EA Store or Steam???

Joined
Aug 11, 2010
Messages
801
I'm planning on getting BFBC2 expansion but dont know where to download it from better. EA store or Steam? I never tried them. I dont want to download extra software that the game requires in order to run or any of that. I know Steam is popular but does it run in the background when the game is running? or something like that. I bought the BFBC2 main game as a package not download so thats why I'm worried as to how that would work.
 
If you bought the normal game retail or on any other service you can not buy the expansion on Steam. The expansion on Steam requires you to own the original game through Steam.

Yes Steam does run in the background, but it has no impact at all on performance. It barely uses any resources. EA's downloader doesn't need to run once the game is downloaded and installed.
 
So steam is out of the question but I was just reading other forums and it turns out that EA store only allows you to keep downloading the game for 6 months. Why is that?
 
So steam is out of the question but I was just reading other forums and it turns out that EA store only allows you to keep downloading the game for 6 months. Why is that?

Whoever said that is an idiot. EA hasn't had that limit for something like two years.
 
I'd recommend Steam simply because having more than one downloader can be quite a clusterfuck. Steam does it well.
 
Whoever said that is an idiot. EA hasn't had that limit for something like two years.

I dont think so, EA says here

Performance of the Contract:

The products and services that we make available on the Websites may be downloaded or accessed for at least one year after you have completed your purchase. Certain products and services will be available to you as soon as you complete your purchase. In some cases, we may also give you the opportunity purchase a license for a software product prior to its scheduled release date...If you have purchased services from us, your right to access the applicable services will commence immediately after we have sent our purchase confirmation email.

from EA terms of service http://tos.ea.com/legalapp/termsofsale/US/enl/PC/
 

I wasn't aware that six months was the same as a year. Beyond that its a guarantee of at least a year and its something imposed by their host Digital River. After that year they're not obligated to keep it on their servers, but I've never heard of EA removing someone's ability to download a game after that period.
 
The products and services that we make available on the Websites may be downloaded or accessed for at least one year after you have completed your purchase

Ive had all the BF games on the EA download manager for years and have yet to have an issue up to and including this year.
 
Still guys, the fact that its part of their rules, is worrisome enough. Plus Ive read many who complain about having to re-buy the game because of it. Even EA customer support said the same in one forum. Sure i might just do a back-up but why all the effort of having a fake physical copy. I like games being stored on the net that why I would never lose them, especially expansions. How about Direct2Drive? I would like to use EA but they dont seem trustworthy.
 
Still guys, the fact that its part of their rules, is worrisome enough. Plus Ive read many who complain about having to re-buy the game because of it. Even EA customer support said the same in one forum. Sure i might just do a back-up but why all the effort of having a fake physical copy. I like games being stored on the net that why I would never lose them, especially expansions. How about Direct2Drive? I would like to use EA but they dont seem trustworthy.

I've had Mass Effect on my EA account since the day it released, over two and half years ago and that was back when they only had a six month limit unless you paid for longer. I've also had Burnout Paradise on my account since it was released, also well over a year ago. You as much of a guarantee of keeping your games with EA as anyone else, EA is just up front about it.

D2D is pretty good as well, though they really want to push you to use some shitty Gamespy program.
 
but there are many examples of people losing their games, like this guy:

http://www.davidcramer.net/other/455/the-ea-experience.html

He didn't lose his game due to any time limit issues, he lost it due to some kind of order screw up and since he never actually updated that post its impossible to say if he ever got it or not. If you look you'll find people having these problems with every download service out there. No service is ever going to have a perfect record. Just ask around these forums for people who have had issues with Steam, there are bound to be a number of responses. There is always going to be some risk involved, but all the big ones have a good enough reputation to be trustworthy.
 
I bought the BFBC2 main game as a package not download so thats why I'm worried as to how that would work.

If you bought a retail copy of BC2, then you cannot purchase the DLC from Steam. The DLC on Steam requires you to have bought the game on Steam as well. D2D might have a similar requirement, although it's not mentioned on their page.

Your best bet is to buy it from the EA store. Don't worry about not being able to download it again... all the content of the Vietnam DLC has already been released in the latest patch for the base game. When you buy the DLC, all you are really doing is buying a code to unlock that content for your game. You will enter that key in your BC2 main menu and it will then be associated with your multiplayer account. There isn't any separate content that needs to be downloaded from the EA store. So it shouldn't matter what their terms of service say.

