EA Exec: Games Are "Too Hard to Learn"

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If your chief creative officer gets up on stage and tells the world that your games are "too hard to learn," you might want to take a long, hard look at the games you are making.

"Our games are actually still too hard to learn," Hilleman said during an on-stage interview at the DICE Summit in Las Vegas. "The average player probably spends two hours to learn how to play the most basic game."
 
He might have a point...most users might be idiots. If your users are so time limited and stupid an hour or so tutorial level is asking too much...maybe you as a game maker should just stick to Angry Birds.
 
So because soccer, football, baseball, and tennis have too many rules and its too complicated for an idiot, we will all now just play roshambo and kick each other in the nuts to make it simple.
 
So because soccer, football, baseball, and tennis have too many rules and its too complicated for an idiot, we will all now just play roshambo and kick each other in the nuts to make it simple.

Well why not? EA has been kicking their customers in the nuts for the past two decades now... Eliminate the middleman.
 
If your chief creative officer gets up on stage and tells the world that your games are "too hard to learn," you might want to take a long, hard look at the games you are making.

This is why we don't get good games anymore. Because people who aren't gamers think that games need to appeal to the lowest common denominator. I'm sorry that the average player sucks, however appealing to them makes terrible games.

Unfortunately those fly by night "gamers" also spend retarded amounts of money on games because they have a 2 day attention span. So those like me who actually want to get good at a game and spend the time are less appealing to those wanting to make money.
 
It does make a lot of sense, coming from an exec.

"Wait, you mean I have to do work to earn my pay and bonus?"
 
So you aren't supposed to learn a skill to play the game? To learn the game's mechanics, become proficient, and then win?

You just push a button over and over and soon you have progressed through the game?

We have a word for that.

It's called Television.
 
Maybe EA's execs are the dumb ones? Seriously i cant remember the last time it took me longer than 10 minutes to learn a game. AI Wars maybe? Dwarf fortress absolutely.
 
Finally EA can makes for people like me!

retard-superman.jpg
 
I guess EA's next batch of games will all be flappy bird clones now.
 
Maybe EA's execs are the dumb ones? Seriously i cant remember the last time it took me longer than 10 minutes to learn a game. AI Wars maybe? Dwarf fortress absolutely.

Oh I can. Any of the older Elder Scrolls games had learning cliffs. As did the early Fallout games. To name a few, OTTOMH.

I categorize "learning a game" as in knowing what all the elements in the GUI of the game does, granted....not just knowing the basic keyboard/mouse input layout.
 
So because soccer, football, baseball, and tennis have too many rules and its too complicated for an idiot, we will all now just play roshambo and kick each other in the nuts to make it simple.

Is the bomb (fist with thumb up) allowed, or is that DLC? :D
 
Oh I can. Any of the older Elder Scrolls games had learning cliffs. As did the early Fallout games. To name a few, OTTOMH.

I categorize "learning a game" as in knowing what all the elements in the GUI of the game does, granted....not just knowing the basic keyboard/mouse input layout.

Only daggerfall, and that was due more to the unrefined gui's of the day. I thought fallout 1 and 2 where actually very intuitive, tactics took a little but it was glitchy.

If it take your two hours to learn the gui your doing it wrong, or your playing dwarf fortress.
 
They have already dumbed down the average video game that children play them before they are even old enough to read. How much lower can they go? If they dumb it down any further, it will just be television.
 
If it takes your two hours to learn the gui you're doing it wrong, or your playing dwarf fortress.

QFMFT. If I wasn't convinced before that studios were run by morons, I would be one myself now if I was not.
 
he should go back an play some older games like super mario or metroid.
 
With the amount of Quick Time Events and 'press x to win' actions in modern games, you would think even a moron would be able to grasp the art of pressing a few buttons in sequence, no?
 
dear god there goes any hope of any good RTS or space sims form EA
Wing Commander and CnC are now permanently dead
 
QFMFT. If I wasn't convinced before that studios were run by morons, I would be one myself now if I was not.

