Drobo: Who has one here?

Joined
Mar 30, 2006
Messages
2,578
Hey guys, since I can't use the search feature at the moment I'd like to ask if any of you guys have a Drobo, and what do you think of it? I'm thinking about picking one up. (Inspired to buy one after I just lost 487GB's of data in a HDD failure).

I'll be getting the USB 2.0 Drobo for $349+(2) 500GB WD Drives for a total of $500


What are your experiences with it? Thanks again!
 
At one point, I had two of the first gen Drobos. If you're ok with slow USB 2.0 speeds, it's not bad. For a while, I had a system ripping CDs to it and the only time I experienced problems was when iTunes was then copying files from it to an iPod. But as far as data reliability, I never had a problem. It was easy to expand and work with. I got rid of them though because I didn't like USB 2.0 speeds and wanted NAS (tried DroboShare but still wasn't happy). But the two Drobos went to family and friends and they couldn't be happier.

One last aspect I didn't like was that the I had to pay for the last version of the firmware. :\ I haven't had to pay for any updates for just about any other device I have regardless of fixing bugs or adding features. That just didn't sit well with me.

Having said that though, it's a nice solution for easy and expandable storage and I never worried about data I had stashed on them. Just know it won't be a speed demon.
 
At one point, I had two of the first gen Drobos. If you're ok with slow USB 2.0 speeds, it's not bad. For a while, I had a system ripping CDs to it and the only time I experienced problems was when iTunes was then copying files from it to an iPod. But as far as data reliability, I never had a problem. It was easy to expand and work with. I got rid of them though because I didn't like USB 2.0 speeds and wanted NAS (tried DroboShare but still wasn't happy). But the two Drobos went to family and friends and they couldn't be happier.

One last aspect I didn't like was that the I had to pay for the last version of the firmware. :\ I haven't had to pay for any updates for just about any other device I have regardless of fixing bugs or adding features. That just didn't sit well with me.

Having said that though, it's a nice solution for easy and expandable storage and I never worried about data I had stashed on them. Just know it won't be a speed demon.


Ah yea, I can deal with the USB 2.0. I'm not looking for speed, but how much were the firmware updates? Thanks for the help! I think 349 is a steal for it at the moment.
 
drobos are a little overpriced imo.
 
I may have my info wrong as it's been a few months but when the last version I dealt with at the time came out, they introduced their "DroboCare" program as a means of extending warranty on the unit itself as well as being able to download firmware with new features. So for the duration of the intial warranty, you'll have no problems. Beyond that, if they release new firmware with new features, you'll have to pay for DroboCare and the price depends on when the Drobo was purchased. I forget what I paid but the warranty now expires some time in 2009. Firmwae that fixes flaws are free. It's just new features after the warranty expires.

See: http://drobo.com/buydrobocare/FAQ.html

In an e-mail response, they claim Sarbanes Oxley is what forces them to do this. I just know I won't ever by buying anything from Data Robotics until they stop this type of stupidity.
 
I saw some guys on Newegg saying that it was very slow. However, I am thinking that they must have had it connected to a USB 1.1.

USB 2.0 shouldn't be slow, unless I am missing something. 480Mbit/s is plenty of bandwidth, if the array is still slow, then it is caused by controller implementation inside of the Drobo.

I have a Cavalier external HDD that has a USB 2.0 interface and eSATA, through the USB I only get about 10MB/s on a good day, the eSATA goes up to like 35MB/s-ish. I think some manufacturers just skimp on proper USB 2.0 implementation on the enclosure side.
 
Then again, who's to say that it will actually reach the bandwidth limit of its interface? My external hard drive on USB 2.0 can only do 25 MB/s tops. I'm sure it has a higher STR than that, but for some reason, that's all it can do, when I copy big files (which will give you the best STR).

STR = Sequential Transfer Rate.
 
The Drobo website doesn't fully explain the technology afaik. This makes the product look like a gimmick. In some ways it reminds me of NetCells RAID 3 technology that was marketed as something revolutionary and new when it was just RAID 3.
 
The Drobo website doesn't fully explain the technology afaik. This makes the product look like a gimmick. In some ways it reminds me of NetCells RAID 3 technology that was marketed as something revolutionary and new when it was just RAID 3.

Exactly, this is why true "power-users" (id like to consider myself and Ockie in that group, oh mighty Ockie Scourge of Storage). Its a proprietary platform, which will only cause headaches later on. Its a bit overpriced, but youre getting a deal on one. Seriously tho, just slap some HDs in an old box and throw in a decent 10/100/1000 NIC and youre golden.
 
I use one attached to my mac mini doing service as a media center. It's the house iTunes repo and has rips of all our dvds to play through front row on the hdtv its attached to. I love it.
 
Exactly, this is why true "power-users" (id like to consider myself and Ockie in that group, oh mighty Ockie Scourge of Storage). Its a proprietary platform, which will only cause headaches later on. Its a bit overpriced, but youre getting a deal on one. Seriously tho, just slap some HDs in an old box and throw in a decent 10/100/1000 NIC and youre golden.


