Feel like giving some advice - read this!

Tin_10

Bad Trader/Returning Ban
Joined
Nov 7, 2004
Messages
796
Guys, this is my very first post, ever on the forums here, ive been reading posts on here daily, teaching me whats new and whats hot....... so I decided to become a member and ask a few questions! I was referred here by a friend many months ago, so I thought Id give u guys a shot!

I feel the need for speed....and want to do an upgrade, my wallet wants to speakout! Although I have the money to do it(which isnt that much, but worth me spending for an upgrade), I just want to know if what I have now and what I want to get will be a sufficent increase in performance. Here is my current setup.....

Abit NF7-s ver2 nforce 2 motherboard
Barton 2500+ with SLK-900 not oc'ed
3x 512 Corsair XMS pc2700 = 1.5gb ram in dual channel
Ati Radeon 9700 pro AIW 128mb
1 Western Digital 160gb 7200 rpm 2mb buffer ata100
1 Western Digital Raptor 10k rpm SATA 150
and then the misc items like cd-rw - DVD-rom fans, wireless nic

I am looking at doing the upgrade thing here, possibly going intel, but not for sure...what I need to ask is this, all I am going to upgrade right now is the MOBO/CPU/RAM, nothing else, my video card is a good card, and will be for some time IMO, and mainly because the prices are OUTRAGEOUS for them nowdays! So guys, being my first post, I hope u dont flame me, I really want to contribute my part to the forums, so please help me!

Thanks in advance!

THIS IS FOR A GAMING MACHINE, wanting to upgrade before the HL2 release, or do u think my system now will hang just fine with the current setup I have?

Also, doing a little editing to the orignal post, http://shop4.outpost.com/product/3974878 this is 1gb pc3200 Geil Ram for $139, tell me if this would be a good choice on ram?
 
well, i'm sorry to say, but any "major" upgrade would put ur video card as the bottleneck...so you might want to save up a little longer to afford an upgrade...the plain 6800 can be had for like $250-ish (not exactly sure) nowadays, so, you might want to look at that too....as for CPU/mobo/ram, you could get a s939 Athlon 64 3000+ and an ASUS A8V Deluxe...as for RAM, PDP Systems 1GB (2x512) PC3200 with really nice timings for like $180 on newegg...

if you wanted to go intel (i'd reccommend the AMD), i'm not EXACTLY sure what to get, but you could get like a 2.8 or 3.0...not sure about mobo, and RAM you could stick with the same...

hope that helps!

alex
 
if you are going for a good current-grade upgrade, go for a64, it smacks the pants off teh XP line, even if its only the 2800+

you really dont need 1.5gb of ram, and even if you did, you can only run 2 or 4 sticks in dual channel, not 3. id go for a nice set of pc3200 (there really isnt much of aprice diff between 2700 and 3200, might as well go for the higher) with tight timings, as a64 LOVES low latency, and so does aXP for that matter. i just invested 250 bucks in a gig set of PQI dimms based on the samsung TCCD chips (2-2-2-5)

since it seems you are operating on a fairly restricting budget( the aXP and 2700 choices), i would def not recommend a raptor. go for one, larger current gen 7200rpm drive, they are almost as fast as a raptor, quieter, and much less expensive.

as for cd rom drives, go for the NEC 16x dual layer peice, its a nice one so ive heard, and its only 70 bucks at the egg. for the second drive, get a cheap DVDrom drive, so you can copy dvd's on the fly much easier.

i agree that the 9700 is still a good card, especially since you already have it.

hope this helps!
 
