FCC Updating Broadband Subsidy Program

Again, it is part of the cost of choosing to live in a certain place. It is a choice between how fast the internet is, not whether they have it or not.
I get to pay, usually higher property taxes, more for food, deal with more traffic, smog, pay higher insurance premiums, deal with more crime, and a ton of other shit they don't have to. I don't get to bitch, because I chose to live here.

And I was not suggesting federal or even state tax dollars be used. I was suggesting if a community wants broadband via cable or fiber, that that community brings it in their selves or that they convince some company that there is money in doing so for them. I am against the FCC's lame attempt at keeping control of money they were about to lose control of under this pretense. Especially since we would not get broadband to the stix out of it. We would get broadband to a few places in the stix till the FCC ran out of money for the ISPs to stuff there pockets with while doing the bare minimum, and then the program would be expanded or quietly canned. It makes little sense to do this unless you just want your cake, and to eat it as well, all at taxpayer expense.

Unfortunately, 5 years from now, when we are paying interest on the billions we loaned to do this.. people will still be arguing the same thing? I fail to see how people can forget history so easily.
 
Or they are strong on values like work hard for what you want, and don't expect the government to take care of you. You know the American way, unlike half of you with your socalist ideals.

No, they're poor. Any safety net measure that doesn't end up somewhat disproportionally benefiting people in conservative states that are not Texas is doing it wrong. The aforementioned states tend to have relatively high poverty rates, especially Mississippi which is statistically known as the poorest and fattest state in the union.
 
"A few thousand more people can probably get satellite internet before the cost of the hardware overcomes the amount they can realistically charge"

^-- Fear mongering...

If they wanted to be on satellite for broadband, they would have already had it.. the change between current demand for satellite, and satellite in a world where we don't have expansion of the infrastructure to the boondocks is... 0.

We already live in a world where this hasn't happened.. and Satellite's are a perfectly viable option.

In fact, if I lived in the country.. I wouldn't be trying to blow a highly in debt countries money on bringing me broadband on cable.. I would buy 1mbps-2mbps satellite and get over it..

What ever happened to fiscal responsibility?
 
I pay $110 for my 0.5 Mbps internet. So how much more than that do you suggest I have to pay to have high speed internet brought to my house? We have our neighborhood wired for fiber already; all they have to do is go to the individual houses.

But they refuse to because they are waiting for the FCC to finalize the definition of what is broadband. Centurylink is waiting for the go ahead where the FCC switches from The Universal Service Fund to Connect America fund. So they tell us that it's not available in our area. Even though I live 2 houses down from the main fiber hub supplying the elementary school.

Satellite internet isn't an option because 1 satellite can't feed enough connections to make a difference. I tried taking a Cisco exam on satellite, and ended up making another 4 hour trip to the school because the connection kept dropping.

The spectrum the FCC took away from television stations could be used to run a nationwide wireless broadband initiative. In my area there is only US Cellular. If you show up here with your fancy Droids, Iphone, etc we lol at you. So even then, someone would have to roll out wireless towers to feed wireless broadband.

In short, money has to be spent regardless. Why not take it from the preexisting Universal Service Fund? I don't see what the big argument is if we take existing dollars and use it better our country. Denying education to part of your population based on where they live is illegal in America. Denying them broadband internet for education is the exact same thing as it's the future.
 
Just like you paid to have internet access brought to your area, right? I'm not seeing whats different here. There is no other way to get service. A few thousand more people can probably get satellite internet before the cost of the hardware overcomes the amount they can realistically charge. Time Warner had no problem bringing 10mbit/s cable internet to my town of 3,400, but it would somehow require a monumental amount of tax revenue to do it somewhere else?
I AM paying the cost to have internet access brought to my neighborhood, even though it was put in 12 years before I moved here. You see, companies take out debt in order to build the networks, in the hope that they'll make enough revenue in the future to pay off the debt and make a profit.

The telcos and cableco's don't build networks for charity. They're in it to make money. And there's nothing wrong with that.
 
I AM paying the cost to have internet access brought to my neighborhood, even though it was put in 12 years before I moved here. You see, companies take out debt in order to build the networks, in the hope that they'll make enough revenue in the future to pay off the debt and make a profit.

The telcos and cableco's don't build networks for charity. They're in it to make money. And there's nothing wrong with that.

I'm not sure what you're trying to say here. I never implied the teclos or ISP build networks for charity. I'm saying that we all paid taxes towards the past infrastructure buildup, giving everyone in the cities nice fast networks, but now that its time to improve the rest of the network no one here cares because they already have their nice fast connections. You want to continue to use USF funds to "maintain" copper lines (more like maintain the wallets of the telcos), while I would rather see those funds used to replace the copper lines with fiber, which is what this article is about.
 
