Do I go back to CRT's?

knightsilver

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 5, 2008
Messages
197
My knowledge of LCD's are limited.

Im using a Samsug 1000.1,5ms(920BM) and it sucks compared to my old Trinatron CRT(RIP). I also had a Samsung 24" and it sucked as well, dont remember the model but I did pay $600 for it...

Ive looked at HP,View Sonic and Acer LCD's. I was use to 100/refresh on my CRT. Ive been looking for a LCD that can handle full motion playblack with out any flaws. Is there such an LCD? I work with Photoshop,After Effects and Maya all day and need something well made or do I just go back to CRT's??

I only need two 22" LCD's

thanks
 
In the 22 range no..period. Since you work with Photoshop,Maya .. you are gonna want color accuracy period and you also want a decent sized monitor since you probably can only afford one of the better more expensive 24 inch's out there.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824002349 Is a great choice but expensive.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824002334 Another good choice for the money but also not cheap.

NEC tends to use IPS panels so you'll get the color accurate picture you want and the only downside to IPS panels is they tend to have a "gold glow" effect but honestly its not noticeable for me so you should be fine , for full motion it should be fine as well but there other panels that do full motion video better but aren't as good color wise that I know of.
 
Ya, thats way out of my price range. I can get a 24" Sony CRT for $320 each. But thats also an extra $150 for VGA cables and I have to build a new heavy desk. I was just wondering if there were a good LCD for less than $500 that would do both video and color.
Maybe one for color and the other LCD for video...

thanks
 
Forgot to add, Im using a Quadro 1700. Has a break out box that has componet out that I cound use as a 2nd DVI.

thanks,
 
Gold Glow effect??? are you talking about White (gamma) Blooming?


The NEC 90 series have AT-W polarizer and thus do not white bloom.



To answer the OP's Question, You want a fast IPS screen. You might be able to find a used 2007 wfp Dell for under $500 that should meet your requirements.
 
I don't know about 22" but I just got 3 NEC 20WMGX2 with a 20" 6ms AS-IPS panel...TechforLess has them for about $200 each and with live cashback came out to about $155...You can occasionally check TechforLess...They sold out almost a month ago and came back in stock 5 days ago and now I think their sold out but if they meet your need you can check them out...
 
Gold Glow effect??? are you talking about White (gamma) Blooming?


The NEC 90 series have AT-W polarizer and thus do not white bloom.



To answer the OP's Question, You want a fast IPS screen. You might be able to find a used 2007 wfp Dell for under $500 that should meet your requirements.

Big problem with the Dell is that there is a chance you might get a *VA instead of an IPS.
 
If you insist, you can find a 2005fpw which is guaranteed IPS panel by looking on your local Craigslists for $100-$200...I am just giving you a general estimate as that is the price I can get one locally...

2005fpw is guaranteed IPS but also be aware that it call also be the 20" 1600x1200 2005fp...The 2007fpw version is the panel lottery whether you get a *VA or IPS as 450 said
 
Gold Glow effect??? are you talking about White (gamma) Blooming?

Well when I see it , it looks almost gold in color from certain angels. If you wanna call it gamma blooming then go for it. Either way its kinda annoying and I wouldn't play the dell IPS lottery , this guy is probably better off getting a CRT since he seems to have one picked out and ready.
 
I agree, your better of with CRT's for your needs. To this day no LCD is still perfect, gonna be that way for awhile until the technology is continually refined. Come along way in just a few short years but for some peeps, it still aint good enough without shelling out major moola for a professional grade LCD
 
If you're in the print business you want very accurate colors but realize that from monitor to monitor and from monitor to print the colors will all look even if slightly different.
wink.gif


The ones that godmachine posted seem good enough bit expensive probably but you get what you pay for.
cool2.gif
 
Ill be getting in to print as well soon.

My I ask if we could get a sticky for OLED/SED to pull all the threads together? I havent heard anything about SED in a while?

But as Im a stubborn one, looks like Ill be going back to CRT's(trinitrons)...

thanks for the feedback guys..
 
SED is all but dead. That is why you haven't heard anything. Canon won in court and can keep working on it but they have announced no dates. FED is similar tech and being worked by Sony. Many are working on OLED.

But none of these are affordable within the next couple of years and even then they will be TV only. No sign of anyone building computer monitors with them. Some tech just doesn't work for monitors. Have you seen a Plasma Panel computer monitor yet?

Basically I don't expect to see a new and affordable computer monitor tech before 5 years from now. I hope my NEC keeps running that long...

Here is a good forum to read if you want to keep up on new flat panel tech:
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/forumdisplay.php?f=40
 
Sad, SED looked really good on paper. I guess the DCC market doesnt warrent attention for better LCD development. If Im going to pay a grand for a LCD its going to have to do better than a Trinitron.......

thanks alot for the link Snowdog...
 
In your case, only go back to CRTs when you can buy new/unused.

If you decide to go used:
Graphics will probably look fine/OK-ish (you mention PS, AE, Maya).
But make sure that text also looks sharp on the CRT of your choice.
Especially white (light grey) text on a black background. Like on this forum (especially people's sigs).
The older a CRT gets, the more difficult it will be for it to display light text on a dark background sharp.
It will look like it's blooming/fuzzy.
The above also depends on whether you have a high-bandwidth clean analogue signal from your graphics card. Which your Quadro should have.

Also check the alignment of the guns.
If you can see one of the primaries (red, green/yellow, or blue) casts directly surrounding the shape of a white letter "H" on a black background, and you cannot completely correct it with the convergence setting in the OSD, stay away, because the guns are permanently misaligned. Cause could be rough handling.

Also find a place where you can bring it in for servicing at reasonable cost.
 
God do you see this gold effect on a NEC 2490/2690? Sounds like something messed up with the screen.
 
Back
Top