular opinion.
Also, playing games is what you make of it. I have a full-time job, a nice girl, a social life, and yet i still play games when i have the time. As long as you don't let it rule your life, there's no harm in having fun, especially if your better half plays too... :)
 
Can you be the south (didn't read the article) and if so how woudl the ending be like?
 
Back
Top