Figuring out which x79 board...

kur1j

Gawd
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
682
There are several boards from Asus that look almost the same. Same goes for the MSI boards. Anyone have a recommendation over any of them?

ASUS P9X79 WS
ASUS P9X79 Deluxe
ASUS P9X79 PRO
MSI X79A-GD65 (8D)
MSI X79A-GD65(8D)


They are almost all the same it seems.
 
This is [h], go rampage or go home.

Loljk.

They have different external ports, bluetooth/no bluetooth different PCIe slot layout, and probably different little things here and there. Also, there are probably differences in the power phases, some probably have more or less phases depending on how much overclockability they're intended for. I havent looked too closely, but what i've noted is typical of the differences between asus boards.
 
different features, find the one that has the features you want/dont need and buy that one.
 
This is [h], go rampage or go home.

Loljk.

They have different external ports, bluetooth/no bluetooth different PCIe slot layout, and probably different little things here and there. Also, there are probably differences in the power phases, some probably have more or less phases depending on how much overclockability they're intended for. I havent looked too closely, but what i've noted is typical of the differences between asus boards.

Lol if you can find em! Sold out everywhere. What I cant understand is why chips never sell out but boards are continuously out of stock. Most people typically buy one chip per 1 board. But it seems Asus never makes enough motherboards.
 
I bought it but i needed more sata ports and pci slots. Where the hell is the ud7? Why is this assassin board not selling out but the asus one sold out in 10 minutes.
 
Last edited:
Hey look somebody put a squirt gun on that board where a heat sink was supposed to be.

Seriously though I have agonized over buying the SB-E until I read the review at xbitlabs. The final page had some very insightful criticism for Intel regarding them rushing this to market incomplete. Thoughts came flooding back about the first round of boards that went on the market for the 1155 SB and the recall that followed. I will wait till all the bugs are ironed out and the prices to fall a bit.
 
Lol if you can find em! Sold out everywhere. What I cant understand is why chips never sell out but boards are continuously out of stock. Most people typically buy one chip per 1 board. But it seems Asus never makes enough motherboards.

You're assuming that they motherboard manufacturers are releasing one motherboard for every CPU that Intel or AMD ships out. Clearly, that's not always the case.
 
The gun is cheesy but at least you wont really be able to see it when you populate it with cards.
 
I am also trying to decide on which board. In fact I am trying to decide if the x79 is worth the upgrade. I crunch data for a living and outside of a occasional game of solitaire while a query is running, I don't have time to game.

Typically, I build a decent system and skip every other generation of CPU and chipset. My current setup is I7-960 on an X58. So, following my typical pattern, I am due. Also, I would like to upgrade to get away from using the Marvel SATA controller for SATA 6gbs. I would like to raid a couple SATA 6gbs SSD drives. But, I have had too many issues with the Marvel controller.

So, my choices are the same as others with a X58 system:
A: Upgrade the the X79 at the higher price point (if so which MB)
B: Upgrade to a X67/68 at a moderate price point (if so which MB)
C: Sit back and wait until March for IVY and hope it outperforms today's X79

Ahhh, decisions, decisions...................
 
I am trying to find a place to get the Rampage IV Extreme as well. I was going to go for the Gigabyte, until I saw that it only had 4 slots for ram as compared to ASUS's 8, that and the gun looks really cheesy on there.
 
I am trying to find a place to get the Rampage IV Extreme as well. I was going to go for the Gigabyte, until I saw that it only had 4 slots for ram as compared to ASUS's 8, that and the gun looks really cheesy on there.

Your not going to find the Rampage IV in stock for probably like 2 months. <<<<<<<---------------------- LOL read my post below this one. Talk about irony kicking me in the nuts.

I went through the same thing with the Max IV. ROG boards apparently are made with teleporters on them so they vaporize into "Out of stock mode" the very 1 min they are placed in stock at retailers.
 
Last edited:
Okay Tiger direct had or has a few ROG boards in stock. I just bought one. Good luck!
 
I got one on Tiger Direct as well, but I don't know if that means they are in stock or not their website doesn't say. Cheaper than the one on Amazon, too!
 
I got one on Tiger Direct as well, but I don't know if that means they are in stock or not their website doesn't say. Cheaper than the one on Amazon, too!

The regular Rampage IV is a pre-order and the one bundled with BF3 there was like 15 left in stock when I called 20 minutes ago.
 
Hey look somebody put a squirt gun on that board where a heat sink was supposed to be.

Seriously though I have agonized over buying the SB-E until I read the review at xbitlabs. The final page had some very insightful criticism for Intel regarding them rushing this to market incomplete. Thoughts came flooding back about the first round of boards that went on the market for the 1155 SB and the recall that followed. I will wait till all the bugs are ironed out and the prices to fall a bit.

Hahaha squirt gun. :D

I looked up the xbitlabs article you referred to and it made me feel better about the fact that I was leaning toward not doing an x79 upgrade. I slapped together a wish list with a mobo (the G1.Assassin) and a CPU, GTX 580 and some RAM and it came to $1650. Just not worth it at this time. Buyer's remorse is expensive.
 
anyone have info on asrock's mobos? i see the extreme4 on sale at newegg, but i'm kinda annoyed that i can't find any reviews on it. Regardless I'm interested in the extreme9 yet theres almost no info on when it will be available or a review will come out. Anyone have any info they'd like to share? :D

I was looking at the p9x79 pro since i love asus's uefi bios and it has basically everything that i want. Does anyone know if gigabyte's uefi implementation is as pleasurable to use as asus's? I've never had a gigabyte mobo, so i can't even recall their bios.

asus p9x79 pro,gigabyte's ga-x79-ud5, or asrock's x79 extreme9, oh choices.
 
