Does Google Now Have A Women Problem?

This has NOTHING to do with women. This is the internet. This is Google. This is 1's and 0's. This is (by nature) gender neutral.

All I see is a person so overwhelmingly consumed by "apps" that there is a major failure to see a much larger picture. This is happening to both men and women and of all ages all over the world. It's all quite sad really. She (like so many other people) has become mesmerized by the power of the "app" that she doesn't even see that she's being manipulated. Too many people allow themselves to be completely controlled by what some company out there does. It's no longer about convenience. It's about submission. Ultimately, it turns into a form of slavery.
 
So women don't want traffic reports, stock reports, sports scores, package tracking information, news updates on stuff you've searched, events that happen around you, and restaurants in your vicinity?

Um...sounds like this lady needs to get off the Internet and back in the kitchen because according to her that's all women are good for. :rolleyes:

Please Yahoo show this woman the door. She only makes your news even more irrelevant.
 
She's very correct. Google thinks and acts as though there's a male user at the keyboard and that's simply not the case all the time. Men tend to die sooner and their shorter lifespans in the US results in a population disparity where there are more women versus men alive. What Google fails to do is to offer gender relevant information. I'm not sure why pointing that out makes someone awful. Of course she's biased since she's carting around a penis and penis-driven Google services just don't interest her.

And on the other hand, if they had say put in a prompt to drop your child off at daycare because in her words most people deal with that, she would think it's sexist because not all women want or can have children.

She needs to start studying better trolls like John C. Dvorak and MG Siegler Both of them get that whatever they write is going to attract attacks but at least they don't complain about it.
 
So if someone in the tech industry doesn't like an app, they're not allowed to say so or explain why. What if someone doesn't like someone else's opinion about an app? Shouldn't they just not read that opinion and/or keep quiet in a forum about it? Saying something negative might be ignorant or idiotic since the world doesn't revolve around that person.

You can say you don't like an app. Saying the app isn't good for an entire gender just because you personally didn't like it however is idiotic. If I order pizza, and don't like the taste, if I was this writer I'd write an article titled 'Why does (insert pizza chain) have a problem with men?' That you would defend such a thing means either you never clicked through to the source article, or you're just trying to argue with everyone without really caring what side you take.
 
So women don't want traffic reports, stock reports, sports scores, package tracking information, news updates on stuff you've searched, events that happen around you, and restaurants in your vicinity?

Um...sounds like this lady needs to get off the Internet and back in the kitchen because according to her that's all women are good for. :rolleyes:

Please Yahoo show this woman the door. She only makes your news even more irrelevant.

That's not what she said. She's complaining that Google profiles women as housewives with the Yoga apps, cooking apps, and shit like that, while men enjoy stock trading apps, traveling apps and all of that. She's correct that Google is profiling gender as if this was the year 1960. Women aren't your stereotypical housewives and soccer moms anymore.
 
or you're just trying to argue with everyone without really caring what side you take.
You could have just led with this and saved yourself the effort of typing the rest of the reply ;)
 
That's not what she said. She's complaining that Google profiles women as housewives with the Yoga apps, cooking apps, and shit like that, while men enjoy stock trading apps, traveling apps and all of that. She's correct that Google is profiling gender as if this was the year 1960. Women aren't your stereotypical housewives and soccer moms anymore.
Yes, because my phone checks if I have a penis every time I install a stock trading or traveling app. If I give my phone to a woman, it comes up with a "penis not found" error and just brings up a cooking apps up instead.
 
Yes, because my phone checks if I have a penis every time I install a stock trading or traveling app. If I give my phone to a woman, it comes up with a "penis not found" error and just brings up a cooking apps up instead.

Troll post? You're forgetting Google's trading policy with the Glass. I'd imagine when you set up your profile first time you get the Glass, you're asked if you're male or female so it can fetch some default profile accordingly.

I see male chauvinism has a long way to go in [H].
 
She's very correct. Google thinks and acts as though there's a male user at the keyboard and that's simply not the case all the time. Men tend to die sooner and their shorter lifespans in the US results in a population disparity where there are more women versus men alive. What Google fails to do is to offer gender relevant information. I'm not sure why pointing that out makes someone awful. Of course she's biased since she's carting around a penis and penis-driven Google services just don't interest her.

