Do Conroes really start to slow down @ 43.7C?

Joined
Oct 29, 2004
Messages
33
Sorry if this is a real noobie thing to ask or is widely known. I was hoping to get clarification for a post from the Everquest2 Technical Issues forum. In this post down towards the end of the thread a poster (Deepjay) commented "The cpu was hitting 50 degrees, that apparently with core duo's slows the cpu down to protect it or something". I had never heard this before so asked for a link confirming, and the Sony Technical Support Representative showed up on the boards with this:


http://download.intel.com/design/processor/datashts/31327802.pdf (Warning, PDF file)
Check Table 28 on page 77. It's actually 43.7 degrees celsius, not 50 degrees.

Jason Crawford,
Customer Support Representative​

Is this actually true, that you need to keep a conroe under 43.7C or it starts to slow down "to protect itself"? I frankly couldn't understand the table so was hoping someone technical here could explain this more fully. (Mine is very often over that temperature in games, so now I am worried I need better cooling ..) Anyway I am mostly hoping to be told it isn't true or explained what the table he refers to, actually shows.
 
No, the general temperature in which a C2D starts throttling is at 85C as measured from Core Temp and Intel TAT using the new digital sensor, this probably corresponds to the 60.1C Tcase, which is the temperature at the top-center of the heat spreader.
 
It is called thermal throttling, and slows down the CPU to reduce temps and protect the CPU. On Intel Core 2 Duos, this only occurs at 85 degrees Celsius.
 
if you are running an air-cooled c2d at any kind of load for a decent time, it would be really tough to keep temps as low as 43-44c (coretemp).
 
I read that chart as the amount of power dissapation with associated cpu temperatures... not "the conroe starts throttling down anywhere above idle".

But then I'm not a semi-retarded Everquest 2 customer service rep. :confused:
 
Brash Endeavors said:
Sorry if this is a real noobie thing to ask or is widely known. I was hoping to get clarification for a post from the Everquest2 Technical Issues forum. In this post down towards the end of the thread a poster (Deepjay) commented "The cpu was hitting 50 degrees, that apparently with core duo's slows the cpu down to protect it or something". I had never heard this before so asked for a link confirming, and the Sony Technical Support Representative showed up on the boards with this:


http://download.intel.com/design/processor/datashts/31327802.pdf (Warning, PDF file)
Check Table 28 on page 77. It's actually 43.7 degrees celsius, not 50 degrees.

Jason Crawford,
Customer Support Representative​

Is this actually true, that you need to keep a conroe under 43.7C or it starts to slow down "to protect itself"? I frankly couldn't understand the table so was hoping someone technical here could explain this more fully. (Mine is very often over that temperature in games, so now I am worried I need better cooling ..) Anyway I am mostly hoping to be told it isn't true or explained what the table he refers to, actually shows.

The document you link to does not say that the processor slows down at 50 degrees in Table 28. The Sony Rep is incorrect about his interpretation of those graphs. He is right that 85 degrees is way too hot. You definitely want to cool the processor better than that even if that is theoretically sustainable. But he seems to think that graph is a graph of how the thermal throttle works. And it is not. That graph is intended to help OEMs design their systems for a particular thermal design point.

He thinks thermal throttling kicks in at 43.7 degrees? Shoot, a E6600 with the stock intel fan and a cramped case with sub-optimal airflow (i.e., pretty much most inexpensive C2D systems that you might buy from a low end OEM) will very likely have an idle temperature that exceeds 43.7 degrees!!

Page 76 pretty clearly states that the thermal design point of the processor is in fact 65W. What Table 27 says is that if you keep the operating temperature below the specified Maximum Tc in the right column, the watts that the processor will draw will come from the left column. Now how he draws the conclusion from that graph that the thermal throttle kicks in at 43.7 C is beyond me. If you were successfully to keep the temperature below 43.7C peak, that would mean the the processor would be drawing an average of 2 watts from the power supply. But the design point of the processor is 65W, not 2W. And the table is showing that if you keep the peak temperature below 60.1C, then the power draw will be within that 65W envelope.

Now as the comments on page 76 indicate. Actual TDP's vary a little and some processors won't be able to sustain 65W, whereas some others may be able to sustain more. But certainly, Intel is not selling any processors where the TDP is 2W!!! There isn't that much variance.
 
Intel has set the Tjunction at 85C for C2D when damage "starts" to occur, why would it be necessary to throttle way before this?.


Logic answer the question.


On a further note people get confuse between Tcase and Tjuction, any temperature statement is meaningless without quoting which one.
 
Its 85C (as said numerous times already).

Heck with my case with good airflow from dual 120mm fans and a top 80mm blow hole fan plus a Zalman 9500 on my Conroe it still idles at 38C and under load gets to almost 50C. I cant imagine what stock with bad airflow would be compared to that 43C number :rolleyes:

Also, many of the guys that OC use 60C as a rule of thumb to stay at or under for the max underload temp.
 
Its 85C (as said numerous times already).

Heck with my case with good airflow from dual 120mm fans and a top 80mm blow hole fan plus a Zalman 9500 on my Conroe it still idles at 38C and under load gets to almost 50C. I cant imagine what stock with bad airflow would be compared to that 43C number :rolleyes:

Also, many of the guys that OC use 60C as a rule of thumb to stay at or under for the max underload temp.

probably around 50*C idle and 60*C load nothing too major or could be less since you have more airflow than 1 do, I estimate around a 2*C drop.
 
Back
Top