Does good for storage = good for media streaming?

evophile

n00b
Joined
Mar 21, 2006
Messages
42
Hi all,

I'm trying to decide which 1TB drive to buy, basically a WD Black/Samsung SP or a WD Green.

I see that everyone says the Green is better for storage, and thats basically what its going to be. I'm going to put all my media, videos etc in there.

However I think I will be doing a lot of streaming video to other devices into the drive so I was wondering if the Greens lower performance specs make a difference as opposed to the Black or Spinpoint.


Thanks!
 
Well, for 1 stream, any HD will work fine. If you are going to be doing multiple streams at the same time, then you could run into some bandwidth issues.

They also make special Multimedia drives that are designed to stream media smoother, such as the Seagate DB35 series drives. I have had one of these in my Directivo for a couple of years with no problems. I normally am recording 2 SD streams while watching a third with that box. Other OEM's make similar drives, but I just can't think what they call them off the top of my head.

Don
 
I think you would be fine with any of those drives. Any newer drive should not have a problem streaming video. Even blu-ray quality video should be fine. As for populating a list of video it may take a little longer on the green but thats about it.
 
Also depends on the SW. Some "better" SW will take large chunks of data at a time and thus create a "deep buffer". By creating a deep buffer you call thus get nice long bursts of data before "re-seeking" on the HDD. However, some software sucks and it might create a short buffer and thus you get a lot of seeking.

My rule of thumb is that every task that actively reads/writes a HDD reduces its ability by ~1/2.

Therefore if your HDD can read @ 60 MByte/second and you have 2 tasks trying to use it, you will get 30 MByte/sec total for both tasks or 15 MByte/second each. If you have 3 you are now down to 1/4th or 5 MByte/sec each. 5 MByte/sec is still 40 Mbit/sec though.
 
I run a WD Green 1tb drive on my HTPC, and it streams my Blu-ray backups flawlessly.
 
cool! Thanks for all the replies guys.

The Spinpoint is at a good price right now, so I'm thinking about getting that. However it seems a lot of people are complaining about its reliability and breaking?

The Green is good, but I had one arrive at my office from Newegg DOA so now I'm scared of them (I know I shouldn't be).

Thanks again
 
I ordered 3 of the WD 1TB GP drives to go in my new NAS last month from ZZF. 1 of the 3 was DOA.

the 1.5 7200.11's are only $189 right now. I think that's what is going into my remaining 2 NAS slots next year.

Don
 
Back
Top