Do You Use Anti-Virus?

Do You Use Anti-Virus?

  • Anti-Virus Only

    Votes: 66 19.5%
  • Firewall Only

    Votes: 37 10.9%
  • Anti-Virus & Firewall

    Votes: 179 53.0%
  • None

    Votes: 56 16.6%

  • Total voters
    338
Windows: Anti-spyware, Anti-virus, Firewall
Linux: Firewall

Ontop of a firewall just after the cable modem, and an intrusion detection on the network.
 
Tweakin said:
Recent virri have propogated by means that a lot of AV Software were not able to detect until days to weeks after they hit. Not to mention the people with out of date definitions. What is your point? In my earlier post, I did say I run a firewall (a linux machine at the head of my home network). Your view on Av Software is my view on good hardware firewalls and smart computing.
What do you do about browsing the internet? How can you be assured that code opening in your browser is safe? Firewalls don't stop a malformed page based attack.

What about .exes? Ever run them? How can you be assured it's a safe file, even if you got it from a "trusted" source? What if the trusted source was poisoned?

What if someone brought an infected machine into your network, like a friends laptop or if you setup a small lan party?

His point is, a firewall isn't an end-all solution. Just because you haven't been infected, doesn't mean your system is flawless. Your setup has served you well, but you are quite ignorant if you think it's secure.

edit:
SmokeRngs said:
It's actually somewhat scary I'm in 100% agreement with djnes. It's not often that something like this happens.
:D
 
SmokeRngs said:
It's actually somewhat scary I'm in 100% agreement with djnes. It's not often that something like this happens.
I must be like the forum leper, where people are afraid to stand next to me! Feel free to make it a habit. ;)
 
Only antivirus software

do have a hardware firewall though with many open ports
 
Can someone suggest a good/free antivirus program? Tried a few in the past but none to my liking....
 
Phoenix86 said:
What do you do about browsing the internet? How can you be assured that code opening in your browser is safe? Firewalls don't stop a malformed page based attack.

What about .exes? Ever run them? How can you be assured it's a safe file, even if you got it from a "trusted" source? What if the trusted source was poisoned?

What if someone brought an infected machine into your network, like a friends laptop or if you setup a small lan party?

His point is, a firewall isn't an end-all solution. Just because you haven't been infected, doesn't mean your system is flawless. Your setup has served you well, but you are quite ignorant if you think it's secure.

edit: :D

I think you must have scimmed over my second post, you quoted from my third.

I feel my network is about as safe as any that has a connection to the internet. That feeling is justified to me with the lack of a single problem over the course of 5-6 years of having serious computing power at home, not just work. I understand your feelings that I am wrong, and that's ok, I don't need your approval :)

Don't get me wrong, I understand the need for AV Software and suggest it on most new computer builds, particularly for family PC's. They stop a lot of garbage for people who are quite obviously not going to be careful, even if just for a lack of knowledge on how to be. Commercial scanning tools are also a must for any network of decent size and online scanners are an awesome diagnostic tool. In a lot of cases these things save the day.
 
Simple: backup all data to an external hard drive and avoid wasting resources by using AV / FW software. I'm pretty sure I have a virus, somewhere. I'm still functioning just fine, and I'm anal when it comes to my PC's performance. I reformat about every 2 months. Works for me.
 
Tweakin said:
I feel my network is about as safe as any that has a connection to the internet. That feeling is justified to me with the lack of a single problem over the course of 5-6 years of having serious computing power at home, not just work. I understand your feelings that I am wrong, and that's ok, I don't need your approval :)
They way you feel isn't based on anything factual. You're wrapping yourself in the concept that knowledge prevents viruses, and that's wrong, as others have pointed out. Scan back up and read MajorDomo's post. What happened in the past doesn't mean anything for the future. If there's a big lottery drawing, and you've never won in the past, do you still play? Millions do, thinking they have a chance. In your logic, you'd refuse to play, thinking there's no way you could win because you haven't in the past. I could come up with a ton of analogies to show you how illiogical your thinking is, but there wouldn't really be a point since you've closed your mind to listening to others. That's why I think you should follow MajorDomo's post, and learn this for yourself. Don't take our words for it.

Here's another one. I've never been struck by lightning, but I'm not foolish enough to run through a field holding up a golf club, thinking I'm safe because it's never happened before.
 
