E6600 Now -- Q6600 Later

goleldar

n00b
Joined
Apr 20, 2007
Messages
24
I have been putting off buying a new computer for quite some time now. If I go ahead with the below build will I easily be able to upgrade to a Q6600 down the road? I read somewhere that going with a E4300 for now would be more cost effective until the price cuts in mid July. What do you guys think?

I want to use the rig to learn video editing and fuel my graphic & web design freelance business.

http://secure.newegg.com/NewVersion/wishlist/PublicWishDetail.asp?WishListNumber=5440806

CASE: ANTEC P180B

PSU: CORSAIR 520

MB: GIGABYTE GA-965P-DS3

MEMORY: G.SKILL 2X1GB DDR2 800 (F2-6400PHU2-2GBHZ)

CPU: INTEL E4300

COOLING: SCYTHE NINJA

FAN: REXUS PANAFLO CASE FAN

HD: (2) SEAGATE BARRACUDA 7200.10

DVD: SAMSUNG 18X DVD+-R DVD
MODEL SH-S183L OEM

DISPLAY: SAMSUNG 226BW

MOUSE: LOGITECH MX518

KEYBOARD: SAITEK BLACK USB WIRED ECLIPSE

OS: VISTA 64BIT ULTIMATE OEM
 
Will you be gaming? if not, drop the vidcard down to a $30 one, lol. Yes, the E4300 would be your best option, since its the cheapest Core2Duo. Drop the HZ ram sticks, no need for them. In fact, drop down to some DDR2-667 sticks instead. No need for higher speed with either of the three CPU's you're contemplating (E4300/E6600/Q6600; they all have a 9x multiplier, lol). Drop the X-Fi, its useless in Vista. Get the DS3 from clubit.com -- they guarantee rev3.3, which would be better for the Q6600.

Stock:
E4300: 9 * 200 = 1.8Ghz, DDR2-400
E6600: 9 * 266 = 2.4Ghz, DDR2-533
Q6600: 9 * 266 = 2.4Ghz, DDR2-533

Typical OC:
E4300: 9 * 333 = 3.0Ghz, DDR2-667, can prolly reach 3.4Ghz with this setup
E6600: 9 * 333 = 3.0Ghz, DDR2-667, can go much higher, 3.6Ghz w/ DDR2-800
Q6600: 9 * 333 = 3.0Ghz, DDR2-667, hard to go much higher on air, lol
 
^^^^^^ dont listen to this person above. Obviously doesnt know anything bout overclocking.

Everyone will suggest the Q6600 hands down. It will be great for upcoming gaming. Since they will be using more cores.

Also ive seen the Q6600 clock to 3.5ghz. highest 3.8 but remember. these chips run hot so Watercooling will be a factor.

But anyways. Best bang for the buck is Q6600 hands down.

They overclock well depending on what ram and mobo combo.

And why do you have your ram listen twice. Gskill 2x1gb and then 2gbx2 ? all you need is then

2x1gb .. :)
 
I just checked that link to your wishlist and you're rockin 8GB of ram (three different types), so I'm assuming you were changing things around and haven't deleted two of em off yet right?

That Q6600 will make life so much better when editing videos. Me and a couple of my friends make videos to enter into various competitions and rendering videos and digital effects with a single core CPU is the devil. The more cores the better.

Also, if you can, I would suggest going for a dual monitor set up. Scrap that 22" Samsung monitor and get two Dell 20" monitors at $219.00 each. A bit smaller but they run at the same res. That will of course require a bit more on the vid card side,
but this 7900GS is $139.99 after MIR:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814150202
 
^^^^^^ dont listen to this person above. Obviously doesnt know anything bout overclocking.

Everyone will suggest the Q6600 hands down. It will be great for upcoming gaming. Since they will be using more cores.

Also ive seen the Q6600 clock to 3.5ghz. highest 3.8 but remember. these chips run hot so Watercooling will be a factor.

But anyways. Best bang for the buck is Q6600 hands down.

They overclock well depending on what ram and mobo combo.

And why do you have your ram listen twice. Gskill 2x1gb and then 2gbx2 ? all you need is then

2x1gb .. :)

Yes... I OBVIOUSLY don't know ANYTHING about overclocking. :rolleyes: Just because you've seen some qc chips reach that high doesnt mean they all can. Getting all 4 cores stable is the hard part. They don't OC like the Core2Duos. The more cores to get stable, the harder it is to reach high base FSB speeds.

Q6600 best bang for buck right now (early june)? Are you insane? Its only good for video editing and supcom, lol. Sure, he'll be video editing, but that wasn't his question. He's already planning on getting the Q6600! He's asking if the E4300 will be good enough, FOR NOW, until the July price cut on the Q6600. Then he lists the E6600 in his wishlist.

Maybe he's deciding between the two different kits?

@OP: Anyhow, yes, the E4300 is the most cost effective solution to your plan. Other options would be the Pentium E21X0 series, which have half the L2 cache as the E4X00 series, but are a bit cheaper. Keep in mind, you could always sell whichever chip you get now to help offset the cost of the Q6600 at the end of July.
 
I have a few questions:

video card
What video card do you guys suggest for video editing? Would an 8800GTS 640MB make a difference?

memory
Should I go with DDR2 667 over 800?

monitors
What are your thoughts on (2) Dell 20" vs (1) Samsung 226BW?

Thanks guys.. I am going to throw my old computer out the window in a week hopefully
 
Which Dell 20" monitor? If it's the 2007WFP, then i'd definitely get that over the Samsung 226BW. Although, i'm guessing it's the E207WFP, right>?
 
Just now took a chance to look at the E207WFP. It like a great buy on the surface...
 
For video editing, you can use integrated graphics. It really doesn't matter, as most video editing apps will use the CPU exclusively for tasks such as encoding and whatnot.
 
Q6600. July 22nd. $266.. Hmmmmm lets see..Will future games benefit from more cores?

YES!.

Umm my opinion. Best bang for the buck.. Unless you dont care much for it

E6850 is also coming out at that time. Same price. 4mb cache . 3 ghz stock. and they have been hitting quite high in overclocking. so far 4 ghz is what Ive last seen.

Regardless. Get whatever benefits you
 
I have a few questions:

video card
What video card do you guys suggest for video editing? Would an 8800GTS 640MB make a difference?

memory
Should I go with DDR2 667 over 800?

monitors
What are your thoughts on (2) Dell 20" vs (1) Samsung 226BW?

Thanks guys.. I am going to throw my old computer out the window in a week hopefully

Will you be gaming? if not, drop the vidcard down to a $30 one, lol.

If you're not doing any 3D modelling or gaming, then you don't need a high power vidcard. Even with dual monitors, all you need is a dual DVI vidcard, which shouldn't run you more than $50.

Which CPU did you decide to go with? If it has a 9x multiplier, you could get away with DDR2-667. If the price difference between that and DDR2-800 doesnt matter much to you, then go for the DDR2-800 kit.

Its somewhat of a personal preference. However, your two choices are vastly different. The 2x 20's give you a lot more desktop space than a single 22" lcd. To make a single monitor worthwile to match against the two 20's, I'd look into at least a 24" instead. I prefer dual monitors, for more desktop space. When doing web dev, you can keep the code on one screen and see the result on the other. If you have cash and a deep desk, the Westy 37" is also nice.

Sell you're old comp or donate it... don't throw it away.
 
Back
Top