disk contention / activity on my WHS, causing streaming stutters

sabregen

Fully [H]
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
19,501
title basically says it all. I have several MyMovies clients pointed to my MyMovies DB that's on my WHS (not the WHS version, though.) I also have a lot of other files (duh on the WHS). On regular occassion, while I am watching a file, the disk activity light on my WHS goes solid...playback stutters or stops completely, and the audio will usually continue to play, and then the video goes into fast forward until the two come back into sync.

Anyway to know what the hell is causing this? I prefer my WHS over a raid array, a controller, OLM, OLE, RLM and all that other crap that I'm currently not dealing with due to my WHS. Here's the disk info:

Hitachi 1TB 7200RPM
WD Green 1.5TB
WD Black 1TB
3x Seagate Momentus 500GB
 
Sounds like DEmigrator.exe kicking in. Create a script to turn it off during the day and enable it early in the morning to duplicate your files. Its the drive extender migrator service for WHS.

Just do a search for demigrator.exe and you will read all about it. This is fixed in Vail.
 
set off to occur every weekday @ 3pm, on to occur every weekday at 3:00am. this way it wont be on during the weekends, or when i'm home.
 
@sabregen

I have had this theory for a while and i want you test it. 90% of time when i see this issue the person is running a GP drive. Do you have enough space to pull the GP and try it for a week without the GP drive?
If not I have an extra 2TB hitachi here i can mail you if you are willing to try it.
 
willing to try it, but i don't have enough free space to do it without another spare. swap would be easy enough, as i'm using my rocketfish full tower. hop on msn
 
I just wanted to say that I've been questioning the GP drives also. At one point I had a horrible experience with stuttering and freezing when recording/watching TV shows with SageTV. It all started after adding a Supermicro SATA card (the PCI-X version) and a 1.5 TB WD EADS drive. I thought it was the Supermicro card and moved my drive pool (which I was recording to) to the onboard controllers, but had the same issues. Unfortunately, at the time I didn't have enough space to pull the GP drive out of the drive pool and use it strictly for recording. Instead I added an older 400 GB drive in, left it outside the drive pool, and moved all my recordings to it. Haven't had any issues with it since. I'll be interested in seeing your results if you swap out the drives though.

On a related note, what types of video files are you playing? AVI? MKV? Uncompressed DVD rips? I'm still using GP drives (the WD EADS and a Samsung 1.5TB) for my storage and haven't noticed any issues. Of course, I'm playing the videos off of a SageTV extender and not using Media Center. I've played both personally-ripped videos (in H.264 and uncompressed VOB formats) as well as the common AVI and MKV video files. The one thing I haven't tried is Blu-Ray since I don't have a Blu-Ray drive or any disks.
 
personally ripped DVDs, HD-DVDs, and Blu-Rays in h.264 encoded (personally) .MKV containers with all original English audio, but only keeping the highest bitrate streams. This is over an entirely gigabit network on a single switch. All playback devices have SSDs, if not RAID-0'd SSDs. All playback devices are Core i7 with 4-8GB of RAM, in addition to the SSDs, and all have discrete graphics (of the mid-high end gaming variety). Playback either through VLC or Media Center (Windows 7 x64 Ultimate, on all) with MyMovies plugin (whatever the latest is) pointing to WHS.

I can notice the stutter, immediately look at the WHS, and see a solid HDD light. Watched 2x movies last night after created scheduled tasks for the DEMigrator.exe to be turned off and on at preset times and had no playback issues at all, even over my dual band Wireless N.
 
@sabregen

I have had this theory for a while and i want you test it. 90% of time when i see this issue the person is running a GP drive. Do you have enough space to pull the GP and try it for a week without the GP drive?
If not I have an extra 2TB hitachi here i can mail you if you are willing to try it.

hmm, interesting. I had GP drives when I had this problem.
 
I have never had this problem and 2 of my 6 2TB drives are EADS. I also have never tried to interfere with DEMigrator.

Go figure.
 
I have never had this problem and 2 of my 6 2TB drives are EADS. I also have never tried to interfere with DEMigrator.

Go figure.

Yea its odd most people never see this issue. At the same time there are tons of complaints about it.
 
I only run into this issue at about 1am when I have have backs set to begin. it freezes for about a minute and then is fine again. doesnt really bother me. lets me know that I should have been asleep two hours ago.
 
I only run into this issue at about 1am when I have have backs set to begin. it freezes for about a minute and then is fine again. doesnt really bother me. lets me know that I should have been asleep two hours ago.

What kind of drives do you have?
 
i had this issue with WHS v1 and i had/have GP drives..

pissed me off to no end, i even added a intel nic on my server and HTPC to make sure that wasnt the cause.

WHS v2 I have not had this issue at all.... with GP drives. For what that is worth
 
two hitachi 1tb
1 seagate 1,5tb
1 seagate 750gb
1 seagate 500gb

its all running on a asus server board that was a $20 open box deal on newegg. I just tossed in a old Pentium D I had laying around and 2gb of ram. I think it has more to do with the cpu than anything else in my case. I can also force the same effect by hashing a 34gb torrent.
 
Back
Top