DOOM3 for nVIDIA and HL2 for ATi !!!

Status
Not open for further replies.
^eMpTy^ said:
What I really what to point out in this thread is that there is absolutely no reason whatsoever to believe that HL2 will run any better on ATi vs Nvidia. In fact, if driver releases keep going they way they are going for Nvidia it might end up leading ATi in HL2. We don't really know, and it doesn't really matter, but one thing you can say for sure is that HL2 will NOT counter the loss ATi suffered in Doom3.

Based on the facts about how the 2 companies build their GPUs I would agree with you. I am very interested in how both cards will perform in HL2... but then again .. when the hell is that ? lol. HL2 is but a memory in the back of my brain. I want that game to come out, but I've given up hope on it. One day I'll see a release date and care again. Until then.. its Doom 3, because its out in um.. less then 2 weeks :eek:

I personally just think ATi fanboys are just looking for something to hold on to, and looking terribly ignorant while doing so. All the more reason I'm glad I jumped ship to my 6800GT.

Its almost like politics at the [H] now a days... heh.
 
ShowMeThe$$$$$$ said:
And ATI is just as lame as Nvidia by getting in bed with a game company to ensure HL2 runs better on their cards. This whole Doom is for Nvidia and HL2 is for ATI is fucking dumb. Both games should run on both flag ship cards within 5 fps of each other. But noooooo......to much MONEY flying around.
Optimization is cool
Doom3 is heavily optimized to make it better for NVidia hardware
HL2 is heavily optimized to make it run on NVidia hardware

HL2 and Doom3 still have the same regular DX9 coding for ATI hardware
Doom3 had assloads of work done on the Nvidia path to make it better than ATi
HL2 has assloads of work done on the NVidia path to make it playable.

Now, who's really sleeping with who?
 
Killdozer said:
Optimization is cool
Doom3 is heavily optimized to make it better for NVidia hardware
HL2 is heavily optimized to make it run on NVidia hardware

HL2 and Doom3 still have the same regular DX9 coding for ATI hardware
Doom3 had assloads of work done on the Nvidia path to make it better than ATi
HL2 has assloads of work done on the NVidia path to make it playable.

Now, who's really sleeping with who?

If you read through the other thread with 82347123 replies, you'd know that there isn't an optimized path for NVIDIA.

The 6800 and the X800 series both run on the same path in Doom3. Sorry.

The fact is that the 6800 is completely new architecture, built for Doom3. The UltraShadow technology and what not was built with Doom 3 and other next-gen engines in mind. The X800 series is nothing but a beefed-up 9800 with a few extras, and ATI is now feeling the heat from that decision (in addition to being a generation behind). This, in conjunction with the fact that ATI blows at OpenGL, is why NVIDIA performs better in Doom3.

Unless VALVE seriously butchers and cheats the game to make it suck for NVIDIA, they're going to perform on par with one another as they do in pretty much every other Direct3D game.

Personally, I'll be playing both with my 9800 Pro.
 
Killdozer said:
Optimization is cool
Doom3 is heavily optimized to make it better for NVidia hardware
HL2 is heavily optimized to make it run on NVidia hardware

HL2 and Doom3 still have the same regular DX9 coding for ATI hardware
Doom3 had assloads of work done on the Nvidia path to make it better than ATi
HL2 has assloads of work done on the NVidia path to make it playable.

Now, who's really sleeping with who?

Your entire post is pretty much wrong. ATi and Nvidia both run the exact same codepath in Doom3 and they have for a while now.

I remember hearing something about Valve doing a separate codepath for NV hardware, but I don't know if that's still true, or if it ever was. In either case they teamed up with ATi with the whole voucher debacle so you can't really claim they were in bed with Nvidia at the same time.

Everyone wants to explain performance differences with conspiracy theories and unfair practices. Nvidia is out there beating down doors trying to get every game running as fast as possible on its hardware, and that's a very good thing. ATi does the same thing. There's nothing wrong with it, nobody is "in bed" with anyone.

Doom3 sucks on ATi hardware because ATi sucks at OpenGL, plain and simple. The only mysterious goings on involved is the mystery of why ATi hasn't written a decent OpenGL driver for the r300 core in the 2 years since its release.
 
Yep, ATi pretty much fucked themselves over with lack of opengl support. And they are suffering the consequences now.
 
Most of you are blowing this whole thing way out of proportion.

The 6800U has a 12fps, 7fps, 1fps, and 5fps lead over the XT-PE. (Following the benchmarks in order for AGP.) For an ATI card whose OpenGL drivers 'suck' they sure don't seem too far behind. Some of you need to put down the crackpipe and get some fresh air. I guess people need to justify their purchase or stand behind the company they swore an oath to.

