Don't Buy A Steam Machine

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
How long have we been saying this?

There’s no clear reason for anyone to buy into Valve’s platform right now. The audience that might be most sympathetic to the idea, devoted PC gamers, are far better off just buying or building a Windows-based machine so they can take advantage of everything Steam and PC gaming has to offer.
 
well...at least since the phantom console, so I'll guess 13 years?
 
Or do what I did, buy a Alienware Alpha at a tremendous bargain (lovely little machine) and run windows on it, even though it was intended to be a Steam machine.
 
SteamOS needed something to set it apart from Windows... like better performance, etc.
 
Or do what I did, buy a Alienware Alpha at a tremendous bargain (lovely little machine) and run windows on it, even though it was intended to be a Steam machine.

False.

The Alienware Alpha is a Windows console that will continue to be sold as such after the SteamOS version ships. Not that it will be measurably different from it, however.
 
Your false is false. Alienware Alpha was intended to be a Steam machine, but because Steam wasn't ready, Alienware put their own GUI over Windows. The bottom compartment for example was sized perfectly for the wireless Steam controller USB dongle, but since it wasn't ready they shipped a XBox 360 dongle instead which doesn't fit in the compartment.
 
Your false is false. Alienware Alpha was intended to be a Steam machine, but because Steam wasn't ready, Alienware put their own GUI over Windows. The bottom compartment for example was sized perfectly for the wireless Steam controller USB dongle, but since it wasn't ready they shipped a XBox 360 dongle instead which doesn't fit in the compartment.

Is that what that port was intended for?
 
steamOS is intended for console gamers. Definitely not PC gamers. even a real pc gamer making the switch would go with linux + steam, rather than steamOS.

The target sale for PC gamers is steam link. place it in your living room and have it stream games from your overpowered windows PC.

Steam Machines - not for PC gamers. End of story.

Even the weakest steam machine is comparable performance-wise to a ps4/xb1. They aren't the same games, but SteamOS already has over 1000 games. Missing some notable ones like GTA5, but has quite a few quality/popular ones. One of the most popular game I would consider missing on SteamOS is Skyrim. which is also missing from PS4/XB1. Yay backwards compatibility.

Game libraries are always small with a few major releases at launch. I would assume no different of SteamOS... keep in mind, steam machines aren't even launching for another few months and they're already doing pretty well. Just because they were announced years ago, doesn't mean they launched years ago.

And who knows, Valve isn't like anyone else who has tried this before. They have sway with some developers. There's still months before these things go live. Pre-order one? definitely not, but i wouldn't dismiss them completely. Keep an eye out.

The absolute real problem at this point is GPU drivers. In some games nvidia drivers can be better than windows games... In all cases, AMD is lagging behind. For as much as I feel like steam needs to sway developers to the SteamOS party, they need to get AMD to the linux drivers party.

In the end, its 2 things. 1) An attempt to bring console gamers to Steam, by giving them what theyve grown to expect from a gaming machine (controllers, living room, "just works"). 2) an attempt to loosen Microsoft's stranglehold on PC gaming. Gabe Newell has made it clear in the past(around win8 release) that he didnt like the potential direction windows was moving towards. lack of competition benefits no one.

Setting up a windows gaming competitor takes years (as we've seen). you dont want to wait til AFTER microsoft does something insidious to start, at that point its already too late. And worst case scenario, having a valid alternative may keep microsoft honest. which thus makes steamOS pointless, but at the same time benefits everyone.

tl;dr - designed to attract console gamers and to keep microsoft honest
 
Steam Machines - not for PC gamers. End of story.
A console gamer is going to move from the plug n' play environment in his XBOX or PS4 to...Linux?

Linux gaming is a chore even for [H]ard Forum posters. How is a person who doesn't even know what a driver is going to fare?