lithium726 said:
if you are going for a good current-grade upgrade, go for a64, it smacks the pants off teh XP line, even if its only the 2800+

you really dont need 1.5gb of ram, and even if you did, you can only run 2 or 4 sticks in dual channel, not 3. id go for a nice set of pc3200 (there really isnt much of aprice diff between 2700 and 3200, might as well go for the higher) with tight timings, as a64 LOVES low latency, and so does aXP for that matter. i just invested 250 bucks in a gig set of PQI dimms based on the samsung TCCD chips (2-2-2-5)

since it seems you are operating on a fairly restricting budget( the aXP and 2700 choices), i would def not recommend a raptor. go for one, larger current gen 7200rpm drive, they are almost as fast as a raptor, quieter, and much less expensive.

as for cd rom drives, go for the NEC 16x dual layer peice, its a nice one so ive heard, and its only 70 bucks at the egg. for the second drive, get a cheap DVDrom drive, so you can copy dvd's on the fly much easier.

i agree that the 9700 is still a good card, especially since you already have it.

hope this helps!

On contrare, the 3 sticks of ram actually are working in dual channel, at least thats what wcpuid says, and I why should I go A64, and not intel, I mean, I have never gone intel, I have always been an AMD fan, BUT, the clock speeds, the fsb, and the cache on p4's really get my attention!

Thanks for the replies so far
 
Tin_10 said:
On contrare, the 3 sticks of ram actually are working in dual channel, at least thats what wcpuid says, and I why should I go A64, and not intel, I mean, I have never gone intel, I have always been an AMD fan, BUT, the clock speeds, the fsb, and the cache on p4's really get my attention!

Thanks for the replies so far

well, A64s are better for gaming...the cache and FSB and clock speeds do look nice to me too, but then i laugh when i get better scores than my friends 2.8 P$ (yeah, i meant to do the $...but they are coming down in price) at 2.2 (barton 2500+) :p

well, the 9700 isn't a bad card, just you might want to think about upgrading it soon as well....just my 2 cents
 
Tin_10 said:
On contrare, the 3 sticks of ram actually are working in dual channel, at least thats what wcpuid says, and I why should I go A64, and not intel, I mean, I have never gone intel, I have always been an AMD fan, BUT, the clock speeds, the fsb, and the cache on p4's really get my attention!

Thanks for the replies so far

oy, ok here we go. with the K8 core, amd improved things ALOT. they cleaned up ineffiencies in the barton core, and included the integrated memory controller. sure, the p4s have a higher fsb, but they are still going throught the northbridge to get all the data. the a64 has direct access to the memory, and uses it basically as alot of slower extended cache.

the p4 is based on the netburst architechture, which is a wholly ineffienct one compared to the k8's highly optimized p6 architechture. the netburst has a one, long, 36(e) or 28(c) stage pipeline, and when there is a branch mispreditictoin it has to completly flush itself, whereas the 17 parrallell pipelines in the a64 can handle more at lower frequencies, and dont require a complete flush when there is an error. this is also why there is so much chache on the p4's, it was added as a bandaid to the netburst core, along wtih hyperthreading.

with the p4's highly ineffiencet (compared to AMD's) processor core, they are able to reach insane ghz amounts, but since htey are doing less work per cycle, the result is the same. currently, a 2.4ghz a64 is beating hte pants off any of intel's offerings, including the 3.46EE with the 1ghz fsb

i hope this helps explain some things, i do not claim to be an expert on this, but im certainly no noob
 
Alex41290 said:
well, i'm sorry to say, but any "major" upgrade would put ur video card as the bottleneck...so you might want to save up a little longer to afford an upgrade...the plain 6800 can be had for like $250-ish (not exactly sure) nowadays, so, you might want to look at that too....as for CPU/mobo/ram, you could get a s939 Athlon 64 3000+ and an ASUS A8V Deluxe...as for RAM, PDP Systems 1GB (2x512) PC3200 with really nice timings for like $180 on newegg...

if you wanted to go intel (i'd reccommend the AMD), i'm not EXACTLY sure what to get, but you could get like a 2.8 or 3.0...not sure about mobo, and RAM you could stick with the same...

hope that helps!

