Dell Releases Fix for NVIDIA Mobile GPU

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Dell has issued a system update for notebooks that are affected by Nvidia’s recently announced video problems affecting mobile GPUs. The updates are for the models detailed in the table linked above.
 
thanks for the link, I will try this on one of the laptops at work.
 
So the question is is this every model of Dell laptop that has a G84/G86 in it? That could go a long why towards Charlie D.'s charge at the INQ that all of these chips are bad.
 
From what I have read on other websites, all these bios updates do is increase the fan speed. In some cases, it just causes the fan to run at full speed all the time.

So, it is a really half-assed fix. It will just make your laptop noisier, use up its battery quicker, and it does nothing to solve the real problem. The best Dell can hope for is that it allows the GPU to work long enough so that it is out of warranty by the time it dies.

Note: I have not tried any of these updates, this is just what I understand from what I have read elsewhere.
 
So the question is is this every model of Dell laptop that has a G84/G86 in it? That could go a long why towards Charlie D.'s charge at the INQ that all of these chips are bad.

Every model with a G84 or G86 is at risk. That's because only Dell and Nvidia know which specific models and their date of products could actually be screwed. It's likely easier for Dell just to release it for all of these models and not risk it themselves than take a guess based on data of production.

From what I have read on other websites, all these bios updates do is increase the fan speed. In some cases, it just causes the fan to run at full speed all the time.

So, it is a really half-assed fix. It will just make your laptop noisier, use up its battery quicker, and it does nothing to solve the real problem. The best Dell can hope for is that it allows the GPU to work long enough so that it is out of warranty by the time it dies.

Note: I have not tried any of these updates, this is just what I understand from what I have read elsewhere.

Increasing the fan speed is the only thing they can do. The problem is related to the heat output of the chip and presumably not just when it's under heavy 3D load but most of the time. No software fix, deep in the BIOS or not, is going to suddenly fix this. Now, if they really wanted to do the "right" thing it would be to replace these systems but for instance with the M1330 and M1530 those systems are still shipping with Nvidia GPUs (ones hopefully dated late enough to not be messed up). But that is a very expensive under taking and one I don't think a publicly traded company could justify to its stock holders.
 
i´m surprised that there´s no vostro 1500. i know this model is a bit older (a few months ago it was still sold). did they stop support for them?

i have a vostro 1500 with an 8600m gt and even IF they would release a "fix" for this i wouldnt install it. they should recall them and sue nvidia. i dont want to have a notebook with a chip that may last only 3 years instead of 5 or more. :mad:
 
Well, I just updated my XPSm1330 which I just got back from repair center. Was probably the most painless BIOS flash ever.

I'm worried that they did not replace the 8400M GS chip at the repair center.
 
Every model with a G84 or G86 is at risk. That's because only Dell and Nvidia know which specific models and their date of products could actually be screwed. It's likely easier for Dell just to release it for all of these models and not risk it themselves than take a guess based on data of production.

Dell knows exactly what ones are affected and they should be able to tell you using your service tag. They did this for the PSU swapout for notebooks a few years back and the hard drive replacements for GX240/GX260s when the maxtors were failing.
 
I wonder if this also affects the quadro series chips in the T61p's??
 
Funny you should mention. I just went to Device manager to see which nvidia adapter is in my T61p.

It is a NVIDIA Quadro FX570M. Now that you mention it. It does get hot. :-(
 
I flashed my 1400. The fan speed change so far isn't noticeable. As for the Quadro, I would assume certain models would be affected as well. Not sure which ones are based on the 84/86 die set though.

Glad to see Dell has at least offered some help in the matter.
 
Note: Prior to the Bios flash I've seen my GPU reach 90C under load. Haven't tested load with the new bios yet though.
 
Most ridiculous "fix" ever. How is running your fans at 100% all the time a fix? They should just replace the defective units.
 
Now, if they really wanted to do the "right" thing it would be to replace these systems but for instance with the M1330 and M1530 those systems are still shipping with Nvidia GPUs (ones hopefully dated late enough to not be messed up). But that is a very expensive under taking and one I don't think a publicly traded company could justify to its stock holders.

Yep. Damn the customers, as always. :mad:
 
Well, I just updated my XPSm1330 which I just got back from repair center. Was probably the most painless BIOS flash ever.

I'm worried that they did not replace the 8400M GS chip at the repair center.

They won't replace it unless it breaks under warranty. Once you're warranty is up, you're going to pay for it.
 
Funny you should mention. I just went to Device manager to see which nvidia adapter is in my T61p.

It is a NVIDIA Quadro FX570M. Now that you mention it. It does get hot. :-(

Quadros are definitely affected, since they're used in the D630, which has a BIOS update. You'd have to use the configuration tool on the Dell site to find out which model they use.
 
I am still probably going to order my m1530 in the next few days, i doubt they are still shipping defective GPU's and this seems to only effect a small number of people, the majority of people are very happy and not had any trouble.
 
It figures Dell would go for a quick fix that does nothing to address the real problem.This is why I'll never buy another mass market computer.They screwed me over with their Inspiron 1100 laptops,turned out they had motherboards that self destructed just about the time the warranty expired.Which is probably just what they're hoping for with this update,it will keep the affected systems going just long enough to be out of warranty when they fry.
 
Most ridiculous "fix" ever. How is running your fans at 100% all the time a fix? They should just replace the defective units.

Um, douche...

It doesn't run the fan at 100% all the time. Do you have a Dell that's effected? Have you flashed the bios? Are you a douche?