The nonsense about keeping MS honest is just that, complete nonsense. MS never attempted to strangle PC gaming, the CEO of Valve freaked the fuck out over an app store and went off on this bizarre Linux console quest.
 
steam os is built ontop of linux. what games work for linux will work for steam os.

one of the big issues of pc gaming is user interface and simplicity of hooking up to a big screen tv which is why console gaming has dominated in popularity for so long. with the big picture mode and default controller it solves alot of those issues. So no, while a hardcore pc gamer will probably have an sweet system setup somewhere, the mass market wont. its a good thing, maybe getitng more people over to pc gaming casually to more enthusiasts.
 
A console gamer is going to move from the plug n' play environment in his XBOX or PS4 to...Linux?

Linux gaming is a chore even for [H]ard Forum posters. How is a person who doesn't even know what a driver is going to fare?

The nonsense about keeping MS honest is just that, complete nonsense. MS never attempted to strangle PC gaming, the CEO of Valve freaked the fuck out over an app store and went off on this bizarre Linux console quest.

if microsoft put half the effort in pc gaming it did for xbox, pc gaming could be a bit ahead. but instead companies like valve have come and done what microsoft should have. (MS recently admitted they missed the market)
 
A console gamer is going to move from the plug n' play environment in his XBOX or PS4 to...Linux?

Surely Linux is well hidden such that the consumer only deals with the Steam interface. As an appliance, it's supposed to just work.
 
I just want something that I can easily stream games off my primary gaming rig to my living room TV.
 
well...at least since the phantom console, so I'll guess 13 years?

You had to go there...

phantomprototype.jpg
 
It has a niche market, but nothing more. It doesn't do anything a Windows PC can't, and it doesn't offer anything to console owners. But some people will buy it.
 
Valve seemed to go pretty silent for the past couple years.

- Not engaging the Steam Universe forums.
- Not acknowledging bug reports on Github.
- No significant work to SteamOS for years. (The only updates were to pull in upstream packages and newer drivers.)

Meanwhile they did do a lot of work in the Steam client (In-Home Streaming, music stuff, broadcasting, BPM, whatever) -- which, of course, is not SteamOS exclusive.

I think devs could look at that and be hesitant to commit to the platform. I've followed this for a long time and I'm being just bluntly honest when I say that I'm not completely sure if Valve is serious about this thing or if it was just a political push against MS and that was about it. (?)
 
If MS allows streaming PC games to an XB1, wouldn't everybody just buy an XB1 instead of a Steam Machine?
 
A console gamer is going to move from the plug n' play environment in his XBOX or PS4 to...Linux?

Linux gaming is a chore even for [H]ard Forum posters. How is a person who doesn't even know what a driver is going to fare?

The nonsense about keeping MS honest is just that, complete nonsense. MS never attempted to strangle PC gaming, the CEO of Valve freaked the fuck out over an app store and went off on this bizarre Linux console quest.

Guess what OS the PS4 is based on.? And yet no console kids have to touch drivers or command line there. That's the long plan for SteamOS.

"Microsoft never attempted to strangle PC gaming" that's cute. So when they paid off Crystal Dynamics to keep the next Tomb Raider off of Windows +after+ it had initially been announced as coming to PC, I guess that was MS showing love for Windows gaming. Or when Microsoft told all their first party studios not to include Windows versions.

Or when Microsoft decided to bring Halo 5 to Windows. Oh wait, they didn't. Yeah Microsoft loves Windows gamers.
 
steam os is built ontop of linux. what games work for linux will work for steam os.

one of the big issues of pc gaming is user interface and simplicity of hooking up to a big screen tv which is why console gaming has dominated in popularity for so long. with the big picture mode and default controller it solves alot of those issues. So no, while a hardcore pc gamer will probably have an sweet system setup somewhere, the mass market wont. its a good thing, maybe getitng more people over to pc gaming casually to more enthusiasts.

From the article

you can’t even play games that are compatible with Linux but aren’t on Steam
 
It has a niche market, but nothing more. It doesn't do anything a Windows PC can't, and it doesn't offer anything to console owners. But some people will buy it.

