Dual Boot - XP Pro & Vista x64 issues

mlinz

Weaksauce
Joined
Feb 8, 2005
Messages
71
Ok, let me just jump right in here.

I dual boot XP and Vista x64 - I have 2 seperate partitions on the same drive. I had been running with out problems since RC1 was available.

The other day I was doing some work with a 360, I wont say what..

In order for it to work properly I have to disconnect my HD from the IDE channel it is on. I've done this 3 other times with out problems.

This time however, after I reconnected everything as it was I booted up and got a Disk Failure error message. After a couple reboots it seemed pretty obvious the issue wasn't just a startup error so I removed the IDE cable from the motherboard and put it into the secondary channel. This time when it booted up it loaded my boot manager as it had been doing with out issues previously, but with 1 small difference..

When I selected "Earlier Version of Windows" i.e. Windows XP it went to a black screen and then rebooted my PC. I tried a few more times and got the same thing. Next I tried to run Vista and it loaded up and works with no problems.

I checked out boot configuration files and made sure they were in the correct locations and also made sure the boot.ini was correctly setup

;
;Warning: Boot.ini is used on Windows XP and earlier operating systems.
;Warning: Use BCDEDIT.exe to modify Windows Vista boot options.
;
[boot loader]
timeout=30
default=multi(0)disk(0)rdisk(0)partition(1)\WINDOWS
[operating systems]
multi(0)disk(0)rdisk(0)partition(1)\WINDOWS="Microsoft Windows XP Professional" /NOEXECUTE=OPTIN /FASTDETECT

This is all correct afaik, all of the boot files are in the root of my XP drive... i.e. ntldr,ntdetect, along with bootmgr etc. They were there before when this was working as well.

The question is, how can I fix this? I am still able to access my XP drive from vista and see all of my programs,files etc. I would stick with vista for good, but there are things which I need XP for still and probably will for several months after vista is released. I don't want to have to format that partition and reinstall XP either. There has to be a way to fix it, I just don't know what it is. I researched a bit and saw some people with similar issues, but they haven't resolved anything yet and most of the things suggested I've tried such as making sure the boot.ini was correct, making sure the boot files were in the correct location and so on..

Can anyone assist me with this? Its driving me insane!
 
Try VistaBootPro, or try rebuilding the MBR on your drive with an XP disc.

Note the first two lines of your Boot.ini file: Vista doesn't use this anymore. I don't think the problem is in here, but in the transition from the Vista bootloader to the XP bootloader.
 
If I run Fixboot from the recovery console will that cause any problems with my vista setup though?
 
I dont know if this is the most elegant solution, but it should work.

-Use the XP cd recovery console to fix the XP boot problem. After this XP should boot, but you will have lost the Vista bootloader.
-Pop in the Vista cd and use the bootloader recovery option (can't remember exactly what its called, but its all GUI, so it's easy to figure out). After that, everything should work like before. (you might have to do the part with the Vista cd more than once (like it tells you after it finishes), but don't worry, it will work)

(xp fixboot will distroy the vista bootloader, but running the vista one after will fix that)

Alternatively, you could try using a nice program called EasyBCD (instead of bcdedit), but I don't know if that would work.
 
Just a small update here, and probably the end of my problems for now anyway


I ended up throwing the XP cd in the drive and running the recovery console. Once I was logged into my XP partition I ran Fixboot. I then rebooted the PC and it didn't load anything. I got to "Verifying DMI Pool Data" in the boot up and also Backup CMOS check etc. Usually right here is when it would load the OS or the bootloader etc. It just sat there doing nothing.

I put the drive back on the primary channel, got the system disk error again and then tried to run Fixboot again. Same thing, at this point it was pretty clear the problem was running a little deeper than some boot file problems.

Back into the recovery console I went and I ran CHKDSK and it said it found some errors so I then did CHKDSK /r and let that do its thing for awhile. Afterward I put the drive back onto the secondary channel where it seemed to be working a little better previously and tried again, this time I got an error that said "Error loading Operating system" and that just sat there. Not the same error as the System Disk error I was getting on the primary.

I messed around a little more and eventually used the XP disc to delete and repartition my hard drive, once the full format was complete it loaded all the installation files onto my drive and I rebooted. Same error "Error loading operating system" - Into the recovery console I went and discovered everything had in fact been written to the drive.

This is where I am now, I gave up and played some GOW, but honestly I've never seen a problem like this before. Right now I am chalking it up to a bad hard drive. I've had the thing for like 8 years and its one of the original WD 120gb drives it has seen many many formats and odd partition setups in its time.

Unless anyone else has some other suggestions I am probably going to snag another SATA drive this weekend to go with the SATA storage drives I have already. On the plus side, no more IDE :0
 
Back
Top