I'm not sure what you're trying to say here. I never implied the teclos or ISP build networks for charity. I'm saying that we all paid taxes towards the past infrastructure buildup, giving everyone in the cities nice fast networks, but now that its time to improve the rest of the network no one here cares because they already have their nice fast connections. You want to continue to use USF funds to "maintain" copper lines (more like maintain the wallets of the telcos), while I would rather see those funds used to replace the copper lines with fiber, which is what this article is about.
Whoever said that taxpayer dollars built the phone and cable networks in cities? Certainly the city provides rights-of-way and other types of infrastructure (water, sewer, power, etc), but not telecomms, and besides, the city pays for that itself out of locally-collected taxes. The same should be true for small towns out in the sticks.
 
Whoever said that taxpayer dollars built the phone and cable networks in cities? Certainly the city provides rights-of-way and other types of infrastructure (water, sewer, power, etc), but not telecomms, and besides, the city pays for that itself out of locally-collected taxes. The same should be true for small towns out in the sticks.

As taxpayers, we have given the telcoms large sums of money to help with "upgrades" at least twice (and tried to a third time last year, but they declined due to the amount of regulation that went along with it). We (US Citizens, I was not alive when this happened) also paid to have the country wired with phone lines. Everyone has paid for internet upgrades twice, including people in rural areas, but they have seen nothing in return.
 
Whoever said that taxpayer dollars built the phone and cable networks in cities? Certainly the city provides rights-of-way and other types of infrastructure (water, sewer, power, etc), but not telecomms, and besides, the city pays for that itself out of locally-collected taxes. The same should be true for small towns out in the sticks.

Sorry but my tax dollars subsidize many programs in cities that I'll never see a benefit from. I pay for inner city youth to have playgrounds, fix your roads, buy your schoolbooks, etc. I pay for National Guard troops to be around when you'll riot, have floods, etc. Nobody comes out here to help us when disaster strikes.

Maybe I should boycott paying taxes and let you'll fund your stuff locally. And good luck growing produce in a city or raising an animal farm to feed yourselves.



See how dumb I sound above? That's the same way you sound to me when I read your holier than thou stuff speeches. So what you're saying is that one demographic group shouldn't have broadband for education because of where they live. And they should have to pay taxes just like the group that does. Yea right.

And the funding is already there; just going to switch the dollars to promote modern innovation. That's what amazes me. All they are saying is instead of spending X federal dollars on antiquated BS, let's modernize the network for the future. But that's wrong to you. That's heresy. I don't see anything wrong with it personally. Looks like government finally getting it right for a change to me.
 
As taxpayers, we have given the telcoms large sums of money to help with "upgrades" at least twice (and tried to a third time last year, but they declined due to the amount of regulation that went along with it). We (US Citizens, I was not alive when this happened) also paid to have the country wired with phone lines. Everyone has paid for internet upgrades twice, including people in rural areas, but they have seen nothing in return.

Exactly. I keep funding stuff I never get a benefit from, but as soon as I see a silver lining, the people I "donated" to become snobbish and want it all to themselves.
 
I pay $110 for my 0.5 Mbps internet. So how much more than that do you suggest I have to pay to have high speed internet brought to my house? We have our neighborhood wired for fiber already; all they have to do is go to the individual houses.
I pay $3.40/gal for gas? What about you? If I were to buy my 1300 sq.ft house today it would cost me somewhere north of $600,000 for it, how much would that cost where you live? Sometimes people in certain areas pay more for the same thing. Got fiber already? Sounds like something you need to deal with the company rather than having tax payers make it so.
 
Please cut it! Or at least pay for it from the general budget instead of some hokey line item on my phone bill. While they're at it, can they get rid of the Federal Subscriber Line Charge (which is basically the FCC says the telco can charge whatever they want and call it that, instead of just upping the rate)

The FCC likes to just fuck with everyone. They actually do set min rates for telcos. 2 years ago or so ago my work actually was forced to raise our rates as we were below what the FCC said that telcos had to charge as a min for rates. Our company meeting about that wasn't great news we get to start charging more money, it was more along the lines of get ready for customers to get pissed off and for some people to drop their phone service the government is fucking with our prices.

How about just using Motorola Canopy.... create local broadband ISPs like in my town :)

I just heard of it, it's supposed to be something new and enables small companies to make ISPs. Startup is like $500 but its about the same price monthly for the same basic broadband speeds of nowadays.

It isn't new, that i what my work has been using for year to provide wireless service to customers that we can't provide DSL to, or in areas outside of our phone service area. Problem with that is line of sight to a tower. cost of towers, plus it doesn't give you the greatest speed.
 
I pay $110 for my 0.5 Mbps internet. So how much more than that do you suggest I have to pay to have high speed internet brought to my house? We have our neighborhood wired for fiber already; all they have to do is go to the individual houses.

But they refuse to because they are waiting for the FCC to finalize the definition of what is broadband. Centurylink is waiting for the go ahead where the FCC switches from The Universal Service Fund to Connect America fund. So they tell us that it's not available in our area. Even though I live 2 houses down from the main fiber hub supplying the elementary school.

Satellite internet isn't an option because 1 satellite can't feed enough connections to make a difference. I tried taking a Cisco exam on satellite, and ended up making another 4 hour trip to the school because the connection kept dropping.

