EU Pushes Button for Next Internet Age

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It is nice to see that the EU has put all that money it got from Microsoft and Intel to good use. :D

Europe geared up on Tuesday for a quantum leap in Internet traffic and a new generation of infrastructure to carry data, announcing the launch of a 600-million-euro research and investment programme.
 
Meanwhile in the US it's a race to implement caps and cell-phone style overages for going over the cap. Even if you feel the caps are reasonable today, do you see the caps increasing over time? Comcast implemented a 250gb cap in 2008 - 3 years later and it's still 250gb. Is that because internet traffic hasn't increased in the last 3 years?
 
How much shit does one really need to steal in a month?

It isn't always about stealing shit. Streaming videos, playing multiplayer games, etc etc. Require a lot of bandwidth too for us computer people types. Maybe not now, but soon these little gaps are going to be getting busted faster and faster as more intensive games and higher definition movie encoding comes out.
 
250GB is a pretty big number. You would have to dl around 10 Blue ray movies from Netflix to max it out.... yeah its that easy. Add to that watching things like Hulu or Southpark.com and without even stealing anything, you're at a high number.
Music doesn't take much bandwith, games are usually a DVD, so 8GB a piece and they typically last 20-100 hours, so maybe one a week?
Pr0n? I guess it can be up there with DVDs.
 
250GB is a pretty big number. You would have to dl around 10 Blue ray movies from Netflix to max it out.... yeah its that easy. Add to that watching things like Hulu or Southpark.com and without even stealing anything, you're at a high number.
Music doesn't take much bandwith, games are usually a DVD, so 8GB a piece and they typically last 20-100 hours, so maybe one a week?
Pr0n? I guess it can be up there with DVDs.

This about it like this. 5 years ago it was possible to surf the internet with a dialup connection. Now its nearly impossible because even news sites like CNN require you to download 2mb of code and advertisements. As speeds increase, websites become more complex.

And who the hell still buys PC games on dvd(more like DVDs, even free games like APB take up more than 8gb of space now)?
 
How much shit does one really need to steal in a month?
lol, they prefer the term "share." ;)

The caps affect only the top couple % of users and non file sharers who are in that range are likely a very small portion of those top bandwidth users. Right now.

The problem is the outrageous charges for overages and in the future, far more non-infringing usage is likely to use even more bandwidth.

AT&T bandwidth metering started 5/1 for me. Look how I celebrated on the eve of it:

2011-04-30 10.53 GB 0.89 GB 11.42 GB
2011-04-29 9.06 GB 0.39 GB 9.46 GB
2011-04-28 7.73 GB 0.37 GB 8.10 GB
2011-04-27 2.20 GB 0.07 GB 2.27 GB

I purposely wasted bandwidth re-downloading Steam games and a set of Ubuntu 11.04 discs before my criminal bandwidth usage would cost me more money. :rolleyes:

This is my last month with AT&T.
 
It is nice to see that the EU has put all that money it got from Microsoft and Intel to good use. :D

Sounds like more central planning, by our comrades in Mosc.. Brussels.

Am I supposed to be happy about that? Last I checked central planning never worked and never will. What's worse is that they are giving out money to private firms (who've probably lobbied for it) so it's safe to assume it is going to be way overpriced and in the EU will probably start filtering and regulating internet anyway so all that infrastructure will end up being used by the EU government against the people.

Am I too much of a pessimist? (Or just an experienced optimist?)
 
It is nice to see that the EU has put all that money it got from Microsoft and Intel :D

Yea, cause they won't be giving it back to them or anything when they realize they're going to need a shit-ton of Intel servers to manage the increase in data. . .
 
How much shit does one really need to steal in a month?

just because you have limited internet uses doesn't mean that everyone else does. Piracy is only a small reason why there are caps. Companies like Comcast and AT&T who are entering the cable tv business would be stupid to cut into those profits by providing unlimited bandwidth connections. That's what caps are all about.

With the internet, I see little reason to pay $40 more for a cable tv subscription, and I'm sure others feel the same way. Besides, internet caps stifle innovation for bandwidth heavy applications. I want to see more services like OnLive (cloud gaming) but they don't stand a chance with internet caps.
 
Even a highly compressed film is going to run you about 5GB an hour. When movies and television start increasing framerates to 60, it's going to be about 13GB/hour. We need to start building the infrastructure now and getting rid of caps now, or we'll end up feeling like dialup users when, say, Macedonia's web content and capabilities are blowing the U.S. out of the water.
 
Even a highly compressed film is going to run you about 5GB an hour.
These are Netflix's data rates, taken from the official blog:
  1. "Good" - The default setting with good picture quality and lowest data use per hour (about 0.3 GBytes/hour)
  2. "Better" - Better picture quality and medium data use per hour (about 0.7 GBytes/hour)
  3. "Best" - Best picture quality and highest date use per hour (generally about 1.0 GBytes/hour - or up to 2.3 GBytes/hour when streaming HD content)
 
These are Netflix's data rates, taken from the official blog:
You mean current data rates. And their "best" quality still looks terrible.

When video hits higher resolutions, 3D (double the bandwidth) and/or higher framerates (double or triple the bandwidth), or consumers demand compression that doesn't look as terrible as their "best" quality, bandwidth usage will skyrocket. AT&T and Comcast aren't just limiting their competition in the present; they're limiting it in the future as well. Businessmen aren't idiots; they think beyond today.
 