I'm not denying the GT's supremacy over the Pro, just focusing on the top-tier cards.

As for me, I'm still stuck in the middle as to what card to keep. Using an XT-PE right now, and awaiting for Best Buy to ship me the freaking Ultra already.

- D.
 
datamage said:
Most of you are blowing this whole thing way out of proportion.

The 6800U has a 12fps, 7fps, 1fps, and 5fps lead over the XT-PE. (Following the benchmarks in order for AGP.) For an ATI card whose OpenGL drivers 'suck' they sure don't seem too far behind. Some of you need to put down the crackpipe and get some fresh air. I guess people need to justify their purchase or stand behind the company they swore an oath to.

I'm not denying the GT's supremacy over the Pro, just focusing on the top-tier cards.

As for me, I'm still stuck in the middle as to what card to keep. Using an XT-PE right now, and awaiting for Best Buy to ship me the freaking Ultra already.

- D.

It's not the fact that the Ultra beat the XTPE, it's the fact that the GT beat the XTPE.
The 6800GT has a 6fps, 3fps, 0fps, and 0fps lead over the XT-PE.

That's a STOCK GT...which is 195Mhz slower than an XTPE...and costs $100 less...

Now THAT's a BIG DEAL.
 
ATi has always been behind in opengl, no surprise there. As stated many times already, the difference between nvidias ogl and ati's is quite obvious. It's not too bad, but you would notice it. With Nvidias new line it looks as though the gap between their d3d performance and atis is shrinking, ati being a head by a little with eye candy turned up.

Now, lets take that knowledge and apply it to these games. If some of you can look passed your perception of what might be going on. Doom 3 = OGL. Don't get tooo lost now, but that means that nvidia will more than likely outperform ATi. HL2 = D3D. Seeing as how Dircet3d performance is pretty close between the 2, the differnce shouldn't be too great, but ATi might take the lead at 1600x1200 with eyecandy on. Neither game is out yet so i'm just saying what will likely happen.

Take the above with a grain of salt, I know a lot of you guys take your video card companies a little too seriously.
 
Killdozer said:
Optimization is cool
Doom3 is heavily optimized to make it better for NVidia hardware
HL2 is heavily optimized to make it run on NVidia hardware

HL2 and Doom3 still have the same regular DX9 coding for ATI hardware
Doom3 had assloads of work done on the Nvidia path to make it better than ATi
HL2 has assloads of work done on the NVidia path to make it playable.

Now, who's really sleeping with who?


Dude honestly if you dont have anything intelligent to say I suggest you dont post anything b/c you will quickly be burned alive

/me says, "BURN BABY BURN!!!"

::cough:: yea ah anyways I see your not completely educated in the facts of what is true and what is false so do yourself a favor and just sit back watch, read, and learn. Then you will be able to make either

a) educated and accurate posts

or

b) come up with an educated hypothesis for what mite be a future fact
 
NonBiasedUser said:
I bet you're on the computer more than anyone around here.
I am, for about 9 hours a day. Making money. But I know, more than most, the importance of unplugging and getting out more.

Doesn't change the fact that I'm seeing a bunch of bullshit conspiracy theories written by people who were in diapers when id released their first game.
 
I think both ATI and Nvidia have great products on the market. For the money, however, the 6800GT is an outstanding value compared to the alternatives. I planned on getting the X800 XT, or even the X800 Pro, but opted for the 6800GT after seeing these results. I just installed it a couple hours ago. :)
I just couldnt justify paying that much for the XT, and didnt want to be hamstrung with the 12 pipeline Pro. Sure, the X800 Pro works fine in current games but, who knows, Doom3 might be a good indication of the future.

On the HL2 issue, I think too many people are basing their opinion on the old, and, IMO, completely irrelevant benchmarks performed on the previous hardware. Take a look at the benchmarks again, then look at the 6800 D3D game benchmarks compared to the 5900 and 5950. It's almost 2x faster in a lot of tests. It doesnt take a rocket scientist to see the NV3x hardware was obviously flawed.
That doesnt mean ATI wont still be faster in HL2, but it surely wont be anything even close to what we saw last year with the beta.
 
datamage said:
As for me, I'm still stuck in the middle as to what card to keep. Using an XT-PE right now, and awaiting for Best Buy to ship me the freaking Ultra already.

- D.