The spectrum the FCC took away from television stations could be used to run a nationwide wireless broadband initiative. In my area there is only US Cellular. If you show up here with your fancy Droids, Iphone, etc we lol at you. So even then, someone would have to roll out wireless towers to feed wireless broadband.

In short, money has to be spent regardless. Why not take it from the preexisting Universal Service Fund? I don't see what the big argument is if we take existing dollars and use it better our country. Denying education to part of your population based on where they live is illegal in America. Denying them broadband internet for education is the exact same thing as it's the future.

I'm pretty sure they already defined broadband 4Mbps down, 1Mbps up. Want to say that everyone has until 2012 or something like that to start using that definition. We already changed our DSL customers speeds up to that from the 3Mbps down, 512K up that we were offering them just to be done with it.
 
You have to look at the larger picture. You're not running fiber to 100 people in the middle of nowhere, you're running fiber to the 40% of the population that doesn't live in a city.

You sir, deserve a medal. I agree that you have to judge all of us, by the least of us. Not that rural dwellers are lesser, but their internet is, and that needs to change.

In a world where the internet is becoming a necessity, these cable runs are better done now rather than later. It's a supplement to satellite, it's always best to have more than 1 choice for a consumer based economy (something I thought we prided ourselves on having).

I vote that we stop shipping fresh produce into the city. After all, if they want food, they should move to the country, where the food is.

The U.S government subsidizes corn and other produce. I grown my own, so why should I have to pay for your food?

I saw the response to this, and it's not like rural areas don't subsidize big areas too.. think the state of Illinois doesn't spend alot of state money in Chicago? As an example. Of course they do. I mean it's all proportionate, but lets not act like a rural citizen doesn't pay taxes too.

It's just a partially planned economy, without which, many things (like farming) would have collapsed under international competition from 3rd world nations. Not saying it's right or wrong, just that's the way it is.

No, they're poor. Any safety net measure that doesn't end up somewhat disproportionally benefiting people in conservative states that are not Texas is doing it wrong. The aforementioned states tend to have relatively high poverty rates, especially Mississippi which is statistically known as the poorest and fattest state in the union.

Even Texas is doing it wrong.
http://crooksandliars.com/susie-madrak/why-wont-republicans-attack-texas-the

It definitely seems generally, the more conservative a state is, the better the state is financially, they just also have lower rates in metrics that matter to the nation such as a strong business community, health and education. Though that could be argued to be cultural, or maybe that culture and political orientation are linked.

I would take on personal debt to insure jobs, a healthy body and a good education, and I see no reason to not take the same course as a state. Debt is actually harmless to the economy and not the reason we lost our jobs, it's just a political wedge issue. Something you deal with after you get yourself back on your feet (as an individual or a state).
 
And the funding is already there; just going to switch the dollars to promote modern innovation. That's what amazes me. All they are saying is instead of spending X federal dollars on antiquated BS, let's modernize the network for the future. But that's wrong to you. That's heresy. I don't see anything wrong with it personally. Looks like government finally getting it right for a change to me.

They're selfish, there's no point in even arguing with some people about this sort of thing. If it doesn't directly benefit them, it's simply a waste of "their" taxpayer dollars :rolleyes:
 
I demand people living in rural areas be forced to pay higher housing costs, taxes, prices on food, and general living expenses to subsidize my life in the city. How about, instead of wasting money on a broadband plan that will maybe reach %3-5 of that %4o b4 it runs out of money, we spend it on something like education where that amount of money might actually make a difference.

As an aside, the attempts at liberal elitism in this thread are absolutely hilarious.

Peace, to the masses. [/]
 
Sorry but my tax dollars subsidize many programs in cities that I'll never see a benefit from. I pay for inner city youth to have playgrounds, fix your roads, buy your schoolbooks, etc. I pay for National Guard troops to be around when you'll riot, have floods, etc. Nobody comes out here to help us when disaster strikes.
You may be surprised to find that I think the cities should not be subsidized by rural areas in order to develop their infrastructure, pay for their schools, etc. They should be able to support themselves.
Maybe I should boycott paying taxes and let you'll fund your stuff locally. And good luck growing produce in a city or raising an animal farm to feed yourselves.
I have zero problem with each locality paying for its own stuff. As for your comment about growing produce inside the city, that has absolutely nothing to do with the topic at hand.
See how dumb I sound above? That's the same way you sound to me when I read your holier than thou stuff speeches. So what you're saying is that one demographic group shouldn't have broadband for education because of where they live. And they should have to pay taxes just like the group that does. Yea right.
I think you may be misunderstanding me. I'm saying that if one group decides to live in a less-populated area, they need to recognize the benefits and costs of doing so, and not demand that others pay for it when things aren't perfect. The example you posted (of a student living in a rural area who is required, on a regular basis, to download extremely large files from a professor) is at best a corner case, a rare instance. Perhaps that student should have considered the nature of the course before enrolling, or perhaps that student can find another way to access the files?
And the funding is already there; just going to switch the dollars to promote modern innovation. That's what amazes me. All they are saying is instead of spending X federal dollars on antiquated BS, let's modernize the network for the future. But that's wrong to you. That's heresy. I don't see anything wrong with it personally. Looks like government finally getting it right for a change to me.
I have an alternative. If USF is no longer needed because the PSTN networks have been built out, then let's get rid of it altogether. If we as a country want to subsequently subsidize broadband to rural areas, then let such a proposal stand on its own merits. Make the FCC come to Congress and make the case that such a program is necessary, rather than trying to further expand regulatory reach (and cost) by fiat.
 