alex


as for alex, isnt socket 939 and 940 the a64 FX's? that are like $600-900?
If I go amd would the socket 754 like the http://www.newegg.com/app/viewproductdesc.asp?description=19-103-486&DEPA=1 shown here be a good upgrade from what I have?
 
my bad, the 939 does include onea round $200 oem, BUT, whats the big difference in 939/940 and 754?
 
lithium726 said:
oy, ok here we go. with the K8 core, amd improved things ALOT. they cleaned up ineffiencies in the barton core, and included the integrated memory controller. sure, the p4s have a higher fsb, but they are still going throught the northbridge to get all the data. the a64 has direct access to the memory, and uses it basically as alot of slower extended cache.

the p4 is based on the netburst architechture, which is a wholly ineffienct one compared to the k8's highly optimized p6 architechture. the netburst has a one, long, 36(e) or 28(c) stage pipeline, and when there is a branch mispreditictoin it has to completly flush itself, whereas the 17 parrallell pipelines in the a64 can handle more at lower frequencies, and dont require a complete flush when there is an error. this is also why there is so much chache on the p4's, it was added as a bandaid to the netburst core, along wtih hyperthreading.

with the p4's highly ineffiencet (compared to AMD's) processor core, they are able to reach insane ghz amounts, but since htey are doing less work per cycle, the result is the same. currently, a 2.4ghz a64 is beating hte pants off any of intel's offerings, including the 3.46EE with the 1ghz fsb

i hope this helps explain some things, i do not claim to be an expert on this, but im certainly no noob

that's what i meant, just in about 3000 more words :p

sorry, didn't see ur post above mine...the difference being the on-die memory controller, dual-channel support (both of them for the 939)....i can't think of anything else ATM, but i'll repost if i can
 
Tin_10 said:
my bad, the 939 does include onea round $200 oem, BUT, whats the big difference in 939/940 and 754?

754 is a dead platform for anything besides sempron, there will be no more athlon64 releases for it. 939 is the way of the future these days, it has dual channel included, and will be dual-core compatable when that awesome tech comes to the party

940 is a server only platform
 
lithium726 said:
754 is a dead platform for anything besides sempron, there will be no more athlon64 releases for it. 939 is the way of the future these days, it has dual channel included, and will be dual-core compatable when that awesome tech comes to the party

940 is a server only platform


so dont go 754, and why, they seem much cheaper, and I dont want to spend $275 for this http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=19-103-463&depa=1 when I dont know the difference in performance in 939 and 754, I do plan to go shopping tommorrow, and am trying to narrow it down here fellas, so help me out here! thanks!
 
lithium726 said:
then get this http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=19-103-500&depa=1

or this http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=19-103-499&depa=1

these are the newest revision of a64, and are clocking up to 2.6-2.7ghz as a norm

just as an FYI, theyre raping the p4's :cool:

edit: as a budget platform (for a64's, that is) 754 is still good, its just not as "future proof". if you go 754, alot of people have been raving about the DFI nf3 ultra board.

well lets just say after this I wont be upgrading for at least a year, so im not worries about being able to upgrade, by that time, something new will be out, is it bad to go 754, if not, what is the differences in 754 and 939 besides the chip size?
 
Tin_10 said:
well lets just say after this I wont be upgrading for at least a year, so im not worries about being able to upgrade, by that time, something new will be out, is it bad to go 754, if not, what is the differences in 754 and 939 besides the chip size?

754's have a htt of 800mhz while the 939s are a ghz, and the 939s have dual channel.
all in all, not a whole lot, at all. the 1ghz helps a little and the dual channel helps very little, as the a64 architechture just doesnt need as much bandwidth as dual channel gives.

if you are looking at a slightly cheaper upgrade, go 754. 939 will be around in a year tho, and it will support next years chips (dual core!!)
 
lithium726 said:
754's have a htt of 800mhz while the 939s are a ghz, and the 939s have dual channel.
all in all, not a whole lot, at all. the 1ghz helps a little and the dual channel helps very little, as the a64 architechture just doesnt need as much bandwidth as dual channel gives.

if you are looking at a slightly cheaper upgrade, go 754. 939 will be around in a year tho, and it will support next years chips (dual core!!)

