(Most of this is coming from my original post in the SFF forum here)
Okay, this post is probably going to be fairly long, but I want to make sure that I give all the information.
My system: DFI P55 MI-T36 w/ Core i5 750, 4GB RAM, ATI 5770 1GB, Win7 x64 / Ubuntu 10.04 Lucid
My primary display is a Gateway FHD2400 connected via DVI. I recently picked up a projector off Craigslist (Sharp XG-NV1U), an older model with VGA-in and a native res. of 800x600. The projector works fine at 800x600@60Hz (or 75Hz even) when connected with a DVI-VGA adapter to my MacBook Pro 2,2 (with an ATI x1600). It also works fine with a friend's recent Sony VAIO with a nVidia chipset connected directly to a VGA port.
However, I cannot get a picture out of my desktop. Once I connect it with a DVI-VGA adapter, I lose signal on my Gateway and nothing comes out of the projector. I usually cannot get an image back on the Gateway until I reboot once this happens. When I boot the system up with just the projector connected, still nothing appears - no BIOS boot screen or GRUB or anything. I've tried both DVI ports on the 5770. Using VNC, I have remotely fooled with all the settings - I have tried telling the Catalyst driver to ignore the EDID information (which I don't think exists anyway) and force the output at the resolution(s) I know work. I get the same results in Ubuntu. I also tried creating fake monitor drivers with PowerStrip.
I called XFX tech support and spoke to a knowledgable/helpful tech who said that sometimes the newer ATI cards are weird about what they'll output to and sometimes refuse to output when the EDID info is bad or non-existant.
At this point, I decided that since I use my desktop more for watching movies than gaming recently, I would try and grab a cheap card to replace it, so I got a nVidia 8400GS 512MB with one DVI output and one VGA output. Uninstalled all the drivers and switched over, and STILL NOTHING!
I'm completely baffled - why does it work totally fine on two other machines (with 2 OSes and both ATI/nVidia!) but my computer won't output at ALL with either card?
Okay, this post is probably going to be fairly long, but I want to make sure that I give all the information.
My system: DFI P55 MI-T36 w/ Core i5 750, 4GB RAM, ATI 5770 1GB, Win7 x64 / Ubuntu 10.04 Lucid
My primary display is a Gateway FHD2400 connected via DVI. I recently picked up a projector off Craigslist (Sharp XG-NV1U), an older model with VGA-in and a native res. of 800x600. The projector works fine at 800x600@60Hz (or 75Hz even) when connected with a DVI-VGA adapter to my MacBook Pro 2,2 (with an ATI x1600). It also works fine with a friend's recent Sony VAIO with a nVidia chipset connected directly to a VGA port.
However, I cannot get a picture out of my desktop. Once I connect it with a DVI-VGA adapter, I lose signal on my Gateway and nothing comes out of the projector. I usually cannot get an image back on the Gateway until I reboot once this happens. When I boot the system up with just the projector connected, still nothing appears - no BIOS boot screen or GRUB or anything. I've tried both DVI ports on the 5770. Using VNC, I have remotely fooled with all the settings - I have tried telling the Catalyst driver to ignore the EDID information (which I don't think exists anyway) and force the output at the resolution(s) I know work. I get the same results in Ubuntu. I also tried creating fake monitor drivers with PowerStrip.
I called XFX tech support and spoke to a knowledgable/helpful tech who said that sometimes the newer ATI cards are weird about what they'll output to and sometimes refuse to output when the EDID info is bad or non-existant.
At this point, I decided that since I use my desktop more for watching movies than gaming recently, I would try and grab a cheap card to replace it, so I got a nVidia 8400GS 512MB with one DVI output and one VGA output. Uninstalled all the drivers and switched over, and STILL NOTHING!
I'm completely baffled - why does it work totally fine on two other machines (with 2 OSes and both ATI/nVidia!) but my computer won't output at ALL with either card?