Does propelled water move like propelled air?

imzjustplayin

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jan 24, 2006
Messages
1,171
Does water that is propelled by a fan move the same way as air? I mean you'd use the same type of fan blade angle and everything (use a blade meant for blowing air) and use it to blow water would you get the same effect? The reason I ask is because I'm wondering how exactly does the air move once it leaves the fan blades. It would seem like designing a heatsink that impedes the least would be the most ideal...
 
The over all dynamics are similar, but density and viscosity vary greatly between the two. Vortices and other turbulence will be very different, and these are the factors that contribute to resistance.
 
What are you trying to do, use a fan underwater? A fan designed to move air will not do a very good job of moving water.

...There was an episode of junkyard wars where they had to make boats, one team had an actual boat prop and another team used a radiator fan and their boat pretty much didn't move.
 
water is effectively incompressible, and air isn't, so they are different. Turbulence is probably good for heat transfer in most instances.
 
water is effectively incompressible, and air isn't, so they are different.

Compressibility isn't a factor until you get speeds that are an appreciable fraction of the speed of sound. If your fans are spinning that fast, I think the noise and power demands would be more of a problem than compressibility effects. :D

You can compare fan blades for air and for water by looking at various coefficients (e.g. Reynold's number). These can tell you how you'd need to scale things to get similar performance.
 
Back
Top