I think you and Virginia need that new "Google Mind reading app" specifically targeted for women. It's a combination of Google Translate and Google NOW that can translate words like "fine" into "I'm pissed off you didn't put the toilet seat down" and when it asks "What's wrong" and you answer "nothing" it directly goes to apologize and plays "Magic Mike".

Gimme a break.


Well she does have a penchant for intentionally pissing people off:

http://news.yahoo.com/comment-trolls-women-kogan-173842372.html

Anita Sarkeesian much there Virginia? So passe.
 
Troll post? You're forgetting Google's trading policy with the Glass. I'd imagine when you set up your profile first time you get the Glass, you're asked if you're male or female so it can fetch some default profile accordingly.

I see male chauvinism has a long way to go in [H].
Oh please, get off your fucking high horse.

I think you misread what the woman in this article is complaining about.

She is pointing out that an app gives her information on weather, traffic, stocks, sports, friends birthdays, pending deliveries, flight status and appointments.

She then complains that because she is a woman, she doesn't want those things, she wants slow lighting wake up clocks, she wants yoga stretch demos, she wants an app she can stare at to meditate for 5 minutes, she wants to peruse Yahoo while drinking her coffee, she doesn't want an app to tell her the weather, she wants to be shown an outfit that is appropriate for the weather.

Now you are saying google is profiling by producing an app that gives information on weather, traffic, stocks, sports, friends birthdays, pending deliveries, flight status and appointments and I point out in a sarcastic way that is silly and now I'm a male chauvinist :rolleyes: Give me a fucking break.

Do you have any evidence to show that google created or marketed this app based on gender profiling? Or could it just be, ya know, they found there's a lot of people interested in an app that gives them information on weather, traffic, stocks, sports, friends birthdays, pending deliveries, flight status and appointments?
 
That's not what she said. She's complaining that Google profiles women as housewives with the Yoga apps, cooking apps, and shit like that, while men enjoy stock trading apps, traveling apps and all of that. She's correct that Google is profiling gender as if this was the year 1960. Women aren't your stereotypical housewives and soccer moms anymore.

She's on IOS/Apple, presumably IPhone. She didn't say any of those other apps came from Google.

Pocket Yoga exists on Android, but I could not find Rise on the Play store, and her link shows Iphone and Ipad..

I admittedly am NOT a fan of Google now even though I'm an Android user, and yet her link between "what women want" and what she needs, is tenuous at best.
 
Oh please, get off your fucking high horse.

I think you misread what the woman in this article is complaining about.

She is pointing out that an app gives her information on weather, traffic, stocks, sports, friends birthdays, pending deliveries, flight status and appointments.

She then complains that because she is a woman, she doesn't want those things, she wants slow lighting wake up clocks, she wants yoga stretch demos, she wants an app she can stare at to meditate for 5 minutes, she wants to peruse Yahoo while drinking her coffee, she doesn't want an app to tell her the weather, she wants to be shown an outfit that is appropriate for the weather.

Now you are saying google is profiling by producing an app that gives information on weather, traffic, stocks, sports, friends birthdays, pending deliveries, flight status and appointments and I point out in a sarcastic way that is silly and now I'm a male chauvinist :rolleyes: Give me a fucking break.

Do you have any evidence to show that google created or marketed this app based on gender profiling? Or could it just be, ya know, they found there's a lot of people interested in an app that gives them information on weather, traffic, stocks, sports, friends birthdays, pending deliveries, flight status and appointments?

That's how I took the article too. She was complaining that things like yoga stretches weren't in Google Now. She was bitching simply because Google Now doesn't fit HER morning schedule since she doesn't want any of that information. So according to her Google Now is sexist.

She even bitched that Facebook's birthday reminders aren't part of Google Now while Google+ was. She then talked about how she doesn't want weather in the morning until an e-mail rolls in "which shows the days’ weather in the form of a proposed outfit." :rolleyes:

Here's a little hint for this Ph.D. who writes for Yahoo:

1. Open Google Now
2. Check today's weather
3. Say the word "Google"
4. Say "current news headlines"

Holy Shit! A ton of news headlines including a button for "More news" which brings up everything currently on Google News feeds. Oh and just for her...Yahoo news is number two in the search list. That was an incredibly shameless plug for the new "sharp" Yahoo app in her article too. I haven't read Yahoo news in years because of how pathetic it is and this article is a prime example.

