E-Readers Get Heavier With Each Book

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The results of a new study show that a 4GB Kindle, when completely full of books, is a billionth of a billionth of a gram heavier. Say what? This is what scientists at the University of California, Berkeley are doing?

Little solace can be found in news that e-readers too get heavier when books are added. A 4GB Kindle only gains the weight of a single strand of DNA when a book is added. When it's completely full it will be a billionth of a billionth of a gram heavier than when it was empty. That's a wrist-snapping 0.000000000000000001g.
 
I'm actually interested as to why it is heavier; isn't it the same material, only arranged differently?
 
is there equipment sensitive to even detect this accurately without it being variance?

Kind of like how if you run the same benchmark on a PC, you might be 100fps, 101fps, and 99fps over 3 runs
 
The real question, is who paid this guy to answer that question? and following up with, is there funding available for my study, to determine where this information might be useful?
 
I'm actually interested as to why it is heavier; isn't it the same material, only arranged differently?

Kind of like melting ice in a cup of water. The water level won't rise.


But I think that weight is coming from dust or finger smudges.
 
"Although the electrons were already present, keeping them still rather than allowing them to float around takes up extra energy – about a billionth of a microjoule per bit of data."

Still i think that there is some flawed reasoning there unless he means "at full charge, a full kindle vs an empty kindle, will weight more", in which case it does make sense, as the fully charged and full capacity kindle will require that extra energy and thus "will weight more".
 
"Although the electrons were already present, keeping them still rather than allowing them to float around takes up extra energy – about a billionth of a microjoule per bit of data."

Still i think that there is some flawed reasoning there unless he means "at full charge, a full kindle vs an empty kindle, will weight more", in which case it does make sense, as the fully charged and full capacity kindle will require that extra energy and thus "will weight more".

But the data is non-volatile, so it couldn't be solely due to the charge, otherwise the data would be lost once the battery runs out. Perhaps it is a one time draw from the battery that creates the extra infintessimal gain in weight?
 
Next up time to weigh HDDs and SSDs. ;)

Forget that, I want to weigh brains somehow...is the Far Side where the kid asks to be excused because his brain is full, factual? Or, if I read War and Peace is my brain heavier, and if I read Twilight, is it lighter?
 
Kind of like melting ice in a cup of water. The water level won't rise.


But I think that weight is coming from dust or finger smudges.

If the ice was (held) underwater, the water level would fall when the ice melts. Ice is less dense then water :-P

"Although the electrons were already present, keeping them still rather than allowing them to float around takes up extra energy – about a billionth of a microjoule per bit of data."

Still i think that there is some flawed reasoning there unless he means "at full charge, a full kindle vs an empty kindle, will weight more", in which case it does make sense, as the fully charged and full capacity kindle will require that extra energy and thus "will weight more".

Full Charge and Full NAND are two seperate things. The battery also gets heavier as it's charged. (much more so then the NAND, but still immesurable)

The real question, is who paid this guy to answer that question? and following up with, is there funding available for my study, to determine where this information might be useful?

It was just a quick calculation... why do all that for a 10 minute calc.

But the data is non-volatile, so it couldn't be solely due to the charge, otherwise the data would be lost once the battery runs out. Perhaps it is a one time draw from the battery that creates the extra infintessimal gain in weight?

Has nothing to do with volitile or non volitile. In fact it's probably more accurate to say this affects non volitile memory and not volitile memory.

It requires energy to force electrons into the trap and create the seal that keeps them there in a flash cell. This is the energy increasing the mass. Just like a chemical compound is heavier then the sum of it's elements by an extremely small amount.
 
Has nothing to do with volitile or non volitile. In fact it's probably more accurate to say this affects non volitile memory and not volitile memory.

It requires energy to force electrons into the trap and create the seal that keeps them there in a flash cell. This is the energy increasing the mass. Just like a chemical compound is heavier then the sum of it's elements by an extremely small amount.

I don't mean this in an aggressive way, but you seem to contradict yourself. Or at least the way I thought I wrote my post. What I mean was, it must be because it is non-volatile that the weight increases; if it was due to the battery charge, the weight change would drop which would mean something was being lost, which in non-volatile memory can't happen.
 
There is another good example of wasted grant money! I remember reading once that some college got a grant to study why a shower curtain comes to you while taking a shower!
 
