FCC Updating Broadband Subsidy Program

Meh, I'm not going to get involved with that rhetoric. :rolleyes:

I don't blame you. Politics and ideology are not worth discussing most of the time. Just saying, if city dwellers get subsidized nice benefits, rural people should too.
 
I don't blame you. Politics and ideology are not worth discussing most of the time. Just saying, if city dwellers get subsidized nice benefits, rural people should too.

To a point. If you're going extremes, then...well...you're an extremist. :D
 
I don't blame you. Politics and ideology are not worth discussing most of the time. Just saying, if city dwellers get subsidized nice benefits, rural people should too.
If both parties are subsidizing each other, don't they cancel out? Shouldn't those subsidies just be eliminated?
 
Well, from each parties abilities to another parties needs. Rural people might need a hand here, and city people might need a hand elsewhere like a bite to each sometimes. There's little market incentive to develop this so subsidies in this area are good... this is the "New Economy" or at least, the backbone to any sort of future economy we might have someday. I'd say it's worth it.
 
Well, from each parties abilities to another parties needs. Rural people might need a hand here, and city people might need a hand elsewhere like a bite to each sometimes. There's little market incentive to develop this so subsidies in this area are good... this is the "New Economy" or at least, the backbone to any sort of future economy we might have someday. I'd say it's worth it.
Then why don't you move to Europe, where the subsidies flow free?
 
Fuck all this, give everyone access to FiOS (25-100MBPS internet speeds like verizon has in limited cities right now) for $40 a month.

I would pay $1-5 more on my taxes for this. only one time though, not every year as that is unreasonable and obviously making profit for someone. We need national broadband 100%, FFS!

This is getting insane that we have slow crap speeds, and are forced to use only ONE (2 or 3 if you're in a major city) internet provider at a very overcharged price.

Comcast and AT&T have actually JACKED UP their rates recently for new customers.... and old customers don't get SHIT unless you waste 1+ hours trying to find a cool retention rep.
 
Been there many times. Plan on helping change this nation, my nation. Btw, subsidies flow freely here too.
If you like socialism so much, please go somewhere where they practice it and leave the US alone.

When has socialism ever worked in the long term?
 
If you like socialism so much, please go somewhere where they practice it and leave the US alone.

When has socialism ever worked in the long term?

This is my country, and we've been practicing socialism here for a very, very long time. Open your eyes, it's why quality of life here is decent.
Hybrid socialism/capitalism is what the USA is. It works, well.

I for one, like the idea of public roads, schools, the policeforce / 911, and firefighters. :rolleyes:
 
This is my country, and we've been practicing socialism here for a very, very long time. Open your eyes, it's why quality of life here is decent.
Hybrid socialism/capitalism is what the USA is. It works, well.

I for one, like the idea of public roads, schools, the policeforce / 911, and firefighters. :rolleyes:
Are you assuming that because I oppose government interference in the economy, that I also oppose any and all forms of public service? Wow, way to jump at conclusions. I happen to agree that roads, police, fire fighting, water/sewer, and (funding of) schools are justifiably within the scope of government. Note, however, that with the exception of the interstate highway system, all those items are handled on the local level. And none of those touch on the topic at hand, which is the availability of broadband in places where it's more expensive per customer to install.

In fact, you're missing the entirety of my argument on this topic. My argument is that #1) cities and rural areas shouldn't be subsidizing each other for anything, and that #2) the federal government has no business sticking its fingers into this particular pie.
 
If you like socialism so much, please go somewhere where they practice it and leave the US alone.

When has socialism ever worked in the long term?

Are you assuming that because I oppose government interference in the economy, that I also oppose any and all forms of public service? Wow, way to jump at conclusions. I happen to agree that roads, police, fire fighting, water/sewer, and (funding of) schools are justifiably within the scope of government. Note, however, that with the exception of the interstate highway system, all those items are handled on the local level. And none of those touch on the topic at hand, which is the availability of broadband in places where it's more expensive per customer to install.

In fact, you're missing the entirety of my argument on this topic. My argument is that #1) cities and rural areas shouldn't be subsidizing each other for anything, and that #2) the federal government has no business sticking its fingers into this particular pie.

That didn't sound like your argument that you addressed to me in the quote above. Sounded like a direct challenge on the issue of socialism, which I support and gave concrete references to ways that socialism improves our lives daily. That is what you stated, and I replied accordingly. Now, you want to get into the nitty gritty of your views on the subject which is fine, and I don't really have anything to say as I don't care to debate how you feel about it. I have my views, which are based on pragmatism and 100% realistic reality-based solutions but I understand not everyone sees things the same way. But socialism is socialism, regardless of being "local" (which is always relative) or not "local". I tend to agree, decentralized smaller scale socialism is usually for the best, but federal socialism is also necessary in some areas of life for the good of the national community.
 
That didn't sound like your argument that you addressed to me in the quote above. Sounded like a direct challenge on the issue of socialism, which I support and gave concrete references to ways that socialism improves our lives daily. That is what you stated, and I replied accordingly.
Fine, I'll address it correctly. As I said before, certain things make sense to socialize: fire protection, police, roads, and the like. Heck, I'll even throw in funding for primary education (though I'll exclude the providing of that education). What we've seen over the past century or so is that as soon as you stray beyond those boundaries, socialism doesn't work. Welfare? Social Security? Medicare/medicaid? Britain's NHS? Japan's healthcare system? In every single instance, you get worse (and usually much worse) results than leaving it up to people to decide for themselves, and at a much higher cost.

Don't believe me? Then go run some numbers. The social security administration provides a number of calculators to help you estimate your benefit when you retire. If you then go and calculate what you would receive if you could invest that money yourself (at, let's say, 5% return), the difference is enormous.

And yet, despite that fact, and despite that everyone is forced to pay into the system, it's still running a deficit.
 
<snip> I tend to agree, decentralized smaller scale socialism is usually for the best, but federal socialism is also necessary in some areas of life for the good of the national community.

I thought you said you were a die-hard socialist?
 
What is the definition of a diehard socialist? I believe in the concept as a communal tool that provides things that the market did not do, such as create the Internet.
 
What is the definition of a diehard socialist? I believe in the concept as a communal tool that provides things that the market did not do, such as create the Internet.
Yes, every once in a while the government creates something useful. But please, can't you liberals come up with any other good ideas the government has created?
 
The people in these states who are often poor and uneducated often vote against their best interests. Religion, being in the Bible Belt I'm sure plays a big part of that.

Not even racist, factually correct, sadly.
 
Yes, every once in a while the government creates something useful. But please, can't you liberals come up with any other good ideas the government has created?
Z
 
"Bringing broadband to the people" is just the political marketing, the only purpose here is corporate handout/kickbacks. Billions of taxpayer dollars and then hit us again with jacked up rates, and you know UBB is just around the corner.
 
Back
Top