Department NAS! Enter Storage Pro's ;]

deezy

n00b
Joined
Feb 12, 2007
Messages
9
Money has come available and we may finally be able to purchase some sort of NAS for our department (60 users). With our file server running low, I've been wanting to look into more storage for quite some time (maybe something a couple of terabytes big, not larger than 4TB at this time). Primarily whatever we get will hold some training videos, and class recordings. As well as user profiles currently "my documents" are being redirected to another file server. I keep seeing these little NAS boxes ie. Drobo, Terastation, ReadyNAS...but not sure how much faith to put into one of them for our environment...or should I keep relying on a dedicated true RAID5 file server for these types of things.

What's your thoughts? Can these little NAS boxes replace the normal rack mounted NAS I would expect from Dell/HP?

Thx
 
Do yourself a favor and don't go for the little nas boxes you buy at local stores. Most of the time, their network performance is terrible and any kind of serious issue (array corruption or software malfunction) can lead you to many headaches.

You should look at a HP/Dell solution for your needs since you are only working with 4tb's of storage and you wont see much of a cost offset. Also, you will get the support/warranty/ and a proven platform.
 
Also remember that any Raid is not the same as a multi copy off site backup of your data.

I am no IT expert, but for your situaion, I suggest a real server with a real backup solution. A complete server crash can cost you thousands to recover from without the proper planning.

But, if you are intent on doing this yourself, I found this site really helpful on my recent NAS purchase.

Smallnetbuilder.com

He has great advice and some really wonderful reveiws of NAS devices.

Don
 
I agree with Okie and DonDon.
I would look at getting something such as a Dell Poweredge 2900 and hook it up with four 1TB hdds in raid 5. They're also having some great deals now with free CPU upgrades, free raid card upgrades, and a lot more stuff.

http://www.dell.com
 
Im in HP land...
Just built a small NAS using a DL360G5 head with 2 MSA60 HDD shelves with a P800 controller. Very good, solid stuff for budget-minded folks. My bigger NetApp stuff gets real pricey, real fast but is lightning fast. I don't know your I/O requirements, but remember the more spindles, the faster you'll be serving up those files. Going with fewer, bigger drives is not necessarily the way to go if performance is a concern.
 
HP and Dell are garbage, as is NetCrap.
Argue all you want; I'm the guy with the SVC 2145, EMC Clariions, DS4800's and DS8000's, 'kay? I've tested 'em. Their crap is pure trash at best.Oh, and licensing and hardware will easily break $225K for anything that has any hope of handling 60 users. We were looking at $200K+ for something to handle 20 low traffic servers.

IBM has a 'NAS' box that's actually a modified xSeries. Go with it. It's cheaper than the crap, and it's faster to boot.
 
HP and Dell are garbage, as is NetCrap.
Argue all you want; I'm the guy with the SVC 2145, EMC Clariions, DS4800's and DS8000's, 'kay? I've tested 'em. Their crap is pure trash at best.Oh, and licensing and hardware will easily break $225K for anything that has any hope of handling 60 users. We were looking at $200K+ for something to handle 20 low traffic servers.

IBM has a 'NAS' box that's actually a modified xSeries. Go with it. It's cheaper than the crap, and it's faster to boot.

Haha are you serious? You pretty much just threw any credibility you might have had out the window by claiming storage industry giants are trash. Because that's how you get to be an industry giant right, by being trash? You are right about one thing though, IBM does have great NAS boxes (they're NetApp).

Back to reality, what's your budget Deezy? There's no point recommending anything blindly if it's going to be outside your price scope.
 
HP and Dell are garbage, as is NetCrap.
Argue all you want; I'm the guy with the SVC 2145, EMC Clariions, DS4800's and DS8000's, 'kay? I've tested 'em. Their crap is pure trash at best.Oh, and licensing and hardware will easily break $225K for anything that has any hope of handling 60 users. We were looking at $200K+ for something to handle 20 low traffic servers.

IBM has a 'NAS' box that's actually a modified xSeries. Go with it. It's cheaper than the crap, and it's faster to boot.

Wow dude - you're a friggin' TOOL. I've played with all the aforementioned stuff and have most of it running in one or both of my datacenters. You don't know what you're talking about. Nobody's arguing about cost here either. Enterprise SAN stuff is very expensive. Like mentioned above, the IBM unit it a rebadged NetApp, so why not go with the real deal? Wow.
 
Haha are you serious? You pretty much just threw any credibility you might have had out the window by claiming storage industry giants are trash. Because that's how you get to be an industry giant right, by being trash? You are right about one thing though, IBM does have great NAS boxes (they're NetApp).

See McDonalds analogy, thanks.