So if I go 754 and get the 3000+ or even the 3200+ and the asus motherboard, or any good $100 for that matter, and of course the ram, please check original post for the ram i want to get, it was an edit in the post, - will all this be a really great upgrade from what I currently have now?
 
Tin_10 said:
So if I go 754 and get the 3000+ or even the 3200+ and the asus motherboard, or any good $100 for that matter, and of course the ram, please check original post for the ram i want to get, it was an edit in the post, - will all this be a really great upgrade from what I currently have now?


also, if I do upgrade would anyone be interested in buying the cpu/ram/mobo for say $200-$250?
 
that would depend on what you have.(the sale thing)

lemmie have a budget, and ill put together what i think you should spring for :)
 
$350, maybe a bit more, and maybe more than that if i can get a little for the stuff i want to get rid of
 
350 is real tight for a cpu, mobo, and mem..

cpu: http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=19-103-452&depa=1
mobo: http://www.newegg.com/app/viewProductDesc.asp?description=13-136-147&depa=0
mem: http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=20-145-026&depa=1

i know, only 512, but its hte best i could do with 350.. with 939, the board and cpu alone would be ~350, assuming you went with the 3200+.

that board is a great OCer, so youre really going for bang for buck here...

what do you have now? unless its fairly recent, i doubt youll get 250...
 
lithium726 said:
350 is real tight for a cpu, mobo, and mem..

cpu: http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=19-103-452&depa=1
mobo: http://www.newegg.com/app/viewProductDesc.asp?description=13-136-147&depa=0
mem: http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=20-145-026&depa=1

i know, only 512, but its hte best i could do with 350.. with 939, the board and cpu alone would be ~350, assuming you went with the 3200+.

that board is a great OCer, so youre really going for bang for buck here...

what do you have now? unless its fairly recent, i doubt youll get 250...

$200 , and well, I will go to frys tommorrow, and check out some prices on things they have there!
 
Tin_10 said:
also, if I do upgrade would anyone be interested in buying the cpu/ram/mobo for say $200-$250?
Tin_10 - Greetings, and welcome to the forums. One of the rules to take note of is:
(16) No BUYING, TRADING, or SELLING anywhere with the exception of the For Sale / Trade forum.
...no worries, just a heads up...:cool: FS / FT has it's own rules, so it's good to read them before you post your stuff for sale.

Thanks, and good luck with the upgrade.

Regards - B.B.S.
 
what I'm thinking is that you might want to hold off on the major upgrade thing untill PCIe and DDR2 gets its shit together. Fix the 9700 with a 9800 pro and call it good. But you got to be your own man and blaze your own trails.
 
kubalaTF said:
what I'm thinking is that you might want to hold off on the major upgrade thing untill PCIe and DDR2 gets its shit together. Fix the 9700 with a 9800 pro and call it good. But you got to be your own man and blaze your own trails.


well, I dont plan to buy a video card for quite some time, maybe when the 6800's are between $200 for the lower, and $300 for hugher, MAYBE

However, when do u suppose the PCIE and DDR2 will get worked out?
 
THIS IS FOR A GAMING MACHINE, wanting to upgrade before the HL2 release, or do u think my system now will hang just fine with the current setup I have?
 
who knows, I'm betting on a year or so, but I'm not on the bleeding edge of this kind of thing. I'm in the process of putting my own together and it doesn't look good in terms of upgradeing in 2 years. I might be able to get some of todays newest stuff for dirt cheap in 2 years though. I'm counting on that and learning how to OC to keep me going.
 
kubalaTF said:
who knows, I'm betting on a year or so, but I'm not on the bleeding edge of this kind of thing. I'm in the process of putting my own together and it doesn't look good in terms of upgradeing in 2 years. I might be able to get some of todays newest stuff for dirt cheap in 2 years though. I'm counting on that and learning how to OC to keep me going.