Tanatz said:
Simple: backup all data to an external hard drive and avoid wasting resources by using AV / FW software. I'm pretty sure I have a virus, somewhere. I'm still functioning just fine, and I'm anal when it comes to my PC's performance. I reformat about every 2 months. Works for me.
Many viruses and malware can be running processes, stealing bandwidth, and harming PC performance. If you truly were anal about PC performance, you'd be running A/V software. If your computer takes a noticeable, measurable hit in performance by running something like Avast or AVG, it's time to upgrade that Pentium II you have.
 
I'm running NAV Corp 10 Server on my laptop, and my x64 box is a client.

I'm tempted to remove it, as I haven't had a virus on one of -my- systems for years.

However, I've worked on/with enough computers from other users that whenever it gets put on my network, I'm glad I have it. The problem has never been what I did, but from the idiots that kazaa'd their brains out. Typically, I run into more malware problems (with other people) than virii these days. I'd say, on a scale of 20:1.

I have a dedicated system for downloading files (VMWare Image) that I use as a proxy between the unsafe outside world, and my network. I've routinely downloaded files on that machine that, when ran, installed malware and trojans. It runs AVCE 7.6, and AdAware. It's the only machine I've used in the past 2 years or so that's ever had a hit. Basically, once I stopped using IE for my web browsing (going to Firefox), I stopped having issues.
 
SmokeRngs said:
Do a search for Kerio Personal Firewall 2.15. It's a free download although getting a bit tougher to find nowadays. Many in here use it and it seems to work really well. It's also very light on resources and you'll never know it's running until it alerts you to something it doesn't like.
Thanks I have heard some good things about that one. I have been meaning to try it out.


Lastblade said:
Can someone suggest a good/free antivirus program? Tried a few in the past but none to my liking....
I used to use AVG, also have used Avast. They are better than nothing.


Tanatz said:
Simple: backup all data to an external hard drive and avoid wasting resources by using AV / FW software. I'm pretty sure I have a virus, somewhere. I'm still functioning just fine, and I'm anal when it comes to my PC's performance. I reformat about every 2 months. Works for me.
NOD32 doesn't use many resources, so it can't be wasting many :)
Buy NOD32 and avoid wasting time by reformatting every two months :p
 
djnes said:
Here's another one. I've never been struck by lightning, but I'm not foolish enough to run through a field holding up a golf club, thinking I'm safe because it's never happened before.
That doesn't really seem like an apt analogy. Running through a field holding up a golf club is more analogous to running an unpatched windows system directly connected to the internet. Running a fully patched linux box, however, is like walking down the street some day. Sure, there's a chance I could be struck by lightning, but it is not worth it to me to go out of my way to take measures to guard against such an infinitesimal risk. It's possible for me to get infected, but the chances are so small that it's not worth it to me to take measures against it. I'm not ignorant to the thread of viruses.
 
jpmkm said:
That doesn't really seem like an apt analogy. Running through a field holding up a golf club is more analogous to running an unpatched windows system directly connected to the internet. Running a fully patched linux box, however, is like walking down the street some day. Sure, there's a chance I could be struck by lightning, but it is not worth it to me to go out of my way to take measures to guard against such an infinitesimal risk. It's possible for me to get infected, but the chances are so small that it's not worth it to me to take measures against it. I'm not ignorant to the thread of viruses.
I meant it more in a "nothing bad has happened to me in the past, so nothing will in the future" kind of thing.
 
For the av, I'm using AVG, but for the firewall, I just use windows built in, and have almost everything closed off in my router.
 
I run NOD32 for my AV

And the Windows Firewall + My Linksys router is a firewall as well
 
djnes said:
They way you feel isn't based on anything factual. You're wrapping yourself in the concept that knowledge prevents viruses, and that's wrong, as others have pointed out. Scan back up and read MajorDomo's post. What happened in the past doesn't mean anything for the future. If there's a big lottery drawing, and you've never won in the past, do you still play? Millions do, thinking they have a chance. In your logic, you'd refuse to play, thinking there's no way you could win because you haven't in the past. I could come up with a ton of analogies to show you how illiogical your thinking is, but there wouldn't really be a point since you've closed your mind to listening to others. That's why I think you should follow MajorDomo's post, and learn this for yourself. Don't take our words for it.

Here's another one. I've never been struck by lightning, but I'm not foolish enough to run through a field holding up a golf club, thinking I'm safe because it's never happened before.