They aren't run by morons...they're run by pretty smart people.

The guy flapping his gums here wasn't speaking to gamers...he was flapping his gums to get shareholders happy and try to get shares bought up by looking like someone who has an explanation why sales aren't what they should be. This "summit" is by and for industry execs to talk the business side of gaming...not the gamer side of gaming.


We bitching in this thread are the proverbial kids listening at the door to their parents talking shop after we're supposed to be in bed insofar as this summit goes.
 
Maybe EA's execs are the dumb ones? Seriously i cant remember the last time it took me longer than 10 minutes to learn a game. AI Wars maybe? Dwarf fortress absolutely.

casuals are shitting bricks at Elite
people cant seem to grasp if you cant afford to lose it dont fly it
 
I think there is plenty of room in the industry for super easy-to-play games. As long as there are quality developers making more difficult/deep games we all can enjoy, I see no problem.
 
So you aren't supposed to learn a skill to play the game? To learn the game's mechanics, become proficient, and then win?

You just push a button over and over and soon you have progressed through the game?

We have a word for that.

It's called Television.

Sounds like what Final Fantasy games have become. Having been a big fan over the years, it feels like it has progressed into a button masher.
 
They can't make a game with real difficultly, so they make games with crappy controls and randomized button mashing to get the player killed. Hence titles like Dead Space.

whats funny is i pretty much did just that
but that i play stuff like X-Plane and Falcon4.0 so...:p

Well, that is probably the most complex game in gaming history. Learning the controls, and then learning the tactics and how to survive is a whole challenge on its own.:p
 
They have already dumbed down the average video game that children play them before they are even old enough to read. How much lower can they go? If they dumb it down any further, it will just be television.

Nooo.. it'll be interactive... television with Quick Time Events. :eek:
 
Oh I can. Any of the older Elder Scrolls games had learning cliffs. As did the early Fallout games.

First time I played Fallout 1, I borrowed the discs from a buddy. No manual. Got through character creation and into game play. Instantly hooked.

The game was well designed and interesting.

Between disc and digital, I've bought Fallout 1& 2 at least 3 times each, and I keep playing them.

On the other hand, I think the last EA game I played was Dragon Age: Origins. Nothing they've made since then even looked good enough to get my attention.
 
Well, that is probably the most complex game in gaming history. Learning the controls, and then learning the tactics and how to survive is a whole challenge on its own.:p

see thats what makes it fun
 
Wow this entire thread is like a flashback to 1990, when everyone was bitching that Kings Question V let you choose a response to a question instead of entering a statement in a text box (which made games more challenging, but also meant you sometimes were searching for the exact keyword(s) the parser was looking for.

Those who loved text games in the 80's felt this was the end of gaming. As it turns out, games evolved, found new ways to become even more complicated, while drawing in a larger audience.
 
Too hard to learn is certainly not something that cross my mind with today's game. Games today have step by step tutorials, you don't even need to read any manual to learn the basics. It can't get any simpler than that.
 
Most new games ARE hard to 'learn'. Take Mario for example, how easy was it to figure out how to play that?!? Now a days the intro to a game is longer than a NES game level, and only you get to move around and press buttons you are forced through a tutorial level. AGHH
 
Most new games ARE hard to 'learn'. Take Mario for example, how easy was it to figure out how to play that?!? Now a days the intro to a game is longer than a NES game level, and only you get to move around and press buttons you are forced through a tutorial level. AGHH

Truish. You're comparing a mid-80's video game designed to get quarters from your pocket vs a PC game. There are still side scrollers being made, which are generally about the same as SMB.

If people have a problem with the tutorial, then it sounds like they need to make the tutorial more fun. I don't game much these days (sadly), but I can recall tutorials in MMOs that took an hour or so (the first time through) and I enjoyed them. They taught me how to use the basics of the game and it was part of the game.

FWIW, you might enjoy Trine.
 
Back
Top