I have an alternative. If USF is no longer needed because the PSTN networks have been built out, then let's get rid of it altogether. If we as a country want to subsequently subsidize broadband to rural areas, then let such a proposal stand on its own merits. Make the FCC come to Congress and make the case that such a program is necessary, rather than trying to further expand regulatory reach (and cost) by fiat.

The thing is that the only reason America got a modern road system is because the government stepping in during the 50's and making it happen. The states didn't do it on their own. The government had to see the big picture and justify the cost.

America didn't get nationwide phone service until the government stepped in again and made it happen. The states couldn't figure out how to fund it or agree on standards so you could call across America until then. See the trend?

Now we're at the cusp of finally getting broadband rolled out to the bulk of America. I don't trust our current political stalemate to allow the current USF plan to die. I think if it died then the broadband initiative would be lost in bureaucracy. I would prefer that the FCC's plan go through and amendments be added to cut the extraneous charging that Telcos were doing.

I understand that you want to be fiscally responsible. Especially with our national debt ballooning. I glanced today at Obama pushing a high speed rail initiative. Being that I don't live in a city, I was instantly opposed to it without reading the article. I wonder if we want to afford that with our debt. But after a few minutes of soul searching I said, "Well to get a solid opinion on it I'd need to ask the people that would benefit from it."


And that's what we're trying to tell you in this thread. Rural customers that pay their taxes just like everyone else feel as if they should have the same rights to modernization in their communities. Obviously broadband is a necessity for education now; imagine the future.

Is it going to cost less to run fiber, towers, cable, etc now or in the future? Think about that and then tell me which is more fiscally responsible. Then add in the fact that these customers have been footing the bill for the broadband infrastructure in cities for years without any benefit and debate on what's morally right.
 
The thing is that the only reason America got a modern road system is because the government stepping in during the 50's and making it happen. The states didn't do it on their own. The government had to see the big picture and justify the cost.

America didn't get nationwide phone service until the government stepped in again and made it happen. The states couldn't figure out how to fund it or agree on standards so you could call across America until then. See the trend?

Now we're at the cusp of finally getting broadband rolled out to the bulk of America. I don't trust our current political stalemate to allow the current USF plan to die. I think if it died then the broadband initiative would be lost in bureaucracy. I would prefer that the FCC's plan go through and amendments be added to cut the extraneous charging that Telcos were doing.

I understand that you want to be fiscally responsible. Especially with our national debt ballooning. I glanced today at Obama pushing a high speed rail initiative. Being that I don't live in a city, I was instantly opposed to it without reading the article. I wonder if we want to afford that with our debt. But after a few minutes of soul searching I said, "Well to get a solid opinion on it I'd need to ask the people that would benefit from it."


And that's what we're trying to tell you in this thread. Rural customers that pay their taxes just like everyone else feel as if they should have the same rights to modernization in their communities. Obviously broadband is a necessity for education now; imagine the future.

Is it going to cost less to run fiber, towers, cable, etc now or in the future? Think about that and then tell me which is more fiscally responsible. Then add in the fact that these customers have been footing the bill for the broadband infrastructure in cities for years without any benefit and debate on what's morally right.


I agree, to a point. There has to be a line drawn on how far these lines go, and how many are serviced.

You don't build a $500 million dollar expansion bridge for an island town of 200 people. You offer a ferry service, which is paid by those who use the ferry. Its slower, but more economical...
 
:mad:It really pisses me off reading some of the post of the individuals who disagree with serving our distant citizens. They pay taxes just like you and I and as stated by others, they hardly see any benefit from them. The "Internet" can be considered the most precious innovation known to man and anyone who disagrees of a certain demographics not receiving it because of a typical location should have a career of shoveling shit for a living for being naive, ignorant, and unintelligent. Using the satellite analogy is a poor excuse, cost are entirely too high (I work in this industry) and slow to enjoy the richness of the net and utilize it's full potential. Most of us at [H] know how important the internet is. If our connection is fast enough, we have no need for a phone line or cable service as majority of those services could be attained through the net. Therefore, rural area's deserve high speed internet (none of that 3 Mbps crap) just like we do. Anything less is stiffling innovation.
 
