Does DVI cables make much of a difference?

Muppet

Weaksauce
Joined
Jun 17, 2004
Messages
92
I now have a card that has a DVI output so i can make use of it, but is it noticable different?
 
No, they do not.
I have flat panels LCDs and CRT that take both and there is no differencr you can tell. Actually I will get branded for this but my OLD 21" CRT EO2010 Princeton Graphics monitor looks better than my high end 21" LCD!:D
 
if you use a DVI cable vs a VGA cable on an LCD, makes a big difference..
 
I notice video noise and sharpness issues over VGA (on LCD monitors only).
 
It is very subjective of a VGA (analog) vs DVI-D (digital) to a LCD panel. Quite a few things can affect it including the video card, the display input, and the cable for VGA. If the card, cable, and display are good..you may notice a small difference in favor of hte DVI-D setup however you might not. However, the advantage of the digital method is that it either works or it doesn't and therefore you remove card, the cable, and the input of the panel as factors in your picture quality. The only thing that is left is the panel itself and how well it is calibrated.

So in short...it may or may not help you that much but it can't hurt. So if your panel has a DVI-D input...then go for it. I mean..what better way to spend a few $ (like 5) for possible improvment in PQ.
 
if you use a DVI cable vs a VGA cable on an LCD, makes a big difference..

I definately agree with this. I've used both VGA and DVI inputs on my 26" LCD from the same PC and noticed a signifigant difference; sharper, brighter and less video noise. Definately use DVI with LCD's if you can.





 
One thing to remember is that DVI has a digital signal (it also can have an analog in DVI-I and DVI-A). The point being is distance and attenuation. With analog the signal is going to lessen over distance due to resistance in the cable (so will digital, it will pretty much be an all or nothing), this can cause the picture to cause undesired effects.
 
I couldn't tell enough of a difference between component and dvi at 1080i on a 42" lcd to bother buying an extra dvi cable. (The HD satellite box has a DVI output, I used its cable)

Different display setups will behave differently however, so I'd recommend trying it out and see if *you* notice a difference. It really doesn't matter if anyone else does or not.
 
It seems to depend somewhat on the quality of the analog VGA output of the video card. For example, my LCD looks horrible when plugged into the analog VGA port of my old Geforce 2 MX400, but looks sharp and clean when connected to the DVI port of the same MX400 card!

Basically using a DVI cable will give you the best image quality possible, so I'd say yeah....upgrade to one!
 
The DVI made quite a difference on my Samsung 930B monitor. I was actually going to return the monitor as the VGA cable made the color very washed out looking and a lot of color bleed. Purchased a DVI cable and it made a world of difference.
 
it comes down to a simple analog (VGA) vs digital (DVI)

Which do you think is better?
 
If your resolution is higher than 1280x1024, you will notice a difference. VGA cables start to hit the bandwidth wall after that resolution. As already mentioned, the difference you will notice depends on the quality of the VGA output from your video card - if it's really bad, the difference will be impressive.
 
If your resolution is higher than 1280x1024, you will notice a difference. VGA cables start to hit the bandwidth wall after that resolution. As already mentioned, the difference you will notice depends on the quality of the VGA output from your video card - if it's really bad, the difference will be impressive.

Don't know what you are talking about, BIG difference even at 1280x1024.

FWIW, the thing that MOST irritated me about analog was 'fitting' the image in the display. I'm sure everyone here who has ever used VGA knows the issue. Get everything looking fine, fire up a game that uses a resolution you haven't "set up" yet, and suddenly 1/4 the image is somewhere off one side of the screen. Or it's a little too small to fully fit the screen. Or 3 of the 4 sides line up, but the 4th doesn't quite hit the edge. Etc, et al - and you need to spend time adjusting the horizontal and vertical position, horizontal and vertical stretch, etc. And then you change refresh rate, and BAM, monitor forgets it all and you have to do it again.

Oh, and the constant tinkering with the color, too. Too much red, not enough green, blue has too high contrast, etc.

With DVI - none of that. Picture send to the monitor is always going to perfectly fit the display. Pixel to pixel. Color reproduction is always perfect (at least, as 'perfect' as the display can be) as there are no adjustments needed. No analog signal to degrade. The video output is digital in your system, digital all the way to the monitor, and displayed on a digital panel.
 
