eSATA drive causing system to freeze every few seconds.

JaYp146

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
5,546
Okay,

So I'm having a very odd issue with my eSATA hard drive.

The model # is a Samsung HD501LJ (500GB, SATA2) within an Antec MX-1 external hard drive. It is connected via eSATA to the rig listed below in my sig.

Prior to today, it was working fine and never had any problems. That is; transfer speeds were consistently topping out at around 70 MB/s, and no stuttering would occur.

However today upon transferring files from it to my internal 1TB drive, it began to exhibit a strange issue where it caused the system to "stutter" every couple seconds. That is - the mouse cursor freezes, any music playing begins to loop ... and then it goes away. Same happens again and again until the transfer finishes.

I ran HD Tune and got these results:



The only major piece of software I have installed most recently was VirtualBox - I immediately uninstalled it after this problem began with said hard drive, but doing so resulted in no discernible difference. I have not changed any overclock settings or done anything radically different than I usually do (software or hardware wise) in the past couple days.

Notable pieces of software installed:

Ad-Aware 2008
Acronis True Image Home
avast! Anti-Virus


Any ideas as to why this is happening? Thanks in advance.
 
Remove the ESATA drive then run the drive test on a remaining drive. If that drive also exhibits this behavior then it is not the ESATA drive. It is most unlikely that the drive is the problem, particularly if you are not constantly accessing that drive.
 
Remove the ESATA drive then run the drive test on a remaining drive. If that drive also exhibits this behavior then it is not the ESATA drive. It is most unlikely that the drive is the problem, particularly if you are not constantly accessing that drive.

I ran the test on the 1TB drive with the 500GB connected and it passed the same test with flying colors.

AFAIK I have nothing constantly accessing the 500GB drive.

1TB graph result:


 
Well, that would mean the drive is probably failing. If you have data on it, get it off. Then do a full format (not a quick) so that any bad sectors are mapped / replaced, then try again. If it is indeed the drive, then something that drastic probably means imminent drive failure.

I THINK the stuttering is an IDE timeout issue. When trying to access a drive the OS will wait up to X seconds for a response. Thus if the drive itself does not respond, the OS freezes exactly as you are describing.

To be honest I have never seen a graph like that that wasn't a result of OS processing while the test was running. However to be honest I have never even seen one with that degree of problems.

OTOH I am not a drive expert, and I do not even play one on TV.
 
EDIT - switching the drive's interface to USB 2.0 fixed the problem.

Obviously disappointing, seeing as how eSATA's much faster, but still...
 
Now wait, you said that you had it working. Did the ESATA go bad? I assumed that you tried another SATA port internal to the PC?
 
Now wait, you said that you had it working. Did the ESATA go bad? I assumed that you tried another SATA port internal to the PC?

I'll try internal SATA another time. The drive is "working" in the sense that it's no longer freezing while doing file transfers via USB 2.0.

I've not yet tried it hooked up to an internal SATA port, but the next time I open my case I'll give it a shot.

Thanks for the help.
 
Back
Top