x800pro. it costs more for a reason, the extra performance is there. the x800pro outperforms the 6800 in nearly every game available, with the exception of doom3.
if you were talking about a 6800gt though, that would be completely different.
Here's why: I have a NForce3 based mobo and an ATI 9800 pro card, there are documented issues in some games when using an ATI card with the NForce3 chipset. The issue doesn't happen when you have an NVidia card. I've been going back and forth with Activision support for 3 weeks trying to fix my 3-5 second lag every 2-3 minutes in CoD when I'm playing online and am finally giving up. No one wants to help I've tried ATI, NVidia, EvenBalance, and Activision. This whole debockle is the reason for my choice and I'm going to save my $ and buy whatever NVidia card I can afford and find in the 6800 series.