You mean current data rates. And their "best" quality still looks terrible.
Lend me your time machine so I can read your post in context with some future reality. ;)

Netflix HD streaming looks fine *for streaming video* at 2.5GB/hour. "Best" quality needs to be looked at in context of SD video, which it is. It doesn't look as good as my own ~1GB/hour SD encodings (2 pass x264 @ 2Mbps) but it looks OK.
 
Sounds like more central planning, by our comrades in Mosc.. Brussels.

Am I supposed to be happy about that? Last I checked central planning never worked and never will. What's worse is that they are giving out money to private firms (who've probably lobbied for it) so it's safe to assume it is going to be way overpriced and in the EU will probably start filtering and regulating internet anyway so all that infrastructure will end up being used by the EU government against the people.

Am I too much of a pessimist? (Or just an experienced optimist?)

Probably a little bit of both. I'll give you another funny that irked me about the the EU not too long ago.

In or about 2007, France and various other EU countries insisted that Turkey (a predominantly Muslim democracy) drop its law against wearing hijabs at Universities and public institutions because the secular laws the country had forbade it. Turkey was called repressive because of it.

Fast forward to 2010 France and various other EU nations institute anti-hijab rules for "public safety" reasons. It's ok for us to legislate it and it doesn't infringe on religious freedoms when we do it, but when it's your country, we'll tell you how you can't do it.

I look at shit like that and it turns my stomach every time I think of the EU. Does anyone doubt that there will be a double standard when push comes to shove when talking about crap in the future?
 
Sounds like more central planning, by our comrades in Mosc.. Brussels.

Am I supposed to be happy about that? Last I checked central planning never worked and never will. What's worse is that they are giving out money to private firms (who've probably lobbied for it) so it's safe to assume it is going to be way overpriced and in the EU will probably start filtering and regulating internet anyway so all that infrastructure will end up being used by the EU government against the people.

Am I too much of a pessimist? (Or just an experienced optimist?)
Well you are a pessimist :p because internet can't be controlled by someone or something. Also I don't know what regulations EU plans to put on internet, do you know about any?
 
Lend me your time machine so I can read your post in context with some future reality. ;)

Netflix HD streaming looks fine *for streaming video* at 2.5GB/hour. "Best" quality needs to be looked at in context of SD video, which it is. It doesn't look as good as my own ~1GB/hour SD encodings (2 pass x264 @ 2Mbps) but it looks OK.

Fattypants has a valid point. Bandwith requirements are only expected to go up with video based media. Rooting for the telecom/cable companies aren't going to win you any brownie points with them here.

5GB/h is where their content should be to in order to compete moderately well with BD. Other then a minor cost to them in extra bandwidth, the only real reason we don't see better encodes is because the communications giants are imposing ridiculous caps and horrible speeds across the nation. It's pretty obvious at this point in the game that Netflix wants to reposition themselves to an entirely (or damn close as possible) streaming media service provider. I'd say it's be pretty damn tough to compete with *it looks fine for streaming video content*.
 
Fattypants has a valid point.
Even a highly compressed film is going to run you about 5GB an hour.
It was more like he just pulled a number out of his^h^h^h the air. ;)

5GB/hour requires around a 15Mbps or faster connection. While that's not an impossible speed, it's a data rate that's available to less than 1 in 4 households in the US. Factoring in the cost of it makes it even less available since Internet service rates are highly inflated due to protected oligopolies.

For example, even though I live in a highly populated area, nothing more than 6Mbps-8Mbps is available.
 
It was more like he just pulled a number out of his^h^h^h the air. ;)
Dead wrong.

Ever watch a 1080p blu ray rip on modern codecs that used a data rate less than 5GB an hour? If it's not an animated show (and it has a surround sound audio track), it looks horrible. Colors washed out, compression artifacts everywhere. You'll want to stab your eyes out during dark or semi-dark scenes. Maybe youtube quality videos are your thing, but they're not for everyone.

And movies will only have higher bandwidth requirements in the future. 3D will double the bandwidth requirement. 60FPS will double it again. Increasing the resolution of what we have now will happen, and it will most likely be quadruple the resolution to seamlessly integrate with today's content.

In the near future (Hobbit, Avatar 2), you might take today's 10GB rips...no, better yet, we'll take Netflix's 2.3 GB/hour you quoted.
Multiply by 2 for 3D
Multiply by 2 for 60 FPS
Multiply by 4 for resolution
Multiply by X for whatever number of users you have in your house.

That's 36.8 GB/hour for one user. If you have someone in your house watching something else, assume 73.6GB/hour. At Netflix quality.

And that's just for television watching. Then you add in web browsing (which will likely get more bandwidth intensive), gaming (ditto), and any other web-based services that are not common or not invented yet.

When these things come and we're not ready for them, the rest of the world will laugh in our faces. They have a plan to be ready; we have a plan to keep lowering the amount of bandwidth we use to drive better returns on stock ownership.
 
Streaming roughly 610MB/s from your house just for you, in near future is quite futuristic idea, to have internet connection at home faster than in hi-speed data centers.
 
Maybe they'll developnew compression algorithms as well. If we wont make our pipes bigger at least cream more shit down them.
 
Dead wrong.

Ever watch a 1080p blu ray rip on modern codecs that used a data rate less than 5GB an hour?
If the topic was about playback from disc you'd have a point. Last time I checked the internets doesn't stream atoms of polycarbonite and aluminum. ;)

The streaming over the internets that *this* world uses has somewhat reasonable data rates that actual customers can use (and are cost effective to stream and are acceptable to the owners of the media).
 
Back
Top