Do 3-channels vs 2-channels really matter?

Coldblackice

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Aug 14, 2010
Messages
1,156
I have an EVGA e758 board. Long story short, the two DIMMs in the middle section of dimms don't work. I've now populated the first two dimm slots along with populating the furthest slot in the third dimm slot array. (slots 1,2,5 filled)

I'm debating whether it's worth the hassle to RMA this board with evga. I realize I'll need those slots if I want to expand in the future with memory, but my questions are:

1.) What are the consequences of running the memory like this? How much performance am I losing? I'm guessing I lose the tri-channel feature and that the motherboard is now running these dimms at dual channel.

Is this that big of a deal though? It seems like a lot of people are buying 4x2GB dimms which AFAIK also loses the tri-channel feature. I do want to overclock my i7 930 to 4ghz, so will that be hurt/affected by this unsymmetrical RAM layout?

2.) I have OCD about getting a perfect Windows OS install from the start. If I install Win7 now with these 6GB in unbalanced/non-tri DIMM slots, will Windows see that in any way? Will it be affected?

I'm wondering if when and if I do RMA the board and reinstall it (with the 3x2GB modules in the proper tri-channel config), will Windows change anything or have to reconfigure itself to utilize/recognize this change?

Thanks much guys
 
I think you will be running in single channel. Your MB should of had a manual, I couldn't find one at Evga.com, that shows the result of populating the ram slots in different configs.
 
evga is great for customer service..i did a cross ship with them...you should talk to them and see what they will do for you..id be leary of x58 mobo's with failing dimm slots...3 channel makes a difference in memory intensive apps....
never know if some of the other slots are gonna follow.....
 
You've made sure the slots are clear, made sure you have the newest BIOS for compatability updates, and cleared CMOS?
 
Beats me i remember back in the day looking up on the topic and its like comparing apples to oranges . just like single video card vs SLI setups.
In some cases single is faster and in others dual is faster .I would guess nothing changed really over time.
A single memory module reacts faster and doesn't need as much over head to power and deal with.
dual or triple channel its the other way around but if everything starts trying to grab your memory bandwidth by the balls then that's were more channels seems to really help out .

It doesn't really help with anything if your computer is just playing game "X" or ruining app "X"

source
[1][2]
 
1) The real-world performance difference will probably be negligible. Modern PCs have so much memory bandwidth already that there are only a few types of applications that actually benefit from things like triple and quadruple-channel RAM.

2) It shouldn't affect Windows at all. You can change around your RAM configuration and Windows won't care.
 
if u ever want to sell ur mobo, ur re-sale value is poo-poo: RMA it, its worth it :)
 
+1

Agreed .
Half the point of a i7 vs a i5\i3 is triple channel ram .A would RMA too.
Imho still a apples vs oranges scenario but over all i go with triple setup vs single anytime on the ram topic.
 
Back
Top