E6850 or Q6600???

$150 or less kills your buget?:confused:

Well,you gotta draw the line somewhere,there's always that extra item you'd love to add,before you know it,you've got a bottomless money pit on your hands.:eek: I'm already arguing with myself over going with an 8800 GTS rather than a GTX.:( .
 
What happened to the games that worked on better gameplay and more efficient graphics? Half Life 2, CS:S....Those were the days.
 
Well,you gotta draw the line somewhere,there's always that extra item you'd love to add,before you know it,you've got a bottomless money pit on your hands.:eek: I'm already arguing with myself over going with an 8800 GTS rather than a GTX.:( .

I think it is totally reasonable to draw the line at water cooling. If you are a gamer, I think any Core2Duo with at least 4MB cache is going to be more than sufficient for this upcoming crop of games. Get a good air cooler and get a good overclock out of one. I think today's CPUs are offering more performance than most games can utilize.

The exception is Supreme Commander, but as I mentioned before, SC only uses a maximum of 3 (yes 3, not 4) cores, and only uses two of those cores for the vast majority of operations. In that game MHz matters more than number of cores (you need atleast 2, however) even though it is touted as a multicore game. I know this from experience.

You have to cut through the hype with emperical evidence. Game developers from this point on are going to be touting quad capabilities because it makes their game engines look more "next gen." But what game developers and hardware manufacturers say and what is true are often two different things. Until HardOCP and other sites get their hands on the games and can test on various platforms, we have no idea what kind of performance gains to expect from quadcore in games like Crysis, Bioshock, and UT3. I suspect the difference between a quad and an overclocked E6600 or equivalent will be very little.

What you can ALWAYS rely on, however, is that the graphics card will be the bottleneck. The videos of Crysis that I'm seeing reek of videocard meltdown waiting to happen. Once you get an 8800 series (especially a GTX) in your system you start to see how much more important the graphics card really is. I think it is somewhat nonsensical to concern oneself with quad-core and water cooling and whatnot if you don't have atleast a single GTX.

You can overclock a CPU until you are blue in the face but if your videocard isn't up to snuff it is all completely worthless. Worthless. At least, if you are a gamer who plays first person shooters. The videocard is what is going to dictate what frames per second you are getting at what resolution with what anti-aliasing settings. You just need a CPU that gets out of the way and will let the videocard do its thing. I don't think the physics in these Fall games are going to push a duo that hard. Just my take.

Also, it helps to set a standard for yourself because this is basically a sky's the limit hobby. The hardware just keeps coming and coming, BUT, if you game, the quality of your system is very much a subjective thing. In my experience, games look REALLY good at 1600 x 1200 or 1680 x 1050 (widescreen) with 4xaa and 16xaf and around 45-50 fps. After that you start hitting the point of diminishing returns in my opinion. Core2Quad is probably the way to go for futureproofing, but I don't think my E6600 is going to hold me back at all this fall. If anything, I'm worried that a single GTX won't meet my image quality standards.
 
Another thing that I’m picking up is that unless you’re running the best video card and memory the processor is not going to be the slow part of the system so it’s going to make minimal difference anyway?

And this is why discussing high-end CPU's using gaming performance as the criteria is downright silly and a waste of time.
 
Soo much info... Still can't decide!!! :confused:

What advantage would the 1333mhz fsb of the E6850 give over the 1066mhz fsb of the Q6600?
 
As I understand it, it's basically a new 'strap' (set of internal parameters/timings/tolerances to work with increasingly higher bus speeds) for the BIOS. An analogy would be like changing gears in your manual transmission car... you don't want to be running 40-50mph in first gear :).

So currently, there are multiple straps, at 200 (FSB800), 266/267(FSB1066), etc. The new cpus add another strap at 333/334 (FSB1333). Of course that new bus speed has always been available and most overclockers have hit that and much higher, so in that regard, there's no benefit. But presumably, the new strap would provide a better environment to work with at the higher bus speeds, but it may take some BIOS revisions to work out the details.

The short answer, currently at least is "not much" - not enough to worry about.
 
Here is what Epic Games had to say about this precise question in an interview with Voodoo Extreme.

Ask Tim: Quad vs Dual Cores for Gaming

July 20, 2007 - There was quite a debate about the benefits of Quad vs Dual cores for gaming at VE, so we decided to ask Epic Games' Main Man and Lead Programmer Tim Sweeney for his take on the situation.
VE - Assuming you were making a new rig to run today and tomorrow's games, which CPU would you recommend at the $266 price point? A Quad-core Q6000 2.4GHz or Dual-Core E6850 3.0GHz?
Tim - If you're buying a CPU primarily for gaming, the sweet spot of the market seems to be dual-core. There, you can get a higher clock rate than is available (at least economically) in quad-core. All UE3 games, for example, scale really well to two cores, and you get significantly more performance than single-core much of the time. Though UE3 and many other engines scale somewhat to 4 cores, the benefits aren't huge.

That will change in a couple of years, but that's another upgrade cycle.

If you plan to do heavy level-building and mod making, I'd recommend quad-core. The development tools scale well to quad-core, having lots of content authoring apps open in Windows benefits from quad-core, and if you're going to be running a dedicated server on your machine to test a mod while also playing on that machine, it helps for that.

And there you have it! Maybe it's a bit premature to be jumping aboard the Quad-core bandwagon, even at this low price, if your aim is just to game. Either way -- it's a great time to upgrade!
-- Robert 'Apache' Howarth

http://ve3d.ign.com/#807197
 
Well,you gotta draw the line somewhere,there's always that extra item you'd love to add,before you know it,you've got a bottomless money pit on your hands.:eek: I'm already arguing with myself over going with an 8800 GTS rather than a GTX.:( .

I hear ya.:p
 
If the game takes advantage of it, Quad core can be very useful.

160fs715946.png
 
Well, those benchmarks seem to directly refute what Epic said. Does anyone know how good an overclocker the Q6600 is?

Also, where did those benchmarks come from?
 
Well, those benchmarks seem to directly refute what Epic said. Does anyone know how good an overclocker the Q6600 is?

Also, where did those benchmarks come from?

They're from Anandtech. And I wouldn't base any decisions on an Xbox360 port that's not even a good game in its own right. It might be using 4 cores but who knows what it's doing with them. Unless you're hankering for a new CPU now I would say wait a couple months to see what advantages (if any) quads have over duals in Crysis, Bioshock, UT3 etc.
 
Back
Top