FCC On Schools: Basic Connectivity Is Inadequate

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Instead of hitting up the general public, where are companies like Time Warner and Comcast when we need faster internet for schools? I guess i doesn't matter, they would just find a way to pass the cost on to us anyway. :(

Wheeler on Monday laid out a plan to increase the so-called E-Rate fee on phone bills -- a longtime program that funds Internet access to schools and libraries -- by 16 cents a month, or just under $2 a year, as part of a more aggressive plan to get wider and faster Internet access to schools and libraries in the US. The current fee is 99 cents a month.
 
The internet is a source from instilling rape culture into young males. Why do we want to increase their internet access?
 
So, Wheeler wants the telecoms to be able to pocket more $$$ while still doing nothing to improve access. No surprise.
 
So, Wheeler wants the telecoms to be able to pocket more $$$ while still doing nothing to improve access. No surprise.

my thoughts exactly. Who is going to get the money and do the work? I'm sure big companies. then they'll just take it, do the bare minimum and no one wins but them. Hell they could just feed schools the FCC definition of broadband and wash their hands.

I'd rather the FCC just say here is money extend service to more than just schools.
 
and I guarantee the schools down the street from me will never see a faster connection than the 1.3mb BS DSL frontier feeds out here. Schools are in a valley and couldn't even get cell data if they wanted. Local library is the same way, fed by frontier DSL
 
Instead of hitting up the general public, where are companies like Time Warner and Comcast when we need faster internet for schools? I guess i doesn't matter, they would just find a way to pass the cost on to us anyway. :(

You aren't looking at the correct type of company. That is where they are. Time Warner and Comcast are both CLEC and as such are unregulated and not required to do anything special or offer anything special. They don't have to collect any fees or anything like that. Your ILECs however have to collect all these fees and have to offer certain levels of service to these locations. Since you can't force the companies then to do this out of pocket they turn around and just jack up the rates that we are already paying for these type of services and turn around to give to the schools to pay for services.

The school or library can get whoever they want then for internet and every few months they are cut a check for them to pay toward their services.
 
Instead of hitting up the general public, where are companies like Time Warner and Comcast when we need faster internet for schools? I guess i doesn't matter, they would just find a way to pass the cost on to us anyway. :(

One of my local school districts steals $44 million from the taxpayer each year for only about 1,200 students and yet now on top of my obscense State and School taxes I'm forced to pay this idiot is claiming I need to pay more tax on my phone bill, to furture support the school district?
 
They'll get all the money and then change some provisioning to boost speeds with zero new hardware, cable infrastructure, or labor hours used.
 
One of my local school districts steals $44 million from the taxpayer each year for only about 1,200 students and yet now on top of my obscense State and School taxes I'm forced to pay this idiot is claiming I need to pay more tax on my phone bill, to furture support the school district?

Jeez. That's 3.5 times the national average for expenditure per student. Someone is either on the take or the school was constructed with marble.
 
Instead of hitting up the general public, where are companies like Time Warner and Comcast when we need faster internet for schools? I guess i doesn't matter, they would just find a way to pass the cost on to us anyway. :(

I'm cool with this. As long as they sue the shit out of the telecoms when they don't uphold their part of the bargain (should start immediately). Since that won't happen, I'm not going to support this.

Haven't the telecoms promised to upgrade infrastructure and got paid for it, but haven't done much at all?

My newest question is always - who's to gain the most financially from this? If the people supporting this are related in any way (campaign contributions, former employers, stock holders, etc.), I'm very skeptical. I keep seeing people proposing certain things, then you see that the huge profits go to one of their large campaign contributors. How this isn't bribery is beyond me. It's obvious, and I'm an idiot. So, if I can see it, I'm sure others can, too.
 
I'm cool with this. As long as they sue the shit out of the telecoms when they don't uphold their part of the bargain (should start immediately). Since that won't happen, I'm not going to support this.

Haven't the telecoms promised to upgrade infrastructure and got paid for it, but haven't done much at all?

My newest question is always - who's to gain the most financially from this? If the people supporting this are related in any way (campaign contributions, former employers, stock holders, etc.), I'm very skeptical. I keep seeing people proposing certain things, then you see that the huge profits go to one of their large campaign contributors. How this isn't bribery is beyond me. It's obvious, and I'm an idiot. So, if I can see it, I'm sure others can, too.

to answer your question, no. At least not all of them were paid. Verizon got paid, used most of the money as bonuses for their management and the rest went to "planning"
 
Another problem with internet to the public/government schools is that even if you give them great internet, it all has to be routed through some server at the county so they can lock down the content. The speed is now at the mercy of that one shitty server that's regulating the whole district.

