Dual Display Mystery

milas

n00b
Joined
Nov 26, 2006
Messages
31
(Most of this is coming from my original post in the SFF forum here)

Okay, this post is probably going to be fairly long, but I want to make sure that I give all the information.

My system: DFI P55 MI-T36 w/ Core i5 750, 4GB RAM, ATI 5770 1GB, Win7 x64 / Ubuntu 10.04 Lucid

My primary display is a Gateway FHD2400 connected via DVI. I recently picked up a projector off Craigslist (Sharp XG-NV1U), an older model with VGA-in and a native res. of 800x600. The projector works fine at 800x600@60Hz (or 75Hz even) when connected with a DVI-VGA adapter to my MacBook Pro 2,2 (with an ATI x1600). It also works fine with a friend's recent Sony VAIO with a nVidia chipset connected directly to a VGA port.

However, I cannot get a picture out of my desktop. Once I connect it with a DVI-VGA adapter, I lose signal on my Gateway and nothing comes out of the projector. I usually cannot get an image back on the Gateway until I reboot once this happens. When I boot the system up with just the projector connected, still nothing appears - no BIOS boot screen or GRUB or anything. I've tried both DVI ports on the 5770. Using VNC, I have remotely fooled with all the settings - I have tried telling the Catalyst driver to ignore the EDID information (which I don't think exists anyway) and force the output at the resolution(s) I know work. I get the same results in Ubuntu. I also tried creating fake monitor drivers with PowerStrip.

I called XFX tech support and spoke to a knowledgable/helpful tech who said that sometimes the newer ATI cards are weird about what they'll output to and sometimes refuse to output when the EDID info is bad or non-existant.

At this point, I decided that since I use my desktop more for watching movies than gaming recently, I would try and grab a cheap card to replace it, so I got a nVidia 8400GS 512MB with one DVI output and one VGA output. Uninstalled all the drivers and switched over, and STILL NOTHING!

I'm completely baffled - why does it work totally fine on two other machines (with 2 OSes and both ATI/nVidia!) but my computer won't output at ALL with either card? :confused:
 
Since you tried two completely different cards with two completely different drivers, I would start looking at the OS.

Do you have another drive you can do a clean install on and see if it works then? Maybe your windows install is screwed up.
 
i concur this has more to do with the os then anything else.. if you have a windows disc laying around.. try creating a partition or add some crap hdd in and install windows and see if it works but my guess is its something to do with ubuntu and probably the nvidia/ati linux drivers..
 
Got distracted from this issue, but it still exists. Also, perhaps I wasn't clear, but it's not an OS issue as far as I can see since I have tested both Windows and Ubuntu with both ATI and NVIDIA. It also won't even show up at the pre OS stage in the BIOS...
 
Back
Top