I read his post, a firewall is a very serious thing, and I agree... as stated. What is a little more frightening then just average port scans like he mentions is the direct attacks on specific services. I have port 22 open to my server for ssh (no root logins, no sFTP backup), which runs denyhosts. The list of auth attempts on port 22 (all through proxies or hijacked windows machines) is quite scarey, and shows even linux machines are very open to such attacks even if just by brute force meassures. ( My /etc/hosts.deny list is quite large. )

I liked all your analogies so far. I do wear a seat-belt. I don't play the lotto . You may think I have probably been struck by lightning, but I havn't. I don't have virus software running (well, short of spamassassin and clamav for my mta) though, and if you are right and one day I do get a virus (not out of the realm of possability for me, or anyone who is running AV Software) I will deal with it.

I may be an idiot, but it is certainly not because I don't run always-on AV Software, so please stop acting like it.
 
SmokeRngs said:
Do a search for Kerio Personal Firewall 2.15. It's a free download although getting a bit tougher to find nowadays. Many in here use it and it seems to work really well. It's also very light on resources and you'll never know it's running until it alerts you to something it doesn't like.
So Kerio Firewall was free up until version 2.15? There is a Kerio Firewall version 4 I can get for $15 it says. I'm just wondering why I should get the free one over the paid version if it is so cheap. Does Kerio 4 offer a lot more features than 2.15? I dunno maybe I'll just try out 2.15 and if it is enough I'll just stick with that.
 
Tweakin said:
I think you must have scimmed over my second post, you quoted from my third.

I feel my network is about as safe as any that has a connection to the internet. That feeling is justified to me with the lack of a single problem over the course of 5-6 years of having serious computing power at home, not just work.
Yeah, I was asking rhetorical questions... Oh wait, no I wasn't.

Where the hell did I say you had to do things my way? Don't make an issue where there isn't one. I'm just pointing out things you may or may not have thought about.

Past performance is not always an indication of future performance.

I understand your feelings that I am wrong, and that's ok, I don't need your approval :)
*sigh*
 
Anti-viris and a router here, along with Sygate free personal firewall just to keep track on what's trying to get out. I also use Firefox with the noscript and adblock extensions.
 
Tweakin said:
The smiley face was there because I was messing with you, lighten up :)
Sorry man, people are taking pot shots like a mofo recently. It's taken great patience, and re-writting replies a LOT to keep a level head. That and my mood in general isn't helping. ;)
 
Actually, it's interesting how many people assume you need an AV program. I have a simple request for those of you who feel so strongly about it:

1. Name the last 10 times an AV program "saved" you from an attack.
2. Where did you get the file(s) in question?
3. Were you ever in any real danger from the files?

I asked #3 because if your AV program is warning you about infected spam, are you really that uninformed to run the .exes contained inside? Or is an AV program more like a security blanket?

I'd just laugh at #2 if it's from P2P or other warez sources (including "friends"). That would explain a lot about the attitude.
 
I ran a cisco pix, through to an astaro gateway with 2 antivirus softwares (clam and kapersky) content filters, SPI, the works, then panda enterprise. If you don't ran antivirus you have a serious problem. Your security is only as good as your weakest link, if you have only a firewall and think that is enough, your horribly mistaken. For the rest of you that say, I'm all patched up, I don't have antivirus and don't have a virus or malware problem, you must not have the computer on or plugged in to the wall or the internet. Firewalls are a joke by themselves.
 
How many of you bank online though?

I'm not too concerend about getting a virus. IMHO it isn't that hard for the computer savy user to stay away from sites (Kazaa for example) and avoid a virus. Now, there are some viruses/malware that aren't as easy to stay away from, and an anti-virus program is always usful IMO instead of re-installing XP/Linux whenever you get a virus.

I'm personally more affraid of someone getting a hold of my banking information through the use of a key loger or a program like that then getting a virus. That is why I use both an Anti-Virus and Firewall. Losing all my money to someone in Eastern Europe is more frightening then having to reinstall XP again, or the performance hit I take. I'd much rather be safe then sorry.
 
pxc said:
Actually, it's interesting how many people assume you need an AV program.
There's no assumptions about it. There have been viruses attacking cell phones, and you still think one is not needed for a Windows computer? If you want to get into which side has a strong platform to stand on fir this debate, the best answer you or Tweakin' have given is, "I've never had one before". Seriously, all you have to do is apply some basic security knowledge with common sense...there very same things you said save you from viruses...to know AV software is a necessity. no assumptions, just the facts.