:mad:It really pisses me off reading some of the post of the individuals who disagree with serving our distant citizens. They pay taxes just like you and I and as stated by others, they hardly see any benefit from them. The "Internet" can be considered the most precious innovation known to man and anyone who disagrees of a certain demographics not receiving it because of a typical location should have a career of shoveling shit for a living for being naive, ignorant, and unintelligent. Using the satellite analogy is a poor excuse, cost are entirely too high (I work in this industry) and slow to enjoy the richness of the net and utilize it's full potential. Most of us at [H] know how important the internet is. If our connection is fast enough, we have no need for a phone line or cable service as majority of those services could be attained through the net. Therefore, rural area's deserve high speed internet (none of that 3 Mbps crap) just like we do. Anything less is stiffling innovation.

Though I doubt you're one of them, those who think because they pay taxes they are entitled to everything citizens in the suburbs/large cities have access to are deluded by the "me" attitude.

Does a small town of 500 people that are 200 miles off the beaten road deserve fiber-optics? Hell no...

Does a small town of 50,000 people that are 20 miles off the beaten road deserve fiber-optics? Deserve is a strong word, but if it doesn't cost a large sum to implement, and their rates for broadband service increase a small portion to SOMEWHAT offset the subsidized implementation cost, then its up to the local government to see if its plausible to implement.

Just giving the go-ahead for fiber-everywhere (or just "broadband") without weighing the options is a HUGE waste of resources.

What happens when there is little to no growth in the rural areas over 10-15 years, but the cost of implementing and maintaining service to that area goes up? No tax base to support the implementation = asinine governing, typical at the Federal (and a lot of the state) level.

Should broadband (fiber/etc) be subsidized by government programs to expand coverage? Sure, I'm for that, but for a REASONABLE area of expansion based on population density. There has to be sensible (ha) limits to this type of program.
 
You offer a ferry service, which is paid by those who use the ferry. Its slower, but more economical...

If they're anything like the SI ferry, ferry services are actually not all that inexpensive.
 
Does a small town of 500 people that are 200 miles off the beaten road deserve fiber-optics? Hell no...

This has been addressed many times, cities are subsidized by rural areas too.

But do they deserve it? Yes. Just as they deserve running water, electricity and everything else a civilized nation has, like broadband internet access. It's called socialism, and it's what brought our nation running water to rural areas, that existed even in Roman times yet most of us had grandparents who had no running water in this country.

I live in a city, and stand with the all the people of this nation. They deserve what they, and I, can shove down your throat. This will go through, you're going to pay for it through wealth redistribution, and you're not going to like it.
 
actually, a community of 200 would be sufficient to justify a fiber. just remember that phones, cell phone towers, credit card machines, even dialup, etc. use internet connection. you'd be hard pressed to find a phone line that doesn't run through digital communication. i know of individual cell towers that use their own fiber connection in rural towns before microwave relay and satellite connections were implemented. its all about laying the first fiber down, after that the economies of scale kicks in and it becomes cheaper and cheaper for people to use.
 
The thing is that the only reason America got a modern road system is because the government stepping in during the 50's and making it happen. The states didn't do it on their own. The government had to see the big picture and justify the cost.

America didn't get nationwide phone service until the government stepped in again and made it happen. The states couldn't figure out how to fund it or agree on standards so you could call across America until then. See the trend?

Now we're at the cusp of finally getting broadband rolled out to the bulk of America. I don't trust our current political stalemate to allow the current USF plan to die. I think if it died then the broadband initiative would be lost in bureaucracy. I would prefer that the FCC's plan go through and amendments be added to cut the extraneous charging that Telcos were doing.

I understand that you want to be fiscally responsible. Especially with our national debt ballooning. I glanced today at Obama pushing a high speed rail initiative. Being that I don't live in a city, I was instantly opposed to it without reading the article. I wonder if we want to afford that with our debt. But after a few minutes of soul searching I said, "Well to get a solid opinion on it I'd need to ask the people that would benefit from it."


And that's what we're trying to tell you in this thread. Rural customers that pay their taxes just like everyone else feel as if they should have the same rights to modernization in their communities. Obviously broadband is a necessity for education now; imagine the future.

Is it going to cost less to run fiber, towers, cable, etc now or in the future? Think about that and then tell me which is more fiscally responsible. Then add in the fact that these customers have been footing the bill for the broadband infrastructure in cities for years without any benefit and debate on what's morally right.
You refer to the interstate system, I think? Never mind that it comprises only a small fraction of the total roads in the US and fails to serve most rural areas, so it's not a very good comparison. Regarding phone service, your argument seems to be that if the federal government had never stepped in, those networks may never have been built. However, there's nothing to say that the states could (and should) have done the same, but handled it on a local level, rather than the one-size-fits-all approach inherent in a Federal Gov't approach.

"cusp of finally getting broadband rolled out to the bulk of America" You've got your quantities mixed up. Broadband internet is already available to the bulk of America. It's the minority that's left.

As for the high-speed rail, I presume that since I live in a suburban area, I would fall into the category of those who would benefit. And I strongly oppose it. This is a good Soapbox topic, but the population density and geography of the US make it impractical, too expensive, and too ineffective.