The answer to the last question is probably yes. Sorry, but it doesn't run the fan at 100% all the time... douche.
 
It figures Dell would go for a quick fix that does nothing to address the real problem.This is why I'll never buy another mass market computer.They screwed me over with their Inspiron 1100 laptops,turned out they had motherboards that self destructed just about the time the warranty expired.Which is probably just what they're hoping for with this update,it will keep the affected systems going just long enough to be out of warranty when they fry.

An add in builder has to have an element of faith in their component suppliers. It should be expected that Dell do this to see how it can lower failure rates before instituting a full "recall and replace". If you owned a company would you not try to postpone a problem beyond your responsibility cheaply before pursuing the most expensive fix?
 
inspiron 1420 - Nvidia GeForce 8400M GS
D630 - Quadro NVS 135M
D630C - Quadro NVS 135m
precision m2300 - Quadro FX 360M
Vostro 1310 - Nvidia 8400M GS
Vostro 1400 - 8400M GS
Vostro 1510 - 8400M GS
Vostro 1710 - 8600M GT
xps m1330 - 8400M GS
xps m1530 - 8600M GT

Looks like there may be a reason to give the Inq some credit here. They're all 84's and 86's for the mobile single GPU models.
 
I'm surprised none of the new model inspirons were listed. My 1720 has had graphics problems up the yin yang with an 8600M GT
 
An add in builder has to have an element of faith in their component suppliers. It should be expected that Dell do this to see how it can lower failure rates before instituting a full "recall and replace". If you owned a company would you not try to postpone a problem beyond your responsibility cheaply before pursuing the most expensive fix?

That's exactly the kind of reasoning that makes Dell a company to be avoided.Their responsibility is to sell products that aren't defective.If a problem occurs,you fix it.They did neither,all they did was take a ticking bomb and lengthened the fuse a little.It's not the consumer's fault that Dell decided to trust Nvidia,so why should they pay for that mistake?
Let Dell go after Nvidia to pay for it.
 
That's exactly the kind of reasoning that makes Dell a company to be avoided.Their responsibility is to sell products that aren't defective.If a problem occurs,you fix it.They did neither,all they did was take a ticking bomb and lengthened the fuse a little.It's not the consumer's fault that Dell decided to trust Nvidia,so why should they pay for that mistake?
Let Dell go after Nvidia to pay for it.

You suggest who else to go to? HP already did this and no other manufacturer has done anything from what I gather. At the very least Dell has done something, even if it's not the best. If the laptop fails within the warranty then Dell has to replace it, it's all pretty simple. So until some manufacturer comes along with better service I can see your point. But I don't see that happening any time soon.
 
I'm waiting for another Class action suit. I think its the only way to make nVidia pay for their screwup. I'm still trying to talk to Acer about the laptop issues i have.

I know its heat related and I know its going to get worse. So I'd either like it repairing or replacing. I for one will not be taking this one lieing down. I sure as hell didnt over the faulty caps issue. I wont take it over defective laptops.
 
Note: Prior to the Bios flash I've seen my GPU reach 90C under load. Haven't tested load with the new bios yet though.

Damn thats hot. I'm concerned that although my Inspiron 1520 is not on the list, it might be affected since it has an 8600M in it. I've never seen it go over 68c after a long session of WoW or some TF2. I had it made back in February of this year and I wonder if the chips were a newer revision by that time. I really love this laptop and it has never given my any problems but I'm concerned.:( I guess I will call dell and see what they say.
 
inspiron 1420 - Nvidia GeForce 8400M GS
D630 - Quadro NVS 135M
D630C - Quadro NVS 135m
precision m2300 - Quadro FX 360M
Vostro 1310 - Nvidia 8400M GS
Vostro 1400 - 8400M GS
Vostro 1510 - 8400M GS
Vostro 1710 - 8600M GT
xps m1330 - 8400M GS
xps m1530 - 8600M GT

Looks like there may be a reason to give the Inq some credit here. They're all 84's and 86's for the mobile single GPU models.

Maybe you should read what the INQ said, before supporting their gibberish ?

http://www.theinquirer.net/gb/inquirer/news/2008/07/09/nvidia-g84-g86-bad

They said all G84 and G86 were bad, in both laptop and desktop computers.
 
argh, can't edit, but what exactly does this fix do?

Dell says the fix tweaks fan control profiles to "help regulate GPU temperature fluctuations". In other words, the fan controllers should make them spin faster, to keep the chips cooler, which is what's causing them to fail rapidly.
 
Dell says the fix tweaks fan control profiles to "help regulate GPU temperature fluctuations". In other words, the fan controllers should make them spin faster, to keep the chips cooler, which is what's causing them to fail rapidly.



So basically, fan running more often?
 
I flashed my BIOS and everything went smoothly. I noticed slight artifacting and random lines upon the startup of Windows, though. Hasn't since happened.
 
I flashed my BIOS and everything went smoothly. I noticed slight artifacting and random lines upon the startup of Windows, though. Hasn't since happened.

Your chip may not have "cooked" yet. but your battery life will suck from now on if they just running fans at full revs.
 
Your chip may not have "cooked" yet. but your battery life will suck from now on if they just running fans at full revs.
I was on the laptop for a full hour prior. And no, the fans do not run at full speeds. Not even half. Because here I sit, posting from my M1530, and the only fan activity going on is minimal.
 
All the defective parts should be recalled end of discussion nvidia be damned but it is the RIGHT thing to do in this situation
 
Back
Top