Difference between these 2 motherboards (for XP 2500)

sandman78

Gawd
Joined
Jun 5, 2004
Messages
587
I'm building an extra machine, and I'm going to use an XP 2500 processor. One has on-board video, and the other doesn't. I would like to go with the board that has on-board video, but if the other board is a lot better, I will go with it. The machine will basically be used for burning DVD's, compressing video, and a file server? Would the cheaper board be ok, or would you recommend going with the Deluxe board.(which I'd also have to buy a video card for)

The board that is a little cheaper and has the on-board video is the ASUS A7N8X-VM/400, and the other board is the ASUS A7N8X-E Deluxe.

Thanks
 
sandman78 said:
I'm building an extra machine, and I'm going to use an XP 2500 processor. One has on-board video, and the other doesn't. I would like to go with the board that has on-board video, but if the other board is a lot better, I will go with it. The machine will basically be used for burning DVD's, compressing video, and a file server? Would the cheaper board be ok, or would you recommend going with the Deluxe board.(which I'd also have to buy a video card for)

The board that is a little cheaper and has the on-board video is the ASUS A7N8X-VM/400, and the other board is the ASUS A7N8X-E Deluxe.

Thanks

Been awhile since I used a Socket A Nforce 2 board, but I THINK I remember the the NForce 2 chipsets with built in video didn't use the Soundstorm sound system, the one with built in video will probably just use the basic AC/97 sound codec, so that could be a factor if you're going to be playing back any of the DVD on that system you're going to burn. But it sounds like you're not, so I guess as long as you don't mind that the one with built in video is a MicroATX form factor, and don't mind built in video, go for the cheaper one, just glancing it would work fine for the needs you mentioned.
 
You're right... I won't be playing any DVD's back thru it. But now that I think about it, the Deluxe board would be better if I did decide to do more with the machine later. Plus I found a Geforce4 MX in my closet still new in the box. The main thing is stability. This pc will be on 24/7, and I just want it to be reliable. Will either of these boards be good for that, or should I look at the Abit NF-S v2.0? I've heard that is a really good nforce2 board. I want to order the parts today, so I've got to decide.
 
sandman78 said:
You're right... I won't be playing any DVD's back thru it. But now that I think about it, the Deluxe board would be better if I did decide to do more with the machine later. Plus I found a Geforce4 MX in my closet still new in the box. The main thing is stability. This pc will be on 24/7, and I just want it to be reliable. Will either of these boards be good for that, or should I look at the Abit NF-S v2.0? I've heard that is a really good nforce2 board. I want to order the parts today, so I've got to decide.

Between the ASUS & The Abit? Literally flip a coin. Both are wonderful boards, very similar in features. I had the Abit, my dad the ASUS. So I can vouch for both. I think I remember that the Abit had the overclocking reputation over the ASUS, ASUS the stability rep over the Abit when discussing these two specific boards, but not like neither board was unstable, both were in my experience...and if you do use this system for more, both were good Overclocking boards too IMO.


Anyway...I guess go with whichever brand you like better, or if no preference pick whichever is right now the cheaper of the two, both are great boards.

And cool you found a literally unused video card.

Enjoy your upcoming system build. ;)

Evan AKA Me
 
The thing to watch out for with that vm400 board is that it has no voltage, fsb, or multiplier controls. It won't be a problem unless that 2500 happens to be of the moblile variety, or if you plan on overclocking. Just something to keep in mind, I made that mistake once.
 
the only nf2 igp board that i know of that has soundstorm is the mn31n. it was a good board except it did not have multiplier or voltage adjustment but it was stable for me. it is discountinued now but you might be able to find a retailer that still has it in stock.

if you want a board with onboard gfx i recommend this board http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=13-138-234&depa=0 this board does not have soundstorm but it has multiplier and voltage control so you can stick in a mobile athlon xp in there.

http://www.newegg.com/app/viewProductDesc.asp?description=13-150-045&depa=0 this board is stable and cheap (it also does not have soundstorm). my friend has this with a unlocked 1700+..

btw the abit nf7 2.0 series has a rampant problem. the northbridge hsf is known to go bad, so if you go that route i recommend getting a new northbridge hsf to avoid a possible problem in the future. asus has some rock solid boards but i dont consider the vm400 one of them.
 
get an nf7-s, they' have soundstrom and they're rock soild. And yes the fan will probably die on you, but its a loud SOB to begin with so get a zalman passive for like 5 bux and your good.
 
heero884 said:
btw the abit nf7 2.0 series has a rampant problem. the northbridge hsf is known to go bad, so if you go that route i recommend getting a new northbridge hsf to avoid a possible problem in the future. asus has some rock solid boards but i dont consider the vm400 one of them.