I guess what I'm arguing is that rural areas should not subsidize urban areas, and vice versa. Urban areas should pay for their own infrastructure upgrades, and rural areas should likewise be responsible for theirs.
 
This has been addressed many times, cities are subsidized by rural areas too.

But do they deserve it? Yes. Just as they deserve running water, electricity and everything else a civilized nation has, like broadband internet access. It's called socialism, and it's what brought our nation running water to rural areas, that existed even in Roman times yet most of us had grandparents who had no running water in this country.

I live in a city, and stand with the all the people of this nation. They deserve what they, and I, can shove down your throat. This will go through, you're going to pay for it through wealth redistribution, and you're not going to like it.

Hahahahah....oh, good one. Love the sarcasm in this post.
 
You refer to the interstate system, I think? Never mind that it comprises only a small fraction of the total roads in the US and fails to serve most rural areas, so it's not a very good comparison. Regarding phone service, your argument seems to be that if the federal government had never stepped in, those networks may never have been built. However, there's nothing to say that the states could (and should) have done the same, but handled it on a local level, rather than the one-size-fits-all approach inherent in a Federal Gov't approach.

"cusp of finally getting broadband rolled out to the bulk of America" You've got your quantities mixed up. Broadband internet is already available to the bulk of America. It's the minority that's left.

As for the high-speed rail, I presume that since I live in a suburban area, I would fall into the category of those who would benefit. And I strongly oppose it. This is a good Soapbox topic, but the population density and geography of the US make it impractical, too expensive, and too ineffective.

I guess what I'm arguing is that rural areas should not subsidize urban areas, and vice versa. Urban areas should pay for their own infrastructure upgrades, and rural areas should likewise be responsible for theirs.

No... The states refused to build roads until the fed gov made them do it or set up funding for states to get it done. States were apathetic to the needs of their constituency.

The phone system was standardized by the fed gov also. You're arguing that people in rural areas don't need 911 service? Because that's the main purpose of it; not to call your GF down the road.

40% of America has no access to broadband internet. And that's going by the Telco and cable definition of broadband. They say anything above dialup is broadband; not the 4mb standard the FCC wants. I guess that you are technically right since anything above 50% is a majority of Americans. Modernize 60% of our country and let the other 40% languish in antiquity?

But what you're saying is that since 60% of Americans have broadband internet access in their areas, then the rest of us can go twiddle our thumbs and continue to fund you'll living large in the city. Because that's what happened to get us to this point.

The taxes I paid did not go to fund upgrades in my area. They went to fund upgrades in cities with the premise that they would spread to rural areas at a later date. After I paid to upgrade your lifestyle, now you're saying that you don't think you're obligated to return the favor. That we should stop right here and discontinue the program because I got what I wanted; Thank you very much.


Basically all I see is people arguing that everyone doesn't need equal opportunity in jobs, education, commerce, etc.
 
No... The states refused to build roads until the fed gov made them do it or set up funding for states to get it done. States were apathetic to the needs of their constituency.
Citation? This is new to me. If true, I'd like to find out more about it.
The phone system was standardized by the fed gov also. You're arguing that people in rural areas don't need 911 service? Because that's the main purpose of it; not to call your GF down the road.
I'm not arguing the need for E911. I'm arguing against it being a federal government mandate.
40% of America has no access to broadband internet. And that's going by the Telco and cable definition of broadband. They say anything above dialup is broadband; not the 4mb standard the FCC wants. I guess that you are technically right since anything above 50% is a majority of Americans. Modernize 60% of our country and let the other 40% languish in antiquity?
You say that like it is/should be a nationally-managed/controlled process. I disagree--states should be handling this themselves.
But what you're saying is that since 60% of Americans have broadband internet access in their areas, then the rest of us can go twiddle our thumbs and continue to fund you'll living large in the city. Because that's what happened to get us to this point.

The taxes I paid did not go to fund upgrades in my area. They went to fund upgrades in cities with the premise that they would spread to rural areas at a later date. After I paid to upgrade your lifestyle, now you're saying that you don't think you're obligated to return the favor. That we should stop right here and discontinue the program because I got what I wanted; Thank you very much.
To what extent rural areas subsidized urban infrastructure and vice versa in the past, I'm saying that such policies are a bad idea, especially on the federal level. It's also important to remember the rather generous subsidies given the rural areas in terms of agricultural subsidies...
Basically all I see is people arguing that everyone doesn't need equal opportunity in jobs, education, commerce, etc.
Nope, that's not what I'm arguing. I'm saying that if you decide to live in the sticks, you have no right to complain if certain goods or services are more expensive or unavailable. If it's such a big deal, quit whining and move somewhere that does provide it, rather than demanding that the rest of us pay for the consequences of your decision.
 
NC just finished installing the last public roads in the 90's. They waited for handouts from the fed gov to do so. In my area there are still dirt paths with road signs on them. But they usually lead to the one guy that wanted to live on a wildlife refuge.