Except it'll be the first console that plays mods. And the first console to offer games at Steam sale price points and a network of competitive third party key sellers rather than a flat $60 for every game. A consolr with no overpriced pay-forever subscription scheme for multi-player access. A console where the platform holder isn't paying off developers to keep games off a competing platform - exclusivity bullshit is just lame. A console that is open to being hacked and modded and upgraded for people interested in that, but doesn't have to be for people that aren't. The list goes on.

There will always be naysayers with anything new because people just see their own little world, but hard to argue against these as being a good thing.
 
If MS allows streaming PC games to an XB1, wouldn't everybody just buy an XB1 instead of a Steam Machine?

if all you want to do is stream games to a console like device, just get a $50 steam link.
 
I'm all for more competition in the gaming market. I think the "steam machines" are more of a vehicle to catalyze Valve's ultimate goal: getting to the point where developers include linux/steamOS compatibility standard in new AAA titles. That would be the big win for Valve. Then you could have alienware sell their little "steammachines" to the masses while I still get to build my own rigs but download steamOS for free, if I just want to build a dedicated gaming rig. (And I expect steamOS, if it does get off the ground, will include streaming entertainment as well, so it would really be like a free gaming HTPC OS.)

PC hardware makers probably have as much incentive for this to happen as well, since mobile phones and tablets and laptops are eating up more and more of the classic PC market.
 
Instead of this nonsense, Valve should have been working on Half Life 3. I am beginning to get frustrated with their lack of fan service.
 
If Valve would have done what we all WANTED them to do instead we'd be happy right now.

What everyone expected was for Valve to leverage their insane market share of PC game sales to push a SINGLE distro of Linux (theirs) as the de-facto gaming OS.

Had they done that do begin with, we might actually be sitting on competing platforms right now where MS and Valve duke it out for gaming performance, efficiency and features.

But no. Valve just doggedly insisted it was only for these bizarre hybrid console systems for your living room that no one really wants or needs.

Give us an alternative gaming OS... just in case MS moves too far off the reservation with their desktop OS.
 
If Valve would have done what we all WANTED them to do instead we'd be happy right now.

What everyone expected was for Valve to leverage their insane market share of PC game sales to push a SINGLE distro of Linux (theirs) as the de-facto gaming OS.

Had they done that do begin with, we might actually be sitting on competing platforms right now where MS and Valve duke it out for gaming performance, efficiency and features.

But no. Valve just doggedly insisted it was only for these bizarre hybrid console systems for your living room that no one really wants or needs.

Give us an alternative gaming OS... just in case MS moves too far off the reservation with their desktop OS.

Asking them to make an entire desktop OS seems like a lot of work, doesn't it?
 
There will always be naysayers with anything new because people just see their own little world, but hard to argue against these as being a good thing.

That's just it though, what's new or unique about Steam Machines? What does this bring to the table that can't be done today? Not only that, they do significantly less than the same devices running Windows when it comes to PC gaming. And if this thing is being targeted at console gamers that want a console like PC platform, they may be in for a surprise to find out that their PC gaming device doesn't actually support the majority of Steam games.

So there are legitimate issues with the product coming out of the gate that will have to improve pretty quickly and dramatically for Steam Machines running SteamOS. Not saying that it's impossible or that Steam Machines are a bad idea but they are going to be a tough sell to many beyond anti-Microsoft/anti-Windows folks at least initially.
 
You can put this right next to your Ouya, the Android STB that showed us all that app-games weren't just for portable devices and completely transformed the home-console industry. :p

One thing: What has SteamBox done to address the lack of encoded Dolby Digital in PC games? I'm assuming it doesn't have its own DDLive encoder or an SPDIF/TOSLINK port for older receivers? You probably need a newer (relatively) HDMI-switching receiver with multichannel audio decoding to get surround in your games, or enable some faux-mode with a 2 channel stereo stream?
 
What does gaming on the SteamOS offer that, windows + the new steam controller doesnt? Just the ability to go without paying MS for a gaming OS?

At the moment I dont see the compelling reason to switch off windows for SteamOS.
 