Yeah I set aside 2k for this upgrade and that's after I already bought a 580, and nice fat ssd and new p/s. Looks like at least the ssd will sit till next year sometime. Or they make some revisions to this platform to make it worth the jump.

That new Revo MGX and Dobyns finesse rod will get purchased this week, at least I will see some improvement in my other money sink and get outside while enjoying them.
 
anyone have info on asrock's mobos? i see the extreme4 on sale at newegg, but i'm kinda annoyed that i can't find any reviews on it. Regardless I'm interested in the extreme9 yet theres almost no info on when it will be available or a review will come out. Anyone have any info they'd like to share? :D

I was looking at the p9x79 pro since i love asus's uefi bios and it has basically everything that i want. Does anyone know if gigabyte's uefi implementation is as pleasurable to use as asus's? I've never had a gigabyte mobo, so i can't even recall their bios.

asus p9x79 pro,gigabyte's ga-x79-ud5, or asrock's x79 extreme9, oh choices.

this is my thinking. going for a 3930k tacks 400 on to my build and that assumes I'll stick with the integrated graphics to start
 
this is my thinking. going for a 3930k tacks 400 on to my build and that assumes I'll stick with the integrated graphics to start

The 3930 doesn't have integrated graphics. Unless you have found a mobo that does, and none of them I have seen do, I think that will not be an option for you.
 
The 3930 doesn't have integrated graphics. Unless you have found a mobo that does, and none of them I have seen do, I think that will not be an option for you.

That and I just figured out I have to buy a cpu cooler too.
 
Looks like Newegg got more boards late last night. I was able to snag a ASUS P9X79 WS at about 11PM CST. At the time, all 15 boards on Newegg's X79 list were in stock.
 
this is my thinking. going for a 3930k tacks 400 on to my build and that assumes I'll stick with the integrated graphics to start

If you are not aware the sandy e chips do not have integrated gpus maybe you need to reconsider purchasing this
 
Anyone know how loud the chipset fan is on the ASUS Rampage IV?

/wife is going to kill me...
 
Meh, X79 was a huge letdown. Performance upgrade is minimal at best, with Z68 prices dropping so low it makes NO sense to do this upgrade.

I'm not exactly sure what all of you expected. SB-E is not a new architecture, it is just a Sandy Bridge chip with 2 more cores and more cache and most games and software today are not able to fully utilize 6 and 8 core chips to their potential yet. In heavily multithreaded apps that are optimized for more than 4 cores though the 3930k and 3960x both perform extremely well. And even in gaming with the 3930k your basically getting a 990x Extreme Edition for <$600 so I don't see what there is to complain about.
 
I'd easily go for the Asus ROG Rampage IV Extreme. Asus hasn't let me down thus far and their RoG boards just seem to be the best of the best - no compromises! I too am on X58 and I was looking forward to X79, but I'm not sure I can justify the HUGE cost of entry to the platform for the performance increase. I'm thinking of waiting for a price drop or for Ivy Bridge-E. 2011 is the platform for me I think, but I'm not sure that SB-E is the place to join, at least right now.
 
prone to making video cards hard to get out, I have x58 ROG has same retension mechanisms. Going Gigabyte UD7.
 
prone to making video cards hard to get out, I have x58 ROG has same retension mechanisms. Going Gigabyte UD7.

How is it more difficult to remove the card? I have found our retention clips ( QSLOT ) to be much easier to remove a graphics card then on competitors boards? Especially when using standard Single GPU configs or dual slot spacing configurations for SLI or crossfire. This is due to the fact you can still depress the retention mechanism to remove the card on competitors generally you would have to reach under the card and hold and depress to then remove when can be more difficult inside a chassis. Please PM your feedback.
 
I hard a x58 board with same retension clips would not allow me to release the card even though I have clip pushed down (pins pci-e were wrecked as well as cpu socket was damaged). Regardless, I am going with gigabyte with 3d bios. I got the 3930K processor. Mind you the advantage of Asus is 1366 mounting socket, I am dissappointed of lack of coolers at launch. As well lack of quad ram in Canada. My last board died on windows update. My hard rive acked it in. As far as I am concerned. I have jumped ship to x79 and I want msi big bang to be released.
 
The X79 is for Digital Audio Workstations. Gamers don;t really need this Quad Channel RAM, but most DAW software is poorly optimized so the extra RAM Channels makes everything much easier to achieve more instances, more polyphony, etc.

In all honesty I have a powerful DSP rack so don;t need the 6 or 8 core stuff, and won't even use the 4U ATX chassis or ATX for that matter.
The Clevo X79 desktop replacement with the 3820 using 32GBs of RAM will make my set up time a snap, and save my back from carrying these 28U racks of gear around.

Gamers can probablky make use on an X79, but these are really for CAD, Video and Audio, and are a blessing in a laptop.

CiaoMein
 
Back
Top