FAST fastest IDE / SATA HDD

Finny76

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Aug 31, 2002
Messages
1,236
I'm getting a VelocityRaptor 300 but need a secondary IDE/SATA HDD that is close to performance of a RAPTOR.

Can anyone suggest me a SATA HDD thats 1TB+ and is second to none in Bechnmark and performance?

:confused:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Samsung F3 1TB. Fastest Sata HDD out i think?

Infact i think it beats the Raptor 300 because of its plater density in a lot of the tests... I know bittech has a review.

I'm buying 2 next week.
 
WD black or samsung F3

Infact i think it beats the Raptor 300 because of its plater density in a lot of the tests... I know bittech has a review.

the F3 is fast, but no way it will beat a velociraptor. first of all, raptors spin at 10k rpm, so it will give you faster seek time, which is what's noticeable the most. and second, the velociraptor also has a high platter density because you have to remember they now cram everything into a 2.5" form factor. it's just that the icepack adapter makes it into a 3.5". if you think of the older generation raptors, going from 150gb 3.5" down to 2.5" while doubling the capacity to 300gb is a huge improvement on platter density.

the only chance this drive have of comming close to the VR is if you short stroke the 1tb all the way down to ~100gb.
 
Well hence i said "I think" I wasn't 100%.

But by all means check the benchmarks (simulated and realworld)

Its still right up there with the rest of the drives, I think it wins in all the real world benchmarks.
 
Caviar Black is it!

But between the capacities which Black is the Fastest ?

1 TB: WD1001FALS
750 GB: WD7501AALS
640 GB: WD6401AALS
500 GB: WD5001AALS
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The Samsung F3 and Seagate 7200.12 both use 500GB platters, making them faster than the Caviar Black 1TB.

But to answer your question as to which Caviar Black is the fastest, it would be the 1TB, which uses 3x 333GB platters; unless they started using a single platter in the 500GB version.

IMHO, the performance difference between the VRaptor and the Caviar black isn't extremely noticeable. Sure the VRaptor is slightly faster, but not enough to justify its price premium and space sacrifice. Two Indilinx drives in RAID0 would murder a VRaptor and cost less, but again, sacrifice space (eg. paid $200AR for my 2x 30GB Vertex drives and now its a night and day difference for even less money than my 300GB VRaptor).
 
Last edited:
The Samsung F3 and Seagate 7200.10 both use 500GB platters, making them faster than the Caviar Black 1TB.


My original question was for the Fastest HDD, brand does not matter, but performance does.

If i decide to get the F3 or the Segate 7200.10 which one should i get?
 
Either or, they're both fast and performance difference between the two aren't much different.
 
I would recommend getting a SSD 64Gb or less whatever you can fit your base install with... and then pick up a reasonable storage drive for mp3's, photos, data etc.... No normal drive comes close to 200Mbs transfer ssd's do it everyday.
 
The Samsung F3 and Seagate 7200.10 both use 500GB platters, making them faster than the Caviar Black 1TB.

Do you mean 7200.12 ? And not 7200.10 ?

I have the Samsung F3 1TB. It's faster than my WD 640GB "Blue" AAKS drives (across the board, in fact), but it's also louder. I'm glad I got it though.
 
yes, sorry, 7200.12.

Hm... my F3 1TB isn't any louder than the two WD6400AAKS I have on my desk.
 
Regarding the cuda.12, its actually slower than the F3. I'd go for the F3 over the cuda. I was wrong earlier.
 
I guess the new SATA 6 drives will take over in performance.

Not really. The physical drive itself is only going to be putting out about 150MB/s, which is SATA I speed. The drive itself is still the bottleneck, so a faster interface isn't going to change much. Newer drives will continue to get new technology and denser platters, leading to ever-increasing performance, but the new version of SATA won't really change much itself.


One other thing to keep in mind is that the WD Blacks have a 5 year warranty. The F3 and .12 have 3 year warranties. You personally may or may not find that to be a major factor.
 
The Black still wins in seek time too. By a few ms over the F3 or the 7200.12. I think it's still the better OS drive overall. Though I haven't run an OS on a 7200 rpm drive in quite some time.

Dustin
 
I guess the SATA 6 wont benefit the IDE drives but more of the SSD's
 
I was just reading a review that had benchmarks. In that review the 1 tb caviar black was almost indistinguishable from the 300gb velociraptor in terms of performance. They were very close.

