eXtreme PSU Calculator Update

[[Spectre]]

Please do. I don't want any errors in it, either.

Like I said it would be for another thread though I am not sure how appreciative you will be after I give feedback

 

[454Casull]

Like I said it would be for another thread though I am not sure how appreciative you will be after I give feedback

You would be surprised at how much I can tolerate.

 

[mnemonik23]

Yes I did.

I wasn't addressing your page in my previous comment just your assertion that the calculator makes it easy to find how powerful a PSU is needed (which as mnemonik23 is aware from previous interactions I take exception with the method used as it does not provide the correct information). You didn't ask for a critique of your site. I could critique it and point out a number of errors, mistatements, etc. if you would like.....but that would be an entirely different thread.

I see that my calculator is not welcome here anymore...

If you are referring to Amps - they are coming, don't worry about it. But I do not see any reasons to call my calculator "bad" in every reply of yours regarding it. Is it inaccurate because of no Amps?

"...method used as it does not provide the correct information". Are you saying that current method does not provide the correct information about total wattage? You are wrong my friend. It is accurate.

How many times do I need to explain this? Current version just calculates the recommended total wattage. Is this information not 100% enough to select PSU? YES, it's not 100% enough and I'm stating it on my page.

Is this calculator gives you an approximate idea on total wattage? YES, it does.

 

[[Spectre]]

If you look back you will notice we already discussed this previously.

Is it inaccurate because of no Amps? [/color]

That would be correct it is innacurrate because there are no amp values with their associated distribution. Which we had discussed but nothing came from.

"...method used as it does not provide the correct information". Are you saying that current method does not provide the correct information about total wattage? You are wrong my friend. It is accurate.

Well I would say that isn't completely true. As an example are you using family TDP on AMD processors to determine wattage? If so that will skew your wattage high. In addition your estimates generally come out pretty high compared to real world measurements. This makes me think that something is wrong.

How many times do I need to explain this? Current version just calculates the recommended total wattage. Is this information not 100% enough to select PSU? YES, it's not 100% enough and I'm stating it on my page.

You don't have to explain it to me....I know better. The people you have to explain it to are the people using it who think it IS enough and IS completely accurate.

I see that my calculator is not welcome here anymore...

You are welcome to post what you want that doesn't violate any rules....... which is why this thread has remained open. However, when people ask questions or make faulty assumptions based on something people will answer and correct them.

 

[mnemonik23]

Nothing is completely accurate.

I rather have a total MAXIMUM wattage calculated for each component than one day end up with dead mobo or PSU.

For you (well not only you) it's inaccurate (too much watts) for dozens of other technicians on other forums it's too low. One guy (on c-net I believe) accused me that my total wattage is not acceptable because it's very low Go figure

 

[[Spectre]]

Nothing is completely accurate.

Maybe not but like we discussed before working to be as accurate as possible is better than relegating to being inaccurate.

I rather have a total MAXIMUM wattage calculated for each component than one day end up with dead mobo or PSU.

For you (well not only you) it's inaccurate (too much watts) for dozens of other technicians on other forums it's too low. One guy (on c-net I believe) accused me that my total wattage is not acceptable because it's very low Go figure

Well then I would introduce those individuals to silentpcreview then.........or just get them a kill-a-watt

 

[mnemonik23]

October 15, 2006


eXtreme Power Supply Calculator Mega Update: ATI R600 and GeForce 8800 GTX, Intel Quad CPUs and latest processors from AMD and Intel!

The following changes were made:

Graphics Cards:

- added GeForce 8800GTX - power consumption data is based on a few online sources (wattage value is approximate, not final)
- added ATI R600 - power consumption data is based on a few online sources (wattage value is approximate, not final)
- added ATI Radeon X1300 XT
- added ATI Radeon X1650 Pro
- added Radeon X1900XT (R580+ 256MB)
- added ATI Radeon X1950 Pro

Processors:

- added AMD Opteron 165 1800 MHz Denmark
- added AMD Opteron 165 1800 MHz Denmark
- added AMD Opteron 170 2000 MHz Denmark
- added AMD Opteron 170 2000 MHz Denmark
- added AMD Opteron 175 2200 MHz Denmark
- added AMD Opteron 175 2200 MHz Denmark
- added AMD Opteron 180 2400 MHz Denmark
- added AMD Opteron 180 2400 MHz Denmark
- added AMD Athlon 64 X2 5400+ 2800 MHz AM2 Windsor
- added AMD Athlon 64 X2 5600+ 2800 MHz AM2 Windsor
- added AMD Athlon 64 X2 6000+ 3000 MHz AM2 Windsor
- added Opteron 1210 1800 MHz Santa Ana
- added Opteron 1212 2000 MHz Santa Ana
- added Opteron 1214 2200 MHz Santa Ana
- added Opteron 1216 2400 MHz Santa Ana
- added Opteron 1218 2600 MHz Santa Ana
- added Opteron 1220 SE 2800 MHz Santa Ana

- added Socket F AMD

- added AMD Athlon 64 FX-70 2600 MHz Windsor
- added AMD Athlon 64 FX-72 2800 MHz Windsor
- added AMD Athlon 64 FX-74 3000 MHz Windsor
- added Opteron 2210 1800 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 2210 HE 1800 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 2212 2000 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 2212 HE 2000 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 2214 2200 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 2214 HE 2200 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 2216 2400 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 2216 HE 2400 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 2218 2600 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 2220 SE 2800 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 8212 2000 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 8212 HE 2000 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 8214 2200 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 8214 HE 2200 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 8216 2400 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 8216 HE 2400 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 8218 2600 MHz Santa Rosa
- added Opteron 8220 SE 2800 MHz Santa Rosa

- added Intel Xeon 7150N 3500 MHz Tulsa
- added Intel Xeon 5148 2330 MHz Woodcrest
- added Intel Xeon 5310 1600 MHz Clovertown
- added Intel Xeon 5320 1860 MHz Clovertown
- added Intel Xeon 5345 2330 MHz Clovertown
- added Intel Xeon 5355 2660 MHz Clovertown

- added Intel Core 2 Quadro Q6600 2400 MHz Conroe
- added Intel Core 2 Extreme QX6700 2660 MHz Conroe
- added Intel Xeon 3040 1860 MHz Allendale
- added Intel Xeon 3050 2130 MHz Allendale
- added Intel Xeon 3060 2400 MHz Conroe
- added Intel Xeon 3070 2660 MHz Conroe
- added Intel Xeon 3110 2130 MHz Kentsfield
- added Intel Xeon 3120 2400 MHz Kentsfield


http://www.extreme.outervision.com/