NC wants to set the standard for Broadband in our state. They try every year to pass laws to make the Telcos install filters like the ones at high schools to keep bad things away from us. And they outlawed internet cafes as they have the possibility to encourage gambling. That's their definition of what should be done to regulate internet access. They could care less if anyone had access to the actual internet. That's why we have a federal government to oversee them.

As far as the E911 service goes, before everyone had a phone to call we had town "doctors". The term doctor is used liberally as these people had no formal training. If you got hurt you went to them because town was too far away. When I got a 3rd degree burn at age 7, there was no phone service in my area. So I was taken to one of these quacks until the real doctor could be contacted. Needless to say if I want my arm to look normal, I need plastic surgery now. If NC could have been bothered to install phones in my area for E911 service maybe I wouldn't be disfigured today.

But you argue that the fed gov sticking their nose into it and making them install phone service and E911 service was wrong?
 
Maybe we should have told the fed gov to keep their noses out of our state's business and grabbed pitchforks and marched on Raleigh; our state capital instead to get our basic needs met? We ended up paying for it with our tax dollars; why did we have to wait until the fed gov mandated it?
 
:mad:It really pisses me off reading some of the post of the individuals who disagree with serving our distant citizens. They pay taxes just like you and I and as stated by others, they hardly see any benefit from them. The "Internet" can be considered the most precious innovation known to man and anyone who disagrees of a certain demographics not receiving it because of a typical location should have a career of shoveling shit for a living for being naive, ignorant, and unintelligent. Using the satellite analogy is a poor excuse, cost are entirely too high (I work in this industry) and slow to enjoy the richness of the net and utilize it's full potential.

See it's not a matter of "they pay taxes lets not service them", I pay taxes but those taxes don't go to get me internet. While tax dollars may have given the push, it doesn't continuously fund my internet which is proven by how much in profit telcos and others make from ISP services. When Verizon(?) pushed FIOS out, they spend billions of their own money getting it in play, and you notice you don't really see that happening elsewhere. If it cost a couple billion to bring fiber to rural areas, fine, but then they better be able to pay those costs of keeping it going and not have that cost subsidized to the taxpayer, 200k people paying for a service makes the cost per person relatively low, 200 people paying for a similar service would make that cost per person skyrocket, since the cost of even 1 tech guy divided 200k times is easier to absorb than only 200 times.

You say using satellite is a poor excuse because of it's cost? Why do you think it'd be so cheap to run fiber optics all over the place to rural areas? As mentioned above, the cost of servicing said equipment would be really expensive, which is fine as long as those rural area people are willing to pay for that. Which judging by this thread they're not, they want the cost to them subsidized by the tax payer.

Most of us at [H] know how important the internet is. If our connection is fast enough, we have no need for a phone line or cable service as majority of those services could be attained through the net. Therefore, rural area's deserve high speed internet (none of that 3 Mbps crap) just like we do.
I still pay for tv, I still pay for a phone line. Hulu is nice, but unless you delve into the range of illegal you can't watch everything online just because you have a fast internet connection.

Rural deserves high speed internet? And on top of that "none of that 3Mbps crap... I live in San Francisco and all I got is that 3Mbps crap, I can't get any faster than that either where I live.. So please forgive me if rural areas wanting 10-30Mbps doesn't create a soft spot in my heart.



]Anything less is stiffling innovation.
huh? how?
 
NC just finished installing the last public roads in the 90's. They waited for handouts from the fed gov to do so. In my area there are still dirt paths with road signs on them. But they usually lead to the one guy that wanted to live on a wildlife refuge.

NC wants to set the standard for Broadband in our state. They try every year to pass laws to make the Telcos install filters like the ones at high schools to keep bad things away from us. And they outlawed internet cafes as they have the possibility to encourage gambling. That's their definition of what should be done to regulate internet access. They could care less if anyone had access to the actual internet. That's why we have a federal government to oversee them.
And what, pray tell, do we do when the federal government does something similarly stupid? Relying on the Federal Government to keep state governments in check is a serious case of fox-guarding-the-henhouse. Instead, what you should be asking is "why don't people in NC vote these idiots out of office?" or "why don't I move to another state without such stupid politicians?"
 
Well, it would be nice to get faster internet where I'm at. It's somewhat rural, but 1/2 mile down the road everyone has cable....I have neighbors on 2 sides but we are spaced out enough to not heat each other. I guess that is pretty rural right? All we have for internet is 3MBPs DSL or Satellite.

Anyone suggesting to get satellite probably has not looked at the plans and realized you have to sign under contract, it's 4x as expensive, and you get a data cap.

Unfortunately it seems that cable companies want to cap everyones data and charge more, rather than to invest more money to expand their existing systems.
 
That's why America has a system of checks and balances Mohonri. The wisdom behind it is that if the State is doing something wrong then you can fight it in court. If the courts don't agree then you can present it before the national stage thus the Fed Gov or FCC. If that doesn't work take it to the Supreme Court. And vice versa if the Fed Gov wants to pass something bogus.

Of course there are many steps in between but you get the idea. And as far as moving goes, I own my property and have inherited property close to my home. Why would I want to sell my home in this economy and start another payment? And every time a state makes dumb laws are we supposed to move?