Weird, I never heard of the northbridge fan going bad on an NF7S. Not calling you a liar, but if I may ask (assuming you read this. ;) ), can you link to a message board thread or review or some such?
 
Arvig said:
Between the ASUS & The Abit? Literally flip a coin. Both are wonderful boards, very similar in features. I had the Abit, my dad the ASUS. So I can vouch for both........

Thanks for the info. arvig. I'll probably end up doing what you said, and flipping a coin.:D I As you can see, I didn't order the parts today, but I'm hoping I get my mind made up and get the parts ordered tomorrow. The only bummer about this video card I found is that it's a PCI card.

antirush said:
The thing to watch out for with that vm400 board is that it has no voltage, fsb, or multiplier controls. It won't be a problem unless that 2500 happens to be of the moblile variety, or if you plan on overclocking. Just something to keep in mind, I made that mistake once.

Good to know, but I'm not going to overclock it anytime soon. But I might sometime down the road.

heero884 said:
............ if you want a board with onboard gfx i recommend this board http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProdu...-138-234&depa=0 this board does not have soundstorm but it has multiplier and voltage control so you can stick in a mobile athlon xp in there.

Thanks, I'll check out that board. I won't be using a mobile, it will be a retail xp.

Dephcon said:
get an nf7-s, they' have soundstrom and they're rock soild. And yes the fan will probably die on you, but its a loud SOB to begin with so get a zalman passive for like 5 bux and your good.

If I order the nf7-s, I will just go ahead and order another fan or heatsink.
 
The difference between the 2 boards in your original post seems to be that the cheaper 1 has no SATA controller.. Neither has soundstorm..
 
Arvig said:
Weird, I never heard of the northbridge fan going bad on an NF7S. Not calling you a liar, but if I may ask (assuming you read this. ;) ), can you link to a message board thread or review or some such?

here is a quick search on the abit forum..

http://forum.abit-usa.com/search.ph...d=821531&sortby=lastpost&sortorder=descending

here is the customer review page of the nf7s 2.0 of newegg..

http://secure.newegg.com/app/CustratingReview.asp?DEPA=0&item=13-127-166

im not saying all nf7s nb heatsink fans will go bad but a good percentage of them do (so you should take that into consideration if you do decide to get the board, and no im not going to give you a exact percentage, if you want to know that, youll have to do a little research of your own ;-)

for me personally, my nf7s 2.0's nb hsf was fine for 2weeks (i thought i got away with having to buy a new hsf) but then it started rattling which was more annoying then the constant "vroom" sound i get from my undervolted tornado. while i was replacing the nb hsf, i added a sb heatsink (i heard it reduces crackling in the sound but i did it because my sb was a kinda warm) and this cost me $8, so my motherboard wasn't exactly as cheap as i thought it would be (that and i eventually added mofset heatsinks which cost me $6 =x)
 
heero884 said:
here is a quick search on the abit forum..

http://forum.abit-usa.com/search.ph...d=821531&sortby=lastpost&sortorder=descending

here is the customer review page of the nf7s 2.0 of newegg..

http://secure.newegg.com/app/CustratingReview.asp?DEPA=0&item=13-127-166

im not saying all nf7s nb heatsink fans will go bad but a good percentage of them do (so you should take that into consideration if you do decide to get the board, and no im not going to give you a exact percentage, if you want to know that, youll have to do a little research of your own ;-)

for me personally, my nf7s 2.0's nb hsf was fine for 2weeks (i thought i got away with having to buy a new hsf) but then it started rattling which was more annoying then the constant "vroom" sound i get from my undervolted tornado. while i was replacing the nb hsf, i added a sb heatsink (i heard it reduces crackling in the sound but i did it because my sb was a kinda warm) and this cost me $8, so my motherboard wasn't exactly as cheap as i thought it would be (that and i eventually added mofset heatsinks which cost me $6 =x)

Cool, thanks for the links. Guess I got lucky with mine for the time I had it then.

Me
 
EPOX 8RGA+ had the MCP-T and IGP. It however did not have a SPDIF built onto the motherboard, just the connector for one on the PC,
 
I really like my Deluxe, makes for a really great board if you want to use it for other things. After I go A64 it's going into an HTPC. :)
 
Back
Top