External drive no longer shows up

silk186

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Feb 26, 2008
Messages
1,628
I picked up a Samsung M3 Slimline 1 TB USB 3.0 Portable Hard Drive less than a year ago for my wife. She is a film study and uses it to store movies for use with her macbook air. A few days ago she plugged it into her laptop and nothing happened. I opened the disk utility and it only showed the main drive. I plugged it into my win10 desktop and nothing happened. In all cases when I plug it in the blue light comes on. On my desktop it does show up in Disk Management, but as Unknown, Not Initialized. I know that I can format it but she would lose a lot of old, difficult to locate films that she has collected over the last three years and that I would have to find again for her. A few programs could find the drive but would crash, others couldn't even find it.

MiniTool Partition Wizard Free 9.1 finds the drive 'Samsung M3 Portable' but does not find any partition to recover.
It recommends www.powerdatarecovery.com

MiniTool Power Data Recovery 7.0 crashes when I try select any of the options from the main menu

Yodot Hard Drive Recovery crashes when I select the drive for partition recovery
 
If you're not already, make sure the drive is directly connected through SATA and removed from the enclosure.

Then give us the smart attributes. You can use crystaldiskinfo to get this. Post screen shot.

You are right not to format it, don't. Even if the drive may or may not be dying you can try and clone as much of the data off the drive as possible onto a new drive with recovery or imaging software.
 
I know that a SATA connection is needed for a smart scan but it is not an easy enclosure to open without both damaging it and voiding the warranty.
I'm considering getting Samsung to replace it but would like to get the data off of it possible. It would be very unfortunate if I failed to get the data off of it and voided the warranty.
Anything else I can try without opening the enclosure?
 
Not really. Formatting it may be the only option to even confirm if it is completely functional still. You MAY be able to run some diagnostics on it off of Linux live (flavor of your choice).
 
The other reason I suggest removing it is to rule out the possibility of a broken interface in the enclosure.

If you can hook the drive up to SATA and get the thing spinning long enough you can transfer everything off the drive with tools. Do not format.

It's up to you, do what you can to get the data, or warranty it and lose it.
 
Last edited:
I've just noticed that the drive beeps rapidly for several seconds after being connected.
I've only just noticed this now as the house is quiet and the noise is faint.
 
That's the beep of death. It can do that if not getting enough power, from bad connection, enclosure, etc. Otherwise the drive is going bad.
 
Take it out of the enclosure. The data is worth more than the $50 the drive would cost to replace.

Or you could send it off and pay a few hundred minimum for somebody else to take it out of the enclosure to try and recover the data.

And from now on, when you want an external drive, buy an enclosure and a drive to put in the enclosure.

That way you don't void the warranty when you have to take the drive out to recover the data if the enclosure dies.
 
Back
Top