'Do Not Track' Internet Spat Risks Legislative Crackdown

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Oh come on people, how hard is this to understand? Do not track should be just that. All these exceptions various groups are asking for is what is making things such a nightmare. :mad:

The White House wants a "Do Not Track" option put on websites to give consumers greater control of their personal information online but Internet companies and privacy groups are at odds on how tight the controls should be.
 
Obviously the White House doesn't have more important issues to address. This will certainly turn the economy around!
 
Obviously the White House doesn't have more important issues to address. This will certainly turn the economy around!

The executive branch doesn't have exclusive control over the economy and there are other issues worth some consideration.

As for tracking, I don't think there's even room for debate if someone opts out.
 
The executive branch doesn't have exclusive control over the economy and there are other issues worth some consideration.

You imply that they therefore must then have exclusive control over this issue to address it?

No branch of government has exclusive control of anything. Well maybe the White House can decide to not enforce laws it doesn't like.
 
Well it sure didn't take long for this thread to get derailed.
 
Everyone is too damn scared about this that and another thing is going to harm them in some way so new laws need to be passed in order to protect those who feel at risk, when really, they shouldn't feel at risk. Life is dangerous, educate yourself to protect yourself rather than make more shit illegal. Kind of irritating, not that Google needs more money, just the principal of the matter and the fact that one of the biggest companies is going to get hurt by it. Sounds like a great plan. Keep enacting laws that hurt businesses, maybe our economy will some how revive itsself.

/endrant...
 
Everyone is too damn scared about this that and another thing is going to harm them in some way so new laws need to be passed in order to protect those who feel at risk, when really, they shouldn't feel at risk. Life is dangerous, educate yourself to protect yourself rather than make more shit illegal. Kind of irritating, not that Google needs more money, just the principal of the matter and the fact that one of the biggest companies is going to get hurt by it. Sounds like a great plan. Keep enacting laws that hurt businesses, maybe our economy will some how revive itsself.

/endrant...

It's not our fault Google's business model involves being a creeper. Why should all of society pay in the intangible price of privacy in exchange for the economic stability of a few companies that make it their business to monitor and record your business?

And OHAI AC!!! :)
 
It's not our fault Google's business model involves being a creeper. Why should all of society pay in the intangible price of privacy in exchange for the economic stability of a few companies that make it their business to monitor and record your business?

And OHAI AC!!! :)

Because, the less regulation on the business sector, the easier it is for the economy to flourish. If Google really is that bad, don't use anything they offer. Naturally they would either adapt or die out and be replaced, but with how regulated shit is now, it is just as dangerous to do that as it is to pass new laws. Though I am all about having as many freedoms as possible without anarchy ensuing. That's just me though :D.
 
Because, the less regulation on the business sector, the easier it is for the economy to flourish. If Google really is that bad, don't use anything they offer. Naturally they would either adapt or die out and be replaced, but with how regulated shit is now, it is just as dangerous to do that as it is to pass new laws. Though I am all about having as many freedoms as possible without anarchy ensuing. That's just me though :D.

I guess I'm in a different camp. I think that people in general are silly creatures that need those among them who exhibit rational thought to regulate and control the lives of the less sensible to keep them from disrupting too widely. Such a thing is already the reality of the world at the moment and adding an extra law here or there doesn't matter much since there are already mountains of laws that are not relevant or not enforced.
 
I guess I'm in a different camp. I think that people in general are silly creatures that need those among them who exhibit rational thought to regulate and control the lives of the less sensible to keep them from disrupting too widely. Such a thing is already the reality of the world at the moment and adding an extra law here or there doesn't matter much since there are already mountains of laws that are not relevant or not enforced.

Yes there are already mountains of laws, but lets not fuck ourselves further. Also while I semi agree with the regulating of those who are irrational and uneducated, that will never be possible because laws will always be catered towards the lowest common denominator, which is those people and ultimately it will affect everyone. But if we don't pay attention to those who are irrational and buy themselves a ticket into debt, then we will be fine. If people decide to fuck themselves, let them do it, but don't let it affect anyone or anything else, like my paycheck. By doing this, it will teach people to be much more responsible in the choices they make, rather than letting mommy and daddy government bottle feed us for over a year because we made a bad choice. I understand if one gets fired, but if you fucked up, you fucked up and should be responsible. That would take care of most of the irrational people.
 