Oh, and to answer one of your questions, I've had many occasions, where I've simply opened my e-mail app of choice, and immediately saw a pop-up from Symantec Corporate telling me one of the messages had a virus. These were unsolicited e-mails, in my home personal account, and my corporate account. The e-mails in my corporate account were from co-workers, appearing to be legit e-mails. But yet, you still think they aren't needed. :rolleyes:
 
Can process guard replace AV? Because that's where I'm leaning...

edit:
1. Name the last 10 times an AV program "saved" you from an attack.
2. Where did you get the file(s) in question?
3. Were you ever in any real danger from the files?
1. Naming them is pointless, it's happened recently. I could glance at the server logs and show you how many times it has saved my company. I'm guessing it's at least 10/day.

2. I'd guess more than 50% are bad web pages, or worse yet, legit pages with bad ads. The rest come in through external machines (like auditors, or contractors), personal e-mails (like AOL mail), etc.

3. Yes. Even if the specific virus weren't harmfull, running unauthorized code is always bad, regardless of the outcome. You didn't know what was in the code when you ran it, so the RISK was the same.
 
djnes said:
There's no assumptions about it. There have been viruses attacking cell phones, and you still think one is not needed for a Windows computer? If you want to get into which side has a strong platform to stand on fir this debate, the best answer you or Tweakin' have given is, "I've never had one before". Seriously, all you have to do is apply some basic security knowledge with common sense...there very same things you said save you from viruses...to know AV software is a necessity. no assumptions, just the facts.

Oh, and to answer one of your questions, I've had many occasions, where I've simply opened my e-mail app of choice, and immediately saw a pop-up from Symantec Corporate telling me one of the messages had a virus. These were unsolicited e-mails, in my home personal account, and my corporate account. The e-mails in my corporate account were from co-workers, appearing to be legit e-mails. But yet, you still think they aren't needed. :rolleyes:

When it comes to installig software one my system, I need some hard concrete fricken proof it needs to be there, not the other way around. Your argument is 'if you arn't running an always-on av on a local machine you must have viruses and don't know security', which I know is not true. Also, you seem to think av software means you won't be able to get viruses, also not true. But perhaps I misunderstand your arguments, because I know you misunderstand mine.

Important to note in this whole thread is I don't claim other people should not run AV Software, or put blanket statements on the use of such software.
 
djnes said:
Oh, and to answer one of your questions, I've had many occasions, where I've simply opened my e-mail app of choice, and immediately saw a pop-up from Symantec Corporate telling me one of the messages had a virus. These were unsolicited e-mails, in my home personal account, and my corporate account. The e-mails in my corporate account were from co-workers, appearing to be legit e-mails. But yet, you still think they aren't needed. :rolleyes:


At work I use anti-virus all the time, however at home I don't have anything installed. I don't use outlook, gmail is where all my personal email is, and I guess that has a virus scanner.. so I guess my email is getting scanned.
 
Tweakin said:
When it comes to installig software one my system, I need some hard concrete fricken proof it needs to be there, not the other way around. Your argument is 'if you arn't running an always-on av on a local machine you must have viruses and don't know security', which I know is not true. Also, you seem to think av software means you won't be able to get viruses, also not true. But perhaps I misunderstand your arguments, because I know you misunderstand mine.
You're definitely not understanding the concept in general. You don't need to see proof about needed AV software, as long as you've been reading various tech sites the past few years. If not, if you work in any kind of tech support, you also don't need any proof. My argument isn't that you may have a virus now, it's that you aren't protecting yourself in the future. I clearly understand your "argument", but it's pretty baseless, as others have pointed out. Furthurmore, if you are recommending that others run AV software, but you don't yourself, doesn't that smack of hypocracy? The main point of this debate, again, as others have pointed out, is that if you understand how viruses can propogate, you wouldn't dare leave a system unprotected. You seem to think knowledge is the key, and I couldn't agree more. The problem is, if you have the knowledge, then you know why a Windows computer needs AV software. It's plain and simple.
 
Tweakin said:
Your argument is 'if you arn't running an always-on av on a local machine you must have viruses and don't know security'

I think djnes correct argument is No AV = NO secure, simple as that., and when running a non secured os, it's just a matter of time and luck until you get infected.

These threads always end in a troll way when someone posts "I dont use av in my system and I havnt got an infection in like 10 years" causing controversy and misinformation to other users :mad:

oldmx
 
OldMX said:
These threads always end in a troll way when someone posts "I dont use av in my system and I havnt got an infection in like 10 years" causing controversy and misinformation to other users :mad:

oldmx
QFT.

That's my biggest beef with non-A/V users. They (in general, Tweakin's being pretty level headed about it compared to others ) have an elitist "I'm too good to get infected" attitude and make the less-informed folks think it's acceptable or even recommended.

Layered security for the win!
 