And yes I try to contact my local delegates and make a difference. Took from 1991 until 1999 to get dialup in my area. From that point until around 2008 to get 0.5Mbps ADSL internet in my area. Trust me I called and complained every week without fail. I wrote also. The technician that installed my ADSL can't even get it because the phone lines at his house are too rotten to carry the signal.

They used additional funding during the ADSL roll out to install fiber at the school 2 houses down from where I live. But they say I can't get it until the FCC's package is passed and a standard is adopted. If they gave me fiber w/o allowing others in the neighborhood access; it would be illegal. And after fighting all these years, I'd rather wait for my neighbors to have access at the same time as me rather than be greedy.

But dealing with these people that only get elected because of which church they attended is maddening sometimes. But if I want to make a difference where I live then that's what I have to do.
 
That's why America has a system of checks and balances Mohonri. The wisdom behind it is that if the State is doing something wrong then you can fight it in court. If the courts don't agree then you can present it before the national stage thus the Fed Gov or FCC. If that doesn't work take it to the Supreme Court. And vice versa if the Fed Gov wants to pass something bogus.
Perhaps I should have been more clear. When I talked about the Federal Government doing something stupid, I meant the legislature and president. SCOTUS is entirely different.

My point is that the federal government should be prevented from doing this kind of thing, pushing the responsibility down to the states, precisely because it's easier to keep governments accountable the more local they are. If your (more) local government doesn't do things right, you can try to get them to change. If they don't, then you can try to get them replaced by someone who will do it right. If your neighbors are too stupid to get rid of the bums, then you move to a state/region with better politics. In this way, the states have to compete with each other, and there's pressure to do things right. The problem that arises when the least accountable government enacts such legislation is that 1) it's often not representative of the collective will of a large portion of the population, and 2) people can't vote with their feet. c.f. Obamacare

Of course there are many steps in between but you get the idea. And as far as moving goes, I own my property and have inherited property close to my home. Why would I want to sell my home in this economy and start another payment? And every time a state makes dumb laws are we supposed to move?
It's something you need to factor into your personal decisions about whether it's worth staying there. The benefits of owning the land and being close to your inherited property vs. the inconvenience of bad laws and bad internet access. Life isn't perfect.
And yes I try to contact my local delegates and make a difference. Took from 1991 until 1999 to get dialup in my area. From that point until around 2008 to get 0.5Mbps ADSL internet in my area. Trust me I called and complained every week without fail. I wrote also. The technician that installed my ADSL can't even get it because the phone lines at his house are too rotten to carry the signal.

They used additional funding during the ADSL roll out to install fiber at the school 2 houses down from where I live. But they say I can't get it until the FCC's package is passed and a standard is adopted. If they gave me fiber w/o allowing others in the neighborhood access; it would be illegal. And after fighting all these years, I'd rather wait for my neighbors to have access at the same time as me rather than be greedy.

But dealing with these people that only get elected because of which church they attended is maddening sometimes. But if I want to make a difference where I live then that's what I have to do.
And big kudos to you for being so active in pushing for things you support. Just please don't ask me to pay for it involuntarily.
 
No, they're poor. Any safety net measure that doesn't end up somewhat disproportionally benefiting people in conservative states that are not Texas is doing it wrong. The aforementioned states tend to have relatively high poverty rates, especially Mississippi which is statistically known as the poorest and fattest state in the union.

How does it fit with your caricature that 37% of Mississippi is black, and 95% of blacks voted for Barack Obama? You attempt to conjure up an image of hypocritical conservative hicks, voting against big government while receiving welfare, which for the most part is grossly inaccurate. While it is somewhat correct that the federal government does transfer money from blue states to red overall, Democrat voters are still receiving the lion's share. It might interest you to know that the median income of whites in Mississippi is twice that of blacks in Mississippi. Similarly, it might also interest you to know that the overall (not state specific) black obesity rate is 8% higher than the white obesity rate. It seems a bit disingenuous to malign Mississippi for being poor, fat, and conservative, when the poorest and fattest people in Mississippi vote democrat.
 
Here is my opinion. I don't think any tax payer dollars should be spent on this. I think it should be the responsibility of the people providing the internet, and therefore getting the profit that should have to front the bill. I don't think it's fair that us as taxpayers, should have to pay to have this crap installed, and then pay again monthly, or yearly to receive the service. I think all the responsibility should be placed on the broadband providers. If they want more customers, and want faster speeds to charge more for.....then guess what? They need to pay for it. Why should we have to pay to have the infrastructure installed for this, and then pay them again to use it monthly, or yearly? Seems to me that 1 + 1 = 8 in this case. Either the providers need to pay for the infrastructure, or our tax payer dollars that install this needs to include free internet to every family in america, up to a certain amount at least....I mean, if you are like 70% of us on this forums that uses major bandwidth per month, you should have to pay obviously. But some of those country folks barely even access the interwebs....so screw it. I just think the whole system is fu*ked. Just me though.
 
Back
Top