For the record, many people have confirmed that EA does not impose limits on how long you can download stuff. They used to, a few years ago, but not anymore.
 
If you bought a retail copy of BC2, then you cannot purchase the DLC from Steam. The DLC on Steam requires you to have bought the game on Steam as well. D2D might have a similar requirement, although it's not mentioned on their page.

Your best bet is to buy it from the EA store. Don't worry about not being able to download it again... all the content of the Vietnam DLC has already been released in the latest patch for the base game. When you buy the DLC, all you are really doing is buying a code to unlock that content for your game. You will enter that key in your BC2 main menu and it will then be associated with your multiplayer account. There isn't any separate content that needs to be downloaded from the EA store. So it shouldn't matter what their terms of service say.

For the record, many people have confirmed that EA does not impose limits on how long you can download stuff. They used to, a few years ago, but not anymore.

DLC? We are talking about PC right? so you telling me I dont need to download anything, just get a key and thats it?
 
Yes Steam does run in the background, but it has no impact at all on performance. It barely uses any resources.

I have an OCed i7-920, and lately I've been catching Steam sucking up ~15% CPU. Resource monitor shows Steam doing absolutely no network or disk activity, so I don't know WTF it's doing.

While closing it and re-opening appears to solve it, it keeps happening and happening. And no, Steam's not hanging or acting sluggish at all, it's just sucking-up CPU doing... nothing?

I'm a big Steam supporter, but I'm finding your comment more and more false every day. Steam sucking up ~1/5th of an OCed 920 is a lot of resources, and if you're doing a CPU-bound activity, you'll notice it and catch on to it, as I have...

but there are many examples of people losing their games, like this guy:

http://www.davidcramer.net/other/455/the-ea-experience.html

Buying a game off of Gametap has the monopoly on this, though. Many people just resort to doing a chargeback to recoop their loses. There's a reason the company's rated an "F" by the BBB.
 
I have an OCed i7-920, and lately I've been catching Steam sucking up ~15% CPU. Resource monitor shows Steam doing absolutely no network or disk activity, so I don't know WTF it's doing.

While closing it and re-opening appears to solve it, it keeps happening and happening. And no, Steam's not hanging or acting sluggish at all, it's just sucking-up CPU doing... nothing?

I'm a big Steam supporter, but I'm finding your comment more and more false every day. Steam sucking up ~1/5th of an OCed 920 is a lot of resources, and if you're doing a CPU-bound activity, you'll notice it and catch on to it, as I have...

Recourse leak? Weird bug? Steam is using 0% of my CPU and 18.3k of memory at the moment.
 
DLC? We are talking about PC right? so you telling me I dont need to download anything, just get a key and thats it?

Yes, PC version. BC2 Vietnam is the DLC, or you can call it an expansion if you want. Point is, all the content for it has already been released in the latest patch. You will obviously have to download this patch (the game will autoupdate to the latest version). When you buy the Vietnam DLC/expansion, you will essentially be buying a key to unlock that content in your game.
 
So for EA store, does location matter? because they give different prices depending on location or something. US gets it cheaper.
 
man lots of FUD flying around here.

Recourse leak? Weird bug? Steam is using 0% of my CPU and 18.3k of memory at the moment.

Same here. I'm downloading a game as we speak and steam's taking up 1-2% CPU usage and 28MB of RAM.

but there are many examples of people losing their games, like this guy:

http://www.davidcramer.net/other/455/the-ea-experience.html
Now I’m in my order, and I see the title for “Unlock Code” but it’s empty below it, and I see no download link. Oh, there’s a “View Invoice” button, that must be where I go to download it! But wait, an internal server error, grrr.

At that point I think it would've been clear to most that you're not the only guy having a bad day. Some bad junk is going down on the back end. If you expect software or servers to function at 0% failure rate you'd better expect to have to make several more ranting blog posts in your life time. Shit happens.

Steam is a good service. I've got few problems with them and have had few problems with their service. Their service, (via their e-mail like support-tickets method at least), has been good if a little slow.

My experiences with the EA store are far fewer, but they very much mirror my experiences with steam. Support tickets can sometimes take a few days to get resolved, but I have yet to have one that has gone unresolved.