OldMX said:
These threads always end in a troll way when someone posts "I dont use av in my system and I havnt got an infection in like 10 years" causing controversy and misinformation to other users :mad:

oldmx

I tend to agree, it's been done here at least a couple times. I have tried hard with each post to not attempt to make it seem like my opinion is what everyone should go by. Maybe it's not enough though. I guess I just get annoyed by blanket statements and high horses.
 
I use Windows One Care Live Beta and I been using it since the beta program started, now you can get it since it went to public beta not too long ago. It has its own firewall in it too but it just like the Windows standard firewall pretty much. They are suppose to add antispyware into it, I'm guessing just integrate Windows Defender into it in the future. It also has backup features and a tune-up wizard, defrags, deletes unnecessary files etc...

Before I had Norton and windows firewall but not a big fan of norton, especially all that garbage like internet security, way too much crap just use their AV if you are gonna go with them :)
 
I figured no one would answer the questions, especially the embarassing one about where you get the file(s). Phoenix86 got closest with an answer, but misunderstood question number 3 and mixed spyware with viruses in the other questions.

I'm not saying no one needs a AV program (from the looks of it, many of you do :p). I'm saying that it's not a requirement.
 
Tweakin said:
I tend to agree, it's been done here at least a couple times. I have tried hard with each post to not attempt to make it seem like my opinion is what everyone should go by. Maybe it's not enough though. I guess I just get annoyed by blanket statements and high horses.
It's not about blanket statements and high horses. It's about providing the best answers for people asking for help. This is basically a support forum, where people come for help and answers to their questions. If you agree that others should run AV software, why even post misinformation about how it's not needed if you know what you are doing? Why put that out there for someone to read, instead of just ignoring this thread, knowing that what you do isn't recommended...for anyone? You are right in one of your above posts, you don't need our approval to do something with your own system, and you've even admitted that everyone else should run AV software. So why even post something that might lead to a reader making the wrong choice? That's what Phoenix86 is talking about above, and what OldMX's post is about.

That's the first rule in giving support and advice. You need to give the best answer to the person in need...not just your personal opinion.
 
pxc said:
I figured no one would answer the questions, especially the embarassing one about where you get the file(s). Phoenix86 got closest with an answer, but misunderstood question number 3 and mixed spyware with viruses in the other questions.

I'm not saying no one needs a AV program (from the looks of it, many of you do :p). I'm saying that it's not a requirement.
Did you read where he stated answering the questions was a waste of time? Do you really think downloading warez is the only way to get a virus, and because you don't, you're immune? Do you even realize spyware and other malware can open doors for viruses, so it's okay to lump them together? Please take some time to understand all the different viruses are spread. If not, just talk to someone you know that's in corporate IT, and ask them about viruses and security.
 
pxc said:
I figured no one would answer the questions. Phoenix86 got closest with an answer, but misunderstood question number 3 and mixed spyware with viruses in the other questions.

I'm not saying no one needs a AV program (from the looks of it, many of you do :p). I'm saying that it's not a requirement.
Web-based attacks are a virus, wether they be spyware, or expoits that run code. It's all "bad code". What's the difference...? the source? Why does that matter?

A/V vendors ID spyware as well, just not as well as Anti-spyware. ;)

But really, I'm not talking about spyware, I'm talking about web page based attacks. Not the "do you want to install xyz app" type things. There are several trojan based "open the web page and "bad" code starts to run exploits out there. Many times these get into ad servers, which then get placed on "good" websites. So, the end result is you open an know-safe page, and run bad code. There are java exploits, javascript, activeX, heck some that even affect Firefox/mozilla.

Example.
 
djnes said:
Did you read where he stated answering the questions was a waste of time? Do you really think downloading warez is the only way to get a virus, and because you don't, you're immune? Do you even realize spyware and other malware can open doors for viruses, so it's okay to lump them together? Please take some time to understand all the different viruses are spread. If not, just talk to someone you know that's in corporate IT, and ask them about viruses and security.
Yep, I did.

Warez and porn executables are a vast majority of the problem. Yes, I believe avoiding those puts you in a much better position. Thinking about what you're running puts you in an even better position. It's kept me virus free forever.

I asked about AV, just like the thread's topic states. I would have asked about spyware if I wanted to know about that.

Corporate infections (shared server file infections and internal email spread) are different than most home computer infections. The thread is called "Do You Use Anti-Virus?", not "does your corporation use anti-virus". People have little choice over their company computer, but as much choice as they want over their personal computer.

Arguing with you is like playing Twister with rules changing every turn. Since you can't stay on topic, i'm done with you.
 
Back
Top