Wise words from a master himself :D

I agree with you 100%. I have been bit by these proprietary storage devices a couple of times... when the stupid thing corrupted (I wont name names) I was stuck out of data since the storage method it used was proprietary :(

I think the drobo will serve a lot of users just perfectly, but if you are serious about your storage, listen to xenotype.
 
Wise words from a master himself :D

I agree with you 100%. I have been bit by these proprietary storage devices a couple of times... when the stupid thing corrupted (I wont name names) I was stuck out of data since the storage method it used was proprietary :(

I think the drobo will serve a lot of users just perfectly, but if you are serious about your storage, listen to xenotype.

I completely agree with the disadvantages of using proprietary hardware/software but one has to realize a few things.
-Not everyone wants to build an entirely separate machine with the hopes of storing it in a closet somewhere. (Especially when I live in an incredibly small studio apartmen in Chicago).
-Though proprietary hard/software can cause occasional issues some people, it can have extremely exceptional benefits. Especially with updates/support etc. Most of the time the hard/software 'just works'. It's also streamlined to do specifically what you want it to do, without any previous knowledge required. I know what I'm doing with storage, but if I f**** a rebuild of a drive or anything of that sort, it's all my damn fault without any recourse or help available.
-Portability is a huge plus with me, it's the size of a shuttle pc, or smaller. I would do a RAID build if I had the extra time to do so. There's alot of things I don't know or prob. won't know about setting up a raid, including the add in of additional HDD's over time, including replacement of bad drives. Seems to me that the Drobo has that covered IMO.

Now, I'm not bashing Ockie or Xenotype at all for their methods. What you guys have done in the storage arena is AMAZING. I just think for some of us this is definitely the better choice for going in this area.
 
Heres the thing then, youd be better off with one or two external USB/FW800/Ethernet harddrive enclosure. You could get one, pop in a tb harddrive, and you'd have a better solution than what the Drobo provides. You would have to find or *gasp* buy some software for automated backup, but its redundancy isnt of any real value due to its proprietary platform.

Im not trying to bash the Drobo, but these all in one boxes are usually crap. Even I would prefer a buffalo Terastation or Thecus to the Drobo solution, if forced to chose between one. Read up on the reviews of it, its not that great.
 
I completely agree with the disadvantages of using proprietary hardware/software but one has to realize a few things.
-Not everyone wants to build an entirely separate machine with the hopes of storing it in a closet somewhere. (Especially when I live in an incredibly small studio apartmen in Chicago).
-Though proprietary hard/software can cause occasional issues some people, it can have extremely exceptional benefits. Especially with updates/support etc. Most of the time the hard/software 'just works'. It's also streamlined to do specifically what you want it to do, without any previous knowledge required. I know what I'm doing with storage, but if I f**** a rebuild of a drive or anything of that sort, it's all my damn fault without any recourse or help available.
-Portability is a huge plus with me, it's the size of a shuttle pc, or smaller. I would do a RAID build if I had the extra time to do so. There's alot of things I don't know or prob. won't know about setting up a raid, including the add in of additional HDD's over time, including replacement of bad drives. Seems to me that the Drobo has that covered IMO.

Now, I'm not bashing Ockie or Xenotype at all for their methods. What you guys have done in the storage arena is AMAZING. I just think for some of us this is definitely the better choice for going in this area.

In such a case, I'd prefer a NAS like the Thecus N5200 (which I have). It's a good middle ground, and as integrated / compact as the Drobo, except that it offers customization of RAID levels, a variety of network shares, and etc.

Drobo is like the Apple of NAS devices.
Many other NASes (including the Thecus) are like the Microsoft of NAS devices.

xenotype said:
Heres the thing then, youd be better off with one or two external USB/FW800/Ethernet harddrive enclosure. You could get one, pop in a tb harddrive, and you'd have a better solution than what the Drobo provides. You would have to find or *gasp* buy some software for automated backup, but its redundancy isnt of any real value due to its proprietary platform.

Im not trying to bash the Drobo, but these all in one boxes are usually crap. Even I would prefer a buffalo Terastation or Thecus to the Drobo solution, if forced to chose between one. Read up on the reviews of it, its not that great.

That doesn't work, since external hard drive enclosures are very clunky for a storage solution. I don't want multiple external hard drive enclosures littered all over my desk, with a cable going from each one. I want a single unit (both physically, and logically) with a single connection to hold my data and be able to move it around (occasionally, I will bring my unit to friends' houses) to share files. I agree with your preference of a Thecus box though. Despite its many firmware issues (which fortunately, I haven't encountered, but have seen on Thecususergroup forums), it still has a clear flexibility advantage over the Drobo.
 
Also I only spent
$349 for the Drobo, and (2) $58 Seagate 500GB drives. That still only brings it roughly 465~. I think some other solutions would be around the same price.
 
drobo is a great device. Most people don't realize just what it does and how well it does it. There isn't much else that could match it's features and those that can generally cost far more.

Raid solutions require drives of the same size or you lose space. Take forever to rebuild and your data is unavailable while doing so. And managing that is beyond most people.
If one builds their own server the closest solutions would be WHS, unraid or flexraid.
 
Back
Top