Didn't some [H] forumer say wd is coming out with a new velociraptor model?
 
I was just reading a review that had benchmarks. In that review the 1 tb caviar black was almost indistinguishable from the 300gb velociraptor in terms of performance. They were very close.
In terms of SEQUENTIAL performance; random IOps is basically rpm-dependent.

When people say 'performance' in 99.9999% they mean sequential performance when copying LARGE files. But you need only LOW rpm for those kind of tasks. You need higher rpm for system disk random IOps; assuming SSD is no option here.

So you can say a modern 2TB high-density low-rpm 5400rpm is faster than a 10K raptor drive in terms of SEQUENTIAL performance, but not in terms of RANDOM I/O performance.

As you all know, random IOps is virtually the only thing important if you will be using the drive as a system disk. Still, even for the system disk, many people look at irrelevant throughput benchmarks. Same people don't understand why SSDs are so expensive, as their sequential performance is just barely above HDDs (write anyway). Not realising that SSDs are up to 1000x (that is 100000%) faster when it comes to multiqueue random read IOps. The 1000 factor difference comes from 512 random read benchmarks with a multiple queue depth; there the SSDs do 70.000 IOps while HDDs do 50 IOps. That's the most extreme case, though. 4K random IOps is generally more realistic.
 
Don't get a Seagate desktop HDD, they are beyond horrible and will surely die on you within a year or two, maybe sooner.

The WD Black 1TB is awesomely fast and the Samsung F4 is very good as well for a standard desktop HDD.

If you want speed, then get two 15K Seagate Cheetahs and put them in RAID 0, though you may need SAS. ;)

Personally, I'd go with the WD Black as I have had very good luck with them.
 
Don't get a Seagate desktop HDD, they are beyond horrible and will surely die on you within a year or two, maybe sooner.

The WD Black 1TB is awesomely fast and the Samsung F4 is very good as well for a standard desktop HDD.

If you want speed, then get two 15K Seagate Cheetahs and put them in RAID 0, or go with a SSD.


I never liked Seagate drives, so its either the Western Digital Black or Samsung F4... I do plan on getting a SSD but NOT now... Maybe a few months later...

So for now i need 1 cheap BOOT drive for the OS...
 
Then definitely go for the Black, they are great and most come with either a 32 or 64MB cache which really helps for multi-operation tasks. They are also surprisingly quiet compared to other drives, considering they are 7200RPM drives.
 
Then definitely go for the Black, they are great and most come with either a 32 or 64MB cache which really helps for multi-operation tasks. They are also surprisingly quiet compared to other drives, considering they are 7200RPM drives.

Well at least i have narrowed my search down to 3 drives, so comparing specs we have:

1) SAMSUNG Spinpoint F4 320GB $50.27 (shipped)
SATA 3.0Gb/s, 320GB, 7200 RPM, 16MB Cache and Average Latency 4.17ms

2) Western Digital Caviar Black 500GB $66.28 (shipped)
SATA 6.0Gb/s, 500GB, 7200 RPM, 32MB Cache and Average Latency 4.2ms

3) Western Digital Caviar Black 640GB $69.99 (shipped)
SATA 6.0Gb/s, 640GB, 7200 RPM, 64MB Cache, Average Seek Time 11ms and Average Latency 4.2ms


All Drives are 7200 Rpm, Samsung has 16Mb cache, and the two WD have 32 and 64MB. The Samsung has a SATA 3.0 Interface and the WD have SATA 6, but I don't think the Interface is going to make any difference so no point of taking that into consideration..

I don't care about capacity size BUT what i really need to know how many platters these HDD have? and what is there performance from experience. I do NOT even mind short stroking to further improve speeds..

:)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The fastest would be 1. The 320 GB drive is a single head 600+ GB / platter drive.

The second fastest is 2. This is a 2 head 500 GB per / platter drive.

And the last is a 4 head 2 disk 320GB / platter drive.

Notice the higher areal density yields a faster disk.
 
There is so little difference between hard drives that any 7500rpm (is that the right number) drive is going to look the same to most users.

Only a SSD will be noticeably different.
 
There is so little difference between hard drives that any 7500rpm (is that the right number) drive is going to look the same to most users.

Only a SSD will be noticeably different.

No, there is a big difference between a WD Blue and a WD Black HDD if both have the same specs, normally a 10-20MB/s difference. It's 7200RPMs btw. ;)
 
Back
Top