Do RTS games make you smarter?

Filtrator

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 2, 2006
Messages
199
I've read about people insisting that RTS(CoH, Civ) games make you smarter cause they require more thinking like boards games(Chess, etc) blah blah blah, I wonder what are you thoughts on this?

Personally I think it's a bullcrap, cause all RTS games are pretty much the same and it's build, produce, build, produce.

I think board games are completely different, and do actually require logic and train your mind, but not RTS.
 
All activities can develop skills and rts games are no different.

Civ games however are turn based not real time and require alot of tactical and strategic planning in dealing with other civilisations and you own especially in choosing tech development to suit the circumstances.

Also, CoH involves hell of a lot of tactical thinking, you cannot just build and rush.

it may not seem it but to be able to play an rts well requis thinking and fast thinking at that at times.

This sounds like flame bait to me but if it isn't i think you are being narrow minded.

Just because rts and comp games in general are not sorestricted by rules as say chess is does not mean that a dumb build and rush player will beat a smart tactical thinker.
 
I don't buy the whole "makes you smarter" argument, but I'd say that it might increase your tactical prowess/awareness.
 
An RTS champion can win most games with tank spamming. A chess grand master would defeat tank spam with a quarter of the units.

As Lelouch says, "Tactics cannot defeat strategy!"
 
Maybe they do... but if you're looking to do something to "get smarter" you should read a book.
 
I think board games are completely different, and do actually require logic and train your mind, but not RTS.

Some RTS games are very very close to their board-game counterparts.

Also, Jones in the Fast lane. Definitely doesn't make you smarter on the PC or on cardboard.
 
I don't know if it can really raise your IQ, but I think it can help you build critical thinking skills.
 
unless you have to do math or something I dont see how its going to make you "smarter"...at the most it MIGHT sharpen some multitasking and quick thinking skills...
 
Civilization teaches you about ancient cities, the people, the cultures, the technology, etc. Who knew what an aqueduct was before they played Civilization on SNES? Who knew Memphis was an Egyptian city, or that Syracuse was an Italian city?
 
RTS does not really make you smarter. You might become better at it but that is just your skill improving. What games like fps does for you in real life is making you able to react to stuff faster.
 
Smart is too subjective of a term to answer this question. But if you base it on an IQ test I doubt that playing RTS will increase your IQ.
 
It def takes some serious skill to play RTS games. I wouldnt really say they make you smarter though
 
RTS does not really make you smarter. You might become better at it but that is just your skill improving. What games like fps does for you in real life is making you able to react to stuff faster.

Agreed about peripherals. However, there was a National Geographic study regarding Xellos (korean player) and the brain activity present during a match. The noob used visual (sight) to play, while Xellos was using instinctive parts of the brain to play. I suppose if anything, the better you are at a game, the less "smarts" you are using.

E.g. golf - the more you overthink your shot, the more likely you're gonna fuck up. A great swing is developed through muscle memory and instinct - being "smart" or thinking actually will hinder you.
 
Can't you say that to just about anything? I'm no scientist or anything, but wouldn't having more knowledge in anything increases your brain's reaction to what you percieve? Like in an RTS you would be using the reactions you get through experience. In anthropology, forensics, math, you'd instinctively think of the common problems that might lead you to the answer.

Maybe I'm wrong, but it sounds logical.
 
Civilization teaches you about ancient cities, the people, the cultures, the technology, etc. Who knew what an aqueduct was before they played Civilization on SNES? Who knew Memphis was an Egyptian city, or that Syracuse was an Italian city?

people with a tenth grade education? at any rate, I will say Civ gives you a few useful random facts of historical information but "teaching" is fairly strong for what it gives you...
 
Semantics, fair enough. It introduces you. I was in elementary school when I played Civ for SNES.
 
I think computer games reduces brains to a cottage cheese-like mush, allowing aliens to scoop them out like a melon ball and gobble them right on up.
 
Can't you say that to just about anything? I'm no scientist or anything, but wouldn't having more knowledge in anything increases your brain's reaction to what you percieve? Like in an RTS you would be using the reactions you get through experience. In anthropology, forensics, math, you'd instinctively think of the common problems that might lead you to the answer.

Maybe I'm wrong, but it sounds logical.

no, I'd say you're spot on. Anything that stimulates the brain and makes you think/concentrate is probably good for you to some extent IMO


I think computer games reduces brains to a cottage cheese-like mush, allowing aliens to scoop them out like a melon ball and gobble them right on up.

lol replace brains with muscles and you're 100% right :p
 
Smart is too subjective of a term to answer this question. But if you base it on an IQ test I doubt that playing RTS will increase your IQ.

RTS games can help you develop your critical thinking and problem solving skills by being put into situations where you need to overcome your enemy based on strategy like in chess or tactics like in most normal war games.

As with everything, some RTS games are going to be better or worse at doing that. RTS games that rely on simple mass rushes that require memorization and nothing more, for example Starcraft, are not going to expose you to as much potential to hone your skills.

But that isn't to say the opportunity isn't there, if using strategy you can also use a smaller force to actively solve your problem. But 9 times out of 10, mass zerg's ftw.

Move on to a much better strategy game, like C&C: Tiberian Sun, and you have to worry about counter-attacks and counter-strategies for everything. Massing one unit type isn't always going to win you the game, since there are many strategies that deal with beating a simple tactic like that.

Moral of the story is, SC sucks and TS rules!

Seriously though, my point is...that there is a chance in most walks of life to learn something. What YOU get out of it is going to be different from another person, but that potential is there for both of you to learn the same lessons.
 
RTS games can help you develop your critical thinking and problem solving skills by being put into situations where you need to overcome your enemy based on strategy like in chess or tactics like in most normal war games.

As with everything, some RTS games are going to be better or worse at doing that. RTS games that rely on simple mass rushes that require memorization and nothing more, for example Starcraft, are not going to expose you to as much potential to hone your skills.

But that isn't to say the opportunity isn't there, if using strategy you can also use a smaller force to actively solve your problem. But 9 times out of 10, mass zerg's ftw.

Move on to a much better strategy game, like C&C: Tiberian Sun, and you have to worry about counter-attacks and counter-strategies for everything. Massing one unit type isn't always going to win you the game, since there are many strategies that deal with beating a simple tactic like that.

Moral of the story is, SC sucks and TS rules!

Seriously though, my point is...that there is a chance in most walks of life to learn something. What YOU get out of it is going to be different from another person, but that potential is there for both of you to learn the same lessons.

Um what the heck man. Have you even played very much Starcraft? Sounds like you played around patch 1.01, and lost to a muta rush. A lot has changed since then.
 
Back
Top