I am really foggy on the specifics and I couldn't find anything on Google about it.. but I seem to remember some time around 1989 or 90 in MacUser, there was a contest or a challenge to it's readers to find out how much data and other computer related items & materials that added hardly anything. Eventually MacUser printed on it's back page a long list of weights for items such as what 1K of memory added to the weight a floppy.. stuff like that. Most of the numbers were very microscopic but apparently stuff like that was known about 20 years ago.

jared_subway2.jpg
 
So the energy in the battery is being converted into mass?

Or is that mass present in the battery simply being transferred to the drive?
In which case the device itself would have the same weight.
 
So with all other world crisis issues resolved this is what our best and brightest set forth to research.
 
Full Charge and Full NAND are two seperate things. The battery also gets heavier as it's charged. (much more so then the NAND, but still immesurable)

I didn't say that they were the same.

Maybe your reading comprehension isn't proper, but what i meant is that the only way for the statement to be properly true is when the data state changes yet the battery level is at a constant.

That is because in order for the data to be stored you "spent" some electrons there to create the charge. In a closed system, that is one where you didn't charge the battery and is perfectly insulated, then the total mass oughta stay the same, as it shouldn't matter if all the "extra electrons" are on the battery, "working on the nand", or just flowing around.

But if you have full nand and refill the battery, then the total energy on the system will be greater, in other words the total ammount of electrons inside it will be greater, and thus the mass will be greater.

Still, this is just trivia knowledge without any practical use at the moment as any physical design that has to take weight stress into account is built with safety factors that make this extra charge weight irrelevant.
 
I don't mean this in an aggressive way, but you seem to contradict yourself. Or at least the way I thought I wrote my post. What I mean was, it must be because it is non-volatile that the weight increases; if it was due to the battery charge, the weight change would drop which would mean something was being lost, which in non-volatile memory can't happen.

I just read your post wrong then. That's right.

There is another good example of wasted grant money! I remember reading once that some college got a grant to study why a shower curtain comes to you while taking a shower!
What grant money? It's amazing the conclusions people jump to. :rolleyes:
So the energy in the battery is being converted into mass?

Or is that mass present in the battery simply being transferred to the drive?
In which case the device itself would have the same weight.
It's not about the battery. The NAND only.

I didn't say that they were the same.

Maybe your reading comprehension isn't proper, but what i meant is that the only way for the statement to be properly true is when the data state changes yet the battery level is at a constant.

That is because in order for the data to be stored you "spent" some electrons there to create the charge. In a closed system, that is one where you didn't charge the battery and is perfectly insulated, then the total mass oughta stay the same, as it shouldn't matter if all the "extra electrons" are on the battery, "working on the nand", or just flowing around.

But if you have full nand and refill the battery, then the total energy on the system will be greater, in other words the total ammount of electrons inside it will be greater, and thus the mass will be greater.

Still, this is just trivia knowledge without any practical use at the moment as any physical design that has to take weight stress into account is built with safety factors that make this extra charge weight irrelevant.

My reading comprehension is just fine, you just don't realize that this little article (clearly) assumes and holds battery charge constant. It's about a kindle gaining weight over time as you add books to it. There's no reason to assume that they are talking about "how much can you fill the nand with a single battery charge"

Not only is it not really practical, but the weight change would be essentially immeasurable with current tech.

(YES, you are RIGHT, if you were to fill the NAND with data using the battery only (even if you told it to just write 111111111111....) you would have a net loss in weight, weight gained in the NAND would be less then what's lost in the battery, the rest is lost as heat)
 
I thought this was obvious?

Electron mass is 9.109 382 15(45) × 10^-31

So the more data on solid state media, technically it weighs more.
But by a on a magnitude that is negligible. Extremely. Negligible.
 
I thought this was obvious?

Electron mass is 9.109 382 15(45) × 10^-31

So the more data on solid state media, technically it weighs more.
But by a on a magnitude that is negligible. Extremely. Negligible.

Not even close. It even says clear in the article that the # of electrons stay the same.

I call bs on this one, you cant create matter out of nothing.

Thanks professor. Now the thread can be closed. :rolleyes:
 
For all the "this is what they choose to research?" people: The weight a Kindle wasn't the point. It was probably an attempt to put the results of some research into terms that would make sense to people.

Ever heard of Occam's Razor? What's more likely -- that a bunch of people who have repeatedly, over the course of years, demonstrated themselves to be some of the brightest among us, and then gone on to receive some of the most rigorous training in the history of the world, are doing something we probably don't fully understand -- or that a bunch of guys on a message board who have read a few sentences have all the answers?

Dunning-Kruger strikes again. :mad:
 
Back
Top