Well, I have decided if I have to I will spend $400-500 on this, ONLY if u guys can convince me that going from a Barton 2500+ with 1.5gb pc2700 XMS ram, and the NF7-S ver2 mobo to the K8V SE Deluxe with either the 754 3000+ or the 3200+ and 1gb of ram IS GOING TO BE A BIG jump, I know my 9700 pro will love the setup, but will I see a big difference?

Or will my current setup be sufficent for the upcoming HL2 and mods, help me decide, I leave in 9 hrs to go buy the stuff if I am convinced!
 
one last question, with the a64 setup, which im about to go buy, can u go with a higher ram, like pc4000 or even the pc4400?
 
There is no point in buying higher speed (>3200) ram unless you want to overclock your system. Even then you can usually get away with buying 3200 speed ram with tight timings and loosen the timings and/or add voltage to it to increase the bus speed.

Dario
 
Well tell me this, I just went and purchased the following at FRYS ALL brand new

Athlon 64 754 socket boxed 3000+ for $149 - they gave me box instead of bare, lol
DFI LP NF3 250gb mobo - $129
and 1gb (2 x 512mb) Geil ram - $139 - special they had going

my question is simply this

with the ram I had before, being the Corsair XMS CMX512-2700C2 which is XMS pc2700 cas2 ram, 3 sticks of it, can I use this ram, instead of the ram I just purchased, which is pc3200? If so I can save myself some money and have more ram anyways, just need some help there
 
if i'm not mistaken, the proc runs at a 200mhz fsb (800mzh htt)....so, for that, you would want pc3200 (400mhz ddr) or 200mhz fsb, or else you would be overclocking your ram, or underclocking your cpu...so i would stick with the pc3200 and sell ur current ram.
 
you are correct.. a64's have a 200mhz fsb, unless that ram is pretty overclockable, youll need the pc3200
 
bumping to the top and asking a question

Now here is the question, can I use the CORSAIR xms pc2700 ram which is currently in my system, and have 1.5gb ram, instead of the 1gb Geil that I just bought, I mean, for one, it will save me money, 2 it will give me more memory, and 3 I can oc the 2700 to 3200 speeds, right?
 
i'm gonna be the low bidder... i have only $150 to offer. but it would be well spent on something like that. :( i actually feel kinda sorry that i don't have any more $$$, cuz it's worth it.
 
Tin_10 said:
bumping to the top and asking a question

Now here is the question, can I use the CORSAIR xms pc2700 ram which is currently in my system, and have 1.5gb ram, instead of the 1gb Geil that I just bought, I mean, for one, it will save me money, 2 it will give me more memory, and 3 I can oc the 2700 to 3200 speeds, right?

333mhz to 400mhz would be a near impossible trick. you would probably have to figure out how to watercool ram without shorting anything out... leaks would be disastrous.
 
starhawk said:
333mhz to 400mhz would be a near impossible trick. you would probably have to figure out how to watercool ram without shorting anything out... leaks would be disastrous.

so you are saying that running 166mhz Corsair XMS Ram at 200mhz is near impossible?!? im sorry dude, but it is most certainly possible, just not garanteed.

and watercooling ram, even if it were possible, would do absolutly NOTHING. ram runs cool enough as it is, it all depends on the types of chips and how much they can take, not the temperature of the ram... pc3200 cant hit 200mhz because its running cooler than pc2700. it can hit those speeds becuse it has different chips on it. just like some ram can hit 300mhz when most cannot. its all the chips(and the PCB... actually..).

tin: with 3 DIMMS, 400mhz is gonna be tricky. i know that with one or two, its alot more possible, but with 3, it gets harder. the more DIMMS you have, the less likely you are to be able to overclock. you can give it a shot, but id put my money on the Geil serving you better.
 
Back
Top