Difference between WD Black and WD RE4

sblantipodi

2[H]4U
2FA
Joined
Aug 29, 2010
Messages
3,805
As title,
I noticed that this two hard drives scores quite the same performance when on benchmarks,
what is the difference between this two drives?

I know that once is designed for desktop and one for enterprise, but what's the difference?
 
The biggest difference is the firmware. RE drives have TLER (time limited error recovery). Which is important if you use HW raid or windows software raid but not necessary if you use linux software raid or zfs..
 
Looking at the spec sheets and information on their web pages, here are the differences I noted:

BLACK
---------
BER:1e-14
load/unload:300K
temp:0C-60C

RE4
-------
BER:1e-15
load/unload:600K
temp:5C-55C
TLER
RAFF
multi-axis shock sensor
3G dynamic fly height
thermal extended burn-in test
MTBF: 1.2 million hours


Whether most of those are firmware differences, I cannot say. I think it is clear that the RE4s undergo different testing and burn-in than the Blacks. If they are mechanically the same, my guess is that WD runs production line tests on the parts and skims the best parts off for the RE4s, since that would give them the best chance of passing the subsequent more-strenuous burn-in tests.
 
Like Xeon's and Core processors - Xeons are binned higher and have a few more features (SMP/ECC Memory)
 
Back
Top