Here's another freebie:
1. Open Google Now
2. Check today's weather
3. Say the word "Google"
4. Say "yoga stretches"

Holy shit x2! Images of yoga stretches! Oh and videos too!
 
Troll post? You're forgetting Google's trading policy with the Glass. I'd imagine when you set up your profile first time you get the Glass, you're asked if you're male or female so it can fetch some default profile accordingly.

I see male chauvinism has a long way to go in [H].

...No. Google glass never asks anyone what their gender is. It also doesn't change the available applications automatically for anyone.

Additionally, what does this have to do with her complains about Google Now? And furthermore about your previous post, what do Yoga Applications or cookbook applications have to do with Google Now either? None of that applies to Google Now.

If you don't know what something is, it's better to remain quiet and look like an idiot, rather than open your mouth, and remove all doubt. That or just ask. Or google that shit.
 
I'm all for equality between men & women but such articles don't help the situation at all.

Virginia Heffernan wafts of premium grade BS that's been aged to desication. She'll burn herself out one day & we won't ever read about her again. Let's hope this day arrives soon.
 
Did you read the article? It didn't mention anything about this "-ism" thing which you fear. She merely pointed out shortcomings in the app. That's no different than someone complaining about DRM or ranting about SimCity. This forum's members create hundreds of posts complaining about software and when a woman does it, she's suddenly insane, a feminist, or whatever other silly label a man can invent to discredit a woman's opinion.

Read the title of the article. IMHO, I almost agreed with you. The article hardly adopts the "sexism" card, yet the title invokes a strong framing effect, invoking emotion to get people to read the article, which admittedly, writes about something largely different. "Does google have a woman problem" gets many more views than "Google Now, Half baked?" because it's intentionally inflammatory. And that's just pathetic.

Who knew, an app that's in development, for a product in development, could leave some features to be desired.
 
What ever men create, women will complain about it; even if it is for the greater good of mankind or womenkind or however you want to differentiate genders.

It's funny 'cause the people who were the pioneers of today's technology were seen as geeks and nerds and perceived as un-mateable probably by the very women who complain about something they can't live without (not cars by this woman, but apparently she uses Google enough to bitch about it).

Women, can't live with 'em, can't live without 'em. If my girlfriend is reading this, I want to say: "I Love you, baby, don't hurt me...."
 
What is the appeal of this now thing anyway? I used to have a nexus device when they launched it but couldn't understand why did they have to push so hard. Seemed useless to me.
 
That's not what she said. She's complaining that Google profiles women as housewives with the Yoga apps, cooking apps, and shit like that, while men enjoy stock trading apps, traveling apps and all of that. She's correct that Google is profiling gender as if this was the year 1960. Women aren't your stereotypical housewives and soccer moms anymore.

did we read the same article? thats the OPPOSITE of what she said. she said her google now gives her traffic, weather, sports, stocks, etc but she doesnt use those things and instead wants yoga and her daycare and "shift work" schedules on her phone. you are, lit'rally, stating the exact opposite of her complaint and making a completely nonsensical argument. she is arguing that women are your stereotypical 1960s housewives, and google now doesnt cater to that. it currently caters mostly to businesspeople. read the article again and you willl see why we all think she's full of shit. it's because she is saying that only men are interested in sports, and weather, and flight times, and stocks, and package tracking, and news, etc. that is complete bullshit as women are becoming more and more business-oriented and less housewife-y every year.
 
What is the appeal of this now thing anyway? I used to have a nexus device when they launched it but couldn't understand why did they have to push so hard. Seemed useless to me.

If you're talking about Google Now itself, the reason it's a big deal is because you don't have to set anything on it. It's creepy as all hell, because it automatically scans your emails, search history and text messages, as well as your location information, to tell you what you might want to know.

Did you do a search for the Dallas Cowboys in the past? When you open up Google Now, one of the cards will tell you the latest scores for their most recent game. Did you receive a flight confirmation email recently? It'll have a card telling you when you need to leave to get to your flight on time, taking traffic into account. Meetings and appointments, the same thing. My Google Now learned where I leave and where I work without me telling it anything. In addition, it does voice searches and allows you to dictate emails and stuff.

And all this stuff it does, it never requires you to set anything up. It just knows.
 
Back
Top