Yes there are already mountains of laws, but lets not fuck ourselves further. Also while I semi agree with the regulating of those who are irrational and uneducated, that will never be possible because laws will always be catered towards the lowest common denominator, which is those people and ultimately it will affect everyone. But if we don't pay attention to those who are irrational and buy themselves a ticket into debt, then we will be fine. If people decide to fuck themselves, let them do it, but don't let it affect anyone or anything else, like my paycheck. By doing this, it will teach people to be much more responsible in the choices they make, rather than letting mommy and daddy government bottle feed us for over a year because we made a bad choice. I understand if one gets fired, but if you fucked up, you fucked up and should be responsible. That would take care of most of the irrational people.

The problem is that you can't really let those people screw themselves over. Keeping them employed and paid at a baseline level is vital to maintain economic activity. Their labor drives industries and generates incomes so they can spend on goods and services. Letting them fail drags everyone else down. It's not possible to go N.I.M.B.Y. and pretend they're not there while they cash in their chips because there are just so many of them...they're everywhere! If they weren't, television advertisements would use more sophisticated sales methods and ads on websites wouldn't throw a photo of some chick in a bikini that links to a site about refinancing your home mortgage. We must regulate their lives and lead them along so as many as possible are kept busy doing something marginally productive.
 
The problem is that you can't really let those people screw themselves over. Keeping them employed and paid at a baseline level is vital to maintain economic activity. Their labor drives industries and generates incomes so they can spend on goods and services. Letting them fail drags everyone else down. It's not possible to go N.I.M.B.Y. and pretend they're not there while they cash in their chips because there are just so many of them...they're everywhere! If they weren't, television advertisements would use more sophisticated sales methods and ads on websites wouldn't throw a photo of some chick in a bikini that links to a site about refinancing your home mortgage. We must regulate their lives and lead them along so as many as possible are kept busy doing something marginally productive.

If that is so, then do it without fucking me over in the process lol. It is too early to be talking politics :p.
 
Do not track on the internet is a pretty stupid law... Way too many ways to avoid jurisdiction etc etc etc

Though browsers and security standards should be built to control personal information from being released/tracked too easily.

I have no problem with generic data tracking... Win/PC, IE8, area (from ip), etc It's the personal info that would worry me... name, age, address, phone # etc.
 
it passes, companies who track or would be harmed by it move off US soil, problem solved.

It's a stupid rule, that will have 0 effect beyond the illusion of privacy which is entirely false.
 
Because, the less regulation on the business sector, the easier it is for the economy to flourish. If Google really is that bad, don't use anything they offer. Naturally they would either adapt or die out and be replaced, but with how regulated shit is now, it is just as dangerous to do that as it is to pass new laws. Though I am all about having as many freedoms as possible without anarchy ensuing. That's just me though :D.

Regulating business and enforcing the right to privacy are two completely different things.
 
Regulating business and enforcing the right to privacy are two completely different things.

Ok, tell me how making a law that does not allow a business to conduct a certain task because it would then be illegal is not regulating since that law was passed based on the right to privacy? Laws control what businesses can and can't do legally. With that said, by what you say, I must have the definition of regulation wrong.
 
Ok, tell me how making a law that does not allow a business to conduct a certain task because it would then be illegal is not regulating since that law was passed based on the right to privacy? Laws control what businesses can and can't do legally. With that said, by what you say, I must have the definition of regulation wrong.

Let me ask you this: if a company is attempting to do something that violates the right to privacy--in this case attempting to wiggle out of honoring a 'do not track' checkbox--do you smack them down and uphold a fundamental right, or do you do nothing in the name of 'deregulation'.
 
Let me ask you this: if a company is attempting to do something that violates the right to privacy--in this case attempting to wiggle out of honoring a 'do not track' checkbox--do you smack them down and uphold a fundamental right, or do you do nothing in the name of 'deregulation'.

I think I have my answer :rolleyes:. Now your just arguing against my point. I would have to know how much privacy is being breached by this law not being enacted, then answer your question from there.
 
lol!

the government of all people want people to be able to not be tracked mean while they are doing everything in their power to track people more and more...

kettle... black.....
 
Back
Top