I buy pretty well all my stuff exclusively through steam now, just because the software is so good. If I were the OP, I wouldn't think twice about purchasing through steam.
 
Last edited:
OP, just so you know, it's been stated in various places by people at both Dice and EA that it doesn't matter where you bought your BFBC2 (retail, ea store, steam), you can buy Vietnam through any of the vendors and it'll work. I'm preordering through steam, but I have a retail copy.
 
OP, just so you know, it's been stated in various places by people at both Dice and EA that it doesn't matter where you bought your BFBC2 (retail, ea store, steam), you can buy Vietnam through any of the vendors and it'll work. I'm preordering through steam, but I have a retail copy.

It quite clearly says on Steam that you need a Steam version of BC2.
 
OP, just so you know, it's been stated in various places by people at both Dice and EA that it doesn't matter where you bought your BFBC2 (retail, ea store, steam), you can buy Vietnam through any of the vendors and it'll work. I'm preordering through steam, but I have a retail copy.

Thats because it wont run from steam? as the game already has vietnam patch, right?
 
EA store. You don't download anything, so there's no need to involve Steam. EA store is cheaper.

You just get a serial key emailed to you. Go for the cheaper one.
 
Recourse leak? Weird bug? Steam is using 0% of my CPU and 18.3k of memory at the moment.

KB? I've never seen Steam take less than ~29MB, and right now it's above 100MB.

Sometimes I wonder if the size of my acct's part of the problem, but if so, Valve's still gotta figure that out then.

But if I close and re-load it, it sits at 0%, just like I think it should be.

Come to think of it, I don't think I ever saw the problem 'til I started using shortcuts on Steam ("add a non-Steam game") and began using Steam to launch 3rd-party software. Perhaps this is getting it confused into some cycle. 15% CPU is quite a cycle, though.
 
Ive never used Steam but I might in the future when Portal 2 gets released so hope it doesnt have a negative impact.
 
ea store

dont ever use steam if you dont have to.

Why the heck is that? Steam is the greatest thing since sliced bread :) You can load the games on as many PC's as you want, good bandwidth, integraded chat and voice chat with a game overlay, automatic updating (for the most part, only had trouble with GFW games not autoupdating) and you can add and sometimes register games through steam that you bought retail. I highly recommend steam, not to mention their sales and promotion of excellent indy games.
 
Why the heck is that? Steam is the greatest thing since sliced bread :) You can load the games on as many PC's as you want, good bandwidth, integraded chat and voice chat with a game overlay, automatic updating (for the most part, only had trouble with GFW games not autoupdating) and you can add and sometimes register games through steam that you bought retail. I highly recommend steam, not to mention their sales and promotion of excellent indy games.

He doesn't need to use it and it's more expensive than the alternative.
 
ea store

dont ever use steam if you dont have to.

EA screwed me out of several games because it stated that I had installed it on different computers. I will never buy games from the EA store again. I spent a whole month battling with there god awful support telling them that it had said I exceeded my installation limit. They told me to reinstall windows which I did and it still did not work.

Finally I ended up buying the game again through steam instead, don't use the EA store.

All the other people claiming that steam is cpu intensive, play games in offline mode.
 
Whoever said that is an idiot. EA hasn't had that limit for something like two years.

When I used it they did have a limit to how many times it could be installed, Steam does not have that limitation.
 
I have an OCed i7-920, and lately I've been catching Steam sucking up ~15% CPU. Resource monitor shows Steam doing absolutely no network or disk activity, so I don't know WTF it's doing.

While closing it and re-opening appears to solve it, it keeps happening and happening. And no, Steam's not hanging or acting sluggish at all, it's just sucking-up CPU doing... nothing?

I rarely reboot my computer.. I have an old 6700 OC'd to 3.6Ghz and steam is usually 0% or 1% unless I'm looking at stuff in the store or something, or it's downloading an update, then it goes dormant while a game is running.

really, unless you have a proper soundcard, it is likely using more RAM and more CPU than Steam.
 
EA Store < Steam

The guy's not asking in general. He's not asking which platform is a better content delivery system for games, he is asking which company to pay his money to in order to be able to unlock the content he already has.

The people advocating Steam are doing so out of blind brand loyalty. There is no content to be downloaded from either; it's already on his hard drive. You are telling him to pay more money for no reason.
 
Back
Top