Does Eric Schmidt Speak for Google on Copyright?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The entertainment industry seems to think they are being double crossed by Google because Schmidt says crazy stuff. Where have these guys been for the last decade, Schmidt is the king of saying crazy stuff. ;)

He compared such laws with those employed by countries with repressive governments, such as China. To astonished copyright owners, Schmidt's message was clear. He was bashing a bill that copyright owners big and small see as vital in fighting intellectual property theft online, a bill that others at Google had offered conditional support for only a month earlier. Some smelled a double cross.
 
He's saying the same thing Google is officially, it's just he's saying it more clearly instead of trying to obfuscate it. The ability for any government to be able to take down sites at will, order others not to link to them, and to redirect their DNS entries to other servers than the intended targets IS web censorship and is exactly how China does it. What's China tell it's citizens when it takes a site down? 'That site had illegal content.' - that is if they answer at all, and of course they don't have to provide any proof.

The 'Protect-IP' act, right now, as it is written is a vehicle for complete internet censorship. Don't like a site? Claim somebody posted a link to a bittorrent site in one of the comments, and use it as a reason to take the entire site offline. Safe harbor provisions of the DMCA you say? Invalid under the new act.

Google sees it as a big threat to the internet and says they're working together with congress to make sure it isn't blanket authority to censorship (while still protecting IP.) Schmidt said if the law is passed and still threatens free speech that Google would fight it. One way of saying it might be attempting to mask the ultimate meaning of what's being said more than the other, but they're essentially saying the same thing.
 
A good way to summarize Schidmt's comments would be to say that the Protect IP bill is looking to do away with due process under the law and he is against that. As should anyone with half a brain really.

The gov't doesn't want to be bothered with the process of proving a site is infringing on copyrighted material so it proposes measures such as this.

Schmidt is right in comparing this bill to laws in other oppressive countries because the bottom line is shit like this NEVER gets used for what it is intended and ALWAYS gets manipulated into something more sinister.
 
@Ualdayan I have to agree. I think Steve really missed the mark with his sensational lead on this story. Why would any other than Corporate interests want this law? It is censorship and will likely be abused. Keep in mind that many of the laws put in place for other purposes get used more broadly. You only have to look at the Patriot Act to see increased federal authority ends up being used many purposes will outside the scope of the actual law.

Bravo to Schmidt and Steve, drink some decaf man.:D
 
If this law passes we may as well all walk into the Library of Congress and demand to have the Constitution and than tear it up and burn the pieces.

Thomas Jefferson said "When the people fear their government, there is tyranny; when the government fears the people, there is liberty."
 
@Ualdayan I have to agree. I think Steve really missed the mark with his sensational lead on this story. Why would any other than Corporate interests want this law? It is censorship and will likely be abused. Keep in mind that many of the laws put in place for other purposes get used more broadly. You only have to look at the Patriot Act to see increased federal authority ends up being used many purposes will outside the scope of the actual law.

Bravo to Schmidt and Steve, drink some decaf man.:D

+1 "Bravo to Schmidt" Someone finally speaking the truth for the citizens of America, I thought thats what politicians were elected to do. On;y problem I see is he will be bullied into submission by the hoards of Corporate interests who use their bread and butter issue as an excuse to bring in cencorship and to throw out due process of law. Personally its all about total control and pirates are the fall guys for achieving this end. Totally out of balance, hitting a flea with a baseball bat. At one point the industry thought they were getting some where with the court system, but lo and behold they were wrong, the judges started to see through all the bullshit. So it was time to buy more politicians off while America sits on their behinds watching all of their right being trampled on. First the Patriot Act, now Censorship of the Internet. Shame America Shame, you use to set the example for the rest of the world to follow, now your no different then the Communist Chinese and other socialist countries, but then again the socialist countries are being bullied and becoming submissive by being paid off by the RIAA/MPAA.
 
If this law passes we may as well all walk into the Library of Congress and demand to have the Constitution and than tear it up and burn the pieces.

Thomas Jefferson said "When the people fear their government, there is tyranny; when the government fears the people, there is liberty."

Which is why The French are sometimes admired when they hit the streets to protest. They only put up with so much government bullshit. Like I said before, the last time America took to the streets was to end the Vietnam war and guess what it worked.
 
Which is why The French are sometimes admired when they hit the streets to protest. They only put up with so much government bullshit. Like I said before, the last time America took to the streets was to end the Vietnam war and guess what it worked.

Yes, protesting "government bullshit" like raising their retirement age to 60. Lol.

Look, our problems really came to a head under Reagan. He figured out everyone will love you if you cut taxes and raise benefits - look you can have your cake and eat it too! Politicians of all stripes have been following his lead every since, and look where we are - people think we can balance the budget by cutting foreign aid and earmarks - something like 1.2% of the budget.

Interestingly enough, I heard Rep. Ryan of all people state that if we just went back to Clinton's last budget, adjusted for inflation, we would have a balanced budget. Shit I'm all for it, things seemed to be working pretty damn well back then.
 
@Ualdayan I have to agree. I think Steve really missed the mark with his sensational lead on this story. Why would any other than Corporate interests want this law? It is censorship and will likely be abused. Keep in mind that many of the laws put in place for other purposes get used more broadly. You only have to look at the Patriot Act to see increased federal authority ends up being used many purposes will outside the scope of the actual law.

Bravo to Schmidt and Steve, drink some decaf man.:D

+1 Yeah, I thought this summed up very well.

Schmidt said:
“I would be very, very careful if I were a government about arbitrarily [implementing] simple solutions to complex problems,” he said. A government might find taking down a domain name server (DNS) an appealing solution, “but it sets a very bad precedent because now another country will say ‘I don’t like free speech so I’ll whack off all those DNSs’ – that country would be China.”
http://blogs.forbes.com/parmyolson/2011/05/19/why-google-would-defend-the-pirate-bay/
 
Yes, protesting "government bullshit" like raising their retirement age to 60. Lol.

Look, our problems really came to a head under Reagan. He figured out everyone will love you if you cut taxes and raise benefits - look you can have your cake and eat it too! Politicians of all stripes have been following his lead every since, and look where we are - people think we can balance the budget by cutting foreign aid and earmarks - something like 1.2% of the budget.

Interestingly enough, I heard Rep. Ryan of all people state that if we just went back to Clinton's last budget, adjusted for inflation, we would have a balanced budget. Shit I'm all for it, things seemed to be working pretty damn well back then.

My point was that they still hit the streets when need be, instead of whining over a beer.
 
This law will not be effective for long, so why worry about it? We'll have a peer-based system in no time that can supplement DNS, or otherwise go right past the blocks.
 
This law will not be effective for long, so why worry about it? We'll have a peer-based system in no time that can supplement DNS, or otherwise go right past the blocks.

It's the principle of the government being able to censor something without due process. I don't really care it if someone is no longer able to download pirated material.
 
Back
Top