I'd say there is a big difference with my Westy 22" LCD and X1800 video card on DVI compared to VGA.
 
At low resolutions (640x480 to 1600x1200) the difference between DVI-D or DVI-I and VGA is little to none. However, VGA is only capable of going to a max res of 2048x1536. DVI has a max res of 2560x1600 (XHD) and beyond, up to 3840x2400. This is because it is a digital signal though, VGA is only analog and will start to blur and not differentiate the pixels well beyond 2048x1536.

However, if the choice was mine, especially with an LCD, I would go with DVI all the way due to the higher potential image quality and resolution possible.
 
I suppose it depends on the person and monitor but when i changed from VGA to DVI i noticed a difference like night and day in clearness especially with text. VGA looked fuzzy in contrast.

And when you think about it its like saying is there a difference between component video and HDMI. VGA=Component and DVI=HDMI of course there will be a difference.
 
At low resolutions (640x480 to 1600x1200) the difference between DVI-D or DVI-I and VGA is little to none. However, VGA is only capable of going to a max res of 2048x1536. DVI has a max res of 2560x1600 (XHD) and beyond, up to 3840x2400. This is because it is a digital signal though, VGA is only analog and will start to blur and not differentiate the pixels well beyond 2048x1536.

However, if the choice was mine, especially with an LCD, I would go with DVI all the way due to the higher potential image quality and resolution possible.
Keep in mind though that to get resolutions higher than 1920X1200 with DVI you need a DUAL link connection, not single link like a LOT of cards have. Even my 9800pro has only a single link connection.
 
I suppose it depends on the person and monitor but when i changed from VGA to DVI i noticed a difference like night and day in clearness especially with text. VGA looked fuzzy in contrast.

And when you think about it its like saying is there a difference between component video and HDMI. VGA=Component and DVI=HDMI of course there will be a difference.
But CRTs will benefit more from VGA than DVI since they're analog displays themselves.
 
Personally I've not really noticed difference with a 22" LCD. However it takes some time to adjust timings and other things in the monitor to make it look good, unlike VGA, DVI which does everything automatically. So if you can use DVI, do it. But if you can't it's most likely not worth of changing GPU or monitor.

And about DVI vs VGA, analog (CRT) requires much more bandwidth because of higher resolutions and higher refresh rate. For example 1920x1200@60Hz seems to equal 1280x1024@100Hz... Don't know about the image quality though.
 
It just depends how picky you are about image quality. VGA has phase, sharpness and positioning controls that you have to tinker with. DVI, all of those settings are perfect.
 
On my work LCD monitor there is horrible noise because we use VGA. At home I use DVI and there is zero noise. So I would say yes, it makes a difference for me personally I would never use VGA given the choice...
 
Thats probably true but what CRTs out there have a DVI connection i have never seen one?
I've seen them, it's kinda weird. I also believe that LCDs designed with analog operation alone look a LOT better than those with DVI and VGA support as they have to.
 
True, one will need dual-link DVI to run beyond 1980x1200 with a digital resolution. Some single-link DVI video cards will not provide a digital signal beyond 1600x1200, but those are only on really old models.
 
i have been using dvi connector for my 20.1" WS monitor for a year. Few days ago, i got on one of my friend's computer that have LCD monitor connecting to VGA port. I do see the difference in there. DVI is more sharper than VGA, and i see little of fuzzy on the vga monitor, too. Also, i tried to use vga cable and connect it to my monitor. It totally killin my eye cuz it did same thing that my buddy monitor do...

DVI4life :eek: :D
 
What I haven't seen mentioned here, and I believe is the root of the answer, is that the output of the card is digital, so to go to VGA, it has to be converted, meaning an additional component and possible loss, in the series. Today's cards only have DVI out, or at least my 8800gtx anyways, and I think that says a lot about what NVidia prescribes as the cable to use. Sure, you can get an adapter to convert it to VGA, but once again, that would mean more conversion, and every time conversion is involved, it's going to degrade the signal.

So, if the card has a DVI port on it, and your using a LCD, you should always use the DVI

Additionally, I think LCD displays that have analogue ports ( VGA ) have to convert the signal to digital anyway, once again, more conversion.
 
Back
Top