File server selection

Rakinos

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jul 31, 2001
Messages
1,520
I've decided to finally make a good fileserver for my home network. I originally was thinking along the lines of udat (many hard drives, small case) but I decided that it would be too difficult to have small, fast, and quiet with that form factor. So I've decided on fast and quiet. For the case I'm thinking something like this. I was originally thinking hotswap, but I can't justify the cost for how little I would be "swapping." The next issue is the motherboard. It has to have gigabit as I will be using it to store dvd rips and other media, this decision shouldn't be too hard but is dependant on the next component, the raid controller.
I want your guy's opinion on this one: is hardware raid worth it? I'm thinking raid 5 in case of disk failure + an extra disk or two for weekly backup in case of user failure (others in the household accidentally deleting a file). I'm also torn as to what interface I should use. pci-x (= more expensive motherboard, but cheaper card) vs pci express (= cheaper motherboard, but more expensive card). There is also the option of a pci-x card in a pci slot, but I fear that it would be too much of a bottleneck.
As for hard drives, I'm thinking starting with 4, 500gb disks, with definite plans on throwing more in later down the road (can you expand a software raid like you can w. a hardware raid?). Because of this the raid controller also needs more than four sata connectors, which drives the price up even more :(.
Thoughts on amd v. intel & mem amount (I'm thinking somewhere around 512 to a gig) would also be greatly appreciated.

tltr:
It's a fileserver
-what mobo (needs gigabit)?
-raid hardware raid 5 worth it?
-which raid card w/ more than 4 connectors (pci-x vs pci express)?
-intel or amd?
-how much memory?
 
I made a little spark notes at the end, so hopefully someone has some thoughts and can at least give help answer some of my questions.
 
Well I can tell you this, for a home network nothing will be really a bottleneck on a server besides the network interface.

You really only need raid 5, PCI-X, etc. for file servers that are being accessed by many many users at once. If you put all that on a small user server it will just sit there going to waste as it is meant for simulataneous, not single user use.

I would say for data security go with Raid 1 (mirroring). Find a good hardware SATA card and PCI is most likely fine. It will save you money and you will see the same performance for a small user group.

To give you an idea, my home file server is:
Old Intel Mainboard w/350mhz Processor
Single SATA Drive
256mb RAM
Gigabyte PCI Card

I get the same speeds for transfers and such on that machine as I do on my main file server that I have simply because it was from a old job:
Dual Pentium 3 500s
PCI-X SCSI RAID 1
3x 15,000 RPM 36 GB HDDs (2 in RAID, 1 Hot Spare)
Gigabyte NIC
768mb RAM

The difference would only come in if a ton of people were using the files at the same time, then the SCSI, PCI-X, etc. would come in and help.


I hope this helps a bit in your decision process :)
 
Do you think that a motherboard with gigabit would be needed? I'm worried that having a raid card and a gigabit nic would saturate the pci bus. I would be doing raid 5 less from a performance increase and more from a redundancy standpoint that doesn't require me to sacrifice half of my hard drive space.
 
My thoughts on it (building one myself at the moment):
[this assumes your running a Linux or BSD {not windows} based OS]

Processor doesn't really matter. A Pent 200Mhz should be able to keep up, but any old proc you got around should be fine.

Memory: 256-512 should be enough.
 
If I'm getting a motherboard that already has 6+ onboard sata connectors, the chances are that it already has gigabit lan onboard. What I'm curious about is if I could use an older motherboard (my old Asus a7v333 w/athlon xp 1800) with a pci raid card and pci gigabit and not worry about saturating the bus. I would like to be able to have more of my media just stored on another computer and not have too much of a noticable slowdown in read/write.
 
It will not make that big of a difference. My server with the SCSI in it has a PCI Gigabit Card and it is still fast.

You will never obtain the equivalent of working with local disks, just remember that. There will ALWAYS be more of a delay and slow down as it is over the network and does not come close to as fast as locally accessing the drives.
 
If I'm getting a motherboard that already has 6+ onboard sata connectors, the chances are that it already has gigabit lan onboard. What I'm curious about is if I could use an older motherboard (my old Asus a7v333 w/athlon xp 1800) with a pci raid card and pci gigabit and not worry about saturating the bus. I would like to be able to have more of my media just stored on another computer and not have too much of a noticable slowdown in read/write.

For a home network you'd be fine running that old xp system as long as the stuff works ok. Check the caps on the board to make sure they are good and use it.
 
Back
Top