That's the way it's done here at least. When all the teachers are trying to update their shit at the end of the day, you can forget about speed. Click, wait 10 seconds...... click, wait 20 seconds.........., click wait 30 seconds....
 
I agree 100% they need better internet, but Viper is right. The problem also comes through crap servers and filters. I hate seeing teachers try to branch out on teaching methods and then flop due to unstable internet, terrible wait times effectively wasting productivity time.
 
sure why not, I mean it's not like they're already reaming me with $14 worth of taxes/fees just for all the little bastards who apparently can't get funded by standard budget provisions, so what's another 16 cents.
 
What do they need faster Internet for? Have you seen school websites and the home pages that teachers set up? Let's not pretend they actually know how to use the Internet as an advanced teaching resource.
 
Because a lot of older teachers are moving out and the new ones do want to push content that requires faster internet. If I could swing it, which I am working avidly to do, my students would be almost completely paperless and running tablets. Students could then access materials remotely, I can actually stream video content and use websites or internet based projects on the regular.
 
to answer your question, no. At least not all of them were paid. Verizon got paid, used most of the money as bonuses for their management and the rest went to "planning"

same kinda shit happened in WV. Government gave frontier tons of money to upgrade and expand. they squandered it on BS equipment and verizon contractors who got paid big bucks to sit in an office and do nothing.
 
the public school system that my high school belongs to has exclusive access to fiber that runs through the town beneath the railroad tracks. They're being overcharged by at least 1000 USD per month for a mere 10-20Mbit down . . . this is how it was when I was in HS anyway
 
Connectivity to much of this country is inadequate,not just to schools.

The 90% of internet activity that people use that needs good connectivity is entertainment, the 10% that someone might need like banking, school homework, etc could work with dialup. So if someone doesn't like the internet where they live, they can move.
 
Because education will make people smart enough to realize the FCC is scamming them of course. They don't want children to learn with adequate resources. Idiocracy here we come. This world has come to a big "If we can just make them more stupid, think of all the money we can make."
 
Another problem with internet to the public/government schools is that even if you give them great internet, it all has to be routed through some
I can't speak for all districts, counties and states but we don't have to do that here. We have all of our 13 or so buildings connect through one connection to the internet through a larger WAN and we content filter at the main connection. Some services allow you to filter in the cloud and have a virtual connection to each building.


What do they need faster Internet for? Have you seen school websites and the home pages that teachers set up? Let's not pretend they actually know how to use the Internet as an advanced teaching resource.
Look up PARCC, really look into it and see the recommended bandwidth requirements per student. Then know that the testing window is not set by the district or school. This means that the number of students we test at a time (read also the number of devices to test from) is actually loosely dictated to us.



I'm actually glad to see the comments here are more tame than on a site where they do nothing but talk about broadband. There are still a lot of wrong things here but someone of them may be correct for places that are very far away from cities.

I can tell you that we have AT&T for our service and we have a discounted contract of government pricing AND then we have our erate monies cover portions of that. Without it we would not be able to afford a WAN or the Internet. We've moved recently from their Optiman service to their Giggaman service, both are fiber sisterms but the newer one is metro ethernet I believe and can offer 1Gbps (and possibly over) connections and it comes at less of a cost of Optiman.

In addition to just surfing the web there are things we have and support. We have our own email system, Web based student management system (accessible from home and by parents), and online library management also accessible from anywhere. We also use various online learning subscriptions, youtube (ugh!), a few video calls for Def and Hard of hearing, Video presentations by authors, Online testing, many state required reports and shoving of various databases back and forth. This is just by teachers and students, more is in use by staff and if we count internal and external use we have a security system including video recording and VOIP plus security access system as well. All of this is in use at the same time and some of it is considered life critical

Right now we do have a bottleneck and ironically it’s the content filter which isn’t covered by Erate but is mandated and must be CIPA compliant for us to get our funding. We knew it would be and it was to be changed along with the update but you know how things go.

This program does work and is helpful. Don’t think it is just going all down the drain into some telco’s pocket.
 
If any congressmen or senators are part of the department that gets to make these decisions owners of stock of said company?
 
Back
Top