Except it'll be the first console that plays mods. And the first console to offer games at Steam sale price points and a network of competitive third party key sellers rather than a flat $60 for every game. A consolr with no overpriced pay-forever subscription scheme for multi-player access. A console where the platform holder isn't paying off developers to keep games off a competing platform - exclusivity bullshit is just lame. A console that is open to being hacked and modded and upgraded for people interested in that, but doesn't have to be for people that aren't. The list goes on.

There will always be naysayers with anything new because people just see their own little world, but hard to argue against these as being a good thing.

It won't be the first "console" to play mods as the PS3 was. It never took off, in part because console gamers didn't care for it (and the implementation wasn't superb). And you can't keep swapping the terms whenever you switch stances for your argument. Its a "console", yet half the time "its a PC". Not referring to you personally, but the people who in general support the concept.

It supports mods. Wonderful; what does it do that a Windows based PC doesn't? Offer a limited selection of games? Less hardware options? Less program options? Sounds great! Where do I sign up?! You're better off using a small Windows PC and running Steam. You'll get a lot more software & hardware options.

And you still have to research what version is built the best, look up GPU benchmarks, research CPUs, figure out what settings you can run your games at, configure graphic settings and all the "downsides" to PC gaming. It isn't as simple as "upgrading the memory", which is the extent the average console gamer cares to learn about. Yet, the upsides are stifled - limited updatability in most of those garbage Steambox cases and limits to SteamOS itself. Want to quickly edit some textures via Photoshop for a quick mod? Load up that PC because you're not going to do it in SteamOS.

Bold part sounds like yourself. ;) Software is what sells a platform. I suppose Valve will eventually do what MS did in regards to Windows gaming to push their platform. Because honestly, they need to if the want it to standout. SteamOS first and foremost needs a platform selling software or franchise.

BTW, console games frequently go on sale. Often times they go on sale for larger discounts quicker than their PC counterparts. Its called Amazon.com. They even sell digital only PS4 games. Not as good as Steam sales, but you can certainly grab big name titles for similar discounts as Steam after the same duration after release.
 
What does gaming on the SteamOS offer that, windows + the new steam controller doesnt? Just the ability to go without paying MS for a gaming OS?

At the moment I dont see the compelling reason to switch off windows for SteamOS.

SteamOS isn't asking anyone to switch off Windows because it's not intended as a desktop replacement.
 
if all you want to do is stream games to a console like device, just get a $50 steam link.

This...I'm getting the controller and SteamLink bundle. If you already have a decent PC and a half-decent network, you are that much closer to having a Steam machine.
 
You can put this right next to your Ouya, the Android STB that showed us all that app-games weren't just for portable devices and completely transformed the home-console industry. :p
/QUOTE]

Right because some no name fake company with a clueless lady-CEO that got lucky to be propped up temporarily by a Kickstarter based on a bunch of unmitigated vapor is totally the same as Valve.
 
I honestly dont understand why PC gamers are so fanatical about STEAM. If youre a gamer you should be pissed because Valve isnt doing ANYTHING to satisfy their fan base when it comes to actual gaming. Half Life is long forgotten, and numerous other titles. The titles that made them what they are today were traded for a digital platform that has ultimately stagnated their company.

Either GabeN is satisfied with a % off each sale and thats enough in his book, or they simply got lazy, or both. SteamOS and their machines are useless, waste of time and effort.

People should demand more from Valve. Having a simple digital distribution platform doesn't excite me one bit today.
 
I honestly dont understand why PC gamers are so fanatical about STEAM. If youre a gamer you should be pissed because Valve isnt doing ANYTHING to satisfy their fan base when it comes to actual gaming. Half Life is long forgotten, and numerous other titles. The titles that made them what they are today were traded for a digital platform that has ultimately stagnated their company.

Either GabeN is satisfied with a % off each sale and thats enough in his book, or they simply got lazy, or both. SteamOS and their machines are useless, waste of time and effort.

People should demand more from Valve. Having a simple digital distribution platform doesn't excite me one bit today.

That's why I'm giving my support to GoG. Their galaxy client has a long way to go but it's looking better and better and could be a pretty good competitor to steam down the road. The more competition we have, the better it will be for us.
 
Back
Top