What's your experience in storage? Answer; jack. Do you administer these boxes on a daily basis? No, you don't. You are yet another kid, who thinks that BIG == BETTER. ProTip: It doesn't. I just threw Sun out on their ear, because the boxes they specified for a very common application, were barely 25% as fast as IBMs that cost me half as much.
Secondly, you obviously don't know a damn thing at all, since you're claiming that an xSeries is a rebadged NetApp. Uh, Spinnaker didn't make servers when NetApp bought 'em either, kiddo.

Wow dude - you're a friggin' TOOL. I've played with all the aforementioned stuff and have most of it running in one or both of my datacenters. You don't know what you're talking about. Nobody's arguing about cost here either. Enterprise SAN stuff is very expensive. Like mentioned above, the IBM unit it a rebadged NetApp, so why not go with the real deal? Wow.

Because you're an idiot? Because you clearly are talking out of your rear? Because you're a subpar attempt at trolling? Because you haven't got any "datacenters," much less anything in them?

Just to name a few, mind. But if you've joined the "NetApp builds PCs club," I mean, feel free. We won't mention the other fact, that being that IBM sells the NetApp rebadges a minimum 10% lower than NetCrap direct, much less resold.

There's a reason people don't come to [H] for advice on enterprise hardware.
 
See McDonalds analogy, thanks.

What's your experience in storage? Answer; jack. Do you administer these boxes on a daily basis? No, you don't. You are yet another kid, who thinks that BIG == BETTER. ProTip: It doesn't. I just threw Sun out on their ear, because the boxes they specified for a very common application, were barely 25% as fast as IBMs that cost me half as much.
Secondly, you obviously don't know a damn thing at all, since you're claiming that an xSeries is a rebadged NetApp. Uh, Spinnaker didn't make servers when NetApp bought 'em either, kiddo.



Because you're an idiot? Because you clearly are talking out of your rear? Because you're a subpar attempt at trolling? Because you haven't got any "datacenters," much less anything in them?

Just to name a few, mind. But if you've joined the "NetApp builds PCs club," I mean, feel free. We won't mention the other fact, that being that IBM sells the NetApp rebadges a minimum 10% lower than NetCrap direct, much less resold.

There's a reason people don't come to [H] for advice on enterprise hardware.

Obviously you've got your big blue blinders on. You're making claims against known facts in the industry. Second, you don't even freaking KNOW me , where I work, and what I do in my datacenters. Don't tell me you know anything about me, because it just makes you look like more of an ignorant ass than you already are.
 
See McDonalds analogy, thanks.

What's your experience in storage? Answer; jack. Do you administer these boxes on a daily basis? No, you don't. You are yet another kid, who thinks that BIG == BETTER. ProTip: It doesn't. I just threw Sun out on their ear, because the boxes they specified for a very common application, were barely 25% as fast as IBMs that cost me half as much.
Secondly, you obviously don't know a damn thing at all, since you're claiming that an xSeries is a rebadged NetApp. Uh, Spinnaker didn't make servers when NetApp bought 'em either, kiddo.

This is hilarious, you sir are a supreme fake poster because I'm seriously struggling to believe you are seriously responding. I don't remember stating what my credentials are, how old I am, etc. I never said bigger is better and in fact (without going back and reading) I think I'm the only that actually asked for his budget to be able to give him some appropriate recommendations. I also never claimed the XSeries were NetApp, I was stating that IBM's current NAS lineup are NetApp. As in you go to the website, click storage, then network attached storage, and there you go, the N series.

http://www-03.ibm.com/systems/storage/network/?cm_re=masthead-_-products-_-stg-nas

So if I read you correctly, IBM is the only player in the storage industry worth a damn and the only one you would recommend? If so, you could've worded that a whole lot better man and retained some respect.

Because you're an idiot? Because you clearly are talking out of your rear? Because you're a subpar attempt at trolling? Because you haven't got any "datacenters," much less anything in them?

Just to name a few, mind. But if you've joined the "NetApp builds PCs club," I mean, feel free. We won't mention the other fact, that being that IBM sells the NetApp rebadges a minimum 10% lower than NetCrap direct, much less resold.

Oh lawdy lookit them insults! Assuming once again? Your responses in this thread are so ludicrous I'm starting to question reality itself. :p

There's a reason people don't come to [H] for advice on enterprise hardware.

Your pointless and jaded arguments are the reason. You hate everyone and everything (except part of IBM?), we get it. Let's move on to helping Deezy.
 
We won't mention the other fact, that being that IBM sells the NetApp rebadges a minimum 10% lower than NetCrap direct, much less resold.

Also part of the cost associated with enterprise hardware is the support agreements (RMA, SLA, etc). It's not just straight hardware being sold, and obviously IBM and NetApp have their own terms and service levels equating to a price difference. But you know this right being the storage industry guru?
 
Back
Top