External enclosure's USB controller locked to Seagate drives?

Techno Pride

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 16, 2000
Messages
143
Long story short. My main OS drive, a Samsung developed read errors. Samsung's hutil scan showed CRC faults.

I pryed open my Maxtor Personal Storage 3200 external enclosure and it had a Maxtor DiamondMax 20 (actually Seagate 7200.9). So I used this 7200.9 internally and installed Vista Ultimate. Now I tried to install my spoilt Samsung inside this Maxtor enclosure to retrieve data. The controller is a Prolific PL2507. I had a data backup from Feb08, so the loss was more of time lost than data lost.

However, Vista (non-SP1, 30day trial) detects this as unknown device and refuses to install it. When I installed an old Seagate drive into the enclosure, it's detected as "Maxtor 3200 USB" and works fine.

Has anyone encountered something like that, where a controller/convertor is locked to a particular brand, in this case Seagate-Maxtor? Is this possible?
 
Yes, actually a Maxtor One-touch drive that was a few generations old. The drive inside died, so I thought, sweet, free (it was a friends) external USB drive enclosure, but it wouldnt work with other brand drives (forgot which I tried) other than maxtor.
 
Back
Top