Finalized my new build.. critique please!

Sasiki

2[H]4U
Joined
Apr 10, 2005
Messages
2,818
CPU - Core 2 Duo e4300 - $113.50 @ ZZF
Board - ASUS P5K - $151.08 @ xpcgear.com
P/S - Corsair 620hx - $119.49 after $20 MIR - Buy.com
GPU - Evga 640mb $295.49 after $30 MIR - Buy.com
RAM - Corsair Twin2x2048-6400 2gb DDR2 - $88 after $30 MIR - ZZF

Total before rebates $847.56
Total AFTER rebates $767.56

First off, is Buy.com and xpcgear.com reputable online retailers? I've never dealt with either. The total price includes shipping. I really don't think the prices will fall on much of this hardware in the near future, so I think I'm safe there. All of the components seem like they'd work well together. I'm not going to heavily overclock, so I think the P5K vanilla will suffice. Am I wrong?

Any changes I should make regarding hardware or vendor selection? The reasoning for the e4300 is the anticipation of the quad core price drop this summer.

Thanks in advance.

I'm trying to do this on a semi-budget. No set number, basically as cheap as I can without sacrificing performance.
 
I think the sweet spot in the C2D line right now is the E6420. 2.13 Ghz stock, but with a reasonably good cooler (Tuniq Tower, Thermalright 120 Extreme, ~$50 and you can use it on the quad when you get it, so it's not like money thrown away) almost all of them will hit 3.2Ghz (which will give you DDR2-800 if you link/sync, therefor the memory is plenty fast too) with 1.4 vcore, idle 30-35C, load below 60C, often mid to low 50's. An E6420 is\ $190 at Newegg last I checked.

That said, if you need to drop cash anywhere, that $70 is the place to drop it. You lose 400 Mhz, but you can probably make that up and more by overclocking without too much trouble. Pushing over 3.1, 3.2Ghz with the 4300... dunno. Pushing over 3.2 with the 6420, easy. There are of course bad chips out there that won't do well, but it doesn't seem a common thing... and the quad cores will come down soon, regardless, so you have that option in 5, 6 months if you want it.

A GTX would obviously be preferable to a GTS, but if you can't justify another $200 I certainly understand that. Of the GTS's I'd definitely go with the 640 though.

Consider a 680i SLI board -- with the new Geforce cards coming out (supposedly) in Q4 of this year, you should see a big price drop on the 8800GTS, so you can get another if it appears to struggle with newer stuff and put them in SLI. I got an EVGA because they have very good customer service and RMA policy. Register the board in the first 30 days, pay $30, and if something goes wrong they will cross-ship you a new board and pay shipping both ways.
 
It is still not known though if the 680i will support the 45nm Penryn chips though, is it? I'm trying to get it set up to last me 4 years like this PC has. athlon 2500+ and 9800 Pro haha.

Edit: My reasoning for the e4300 is something cheap to get me by for the Q6600 price drop. I'm coming from an athlon 2500+, so i should be able to deal with the e4300 for a couple/few months.
 
Yeah, that's the way to go then. You can still go quad on the 680i, though, and no, it's not known if they will support the 45nm chips, but it's a risk I'm willing to take. I think a high end quad, once they come down, should hold me for 2 years or so, and I normally build about every 2 years (though this last build lasted me a little more than 2 and a half). The machine in my sig is about a week old now, so I'm pretty much parroting the reasoning I used to get here at this point. The idea is I can go SLI with 2 GTX's once they come down (9000 series comes out) and I'll be able to keep playing current stuff for a good while, I hope, and when I start to feel the processor is a bottleneck worth considering in 6 + months I can drop a quad core in, no more problems there either. Then watercool the GTX's. Of all the current hardware, I do think it's the best/longest lasting upgrade path. I'm counting on the video being the bottleneck, not the CPU, but even if the CPU is, I can still do something, and the 680i may end up supporting the 45nm chips... and then I win all around.

Also, I personally would buy everything from Newegg. Their shipping rates are really good, and often the shipping elsewhere more than makes up for the /sometimes/ higher price at Newegg. Plus they don't screw around, and if you get dead stuff RMAing is not hellish. I trust them, which is something I can't say about any other online retailers.

If you do go with an Intel board (and thusly do not have the option of SLI in the long run) I really would consider a GTX. Just like you got the 9800, it's a certain degree of futureproofing. Of course, the other route to take it to get the 320 GTS or even a 7900 series card around $150 and wait for the 9000 series in Q4 before you go DX-10.
 
Back
Top