What you should do is cancel your 6800u order, sell that X800XT PE for FAR more money then you payed for it on Ebay, and buy yourself a 6800GT.

What CPU do you have?

The benchmarking was conducted on-site, and the hardware vendors did not have access to the demo before hand, so we are confident that there is no egregious cheating going on, but it should be noted that some of the ATI cards did show a performance drop when colored mip levels were enabled, implying some fudging of the texture filtering. This has been a chronic issue for years, and almost all vendors have been guilty of it at one time or another. I hate the idea of drivers analyzing texture data and changing parameters, but it doesn't visibly impact the quality of the game unless you know exactly what to look for on a specific texture.
 
What you should do is cancel your 6800u order, sell that X800XT PE for FAR more money then you payed for it on Ebay, and buy yourself a 6800GT.

What CPU do you have?

Believe me, I'm contemplating that. But I've gotten used to gaming @ 1600x1200 (4x AA / 8x AF) and I'm not sure the GT can handle that as well as the XT or an OC'd Ultra. As for CPU, FX-53. :)

- D.
 
datamage said:
Believe me, I'm contemplating that. But I've gotten used to gaming @ 1600x1200 (4x AA / 8x AF) and I'm not sure the GT can handle that as well as the XT or an OC'd Ultra. As for CPU, FX-53. :)

- D.

What I think BG is trying to tell you (and by all means if I am wrong please do correct me BurningGrave) is that you should by the BFG 6800 GT OC and then OC it to a 6800ultra+. This way not only did you make back like a 25-50% profit off of ebay on your ATI card but you will also saver yourself $100 by getting a GT instead of an Ultra and then just OC'ing the difference between the two
 
Demon,

I know that. :) I'm just saying I can push the Ultra further that I'd be able to push a GT. I know most GT's are hitting Ultra speeds, but with my luck I'll get one that can't and I really don't want to deal with RMAs right now. ;-)

- D.
 
tshen_83 said:
this is just plain stupid.....HL2 ran better with ATI hardware in the last generation hardware(Stupid FX vs Radeon 9800) Of course the Radeon 9800s were better in DX9 stuff. With this generation hardware(6800 vs X800) I personally think that 6800 is designed better in hardware. 6800GT will perform on par with X800XT-PE and the X800 Pro is just outmuscled. I heard that ATI coming out with another SKU that only reduce the clock speed but will reserve the full 16 pipelines

I am not royal to any company, ATI or Nvidia or AMD or Intel, I just buy the best price/performance ratio products at any given time.
I completely agree. I am exactly like tshen. I got for what is best for me at the moment. And to be honest, I own an AMD machine with a nvidia card and a intel machine with an ati card so, I just go with what is best for me.
 
point well taken sorry to underestimate your intelligence ;) And mite I say thats a lot of cash you got lying around and thats gonna be a nice rig for both D3 and HL2, and everyother future fps game that will be coming out
 
datamage said:
Believe me, I'm contemplating that. But I've gotten used to gaming @ 1600x1200 (4x AA / 8x AF) and I'm not sure the GT can handle that as well as the XT or an OC'd Ultra. As for CPU, FX-53. :)

- D.

If you overclock it to Ultra speeds, you'll have no problem running most any game at those settings. And you'll get alot better OpenGL performance.

Of course since it sounds like your rolling in the dough, you might as well go ahead and order a 6800u. I would probably try placing an order somewhere else besides Best Buy. Check nV News for available vendors. Several people have been getting their Ultra's lately.

I would still try and sell that X800XT PE on Ebay because right now their vaporware and impossible to get. You could make a pretty good profit off one i'm sure. Their retailing for only $999 on the sites that actually have a few in stock.

Gateway has said they wont ship any more and CDW has no idea if they will get any in within the next month.
 
Burningrave,

Not rolling in the dough, even if it seems that way. ;-) There's a reason I ordered it from Best Buy since I get to use the nice no interest for 6 months plan. (Same place I got my XT from.) I figured I'd try both cards out and keep the one I prefer. I know there's other places selling Ultras, but usually for a higher price, and I don't want to add any more expenses to my CC. So for now, I have to depend and wait on Best Buy. :/

Demon,

No problem man. And thanks for the compliment. :) I made sure to build a nice rig so I wouldn't have to worry about upgrading in a while. You know, for 6 months.. kidding. :p

- D.
 
Terra, nice fps quote there bud. I was not focusing on exclusively on Doom3 but thanks for playing. A few others seemed to have missed my point as well. Graphics card makers shelling out cash to have the game perform better on their hardware is WRONG. Get it now? Mmmkay ty.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top