ECA on Violent Game Study: 'We Remain Wanting'

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
According to our friends at Shacknews, the Entertainment Consumers Association has responded to that article we posted yesterday (here) claiming that video games made kids more aggressive.

One of the ways in which our stance is likely very different from others in the discussion on the subject is that the ECA would encourage more and better research on the matter. The problem has been, and apparently continues to be, that the agenda of the researchers supersedes our want and need for inclusiveness of all media--not just games--for the overtly sensationalistic spin that will inevitably be employed--to the exclusion of music and movies.
 
For me, this is really simple.

Video games... steadily increasing in prevalance, popularity, violence and realism for 20 years.
Violent crimes... steadily decreasing in prevalance for > 20 years. Especially in youth.

Reports like the one yesterday simply ignore this fact.

It's all a completely moot point anyway. Children aren't playing video games that are too violent without the knowledge and blessing of their parents. The blame was, is, and will continue to be on the parents.
 
Studies can be spun to say anything. It doesn't matter what so much what the study's results are once a person or group with an agenda gets a hold of it.
 
Human beings are aggressive by nature not just by outside influences. It is not always bad to be aggressive. Aggressive does not always mean violent. I wish people would quit trying to strip us of our nature and put us in their boxes because it just isn't healthy. On the other hand letting a 0-17 year play GTA or Postal is irresponsible. I am not saying that all children mature at the speed and 17 is a magic number either just a rough estimate.

Stop pixel violence!? Pixels have feelings too!?
 
90% of facts can be made to say anything...

50% of the time..

Riley
 
The statement from the ECA is very true.
In advanced statistics (regrading research and humans) courses
data can easily be manipulated to produce the desired results.

I think any study and any rport on the study should include the funding
sources of the study in the initial paragraph. Not only are researchers at fault but the media as well for treating research as fact.

I have been involved in statistical based modeling in human factors as well as life cycle analysis and have observed the nature of research first hand.

Source of money = Direction of and results of "research"....

especially in the human factors field...

Xeen
 
I have five children. Here's my take:

I am not stupid. I don't need a study from anyone to tell me how a video game is going to affect my kids. I spend time with them. I even play the games with them. I observe how each one if affected by what they watch and what they do. Each kid is different. If I don't like how they are being affected, we do something else.

We use common sense. My boys are still young (under 10). I look forward to watching Band of Brothers with them - but not until they are old enough to understand it. Same thing goes for "violent" games.
 
I have five children. Here's my take:

I am not stupid. I don't need a study from anyone to tell me how a video game is going to affect my kids. I spend time with them. I even play the games with them. I observe how each one if affected by what they watch and what they do. Each kid is different. If I don't like how they are being affected, we do something else.

We use common sense. My boys are still young (under 10). I look forward to watching Band of Brothers with them - but not until they are old enough to understand it. Same thing goes for "violent" games.

Parents don't, but whenever someone tries to make or stop policy they should have data to backup their claim, which is the point of the research.
 
having studied statistics in college i know how easy it is to make the numbers say what you want which is exactly whats happening here.

when explaining this to friends i give them this hypothetical example:

new study finds over 90% of the population is gay

although we know this is false, the statistic is true. why?

its true because the study was performed at a gay bar.

welcome to statistics!
 
It's just a numbers play game.

Crime has dropped
Video game violence has increased

See the irony in that?
 
Children aren't playing video games that are too violent without the knowledge and blessing of their parents. The blame was, is, and will continue to be on the parents.

QFT

Too many parents do not take the time to get to know and understand what their children are doing and playing. Game ratings and requirements can be legislated; proper parenting skills can't.
 
QFT

Too many parents do not take the time to get to know and understand what their children are doing and playing. Game ratings and requirements can be legislated; proper parenting skills can't.

At least not until we go the way of Demolition Man, and people need a license to reproduce.
 
Back
Top